Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


'We must all remember the Arctic convoys, the danger and those we lost. This must never be forgotten'

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 10 October 2008
THEY were told they were heading for the most dangerous waters in the world – and reality bore out the description.
Fighting horrendous weather and sea temperatures of minus 60 degrees, the wartime heroes were under near constant attack from above and below sea, as well as from the air.

During the Second World War the Arctic convoys travelled from the UK and America to deliver vital supplies to the northern ports of the Soviet Union.

About 1,400 merchant ships and their naval escorts made the hazardous journey between August 1941 and May 1945.

In all, 85 merchant vessels and 16 Royal Navy warships were lost.

The convoys initially ran from Iceland, but from September 1942 they assembled and sailed from Loch Ewe in Wester Ross.

Yesterday, some of the survivors returned, their numbers depleted, for a ceremony to mark their achievements and in honour of those who did not come back.

An RAF flypast was followed by a religious service and two-minute silence before prayers were said at a permanent memorial to the sailors who made, in the word of wartime prime minister Winston Churchill, "the worst journey in the world".

As a mark of respect, warships deployed in the Minch for a modern-day exercise, Joint Warrior, also assembled in Loch Ewe to pay silent tribute.

The event, at Pool House, the convoy's former headquarters and now a hotel, was also attended by Royal Navy officers and representatives from Russia and Norway, as well as local people and schoolchildren.

The Russian Convoy Club has now disbanded and a bell given to the memory of the convoy sailors was handed to the hotel where it will be kept on display.

The hotel's proprietor, Elizabeth Miles, who helped organise the event, said handfuls of veterans had visited the area over the years, but old age and ill health had taken its toll on those who survived the convoys.

She said: "This is a local tribute to the veterans of the Second World War convoys to Russia – a celebration of what they did. It is part of our history.

"For many of the poor souls this area was the last sight of land they saw."

One of the veterans, Jim Osler, 82, from Glasgow, served on the RFA Aldersdale, a Royal Fleet Auxiliary ship that was sunk during convoy PQ17.

PQ17 sailed in June and July 1942 and suffered the heaviest losses of any Russia-bound convoy, with 25 vessels out of 36 lost to enemy action.

Under attack from German aircraft and U-boats, the convoy was ordered to scatter, following reports that a battle group, which included the battleship Tirpitz, had sailed to intercept the ships.

Only 11 of the merchant ships in the convoy succeeded in running the gauntlet of U-boats and bombers. This convoy is said to have inspired author Alistair MacLean to write his first novel HMS Ulysses.

'They must never be forgotten'Jim Osler, 82, from Glasgow, was in the Royal Fleet Auxiliary ship Aldersdale, which sank in convoy PQ17 in 1942.

"I have a memory of everyone on that ship being determined to get to Russia, which unfortunately we failed to do because of bombers.

"The U-boat attacks were horrendous. You could hear the thuds of torpedos while you were lying in the dark. You cannot mistake torpedos and you just leapt up to get to your station.

"Dawn was a desperate time, because that's when they attacked, as the ships were black against the rising sun.

"One of the biggest things in a battle at sea is the noise factor. There were 36 merchant ships and another 24 escorts, as well as maybe 30 aircraft that came at once, all firing at the same time. If you put that all together when you're standing outside with no ear protectors, the noise is just unbelievable.

"This was an important port for the Russian convoys, the first stopping-off point towards Iceland and these things should be remembered.

"It's very important that events like this are held. People should remember the convoys, the hazards people faced and the people who were lost. They must never be allowed to be forgotten."

'Ice on the deck'
Sandy Manson, aged 83 when he spoke last year, from John o' Groats, served in HMS Matchless on convoys in 1943-44.

"The weather was terrible. It was regularly 40 degrees below zero in winter and there would only be about half an hour of daylight at that time.

"There was ice in the sea, and on occasions ice-breakers had to cut through it.

"There was also ice on the deck and we had to wear special suits and gloves.

"You could not touch the steel rails without them or your hands would stick to them.

"We also had to wear a special harness, hoods and leather boots, a life belt and a special light, but if you went overboard you would not have lasted long in that water anyway.

"I never experienced cold like that before or since."

'Hundreds of men were lost'George Murdoch, from South Queensferry, was a telegraphy officer in HMS Zodiac, which helped escort the final convoy in March 1945. He spoke two years ago, aged 82.

"Every convoy had a lot of pressure on it, the eyes of the Luftwaffe watching them. The main difference with the Arctic run was that if you were sunk, you would only last about five minutes in the icy water.

"I was only on that one run, and the trip there was fine. We went around Bear Island and into the Kola Inlet to Archangel. But on the way back, we were hit as soon as we left the inlet; the first escort ship was sunk by a German submarine.

"I think maybe 35 men were rescued, but hundreds would have been lost."

'Terrible cold'
Geoffrey Shelton, 83, from Glasgow, who served on the aircraft carrier HMS Vindex.

"It was so cold. You came off watch and went down into the mess deck to get some sleep, but there was no heating down there and you could break the icicles off the deck head.

"But sometimes you wanted the terrible cold and the weather because it kept the U-boats down below and the aircraft couldn't fly.

"In the summer, there was almost 24-hour daylight – that was when you were most vulnerable to attack.

"The Fleet Air Arm pilots were the bravest of the brave, taking off and then trying to land an old string bag on a deck rising and falling 10-20-30ft.

"I watched one guy come in to land and end up in the sea alongside the carrier. The plane went straight down.

"The pilot had his lifejacket on and the captain put a blue search light on him, which was very dangerous because it could show us to the enemy.

"The admiral wasn't very pleased about this. I watched that lad calling out for help and the arm he was waving get lower and lower.

"By the time he was picked up 15 minutes later, he was dead."

'The worst weather'
"Spud" Campbell, 86, from Alabama, was in the SS Henry Bacon, right,the last Allied ship sunk by the Luftwaffe in the Second World War in 1945.

"We started at Loch Ewe and were told we were going into the most dangerous water in the world and it was. We went to deliver war materials which helped win the war I'm sure.

"We picked up some Norwegian refugees, who the Royal Navy had rescued. On the way back we had a tremendously difficult time, with the worst weather of the war, and then 23 aircraft came in and finally sunk the Henry Bacon.

"I went into the lifeboat with the Norwegians and, fortunately, HMS Opportune found us in the darkness of that Arctic area.

"The captain and 26 of our crew went down with the ship because we had insufficient lifeboats."

'It is simply too gruesome'
Keith Dyble, from Penicuik, was a gunner's yeoman on board HMS Cumberland. Speaking in 2006, when he was 86.

"Suddenly there was an explosion, and I saw that a merchant ship had been torpedoed and was sinking fast. I had to watch and listen to the screams of men in the water begging us to save them, but we couldn't stop. You had to go on, otherwise you would be destroyed. It was heartbreaking.

"People have no idea what we went through, and there is so much that will never be revealed because it is simply too gruesome.

"What I remember most vividly was PQ17, which was the 17th convoy to Russia. We had left Iceland as part of an escort fleet for 37 merchant ships. Only 11 of the ships made it through."








The full article contains 1488 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 09 October 2008 11:27 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Guga II,

Rockall 10/10/2008 02:06:19
Too many people forget the contribution made by the Merchant Navy during the war. If it hadn't been for these men, who were paid a pittance in comparison to the workers in ammunition factories, this country would have gone down the tubes.

Spare a thought also for the men on the Royal Navy escorts. Even on the Murmansk run, they were using armed trawlers with very little by way of guns to fight off the Germans.
2

K.M.,

Centreville 10/10/2008 02:06:42
how can the sea be -60 degrees without freezing?
3

Richardinho,

10/10/2008 02:16:11
I'm so proud of our efforts in propping up Stalin.
4

Guga II,

Rockall 10/10/2008 02:52:23
#3.

That's a silly comment to make. The Russians were our allies at the time. Moreover, it was the Russians that won the Second World War, not the English or the yanks.
5

Lianachan,

Highlands 10/10/2008 02:54:29
#1 Indeed - these people are often overlooked. My grandfather was on these Arctic convoys.

#3 Without the continued involvement of Russia, the Axis would almost certainly have won the war in Europe.
6

Graeme,

Guangzhou 10/10/2008 03:13:56
Gaga, #3

Very brave men and they did it for Great Britain.
Their grandsons and great grandsons would do it all over again if necessary.
You on the other hand get your cheap anti British shot in disparaging their names. Shame on you.
7

Navvy,

10/10/2008 03:36:21
my uncle was on these convoys on his return from the Far East - quite a contrast. When I worked on Flotta there were the remains of the shore facilities which the Navy used while replenishing between convoys
8

senza nome,

10/10/2008 03:40:47
#3. 20 million Russians died fighting the Nazis and they turned the tide of the war, so I am proud that we propped them up. We needed Stalin at the time.It doesn't mean we agreed with him.My father served on the Arctic Convoys and he is very modest about it and never got any medals.
The dangers involved are hard to imagine, so we should never forget them.The Russians don't.
9

Guga II,

Rockall 10/10/2008 04:03:39
#6 Gruamach.

Ah, the wee dwarf spouts some more rubbish. What are you on about little man? You are obviously taxing your solitary brain cell again. I can't see you "doing it again", you're too busy hiding in China from your creditors.

Ask your mother about my comments, and tell me, in detail, what I said that wasn't factual. Better still, get your mother to contact me directly as it will probably be too complex for you to understand.
10

Mikey,

10/10/2008 07:06:03
Gug, I agree with you completely! This half educated moron in China just doesn't have a clue! This clown and about half a dozen of the other posters would probably have been happier if Hitler had won!

My father was in the Merch and I joined in the early 70s. He sailed the Atlantic, North African and Med convoys. I sailed through the Iran/Iraq war and battled pirates in the straits of Malacca.

The likes of Gruamach and Rufus/bto are just little boys wrapped in their own version of the fasces who would run at the slightest threat to their wellbeing. Petty little men who are not fit to lace the boots of people like my father!
11

Ichabod,

10/10/2008 07:40:17
A man near me was on these convoys. He first served on the Malta convoy, just as bad but warmer weather! He has never forgotten those days, neither should we.
12

Richardinho,

10/10/2008 07:52:22
#5 'Without the continued involvement of Russia, the Axis would almost certainly have won the war in Europe.'

And instead Stalin won it. I'm so proud.
13

carrottop,

10/10/2008 07:53:38
My Canadian uncle always says that the silence was the thing that fraught the nerves.
14

Dave,

Western Isles 10/10/2008 08:03:42
Incredible times! We can only imagine what they went through.

Lets also not forget those brave souls on the Shetland Bus!
15

Nell,

Far from the Struan 10/10/2008 08:21:20
Ricardinho:- Stalin was a tyrant who persecuted his own people. But during WWII the Russian people had to fight against invasion by Hitlers forces. Millions died so doing. If they hadnt then it is possible we wouldn't have defeated Germany. I doubt if you would have been posting such comments if that had been the case.
16

James Donald,

Newbridge 10/10/2008 08:42:56
#4 Guga II,Rockall - "it was the Russians that won the Second World War, not the English or the yanks" - An equally stupid remark. Without the efforts of the Western Allies (including the arms and equipment sent via these Arctic convoys) the Soviet Union (as opposed to Russia) would have been unable to withstand the onslaught of the Axis powers.
17

Lianachan,

Highlands 10/10/2008 08:43:30
#15 The Russians were definately key to winning the war in Europe, that's beyond the doubt of anybody who knows anything about the war.

They did (and do) have a bad reputation in a lot of Europe, though. I remember reading a Ukrainian woman's memories of the war - she'd been raped by Germans heading east, who had also killed her father. Later in the war, she was raped by westward heading Russians, who also killed her brother.
18

Anton,

Porto Sant'Elpidio 10/10/2008 09:05:43
Actually, it wasn't the Russians winning the war.. Apart from the fact that without materials and weapons coming from the USA they wouldn't have had the possibility of fighting back the Nazis, what was paramount to Germany losing the war was the utter incompetence of Hitler as a strategist and the fear his generals had of him. Also, what proved the best Allied weapon was the Russian winter.
19

Anton,

Porto Sant'Elpidio 10/10/2008 09:12:11
The Arctic convoys were manned by extremely courageos sailors, both Navy and Merchant. I have a fair idea of what the cold might have been, and also the rough seas, but nothing can really convey to us today the feelings generated in those heroes by the knowledge of what was lurking at them, ready to strike. God bless them all, they KNEW what they were risking, and it wasn't a pleasant end...
20

Venachar,

10/10/2008 09:42:46
As civilians, merchant seamen faced the same statistical odds of being killed as, bomber rear gunners,front line infantry soldiers and fighter pilots during the Battle of Britain.
They also had the wonderfull experience of having their pay stopped when their ship was sunk.
My best friends father was an engineroom rating in WW2. He was sunk 3 times crossing the North Atlantic. First time he was picked up and got home. Second time he was picked up immediately by another ship and then that ship was torpedoed a few days late. He was the first person I knew that suffered from what we now call post traumatic stress disorder. For the rest of his life loud noises and enclosed spaces used to give him the willies.
The Erskine Home looked after him in the last few years of his life and as we are all aware they will have plenty of business for years to come given our current military commitments.
If we wish to remember then it would be a good idea to support any of the benevolent associations or organisations such as the Erskine Home.
21

Mad Jock,

East Lothian 10/10/2008 09:51:21
I was speaking to one of these veterans the other day, an RNR doctor, on the Murmansk run. Eventually, his ship took part in the D-Day landings, which he said they all thought was "very pleasant" in comparison.
No single nation can claim to have "won the war". There were significant contributions by all nations, which,, all things considered, might have changed the outcome had they not been made. Certain turning points were very significant. Dunkirk, and the recovery of 330,000 men that would otherwise ended up as POW's. The Battle of Britain, staving off the Nazi invasion of the UK. The sinking of the Bismark. Stalingrad, which tied up so much of Hitler's troops. Malta holding out for so long, leading to the interception of so much of Rommel's supplies for Afica, and the eventual invasion of Scicily. El Alamein, the turning point of the Desert War. The invasion of Italy. D-Day. The Falaise Gap. The Rhine crossing. The Battle of Berlin. The defeat of the U-Boats. Radar. The list goes on, but taken in isolation, none of these things won the war, but all contributed to it's outcome. Virtually none of these events happened using without the co-operation of another nation or nations. While some of you are bickering about Russians, Americans, English, British, you are insulting the memories of the thousands of Poles, Czechs, French, Norwegians, Australians, Kiwis, Canadians, Maltese, Malayans, Carribeans, South Africans, Rhodesians, Indians, Danes, Dutch, Hungarians, Greeks, Albanians, Yugoslavians etc etc; The list goes on, even if my memory doesn't.
We all needed each other. Just be thankful they all came when they did, or we'd all be speaking German.
22

Lianachan,

Highlands 10/10/2008 10:18:50
#21 Speaking of heroes, which is the general gist here, and with reference to Dunkirk (which you mentioned) - don't foerget those troops only got away due to the sacrifice (literally) of primarily Scottish troops. The 51st Highland Division in particular was abandoned on Europe by Churchill, as part of a political game with the French. It's one of the main reasons why Churchill doesn't enjoy as much respect up here as he seems to in the south.
23

Partan,

Fife 10/10/2008 10:35:10
#20
My dad was a RN DEMS gunner. He lost his best friend and most of the rest of the crew on a tub which probably wasn't fit to be at sea under normal circumstances. It burst its plates in a storm.
He suffered recurring nightmares for the rest of his life. He also disliked going to the beach or swimming pools because of the shouting, screaming and splashing that inevitably went on there.
24

Alternative (High-Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 10/10/2008 11:03:37
#2:

"how can the sea be -60 degrees without freezing?"

Because it is moving. The moment it stops moving, it begins to freeze. Another thing that used to happen is that in the magazines aboard ship, the sailors used to keep trudging round in circles in order to keep the water (from condensation) on the deck from freezing. If they didn't do this, they would have ended up with ice on the deck in the magazines---very dangerous.
25

Venachar,

10/10/2008 11:41:48
Personally I think the "Pedestal" convoy to Malta of August 1942 was the turning point of WW2. If Malta had not been saved then El Alamein might not have been possible. Winston Churchill would not have been able to give his "beginning of the end" speech.
I won't mention the disaster and sacrifice of PQ17, but the effort of the Merchant service and the Royal Navy to get the Pedestal convoy through really was heroic.
14 fast merchantmen left the UK. They were escorted by approximately 35 major warships. They battled all the way from Gibraltar to Malta.
Casualties among the escorts were 4 ships sunk, one an aircraft carrier, HMS Eagle I think it was and 6 ships heavily damaged. Of the merchentmen only 5 of the 14 ships got through. This included the tanker Ohio, it had to be supported to stop it sinking. It also had a crashed stuka divebomber on its fore deck.

Whether or not sons or grandsons would actually be able to do it is another matter. Unfortunately we don't really have a Merchant Navy left anymore. Post the Falklands a certain political party gave license to destroy an industry, something the Germans could not do in two world wars.
26

Ken S.,

Reading 10/10/2008 13:08:08
# 22 Lianachan

The 51st Division had nothing to do with Dunkirk. On arrival in France it had been placed under French command, manning a section of the Maginot Line down near Metz. The massive and rapid German advance to the Channel coast split the British forces. Those to the north of the thrust headed for Dunkirk. Those to the south, including 51st Division, undertook a fighting withdrawal to western French and over 200,000 were evacuated, as part of Operation Ariel. One of 51st’s brigades got out through Le Havre but the other two were heavily engaged by superior forces about 40 miles short of Le Havre, at St Valery-en-Caux. The Division was still within the French command structure and there was controversy arising from Churchill’s reluctance, for fear of offending French political sensibilities at a crucial moment, to restore 51st to British command so as to permit them to make an independent attempt to reach Le Havre. In the meantime the German forces had completed their encirclement, making surrender to overwhelming force superiority inevitable. Even if 51st had been immediately removed from French command, there is debate over whether it could have been evacuated. The same political/diplomatic dilemma would have arisen had the Prime Minister been a Scot and the 51st an English formation.

We should therefore pay tribute also to the Merchant Navy personnel who participated in Operation Ariel, including those lost when RMS Lancastria was sunk off St Nazaire. As they were from my county of birth, might I also mention the participation at St Valery, as an integral part of 51st Div, of the men of the Middlesex Regiment. I note also a memorial at St Valery to a 2nd lieutenant of the Argyll & Sutherland Highlanders – from Wolverhampton.

Would people please stop misusing the memory of the brave folk from all parts of the British Isles (and elsewhere).
27

Lianachan,

Highlands 10/10/2008 13:34:19
#27 Yes, I know. I just didn't see the point in going into as much detail as you did. The fact remains that Churchill is despised in areas of Scotland, and the Highlands in particular. Oh, and Dundee - for different, purely political, reasons.

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Churchills-Sacrifice-Highland-Division-France/dp/185753378X is an excellent book.
28

Ken S.,

Reading 10/10/2008 13:53:25
#28 Lianachan,

"..didn't see the point in going into as much detail.."
Had you not conjoined 51st and Dunkirk, I would just have accepted your mention of the French aspect, without responding.

The false linkage of 51st and Dunkirk crops up from time to time on these boards though the more usual distortion is of 'sacrificing Scots to save English blood'.
29

Mikey,

10/10/2008 18:05:38
My gransfather was taken prisoner at St Valery and spent five long years in Stalag VIIIB.

My mother tells me that when he came home, he wouldn't talk about his time away, but when seeing some German POWs working on the roads in Fountainbrifge, he spoke to the four of them in fluent German and bought them each a pie and ten fags. My mother was dumbfounded but he explained to her that 'these are just working men like me who were fighting for their country.'

He was a gentleman!
30

Ken S.,

Reading 10/10/2008 18:30:36
#31 Mikey,
What a wonderful attitude!

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.