Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Hamilton & Inches - the difference between

10,000 new depression cases in Lothians blamed on crunch

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 03 August 2009
THE number of people suffering depression in the Lothians has risen by almost 10,000, with the credit crunch being blamed.
Latest figures show that, up to the end of March, nearly 9 per cent of the population in the Lothians had been diagnosed depressed by their GP. That is a rise of more than 1 per cent, and coincides with the recession across the UK.

Now health experts and politicians are warning that the problem will only get worse as families' struggles with employment and finances continue.

The Scottish Association of Mental Health (SAMH) recently carried out a study which revealed people who have been affected by the credit crunch are eight times more likely to suffer depression than previously.

Chief executive Billy Watson said: "SAMH's recent research report, Crunch Time for Scotland's Mental Health, found that people who had been affected by the recession were up to eight times more likely to have sought treatment for mental health problems for the first time.

"We're seriously concerned that Scotland's mental health services are facing cuts just when they are most needed. The government must act to ensure that services exist to help those who have lost their jobs or are facing financial problems."

Figures released by NHS Lothian under Freedom of Information showed there were 77,000 people over the age of 18 diagnosed with depression last year. That compares to 68,000 the previous year, with the population of the Lothians at more than 800,000.

Conservative Lothians MSP Gavin Brown said: "These figures are concerning and the increase means we are moving in the wrong direction. My fear is that with the recession deepening and with more jobs being lost, these figures could continue to rise.

"However, it is our duty to ensure the level of care we provide for people suffering from mental health issues is appropriate, of a high standard, and that patients are treated with dignity.

"There must be a greater focus on early diagnosis and early intervention, with treatment and support made available for stress, anxiety, and depression.

"These steps can help to prevent the condition becoming more severe and enduring."

The Evening News revealed earlier this year that £10 million has been spent in the last two years on depression-fighting pills locally.

GPs are now considering alternative ways of helping those with mild to moderate depression.

This includes regular exercise and therapeutic reading.

Medics have been criticised in the past for being too quick to prescribe anti-depressants instead of working with the patient to find a better solution.


Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 03 August 2009 10:15 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

alfonsa pedrosa,

embra 03/08/2009 12:07:19
After reading this story the figures are now,10,001.
2

blackley,

Edinburgh 03/08/2009 12:11:32
If this is clinical depression then surely it strikes regardless of the economic climate? What we have now is a lot of people feeling down in the dumps! That's not strictly depression and it is to be hoped that they don't get prescribed addictive drugs without a second thought.
3

John Knox furr First Meenister,

High St, Embra 03/08/2009 12:50:04
Nothing to do with the credit crunch. It's the Trams and chaos and bins and crappy weather and people spitting their chewing gums out on the pavements . I could go on...
4

lauradoll,

Edinburgh 03/08/2009 12:59:32
If you have never been through depression yourself then its easy to think oh! they're just down in the dumps.
I've been off work since May( nothing to do with the economic climate) and am now getting better. There is still stigma attached to depression.I denied it for about 2yrs. The medication i was prescribed is helping as well
as counselling.Please Please don't judge what you don't
know. PS Anti depressants are not addictive.
5

Kimura,

Kobe 03/08/2009 13:04:53
I would add to the list.."Exercise and Reading" getting some company.
A good blether and a bit of humour, DO help for those with mild depression.
Oh! and a wee spot of trout fishing or hill walking.
6

totally indecent,

03/08/2009 13:07:23
4 - Some of them are Laura - try googling Seroxat. Good luck with it and I hope that's not what you are on.
7

Vandala,

03/08/2009 13:08:07
#4. They may not be addictive but the withdrawal symptoms when you come off them are absolutely ferocious – terrifying, violent, bloody nightmares for me for at least two weeks. In my opinion, anyone considering taking medication for depression should only do so only as an absolute measure of last resort.
8

Pantaloon,

03/08/2009 13:09:55
#4

I agree completely. I too have experienced depression and agree with you that anti depressants aren't addictive, its the psychological dependency on them that makes them 'addictive' to people and the belief that they can't get through the day without them.

But I also believe that you cannot attribute the recession on an increase in depression. My depression manifested itself over a number of incidents spanning several years, and I was probably pre disposed to getting it anyway. Financial worry may cause depression like symptoms, but as soon financial security is returned, will these people be ok again? If so then they aren't depressive.
9

Brianwci,

03/08/2009 13:22:02
Depression, like stress is no friend to the immune system. This will add to our woes when phase two of Swine Flu comes this winter.

Movement, sunshine and laughter are enemies of depression and like vitamin C they help to build the immune system.
10

The Busman,

03/08/2009 13:29:25
Depression can also be from a mixture of clinical and reactive factors - medication for the first, talk therapy for the second, is not mutually exclusive.
11

Foo,

03/08/2009 13:29:56
Beat depression, and reduce the strain on your bank balance by holidaying during the winter.

Although we don't get the best temperatures in the world here in Scotland, we do get exceptional daylight hours. Soak it up during summer, and book somewhere near the equator for the winter months.

12

Angus R,

03/08/2009 13:50:49
Drink yer problems away. Works everytime.
13

Blondie,

03/08/2009 14:13:22
Oh for heaven's sake - it's a credit crunch, not the end of the world! If these people think they've got it tough, how the hell would they have coped during the real "Depression" or two World Wars? In those days, there were no prescriptions being dished out right, left and centre - people just rolled up their sleeves and got on with things instead of wallowing in self-pity. We could do with more of that spirit these days!
14

valleyjim,

03/08/2009 14:21:34
I blame the lazy binmen.
15

wellieboot,

Edinburgh 03/08/2009 14:39:51
Folks,

Clinical depression - a pretty bleak thing to go through. Just wonder how many of these 10,000 are made up credit bingers. ie I've filled up my first credit card, now the second and oh carp the 3rd one's full up and now I've to pay it all back.
16

Ima Stoner,

03/08/2009 14:39:54
I know a few folk that do suffer from depression and are off work/getting support from work - but I also know some folk that use that as an excuse to claim benefits and have no intentions of working at all.
17

lauradoll,

Edinburgh 03/08/2009 15:11:35
Blondie!! I will not lower myself with a sarcastic comment.
Unless you have been there, don't judge people. I"m sure if you knew WHY some people suffer depression you wouldn't
say that we wallow in self pity.I don't want to air my
dirty linen in public. Try and have some empathy!!! Hope things never get to much for you . PS nothing to do with
debt lucky enough to say.
18

Garyoke,

Edinburgh 03/08/2009 15:27:37
#14 Blondie

You obviously have not been depressed. It's not about us people wallowing in self pity, We don't all sit around and bleat "woe is me". Depression is not a figment of someones imagination, it's a very serious issue which without proper support and help can become near life threatning. Depression is a proven chemical imbalance in the brain and not just a feeling of down in the dumps. You could tell sufferers all day to smile and cheer up... it's not gonna work. The hardest part of having depression is to admit it to yourself that you need help. Sufferers certainly don't need the likes of you telling them " you should have lived in the real depression or stop wallowing in self pity". Give me and my fellow sufferers a break please.

To all you out there that suffer from depression....

1) if you have been seeking help then good on ya, keep it going and it will get easier.

2) if you haven't asked for help... please please do so as there is a huge support network out there to help you.
19

Blondie,

03/08/2009 15:35:35
#18 and 19 - You have no idea whether I have any personal experience of depression or not, or whether things have ever got too much for me. All I can say is that I have experience of people who "play" on it and wouldn't know what real problems or depression were if they leapt up and bit them!
While you two may well be genuinely depressed, don't tell me that some of those 10,000 claiming to be "depressed" because of the credit crunch aren't at it! Whether you like it or not, some of them are - and some are very good at pulling the wool over people's eyes when it comes to seeking sympathy. I'll save my sympathy for those who truly deserve it.
20

lauradoll,

03/08/2009 15:50:43
So Blondie every man, woman who has been raped or sexually
abused should stop wallowing in self pity.Thank God the
world is not full of people like you.
21

Blondie,

03/08/2009 15:59:22
#21 I didn't say that for one moment - please don't put words into my mouth. There's a world of different between someone genuinely suffering from clinical depression because of some trauma in their life and someone who's down in the dumps because they're in debt, wouldn't you say?
I can distinguish quite easily between those who genuinely deserve empathy and sympathy because of circumstances beyond their control, and those who need to pull themselves together because their troubles are of their own making.
22

John Knox furr First Meenister,

High St, Embra 03/08/2009 16:02:29
#21 You're right. That's EXACTLY what she said!
23

Blondie,

03/08/2009 16:08:05
#23 You need to learn to read properly - where did I mention anything about rape or sexual abuse? The original article talks about people claiming to suffer from depression because of the credit crunch.
24

lauradoll,

Edinburgh 03/08/2009 16:10:03
Blondie, i didn't put words in your mouth. You came across
as tarring us all with the same brush. I didn't go to my doc and say I"M DEPRESSED DOC!! He told ME i was. I would not admit it to family or friends. laura.signing out for today.
25

Foo,

03/08/2009 17:00:26
You're all arguing as if anyone else cares what you define as true depression or not.

26

eDUCATIon,

03/08/2009 17:58:36



Im getting depressed reading this thread.....
27

eDUCATIon,

03/08/2009 18:03:27


If life was easy it would be boring!
28

,

03/08/2009 19:29:55
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
29

Douglas,

Bathgate 03/08/2009 19:47:22
You know what David? That's a perfectly valid point.
How did that happen?
30

MoiraMac,

03/08/2009 20:43:17
If I lost my job and the only way of getting by was to claim benefits then I think I would be depressed and claim disability allowance. It's almost enought to survive on whereas jobseekers allowance isn't!

Who can prove you don't have depression? You can afterall run a marathon or do a bungy with depression!
All part of the therapy!
31

is it me?,

Edinburgh 03/08/2009 22:19:44
As we used to say in the trenches,

"What's mental illness, as long as you've got your health?"
32

rob hadnum,

04/08/2009 10:14:59
10% of all people in lothains depressed, don't think so.

Try 8% are work-shy chancers using it to get signed-off. Depression has simply replaced back pain as the latest fad.

For anyone genuinely depressed, it's a terrible thing, but all these lazy scroungers don't help those in real need get help from the system. They know what to say to the doctor to get the diagnosis.

Trying to link this to the recession is completely stupid.

33

Proghead,

Embra 04/08/2009 11:52:27
What boll**s. People who are genuinely depressed haven't been made ill by the credit crunch. They wouldn't care less about a global problem as they are wrapped up in their own misery. If you think you are depressed because of the trams, you need to get a life.........

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.