Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


On the brink: Fuel price hike plunges Scottish fishing industry into crisis as one in five boats in Peterhead ties up and cost of food soars

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 28 June 2008
FOR five generations, the menfolk of the Stephen family have braved the waters around Scotland's northernmost shores to make a living. Now however, James Stephen fears he will be the one to witness the death of that proud heritage.
The latest skipper of the Harvest Hope is just one member of an Aberdeenshire town's historic but beleaguered fishing community, about a quarter of which is facing "financial jeopardy" due to ever- rising oil prices, according to industry leaders.

With the price of oil hitting a record high of $142 a barrel yesterday, Scotland's fishermen find themselves plunged into an even deeper crisis.

About a fifth of Peterhead's fleet remains tied up in the harbour due to the prohibitive costs. Crews are looking further afield for work, with skippers finding themselves left with no option but to pare back wages in order to make some semblance of profit.

Ordinary consumers, too, are likely to suffer. The Sea Fish Industry Authority estimates that the fuel crisis means the retail prices of fish could increase by as much as 50 per cent unless action be taken.

The pain caused by the oil-price crisis in Peterhead is magnified by geography. Just over 30 miles away, Aberdeen is enjoying huge benefits from the black stuff. The average weekly earnings in the city are £606.30 – about 20 per cent higher than the Scottish average of £503.70.

Geoff Runcie, the chief executive of Aberdeen Chamber of Commerce, says the economy of the North-east is demonstrating "considerable resilience to world economic uncertainties".

He is right, but only where the urban sprawls are concerned – and that is a world away from the fishermen of Peterhead.

In the space of only 12 months, the cost of filling 45-year-old Mr Stephen's vessel with standard red diesel has doubled. Before he even leaves Peterhead's Port Henry harbour for a nine- or ten-day trip at sea, he must pay as much as £28,500 for fuel alone, compared with a maximum price in 2007 of about £14,000.

Furthermore, due to the way fish are sold at auction, fishermen such as him are unable to pass on the costs. At the end of a ten-day trip, he is left with just enough to pay back interest on his bank loans.

The Scottish Fishing Federation (SFF) – the flag bearers for the nation's 5,435 fisherman and 2,191 vessels, which last year landed catches worth £380 million – insists that the plight of Mr Stephen and others can only be alleviated by government support, either from Edinburgh or London.

"Fuel prices at the quayside have increased by 40 per cent since January, and perhaps 25 per cent of the industry is now in financial jeopardy," Bertie Armstrong, the chief executive of the SFF, said. "Fishermen do not pay duty on fuel, but the industry is unable to pass on increases in anything like real time (as] fish is sold at auction. We are price takers, not price makers."

Final proposals for a package of support measures for European fishing fleets will be decided next month, but what is clear at this stage is that, while some financial help from Europe may be available, the bulk of the funding will need to come from individual EU member states.

According to Mr Armstrong, if the UK fails to come up with support, this could deliver a fatal blow to segments of the fleet. "It would lead to the nightmare scenario where some European fishing fleets will gain aid to help see them through the fuel crisis, while the Scottish fleet is given nothing and is put at a severe competitive disadvantage," he said.

"The Scottish fishing fleet is the third largest in Europe and it is imperative that we get support – otherwise our fishing industry could face the tragedy of an unplanned collapse."





The full article contains 670 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 27 June 2008 11:07 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

,

27/06/2008 23:56:58
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
2

An Beal Bacht,

28/06/2008 00:17:21
I see Angus still manages to get his post in before the thread opens. Magic?
3

An Beal Bacht,

28/06/2008 00:18:41
Is it Westminster's plan to destroy the Scottish fishing and hauling industries?
4

,

28/06/2008 00:19:01
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
5

Senga Jean,

28/06/2008 00:23:44
The answer is simple. Take your country back. Independence can mean that industries crippled by UK Westminster greed taxes are liberated. Scotland deserves better than rip-off Britain.
6

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 28/06/2008 00:25:07

Angus Ogg ~1,

You ruined my intended post with your opening post on here.

If you are being serious, this is sad news, all our posters are individuals and have their individual way of expressing themselves.

If AM2 was 111years old he did well, to keep his comments flying,

But one must respect others, I don't know why you felt it necessary to give us all this imformation.

And how do you know soo much,?

__________________

With that out the way, back to topic in my next post.
7

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 28/06/2008 00:34:28

"On the brink: Fuel price hike plunges Scottish fishing industry into crisis"

And the Government don't care a 'HOOT' Do They,?

Maybe no-one at Number10 eats fish! if they do, do what they do but in mammoth style,..

Put 6000% aggro tax on their 'fish and chips' let them suffer their own consequences! of their,..

All nearly 'TAX' you pay on Fuel!
8

celtic4,

USA 28/06/2008 01:17:41
Something can and should be done about the rising cost of fuel driving various people from badly needed jobs. And if the fishing industry suffers, food prices will also suffer, affecting everyone.
The same can be said for my country, by the way. Something can and should be done, but Congress and House are dragging their feet. The President has been really trying but his ideas are killed in Congress. Sad news for all of us, I am afraid.
9

Eric Ferguson III,

USA 28/06/2008 01:26:59
Idiots. You collect the used oil from the chippies and filter it under pressure. Mix it 50/50 with diesel and cut the price of fuel for fishing boats.
10

jerrymanders,

East Linton 28/06/2008 01:34:28
The cod aren't complaining.
11

2dogs in D.C.,

28/06/2008 01:36:35
AM2 gone? So many come and go, Scaramouch, RIP, AM2, 49thstate here briefly, then gone, galactic c. , and never forget that fine friendly fellow, Suck McCrunchie.
12

I H S,

28/06/2008 01:42:29
Funny, that!
13

jerrymanders,

28/06/2008 01:48:22
Is the fishing industry floundering? Or have they lost their sole?
14

Eric Ferguson III,

USA 28/06/2008 01:54:52
You know - I think that'll go back to sleep. Sir Sean might as well support the new Golf Club - we will never be free.
15

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 28/06/2008 02:17:14

Eric Ferguson III ~16,

"Sir Sean" and 'Trump' are well suited to go out in the same "Boat", run out of "Fuel" and NEVER come Back!
16

Traquir , Alba,

28/06/2008 02:53:41
On the Fisherman story this is just humiliating for
Scotland and our fishing industry something
has got to be done here.

One a separate topic here two wonderful news
scoops from the London Times :

"Scots Labour leader Wendy Alexander ‘on the brink of resigning'"

"David Marshall, the veteran MP for Glasgow East, had decided to resign from the Commons because of ill-health — which would prompt a by-election that would give the Scottish Nationalists a big opportunity."

see - tinyurl.com/6q52mv
17

,

28/06/2008 04:08:38
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
18

Traquir , Alba,

28/06/2008 04:33:19

An excellent day Scotland is getting rid of
two of the remaining 11 Labour Feeble Fifty
Sycophants ( see - tinyurl.com/3kmxfx )-

"Labour MP David Marshall to quit causing Brown more by-election woe"
see - tinyurl.com/6nsrau

"Strang thinks again and vows to quit as Mp"
see - tinyurl.com/63ftu9
19

Traquir , Alba,

28/06/2008 06:01:02
It gets better and better , Come on Elaine

"Labour fears that the SNP will select Scottish comedienne Elaine C Smith as their candidate. She lives in the constituency and is very popular locally."


http://tinyurl.com/6nsrau
20

catgut,

pomona 28/06/2008 06:30:19
not much hope or support for the fishing from our regular posters. please let them express their vanity under some other article
if boats did not have to pay 80,000 a year to buy fish from quota owners maybe they could pay their philipino crew men more than £11 a day.
21

The Tin Man,

28/06/2008 07:25:44
The wholesale price of fish has to increase to accomodate the increased price of duty-free diesil. If 20% of the fleet are tied-up, I am not too sure why the wholesale price dosn't raise? Don't see why the government would have to subsidise what is potentially a highly profitable business.
22

GrahamH,

Edinburgh 28/06/2008 07:51:57
#25. My diesel rate is around £1.06 a litre at the moment, I forward buy.

#3 - It isn't their intention but they bow to the anti road lobby at every turn and witter on about trains which can never deliver cans of beans to the back door of a supermarket or corner shop.

#9 - You are an aggresive and sadly ignorant American with your language. Ignorant as you are unaware that the UK government discourages use of recycled veg oil due to pressure from oil industry and vehicle manufacturers under similar pressure do similar.

I legally produced this arpund 10 years ago in UK when last strike was on, I had old oil supplied free, I had it recycled as you say and had a product at 20p a litre that worked 100% in large engines (not for cars). The government then insisted they take around 60p a litre a time for my 20p a litre product.

A jail sentance awaits anyone doing illegally and not declaring and paying duty.

#22. We all know the quota owners and the 'games' played with buying and selling of same. It would require government to re-shape quotas and surprised SNP not got more involved although in some ways with their links to key people in fishing is maybe not as surprising in some ways.

23

scottish person,

paisley 28/06/2008 07:57:50
Staying on the subject!!!!!
Where was gordon broon yesterday when this news was breaking? glastonbury! What a prat
24

JBowyer,

Australia 28/06/2008 08:09:32
Stop Whinging!!!!
The fuel cost is half tax so just get an exemption or start voting out your local politician. As soon as he sees his job in jeopardy it will have to stop.
Price for fish is astronomical! Let Captain Birdseye just spend another couple of days selling his catch for twice what he gets at auction. We pay five times the auction price. Fishing is an absolute racket the consumer pays a fortune and the fishermen whine? Grow a backbone and then use your heid!
25

Citylocal Fife,

Fife News 28/06/2008 08:21:42
Where is all the money going? Yes - fuel has gone up, but so has the price of fish, so who is making the money?
26

Shellfishfarmer,

Inverness 28/06/2008 08:36:17
If oil goes to $170 a barrel, Alastair Darling will have to do nothing less than a complete revision of his budget. Fishermen and farmers use red diesel at 5% tax rate. The rest of us, including haulage, have to pay the full whack of 60% tax. Life will become unsustainable in the Highlands at these prices. The solution? Take off all taxes on fuel and go back to progressive taxation. The more you earn, the more you pay. It couldn't be simpler. The Swedes have been doing it for years.
27

Phil C,

28/06/2008 08:49:35
#1 Apparently we're also losing Bendy Wendy! A bit of a blow for the SNP. Mind you when you see who might replace her, I foresee a big boost to Scotland's fortunes.
28

scottishcoffindodgerno1,

Tram City 28/06/2008 09:04:33
I'm still here,but then again i'm not a lib/liar unionist.FREE SCOTLAND
29

Phil the Flooter,

28/06/2008 09:30:40
So whats the score on here?

Try and 'out' someone and persecute them because you dont agree with them?
#1
Pretty worrying-Bullying someone on a forum is prety weak isnt it Angus Ogg? Whos next?

AM2 frequently shot many posters down in flames which explains why he/she was so hated.

Back to the playground.
30

Tweedmouth,

Coldstream 28/06/2008 09:42:06
I was in Eyemouth harbour a couple of weeks ago and the story was the same. One woman told me her son had been forced to buy a new engine for his boat last winter- at a cost 0f £68,000 - and that a single trip to Orkney had cost £4,000 in fuel. The five crewmen on board did not catch enough fish to even pay for the fuel - let alone any wages. She told me people were laying-up boats because they could not afford to fish.

Fuel taxes have risen unbearably under ten years of Scottish government of the UK (Blair, Cook, Reid, Brown, Darling) and these neo-marxists (ex communists in Reid's case) have created a vast tax burden to pay for their client state of benefit recipients, middle class quango-istas, local authority managers on £60k salaries, tier upon tier of extra government: MPs, MSPs, MEPs, Regional Assemblies, 'Scottish Development Agencies' ( a contradiction in terms if ever there was one). We now have millions of people who have never worked in several generations; millions more who have meaningless but high paid jobs in endless quangos; millions more on 'disability benefits', millions more new immigrants and asylum seekers with new 'rights; to housing, health, education and benefits. That is why your fuel tax is 80p per litre and why fishing boats cannot afford to make a living. None of the political parties has any solution because they are all committed to endless growth of the State. None of them will consider withdrawing from the EU and taking back the UKs fishing rights or territorial waters. Welcome to the new EUSSR.
31

Auckland Arab2,

28/06/2008 09:58:23
Lots of industries are suffering from the oil price. The issue here is that fishing is just not an important or strategic industry on a British scale and that's why nothing has been or will be done.
32

Jim P,

Netherlands 28/06/2008 10:03:56
ALEXANDER EXPECTED TO STEP DOWN!

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/scotland/7478913.stm
33

Herne the Hunter,

All of Scotland 28/06/2008 10:08:47
Never mind the personal bickering children, this is really serious for our home fishing fleet.First and foremost remove any excise duty from commercial marine and transport,its ridiculous that the oil that is costing so much is coming out of the seabed,in the same area as fishermen are fishing, surely if we own the oil then we must also own the fish. What I cannot understand is during the original Common market negotiations by Tory fishery minister Peter Walker ,why did we not agree that local fishermen fished their own territorial waters and supplied a proportion of their catch into a collective common European market place,that way we are all geographically responsible for our own fish in our own area.Instead of every fishing boat in the ECC clearing the fish stocks all around our coasts.We now have to live with the legacy of bad legislation and unjust negotiations. May be its time to renegotiate under a Scottish Government perspective.
34

The Tin Man,

28/06/2008 10:08:53
#33 Tweedmouth

But fishing boats are fueled with tax-free diesil. It dosn't have anything to do with fuel duty, it is solely to do with the global oil-price.
35

Roy,

28/06/2008 10:40:56
Genuinely sorry to see the passing of Suspendy Wendy.

Bring back sails.
36

The Ghost of Sir William Arrol,

The Forthy Bridge 28/06/2008 11:01:57
Sad for Skippers who have invested in boats that are unsustainable. Red diesel attracts little in the way of tax so it's global oil prices that are the problem. Prices are driven by supply and demand, currently demand outstrips supply, hence rising oil prices. The situation may reverse temporarily, seeing a drop in prices, but the long term trend as oil supplies become exhausted will be upward, very steeply so, and in a few years time today's energy prices will seem cheap.

Perhaps a reduction in industrial over-fishing, hoovering up every living thing for hundreds of miles, will see a huge recovery in fish stocks which will enable more sustainable fishing to make a nice return from shorter trips. Time to learn how to use sail power again!
37

Angus Ogg,

28/06/2008 11:24:01
#18 W. Smith

Why am I a disgrace?

I didn't reveal AM2's details, just made a jockular comment. In fact the last time I encountered AM2 I agreed totally with him and at his suggestion I ended up sending £10 to David Davis election campaign. So it shows what you know Smithy. Fluck All (The bad word was in hommage to Conan the Librarian's marvellous wee idea yesterday to have a sort of literary tourettes in order to confound the automated Scotsman rude word machine).

Last but not least, I am not an SNP member. I was a Labour member. But no more.

As they say in the Labour Anonymous meetings, I am 224 days clean now.

So Mr Smith, away and bile yer heed.
38

Angus Ogg,

28/06/2008 11:28:02

#2 An Beal Bacht, the threads usually open about 9pm the night before when the Scotsman Editorial team start assembling the next days online copy. You just need to know the combination on the back door of their computer. Believe me I can barely work email, and it aint like solving an Agatha Christie thriller.

It amazes me how nobody else posts a little before midnight. I only do it because bedtime at Ogg Croft is 11.30pm every night just after Newsnight Scotland finishes.
39

Angus Ogg,

28/06/2008 11:35:52
#2 An Beal Bacht

These web-board pages usually open between 9pm and 10pm the night before main publication as the Scotsman Editorial Team assemble the next day's online version. You just need a little curiosity and lateral thinking to pop in by the back door. I can barely work email, and have an Amstrad 8256 for a computer. So it amazes me with all these computer whizz kids how nobody avails themselves of an early turn.

The only reason I post is that bedtime at Ogg Croft is 11.30 pm just after Newsnight Scotland, and the generator goes off then so we don't have any power. Also, I cannot keep awake for the small hours like all these youngsters can. My days of partying stopped in the 1970's with the end of the Disco Era. Though I understand they aren't called discos any more something to do with garage or shed music. Why anyone would want to dance in their garden shed is a mystery.
40

Angus Ogg,

28/06/2008 11:42:34

Jings, sorry guys about double posts at 42 and 43. I am not having a senior moment. Really. The Scotsman's website is telling me I am using words that aren't allowed so I retyped everything again.

Just wanted to add for #6 Charles. My apologies for interupting your wanting the number 1 post. The subject of the Fishing Industry is a serious one. I have a friend that built a new boat about 6 years ago and he is really struggling. If the quotas weren't bad enough, exponential fuel price increases are putting him and his partner very close to the wall.

Last but not least, I didn't and wouldn't publish AM2's details, no matter how much I disagree with him.

I wish him a good and humorous fairwell. Though suspect that we will be having The Ghost Of AM2 haunting these boards very soon indeed.
41

Angus Ogg,

28/06/2008 11:51:10
#31

Please read the postings properly. I DID NOT out AM2. I merely posted a small eulogy and quoted the link to the poster that did apparently out him.

At least I didn't do what you did.
42

Geoff,

sa 28/06/2008 11:59:52
Its a sad day for freedom of expression if AM2 has indeed been hounded off this thread. I always found his posts well researched and articulate. If you are reading this old friend, I hope you will reconsider. We should never give in to extremists-I hope you are able to re-enter the debate even under a different name. The behaviour of some of the contributors here is disgusting. Also whilst nobody has a monopoly on loutishness I would say to some of the more extreme SNP supporters here that your constant insults and personal attacks can only be counter productive to your cause. Attitudes it would seem are hardening in Scottish politics-if you saw Wendy alexanders resignation speech I am sure you must have noticed the bitterness in her tone. Such indcreasing polarisation will see Scotland split into 2 irreconcilable camps that could leave the whole Constitutional debate as a festering sore on the land-much as in Quebec or the Basque lands.
43

Geoff,

sa 28/06/2008 12:36:44
On the thread, one must feel enormous sympathy for fisherman everywhere-not only to they have to face the dangers in their job but the fuel crisis is an added burden. It must though be said, that the fuel hikes will affect liveliehoods everywhere and in many fields of endeavour.
44

Hetman,

USA 28/06/2008 12:45:57
The thing to do is to stop looking for government bailouts, which never work in the end and become self-sufficient. The waters of Scotland were fished before oil and will be after. It requires adaptation and a little vision. Your worst enemy is central government. They have everybody under control and thinking that only the government can save you. By the way, we have the same problem here.
45

,

28/06/2008 12:51:20
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
46

,

28/06/2008 13:38:14
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
47

Paulc37,

Fairfax Va. 28/06/2008 16:20:59
It seems unthinkable, but, when you do think about it, Saudi Arabia is financing and manning terror all over the world. They must be invaded and their Oil confiscated or people starve. These terrorist people must be brought to heel to the death, destruction they have already inflicted upon the innocent and their intent to continue as they build and finance hate spewing Mosques and supporting groups like the Muslim Brotherhood.

When is the civilized World going to wake up its at war with Muslims?
48

lynitic,

U S A 28/06/2008 17:26:43
In the states quite a few people are going back to basics. The work may be harder but it's more fullfilling. Roy is right with the gasoline engine we took the fishing out of fishing. It's called snagging now. Throw in a net and snag some fish. It all has to do with money not survival. What's going to happen when they take your boats.
49

Schot,

28/06/2008 17:34:54
Looks like it is you Paul who is spouting hatred. Still, the civilised world thanks you for imaginative opinion, recommends you learn how and when to capitalise. Reading and writing may seem unnecessary skills, but honestly once you master them they open up new ways of looking at the world.

Alternatively, why not just fly to Saudi Arabia yourself and tell them what you think of them ?
50

Paulc37,

28/06/2008 18:51:38
Schot

An out--------standing comment.
51

Beth Boyle,

NY 28/06/2008 20:46:56
This story is heart breaking.
52

Beth Boyle,

NY 28/06/2008 20:48:47
#52 I am so sorry we live in the same country. You are sick!
53

Paulc37,

28/06/2008 21:57:58
Beth Boyle

So all Mafia Members are not Criminals?

Islam is a terrorist organization Masquerading as a religion.

Ignore that or start to read about this Organization that spreads its ideology by killing and terror. Your from NY. Who do you think killed 3000 Americans in one hour while yelling Allah Akhbar? Islam for 1400 years has Terrorized and Killed Non Muslims. We fought the Pirating Muslims in 1802. Why do you think Thomas Jefferson had the Koran? If you read the Koran it tells Muslims to kill the infidels. That's you and they did on 9/11. Are you going to do some homework or think with emotion.

And Obama was raised a Muslim and associated with them his whole life. Tell me who your friends are and I'll tell you who you are.
54

jerrymanders,

28/06/2008 21:58:59
#52

What exactly has this got to do with fishing in the seas around Scotland? Go see a therapist.
55

Schot,

28/06/2008 22:22:08
Beth,

Don't be too sad. 60% of the British catch is still landed in Scotland. Scotland's fleet could revert to sail soon as oil gets too expensive, assuming there are still fish to catch. They are also starting to catch more exotic beasts like squid.
http://www.scotsman.com/climatechange/Squid39s-in-and-the-bees.4144435.jp?CommentPage=1&CommentPageLength=1000

Paul's comments are sadder. In Scotland we'd call him a 'saddo'. If you don't want to live in the same country as him, and he isn't man enough to move to Saudi Arabia, then you could always move here. With a name like Beth Boyle your family probably came from here, and the SNP are encouraging everyone home.

Personally I am for totally open immigration for anyone regardless of ancestry as long as the immigrant is is either pleasant, intelligent, good-looking or good at football. In fact I'd be for forcably deporting locals who don't match at one of those criteria.


56

Paulc37,

28/06/2008 22:22:18
jerrymanders

Who controls the price of oil? Primarily the Muslim States? They already got you virtually praying on your knees as they squeeze you out of a livelihood. I suggest you start thinking outside the box.
57

Paulc37,

28/06/2008 23:22:10
Schot

What if Mary Beth is not "your" definition of good looking or are you more democratic and take polls before throwing out immigrants.

Your a good one to talk. What a sad/pathetic criteria to judging others.
58

Schot,

28/06/2008 23:48:21
"What a sad/pathetic criteria to judging others."

I take it from your negative response to my criteria that apart from being dim and unpleasant that you are also ugly and bad at football ? Nae luck, but most of those flaws you could improve on with a little effort. I realise now asking you to capitalise properly was an unfair request that could only embarrass you. I apologise.
59

Schot,

28/06/2008 23:53:00
ygUDuh

ydoan
yunnuhstan

ydoan o
yunnuhstand dem
yguduh ged

yunnuhstan dem doidee
yguduh ged riduh
ydoan o nudn

LISN bud LISN

dem
gud
am

lidl yelluh bas
tuds weer goin

duhSIVILEYEzum
60

Sprightly,

Oxshott Surrey 30/06/2008 08:46:05
Has no-one told G Bush that they have discovered huge reserves of oil in Zimbabwe? Near the Motopos Hills. Shhhhh, it's a secret. We do not want a US led UN 'peace-keeping' force to invade Zimbabwe, track down Mugabe, have him sentenced by his own people and executed, do we.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.