Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Tuesday, 13th May 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

All you need to know about ID fraud



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 22 November 2007
HM REVENUE and Customs' loss of the details of virtually every family in the UK with a child under 16 is undoubtedly the biggest and most serious breach of personal information the country has ever seen.
The admission by the Chancellor, Alistair Darling, has unleashed widespread fear that the details could fall into the wrong hands to be used for criminal gain.

It has also thrust into the public glare the issue of identity fraud, which has been burgeoning over the years, alongside legitimate technology, and now costs the UK an incredible £1.7 billion a year.

Information has long been easy to obtain - through, say, hastily discarded bank statements or paper applications for the likes of store cards.

But with the proliferation of social networking websites, the growth in online banking, and the explosion of internet shopping, our personal details are much more widely disseminated than ever before.

Here, The Scotsman looks at what identity fraud is and who is committing it against whom. We also explain how you can do your best to protect yourself - first by preventing your details from falling into the wrong hands and, if that does happen, how to prevent the details being used for criminal ends,

Q & A: GUARD YOURSELF AGAINST IDENTITY THEFT
Wh

at
is identity fraud?
It
is using information belonging to another person for gain - be it monetary or in the form of goods or services. It starts with identity theft - when the information is stolen - and becomes fraud when it is used for profit.

What
are the key pieces of information thieves want?
Id
entity theft can be committed if a third party has only a name and address, but the more details they have, the easier it is for them to adopt the identity. These could include date of birth, place of birth, bank account details and credit card details.

What
will this information be used for?
On
ce thieves have accumulated enough information, they can approach financial institutions with it and apply for credit. They can also try to access existing accounts.

How
else might an identity thief use my details?
It
is becoming increasingly common for the thief to sell on the details to a third party, rather than using them directly. This would see the details go on the information black market, where hundreds of thousands of people could potentially access them.

Who
are the identity thieves?
In
97 per cent of cases, the perpetrator is unknown to the victim, making identity theft a highly unusual crime. The thieves often start by rummaging through people's rubbish to find out personal details. However, there was the high-profile case this summer of Jeannie Smith, 45, of Denny, near Falkirk. She pretended to be her sister, Linda Cowan, 35, obtaining £123,000 of goods in the process.

Who
are the identity theft victims?
Am
ong the groups most at risk are graduates renting private accommodation; young couples with children and high outgoings; young, reasonably affluent single people in shared, rented accommodation; successful people from very wealthy households, and high earners who live in premium city addresses.

Londoners are four times more likely than the UK average to become victims of ID fraud - of 54 areas classified as very high risk, 20 are in London. Fraudsters have used birth certificates to impersonate dead people - a crime known as jackal fraud, after the novel The Day of the Jackal.

How
does identity theft happen?
Of
ten, people are too eager to give personal information away. Research has shown that many do not think twice before answering surveys or filling in forms. Social networking sites such as Facebook attract members who reveal their most intimate secrets. Experts are concerned that we do not employ the same safeguards in the virtual world as in the physical one.

How
else can it happen?
Fa
ke websites, purporting to be those of banks, have been set up to steal account holders' details. The organisations which hold data can also physically lose it, such as the HMRC auditor who lost thousands of investors' details.

What
happened in that case?
A
computer belonging to an HM Revenue and Customs employee was taken from his car in London. He had been using it for a routine audit of tax information from several investment firms. It contained details of customers from companies including Standard Life and Liontrust.

Have
there been any other major information security breaches recently?
As
ide from the catastrophic loss of the entire child benefit database this week, a CD containing the personal details of thousands of Standard Life pension holders went missing from HMRC, leaving them at heightened risk of identity theft. Nearly 15,000 customers were warned to be on high alert for potential scams after their data was lost in transit by a courier.

How
can I protect myself?
Be
fore you give out personal information, stop and think who you are imparting it to - and why. Are they a respected body or not? If you are filling in a form, either on the internet or on paper, check the box which says you do not want your information to be passed on.

Also, if you buy goods online, use only one card, and make it a credit card rather than a debit card.

My c
hildren use social networking sites - should I be worried about their identities?
Tr
y to educate youngsters to behave in the virtual world as they would in the physical world - by not passing on information about themselves to strangers. They should also be aware of what information they are allowing to be viewed by anyone.

Are
there any other steps I can take to guard against identity theft?
Yo
u could make sure your bank and credit card account passwords do not relate to the data that could be compromised.

For example, do not use details such as your children's names or your street name. Fraudsters are likely to make a good guess at such passwords - so make sure you update them on a regular basis.

Can
companies sell on my personal data?
Ye
s. If you do not tick the box on the form you are filling in which prevents them, they can either sell it on or swap it with companies they deal with regularly. They can sell it on to mailing lists which are used by other firms, although the information is not worth much.

How
easy is it to access bank accounts?
No
t very. Someone could either try to go into a branch with a sort code and account number and withdraw cash, or they could hack into the account on the internet, using online banking.

Have
banks got any protection in place to stop this happening?
Ye
s. Online banking security is improving and there are now normally two levels of checks in place before a user can access the account. In the bank, users will normally have to enter their personal identification number to withdraw cash.

How
will I know if someone has accessed my account?
Mo
dern fraudsters are moving away from the "smash-and-grab mentality", which dictates they get in and out as quickly as possible with as much cash as possible. They are now more likely to siphon off small amounts of cash over long periods of time. This means that any changes to an account may not be very obvious. Bank accounts should be checked carefully.

Will
my bank notice if my account has been compromised?
Mo
st banks will contact you if they notice any suspicious activity on your account to confirm that it has not been hacked into. If there is a known identity theft, they will also step up monitoring of accounts.

How
else might I know if my identity has been appropriated?
If
you receive any suspicious letters congratulating you for signing up for a loan you know nothing about, or thanking you for your application for a credit card, do not ignore it.

It could be a clue that someone else is out there masquerading as you. Call the company concerned and get to the bottom of it as soon as possible.

Similarly, watch out for hoax calls trying to extract more information from you. A criminal may have got some of your personal details but needs more to execute a fraud.

How
likely is it my information will be lost from a government department?
On
e in four data breaches in the UK occur within government departments - and government departments hold all manner of personal details, from pension funds to child benefit accounts.

Will
I be told if my data has gone missing?
Th
e government recently dismissed the idea of a breach notice instrument proposed by the House of Lords. This would have required organisations to disclose when information security had been breached and how they proposed to protect the victim against fraud and identity theft following the loss of their information.

What
about the Data Protection Act?
Th
e Data Protection Act regulates how your personal information is used and protects you from misuse of your personal details. It provides a set of eight data protection principles, which prohibit the misuse of your personal information without stopping it being used for legitimate or beneficial purposes.

A "data controller" - someone who holds your information - must abide by them. There are also stronger protections for sensitive information, such as that which relates to religion and sexuality.

What
are the principles?
Th
ese require personal information to be: fairly and lawfully processed; processed for limited purposes; adequate, relevant and not excessive; accurate; not kept longer than necessary; processed in accordance with your rights; kept secure, and not transferred abroad without adequate protection.

What
rights am I afforded by the act?
Th
e act, with some exceptions, gives you the right to find out what information is held about you by organisations. This is known as the "right of subject access". On written request, you are entitled to be supplied with a copy of all the information an organisation holds about you.

The organisation may charge a fee for providing the information, up to a maximum of £10 in most instances and up to £50 in the case of manual medical records.

To see what information is held on you by credit reference agencies costs £2.

Does
it have any provisions for instances when my information is misused by the data controller?
Pe
ople who suffer damage because of a breach of the act are entitled to compensation from the data controller. They can also claim for any distress they have suffered.

If I
am a victim of identity fraud what will the consequences be?
Th
ey could be very wide-ranging, depending on what your identity is used for. At the worst end, you could find you are implicated in a criminal investigation. You could be turned down for a mortgage and lose out on a new home while the mix-up is sorted out.

Your credit rating could plummet and it will take time to fix. If your bank account is accessed, you will have to spend time sorting it out.

It takes an average of 539 days to discover that you've become a victim and it can then take a further 300 hours of work to clear your name.

How
big an issue is identity theft in the UK?
Ma
ssive - and growing all the time because the amount of information out there is vast and easy to access. Last year there were 178,000 victims in the UK.

How
much is identity fraud costing us?
La
st year - £1.7billion. Average losses ranged from almost £2,000 on a credit card to more than £7,000 on a current account.

Is t
here a greater cost?
Ye
s. A lot of the sale of information is used to fund other crimes.

The identities adopted can be used to pursue terrorist agendas. Identity theft was a factor in the 9/11 attacks.

The full article contains 1987 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 22 November 2007 12:23 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Identity cards
 
1

Jason,

Japan 22/11/2007 02:20:59

Do a search and you'll find that over the passed few years HMRC have been the victim of white-collar crime to the tune of literally billions of pounds. And I’m not talking only of the guy that changed his name to Mr. I. Revenue. "You pay, we give it away" must be their motto. You tell them again and again by letter and phone that you emigrated years ago, but they still try to tax you as if you were in UK on the same income. Demanding tax on income you didn’t earn for a period you weren’t even in UK. Partly this comes about because they keep transferring taxpayers between offices and the paperwork gets lost in transit. So you have to start all over. The real clincher is when they send a form demanding reasons you left UK. "Harassment from IR" being top on the list. Did I mention humourless?
But this time their incompetence has seriously inconvenienced them. Still at least someone at the top has had the integrity to take responsibility and resign. Refreshing change wouldn’t you say Sir Ian, Alistair, George …?

2

Ard Righ,

The Rock Of Edinburgh 22/11/2007 02:24:07

NEVER FORGET WHO YOU ARE.
NEVER FORGET YOUR TRUE HISTORY.
NEVER FORGET YOUR IDENTITY.

NEVER SELL YOUR LIBERTY FOR ANY PRICE.
NEVER ACKNOWLEDGE FACELESS POWER
NEVER ACCEPT ID CARDS

DESTROY YOUR CREDIT CARDS
SET UP CASH TRANSACTIONS AT ALL TIMES
BUY WHAT YOU NEED, NOT WHAT YOU WANT.

3

Big Alan,

22/11/2007 02:36:00

"All you need to know about ID fraud"

There's a starter pack to tell you all about it on ebay - it comes complete with 25 000 000 identities to try out.

We really know who put the tit in identity now!

4

TommyKaye,

UK 22/11/2007 02:49:31

Number 2 I love it.

Are you the Omega Man?

5

Guga II,

Rockall 22/11/2007 06:49:43

And that clown Maggie Broon actually thinks that people will go along with his ID card proposal and its massive database.

Not only would the information contained in it be accessible by all sorts of people, including local councils, but there is no doubt that it would be hacked into, or misappropriated by someone with access to it.

There is a fortune waiting to be made on the back of Maggie Broon's ID card database.

6

Boy Wonder,

22/11/2007 06:49:44

I shred everything. It's a pity banks, hospitals and the Civil Service, who continually remind us to beware of possible ID fraud, do not!

7

Rulesbutnotrulers,

Don't follow any leader with GB initials. 22/11/2007 08:08:09

Why don't 'they' just phone us up to check if we have made such and such unusual or more frequent requests? Our credit was cloned abroad. A simple call would have verified fraudulent use. This isn't the total answer, of course, but every little helps.

8

Roy,

22/11/2007 08:11:30

Maggie Broon will undoubtedly press ahead with his ID card crusade, while simultaneously practising his new-found art of being 'profound'.

A job for a 'culture change facilitator' floating around here somewhere.

9

weeshooie,

Livingston 22/11/2007 08:12:01

What is all the fuss about? HM Government department, DVLA will sell your identity for a fiver and have been doing so for years. where does data protection come in?
Job Centre plus have been emailing your detailed claims to the local authorities for years and nothing has been done about it.
Government department NHS will provide an insurance company with your complete medical history whether or not you have signed a waiver. I know, it happened to me.
Data protection is only there for appearances to make you think the Government is protecting your identity.
ID cards will probably be sold to the highest bidder and God knows who that will be.
sorry to be so cynical, but I would not trust this Government with my dogs ID, which is better protected than mine.

10

Guga II,

Rockall 22/11/2007 08:14:28

#9 weeshooie. Are you home for the New Year?

11

Sinnerman,

Another Planet 22/11/2007 08:39:50

It does not matter which gang of self-seeking numpies is in power, they will always fall foul of the numpties employed in the civil service departments.

12

Cal,

Edinburgh 22/11/2007 08:53:11

Identidy fraud is buisnesses being defrauded not individuals. All this nonsense above as about business losing money because they are too willing to hand over goods or services on the flimsiest of evidence - don't believe the hype. ID fraud is commercial crime not a crime against the individual.

13

Jeeemy,

22/11/2007 08:55:59

Your identity has been compromised by successive governments since Margaret Thatcher spent £250 million on a computer system way back.
This system has cracked all data and can access all encrypted data bases in this country, the control words are “National Security” Prior to Mrs Thatcher leaving office she again spent a similar amount refurbishing it, to make it work faster.
Now we at present do not know how much money was spent during Tony Blair’s years on that system, which is being with held under the thirty year rule and the need to know culture.
The freedom of information act can not be used to acquire information, and as we all know the government can spend monies as and when they see fit to bury information at will.

14

scottish person,

paisley 22/11/2007 09:32:33

Jeannie Smith is a perpetrator! What about Baldy who killed the young scot in Shawlands, are the hootsmon scared to say who the real perpetrators are, in case of the racist card being shown.

15

The Federalist (the poster formerly know as NAUON),

22/11/2007 09:45:06

A lot of your personal information is already readily available - often through paid-for internet sites. Every time you use the net - register at a site or have a cookie placed in your PC you are sending personal information back. Then there are the data miners and spybots monitoring our activities and every key stroke - this is a bigger danger than the loss of these files.

16

yolanda,

22/11/2007 09:45:26

"How can I protect myself?
Before you give out personal information, stop and think who you are imparting it to - and why. Are they a respected body or not?"

Well, they're not now!!

17

Walkerman,

22/11/2007 09:53:00

#14. Whit? Have you been at the sherry?

Back on topic.... Will there be a full and transparent public enquiry regarding this latest shambles? Surely we are entitled to more than our esteemed (yeah, right!) politicians being wheeled out to say we're sorry that this happened. Not good enough. If they aren't up to the job (which obviously they aren't), they should all be sacked.

Good advice in the article about protecting ourselves. The problem is that our private information is in the hands of a mickey mouse establishment who can't, or won't, protect us from their own incompetency.

18

rogerB,

Perth and Hong Kong 22/11/2007 10:56:36

We are responsible for our identity not others. Understand that and you will go a long way to keeping it "secure". I have a national identity card and a passport. I find the ID card extremely useful. No government knows (to the best of my knowledge) the access codes to to anything I need kept secure e.g bank accounts. However the banks do and they are more adept at loosing information than Governments so I use more than one credit card and bank ...... I get annoyed by credit card companies phoning to verify small transactions asking if it wiz mee who spent it... I have had refunds when it wizzny but I am happy if they ask for verification of really unusual transactions, often on the spot.
SO STOP BLAMING OTHERS
I suspect I am more likely to lose a wallet of cash than my identity and more likely to die crossing the road than crashing my car or crash in other means of transport.
Instead of witch hunting those in office realise Darling had little to do with this. He is like the bowsprit of a ship, there to look good but he has no hope of knowing what the Civil service is doing not to mention the if deck hands are having yet another fag break.
Education used to begin in the home but I see little evidence of that holding true.

19

Remember 1820,

Glasgow 22/11/2007 10:57:14

Get real here.

We are talking about millions of peoples personal identity here, and their bank security, etc, etc. In other words their lives, for as long as they live.

It is very serious indeed !.

And it's not only Mr Darling who should resign, it is also Mr Gordon Brown as he is the man in charge, and was involved in setting up the systems and giving it the ok.

This appears to be run by the same company who ran the election in May.

It appears that the DWP asked for people’s names and National Insurance Numbers ONLY, and was given the COMPLETE data on millions of people. Seemingly this was cheaper than filtering the data, which they should have done.

Very few people should have access to this information, and should not be able to access it, and remove it, without the highest security authority.

It really is basic computer security and Government must take their responsibilities seriously.

This could cost the Government, ie. you and me Billions of pounds.

And these are the same people who want to make it mandatory for people to give them all of their personal data, in the form of a Biological ID Card.

In the old system it is possible that you could eventually get a new account and password when things go wrong.

In the new Biological ID Card system, how is it possible to go out and get a new set of eyes or fingerprints if things go wrong.

Think about it !.

We haven't heard the last of this one yet.

.

20

Ken S.,

Britain - and not very proud of it just now. 22/11/2007 11:08:51

Simple solution: Sack the clerk who simply did what he was told. Voila; sorted.

Ignore the culpability at several more senior levels that permitted a system with such cavalier disregard for the basic principles of data security, governmental or otherwise.

21

Greenloaning view,

Central Belt 22/11/2007 11:32:40

The Millennium bug ate the missing discs.

Name and address with-held for security purposes.

22

KitWilding,

Greater Britain 22/11/2007 11:33:48

Going back to the original story, where were the disks lost?
The post was blamed and another report says they were sent by TNT Courier.
If HMRC cannot even be correct on this point, what hope is there.
Maybe the post was blamed, because the Post Office has such a bad reputation whilst TNT has shareholders whose investment must be protected!

PS Why should my taxes be used to bail out Northern Rock investors who presumably invested there for an attractive rate of interest. The higher the return, the more your savings are at risk. Rock investors are getting protection from the government yet those who play safe and invest in National Savings are being hit twice. Lower rates of interest and higher taxes to bail out the Rock.

I seriously feel £20 notes under the bed are safer!

23

rogerB,

Perth and Hong Kong 22/11/2007 12:53:41

What happend in 1820?

We need to know what data was lost in detail. It is easy to get names, names of famiy members, addresses, dates of birth but should not be easy to get NI numbers (that is a bad disclosure). Bank account numbers and branch addresses should not be easy to get but somehow it does not appear difficult.
Pass codes/pin# the second step security should not be easy to get and should not be known by the tax man so should not be out there with this leak?

Instead of panicking the country the Press should be doing a responsible job of improving the government - not attempting to sack it.

The "tax man" was correct in refusing to spend tax revenues filtering the information. The Audit officers should have gone to where the "sensitive" data was and taken their audit sample - just as was necessary when data was only on paper. No you must send it to us......

Yes the government is ultimately responsible for this but we elected it. This matter needs to be approached in a constructive way. The Civil Service (not an indivuidual employee) is at fault (and would be no matter the name of the Minister in charge) be it due to cuts in resources or other more likely reasons. My view is two "lazy" parts of the civil service created the spark that caused this fire. We should put the fire out instead of fanning the flames and warming our hands by it, as the TV Political commentators so visbly are.

There is no need for all information to be on one data base. There is no need for bank details to be on a National Identity card. No one department or organisation needs all the personal details of any one individual let alone half the nation.

Access to sensitive data is not difficult to manage properly.

However now presently have parents, and especially single parents, convinced their money is going to be stolen over night and over many nights to come.

Identity theft/fraud usually means a new a

24

The Federalist (the poster formerly know as NAUON),

22/11/2007 13:26:45

#23 Good post - many in the press are reporting (inaccuaretly) what can be done with the data. The biggest threat is ID theft but then we already face that problem because of the number of locations data is held insecurely on individuals - not just by government by the way.

25

Paula,

22/11/2007 14:00:42

The really good news is that if you are targeted and become a victim of identity fraud you are completely on your own as the authorities will do absolutely nothing.

That is why it is such a lucrative business for criminals, they know they will get away with it and any money they steal.

26

Remember 1820,

Glasgow 22/11/2007 14:25:36

rogerB

Thanks for your interest.

Checkout:

http://the1820society.150m.com/

to find out what happened in 1820.

27

Dumb Eye @,

Out of the country 22/11/2007 17:30:46

#23

"Bank account numbers and branch addresses should not be easy to get but somehow it does not appear difficult."

When a cheque is used (admittedly rarely these days), that information is already printed on the front, so has always been fairly readily available. Nowadays, when using a debit card, the account number is embossed on it, along with the branch sort code, and the issuing bank name is prominently displayed, so I doubt if the info would be difficult to obtain.

28

Lianachan,

Highlands 22/11/2007 17:42:35

All I need to know about identity theft is that it doesn't matter how careful I am (and I am very careful indeed) because it can all be compromised by the incompetant UK government we are forced to still be attached to.

29

Ard Righ,

The Rock of Edinburgh 22/11/2007 18:20:07

4. TommyKaye, UK / 2:49am 22 Nov 2007

I AM THE THETA MAN

30

whatsyourname,

22/11/2007 19:27:25

Ow sure are you ready to get chiped ? thats the next thing when they bring in the police state.
they are trying to put fear into people dont listen to this propoganda

31

JoeMcT,

Big Brother 22/11/2007 21:58:49

New Labour are creating a monster with all these databases, and eventually all the data will be linked so that they have access to all our personal information.

32

NemarketNDPer,

Taipei, Taiwan, FORMOSA 23/11/2007 03:40:54

If you feel someone is attempting to fleece your ID data via a phone call, ask him for his telephone number so you can call back.
After that bait him. By all means answer his questions, but with slightly fudged data. "Want my bank a/c?" Just increase or decrease a a few a/c figures. "Want my birth date?" Okay, make yourself a couple of years younger! You can also use this approach on those questionable lottery forms you get in the mail from sourthern Spain. It will contaminate their data bank with trash. As for that telephone number, give it to the relevant police authority for follow up, raiding, and shutting down. I suspect most of these rackets are backed up by Nigerian or Russian gangs who for the average person are the real terrorists.

33

Call Centre Specialist,

Morth West 23/11/2007 10:56:16

WHERE DO YOUR CALL CENTRE STAFF COME FROM?

? Call centres employ hundreds of people and constantly have to recruit new candidates, as the rate of attrition can be very high
? Recruitment agencies are often used to source candidates for both temp to perm and straight permanent positions
? To properly screen and assess candidates for identity, qualifications, the right to work in the UK, references on previous employment etc. etc. the list is long takes time
? The recruitment industry is unlicensed - anyone can set up an agency from any type of premises
? Procurement negotiate the best price for their company, not always the best service - cheap is dear
? The necessary processes required to screen and vet potential workers properly by agencies, can be compromised because of cost
? The lowest margins will not attract those agencies which adhere to best practice and the strict criteria required
? Call centres that handle sensitive information, should demand to inspect the agencies they use, and their procedures and systems
? Failing to adhere to high standards will inevitably expose call centres to the risk of identity theft fraud and jeopardise their customers’ details.

In 1999, 9000 cases of identity fraud were reported in the U.K.
In 2006 it was 80,000 and rising

? TBC has been in the business for nineteen years and have been visited and vetted by two of the biggest names in Financial Services
? Our dedicated team using established and proven skills and processes, can recruit call centre personnel anywhere in the UK
Risks additional to financial loss:
· Regulations - Data Protection Act ref customer info
· Commercial - Payment Card Industry, Data Security Standards, ("PCI, DSS")
· Reputation - Loss of confidence from media exposure.

The £28 Mil


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.