Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Saturday, 5th July 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Tonsillitis? More like lazy-itis – star Macdonald attacks X Factor's Leon over cancelled concert



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 02 January 2008
LEON Jackson's last-minute decision to pull out of Edinburgh's Hogmanay celebrations the day after he turned 19 left thousands of the X Factor winner's fans disappointed.
But fellow singer Amy Macdonald yesterday questioned whether Jackson was suffering from tonsillitis – and blamed "lazy-itis" for his no-show.

Singer-songwriter Macdonald, 20, whose debut album This Is The Life hit number two in the charts last
summer, said she was also suffering from the throat problem.

But the illness didn't stop her from performing at Glasgow's celebrations in George Square or on the BBC's Hogmanay show.

Macdonald, from Bishopbriggs in Glasgow, said: "I think Leon has got lazy-itis if I am honest. Maybe he was feeling a little fragile after his 19th (birthday party].

"I think it is shocking because so many people voted for him on The X Factor, then he had two weeks off even though he hadn't even done anything, and he still manages to pull out.

"If he misses one of his first gigs it doesn't say much for his staying power."

Jackson, whose debut single When You Believe was at number one for a second week on Sunday, had been due to open the capital's world-famous street party.

The singer, from Whitburn, West Lothian, said he was "disappointed to be letting people down" by cancelling.

He enjoyed a 19th birthday party in Glasgow's Tiger Tiger nightclub with 100 friends and family on Sunday night. He reportedly left the party at around midnight.

Macdonald said she took an intensive course of penicillin to deal with her tonsillitis and ensure she could perform.

Speaking after playing in front of 17,000 revellers in George Square, she said: "I think it is absolutely terrible that he pulled out.

"Tonsillitis doesn't harm your vocal chords at all. I have got tonsillitis too and I had to phone NHS 24 so I could get some penicillin.

I have got a sore throat but I can still sing totally fine on it."

She added: "Just wait until he is really into it and is having to go to different countries and trying to become known in other territories. It is going to get much tougher for him than it is just now."

Macdonald also claimed that reality programmes such as The X Factor were making it more difficult for talented youngsters to break through.

The singer, who started playing gigs at 15, said: "It is not that I don't think much of Leon, but there are more accomplished people out there who can sing better than he can, but he can go on The X Factor and become big instantly … It is unfair on proper struggling musicians."

Simon Jones, Jackson's publicist, last night described Macdonald's claims as "ludicrous".

He said: "I can assure everyone that Leon is very upset at not being able to perform at the Hogmanay celebrations.

"He is unwell and did not perform due to advice from his doctor and record company, which was to stay in bed.

"I don't know why Amy has made these remarks. She's not a doctor and I can only think she's doing it for the publicity."



The full article contains 540 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 01 January 2008 9:28 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Hogmanay
 
1

Ross Fyffe,

Scotland 02/01/2008 01:45:05
Ah new information a birthday party, ..........
2

connaughtboy,

stonehaven 02/01/2008 01:57:33
The wee laddie can't sing anyway. He was probably scared witless at the thought of being on a big stage.
3

Will567,

Edinburgh 02/01/2008 02:28:19
Amy McDonald says "I have got a sore throat but I can still sing totally fine on it."

Well I am lmao at that statement. I heard her and my message is get some singing lessons love.


4

Stell,

Ayr 02/01/2008 03:47:06
This is the same Amy McDonald who worships talentless hanger-on Pete Doherty?
A dribbling imbecile who never seems to turn up to concerts at all, let alone issue an apology or excuse.

Does seem rather unnecessary for her to comment anyway. Why does she assume that we care what she thinks, all she has to do is warble through her one and only semi-decent record.
5

Boy Wonder,

02/01/2008 04:50:38
Compared to Amy McDonald, wee Leon is a talented singer with more experience.

Has anyone heard her without earplugs??
6

Iain fae Elgin,

London 02/01/2008 07:41:51
No Leon at the Hogmany celebrations?


Phew...close one!
7

Joe,

Harthill Rim 02/01/2008 08:03:44
Who is Amy Macdonald and who was watching BBC Glasgow on Hogmanay?
8

Profit Seeker,

Edinburgh 02/01/2008 09:23:34
Amy really needs to grow up and act like a big girl! We heard you at Hognanay Amy and I'd go for Leon any time love. Like Will567 says go get some singing lessons. Some decent material would not hurt either dearie.
9

McMillar,

Fife 02/01/2008 09:26:40
Sounds like jealousy and what's she selling? Docherty is just a joke and the sooner he goes the better.
10

Liam,

02/01/2008 09:46:07
Who cares? He's going to be a one-hit wonder and by Hogmanay next year we'll all have forgotten who the kid is.
11

Mikey,

02/01/2008 09:53:19
Who is Leon? Who is Amy McDonald?
12

Leopold Dilg,

02/01/2008 10:07:58
Amy is all of 20 years old and apparently not in possession of any qualifications in anything other than musical noodling and wearing make up, and has had limited success in the pop music industry, and so obviously is entitled to offer medical advice in respect of a 19 year old more recently entered into the pop industry. I do think it is a bit much of the Scotsman to describe either of them as "stars".

I wonder if she is really going to be that pleased with a publicist who has exposed her to ridicule in this way. Slagging off the competition and slyly suggesting that he is a drunken lightweight is perhaps not the way forward.
13

Toast,

02/01/2008 10:16:13
#5 what a clown you are,Leon will be unheard of by easter
14

Steve,

Bo'ness 02/01/2008 10:17:19
Amy McDonald's Album is excellent. She's had three or four hit records already at 20. Her voice is distinctive, and her songs are her own. In short, she is bristling with musical talent.

Sorry, but even the most starry eyed teenage girl cant say that about Leon, who if there was any justice in the world, should still be selling discounted GAP underpants in McArthur Glen.
15

Paul Voltaire,

02/01/2008 10:24:12
Mcarthur where?
16

Douglas,

Bathgate 02/01/2008 10:38:54
MCARTHUR GLEN!!!! I'll have you know it's now known as Livingston Designer Outlet. :o)
17

calum,

02/01/2008 10:49:12
Leon probably had no choice but to pull out of Edinburgh's Hogmanay concert ......but nothing to do with a sore throat. I'm surprised that no-ne has twigged to the fact that he will be tied contractually to the X-Factor producers who will decide which shows he does or doesn't perform at. And the thought of their precious new talent being sullied by the Pete Irvine bandwagon would be too much for Simon Cowell et al. Was Amy MAmy MacDonald the sctratchy lassie who was on one of the Hogmanay programmes on TV? If it was I hardly think she's in a position to lecture anyone about ability or talent.
18

Mop,

*********** 02/01/2008 10:57:17
I think Leon has alot of professional "growing up" to do.
This lad has been handed a poisoned chalice.

Im thinking of a certain young lass with a powerhouse of a voice called Lena Zavaroni (God rest her)look what fame did to her and many others who got it so young.Take note Leon,you are Daniel in the lions den.
19

Boy Wonder,

02/01/2008 11:22:05
#19. Mop ... Daniel was actually quite safe in the lion's den, according to the scriptures. He was more at risk from the jealousy of his peers outside the den. I suggest you think of something else to illustrate what it is you mean to say.

20

Hagar,

Somerset 02/01/2008 11:22:25
I can't believe those who prefer Leon to Amy Macdonald. Amy Macdonald has released a superb album of songs that SHE has written. She also has rich almost Irish sounding singing voice.

Sorry if some of you wasted your money voting for reality TV "star" Leon.
21

OscarMacApfel,

Dumfropolis 02/01/2008 11:32:33
Loving how all the fuddy duddys are commenting on a 'pop' story. Particularly those who are slamming one Pete Docherty, no dounbt informed of his musical abilities by the tabloids. Like it or not he and Amy MacDonald managed to attain musical recognition by virtue of their own talents as singers and more importantly as songwriters.

As #18 says this latest pop moppet was probably forced to cancel by his Opportunity Karaoke management. Ms MacDonald at least has her own mind and has criticised her own releases despite the obvious palpitations this caused her management. Also, did she approach the journo or did he ask for her views?
22

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

02/01/2008 11:51:52
She's only a twenty year old Lassie - but she is right about one thing.

Amy is an artist - she writes her own songs and tours extensively. It's a job and she treats it as such while bringing her own contributions to those who want to take the time to listen.

Leon is a reality TV show winner. He does not write songs , he sings karaoke.

Can you see the difference ? CAN YOU SEE THE DIFFERENCE ?

This lad did not turn up for his first public performance , as a bottom of the bill on the 2nd stage in Edinburgh.

Things do not bode well for him.

Well said Amy, I dont even know her music but people WAKE UP.

23

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

02/01/2008 11:53:53
22. Pop Music has been around for 50 years , with the same chords just slightly different drum beats now and then.

Perhaps you should pay a bit more attention to the fuddy duddies instead of thinking youre the first generation to discover music you wee tube.
24

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

02/01/2008 11:55:18
actually forget that i agree with most of what you say apart from the ageist thing..

cheers.
25

Gothic Rose,

02/01/2008 12:27:30
Mikey#12. Don`t know.
26

d.j.,

02/01/2008 12:48:30
The New year programmes on both STV and BBC Scotland were sheer and utter drivel unless, of course, the English Language and Culture is Scotlands language and culture which it most certainly is.
So this is what all the Angliscised children of Gaelic speakers have ended up with. What a great prize to behold.
27

OscarMacApfel,

Dumfries 02/01/2008 13:23:02
#24 Nae probs, chance are I'm older than you anyhoo, and more befitting of the term fuddy duddy!

#27 A far more beneficial approach to bringing in the bells was to be had watching Jools Hootenanny recorded back in May.
28

livilion,

livingston 02/01/2008 14:06:13
So it begins?

I admit that I didn't watch X Factor but I did catch a few minutes of the re-run of the final and wondered what the standard of the losers must have been like, if he was the best.

Once again this country can't wait to rip into some wee guy who's only crime has been to win a tv talent contest.

This time last year he was stacking shelves in a supermarket and this year we are expecting the seasoned pro ready to perform in the biggest shop window of the year.

I can only imagine the panic he'd be feeling if he'd come down with a throat infection.

Picture yourself live on the Hogmanay countdown show minutes before the bells, only weeks after winning this glorified karaoke contest, and wondering if you were about to make a complete chump of yourself.

Aye, I reckon in his position any of us might've come down with 'tonsillitis' too, much more dignified than diarrhea, don't you think?

Give the boy a break, I don't think we'll be hearing much more from him in future anyway.
29

x-x,

england 02/01/2008 14:44:57
amy macdonald is just an insensitive person who thinks she is "it" because she has a little bit of a singing talent. Well I personally hate people like that. I truly believe that leon was ill so he couldn't perform. For those who don't actually know the truth should not make slanderous comments!
30

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

02/01/2008 15:21:44
"but he's LOVELY - how can he be a chancer" etc.
31

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

02/01/2008 15:47:02
20 its her opinion , in an increasingly mediocre and crap accepting society so i say well done Amy.
32

JG,

Fife 02/01/2008 16:49:25
If Leon is any good at all he'll still be around next year. Trying to think back over the other "X-factor" winners, the only 2 I can think of are Leona Lewis (no' a bad singer) and Will Young. The rest all slipped down the toilet.
33

Jingling Geordie,

Sunshine on Leith 02/01/2008 17:45:38

Wee Amy Macdonald, what a talent, singer, guitarist and now an Ear Nose and Throat specialist, truly amazing.
34

SophieJ,

Edinburgh 02/01/2008 17:47:21
Amy MacDonald should keep her trap shut - since when has she been a doctor and has she spoken to Leon to know how poorly he is?

What goes around comes around Amy!

Your voice 'live' isn't as good as you think it is and I heard you out of tune at HMV Braehead a few months ago!
35

mac1888,

02/01/2008 17:54:45
Amy has talent unlike the we guy who won some crap tv contest :)
36

Isabel,

Edinburgh 02/01/2008 17:59:51
Tonsillitis? This must be the new name for massive hangover. Big birthday bash, with plenty to drink = thumpin' sair heid.

Leon shouldn't have won the X Factor in the first place because Rhydian was streets ahead. It was the all the wee 10 and 11 year old girls and the Scots who voted for the Scottish finalist, rather than the more talented, polished performer. Leon will certainly be remembered now but not for his singing.
37

Methalions,

02/01/2008 18:24:34
12
Mikey,
02/01/2008 09:53:19
"Who is Leon? Who is Amy McDonald?"

Who is Mikey?
38

Methalions,

02/01/2008 18:28:04
Never seen the x factor. Is it a bit like Opportunity knocks with Hughie Green or am I missing something?

Who, Waters, Gabriel, Yes.... I think I'm stuck in a time warp.javascript:__doPostBack('wctlAddComment1$ctl00$btnPost','')
Post Comment
39

Methalions,

02/01/2008 18:28:36
What the "x" happened to ma post?
40

Steph2679034975,

02/01/2008 21:18:03
Amy MacWho??

Who dus she think she isss?

Tbh she shud keep her mouth shut! She has tonsillitis nd her singings fine? IS IT?? No it aint but thn again it never is!!!

Jealousy aint a reason 2 slate another person!

Leon has been singing week after week non stop nd after winning the x factor he was still singing! No wonder the poor boy has tonsillitis!!

Stupid Woman needs 2 get her facts straight!
41

RubyRed,

Old Town 02/01/2008 22:33:39
#8 Col. Blimp IV*
Did you notice that Ray Gun (Rhydian) looked perfectly normal in his first audition then when they X-Factor stylists got a hold of him he look totally weird.

I thought he was a fantastic singer/performer inspite of the makeover. I recorded the x-factor and just fast forwarded to Rhydian's performances, which I found to be incredible! Every performance was impecible! Leon is just boring and so is 95% of the X-Factor.
I would imagine Rhydian has better fish to fry than to wait around for Leon to crack!
42

woop,

whitburn 03/01/2008 00:04:14
right just to clear things up....i am good friends with leon, and before u all slag him off, he is absolutely gutted that he couldnt make it on monday night. amy mcdonald doesnt have a clue what she is on about, he hardly even had anything to drink at his party, if he did dont you think it would be all over the papers. amy has to realise that this guy has only been in the spotlight for 2 weeks and considering he is number 1 for the 2nd week in a row proves he doing something right, unlike all her number 1's...oh wait theres none! he is gonna be a star and is determined to make his fans proud of him. give the guy a chance.

cheers
43

RubyRed,

03/01/2008 00:54:31
#43 woop,whitburn
The guy has been given a chance! The most amazing chance! A million pound record contract!!! What more does he want??
I think its time for you friend to grow up and be aware of his obligations - he's no longer a minimum wage employee who can just phone it sick.
The UK public have not done this vulnerable/inexperienced/immature young man any favours!
My advice to Leon would be 'BECAREFUL WHAT YOU WISH FOR'
44

Froggatt,

Edinburgh 03/01/2008 04:02:25
Find this young ladies comments amazing really, does she really believe all the platitudes Jackie Bird showered upon her during the Hogmanay programme.
She was overshadowed by the rest of the line up on this programme (including the big drum).
Not a great fan of x-factor or Leon, but maybe the best advice that NHS 24 should have given Amy was to rest her voice, by means of keeping her gub shut - especially around newspaper reporters !
But then her comments have got her some more publicity I guess...........
45

Lynn Smith,

Edinburgh 03/01/2008 12:25:58
I find alot of the comments on here quite shocking.
Saying Amy Macdonald has no talent is quite frankly laughable.

I'm sure she didn't go looking for reporters to talk to.

Anyway will someone tell me what is so bad about saying that it's terrible for someone like him to cancel such a high profile show?
It's completely true and i find it obscene that everyone does not agree.

How many struggling musicians would give anything to be able to play at 'The biggest street party in Europe' ?
Except this lad thinks he can cancel at the last minute.
If i'm not mistaken on every X factor show i've seen there's always one who in one episode has a sore throat, but are they not always made to sing?

I find it quite shocking that him and his management think that he's a superstar. Has he proved himself? No!
Maybe Edinburgh hogmanay was his chance but he blew it.

What's most shocking of all is the harsh way some of you have treated Miss Macdonald for simply stating her opinion.

Did any of you watch X factor? Simon Cowell repeatedly called Leon worse than Lazy, except you all fail to mention this.

Infact did Cowell ever say he was good?

46

WKKB,

03/01/2008 14:07:19
sounds like it's more a case of jealous-amy-itis than anything else. she's just upset because he caught a break and was instantly put in the public eye. besides Amy... I know a whole he** of a lot of more talented people than you. plus, a good singer knows how to take care of his/her voice. maybe you should take better care of yours and it wouldn't sound so... well... uh... painful to my ears. MISS SOUR GRAPES!
47

WKKB,

03/01/2008 14:42:58
#46,Lynn, Simon Cowell did in fact make very positive comments about Leon and his talent. Sure he started off slow but he wasn't a polished performer like some others on the show. Yet, he pulled himself up and WON the show by popular vote. Plus, in case you missed it he sang with another performer, perhaps you've heard of him... and this is what he had to say, "LEON JACKSON is going to be a huge star with or without The X Factor." And that according to his musical hero Michael Buble.

Another thing Lynn, if you know anything at all about vocal chords they CAN and often ARE ruined by not taking care of them even with what you may consider a simple case of tonsilitis. When ever your have a sore throat if you push so that you can be heard you will do damage. If people like "Miss" MacDonald wants to sing or try to sing over a sore throat more power to her but in my opinion, and I've been around a lot of musicians for a number of years, your voice will last longer and sound better if you take care of it. Good singers won't even do a lot of speaking the day of a concert.

Now to address your comments about the x-factor sore throats... have you ever been involved in a competition of this nature? No I suspect not, well then you may not know how demanding the schedule is. Not only are they in the studio very early every day rehearsing and learing new music for the weekly show but they're also making promotional videos, making personal visits to promote themselves, having coaching sessions, dance classes, performance training and then back in the studio every day for more rehearsal. It's a gruelling schedule and by the time it's over most of these people feel the need to drop in a large overstuffed chair and just chill for a while. In other words, if you've not been there you have no idea what you're speaking about. I have been there, I have seen what goes on behind closed doors, I've seen how hard these people work. If he had a sore throat or tonsilitis or ju
48

WKKB,

03/01/2008 15:02:32
#42, Rubyred - you are right about Rhydian's talent but the problem is that he's not really what the general pop culture is looking for. He'll have no trouble at all scoring a great role somewhere on the stage or as a recording artist but his style, although really great, does't really suit most of the general public. Plus his arrogance really put people off straight from the start, that was his downfall I'm sure. He's a talent that WILL be noticed and has actually been noticed by Lord Weber himself and that can't be bad.
49

RubyRed,

03/01/2008 15:05:38
#46 Lynn Smith
Well said.

#46 #47 WKKB
Put your money where your mouth is and tell us what you sang on the X-Factor???
50

Polaris,

03/01/2008 15:11:42
I agree that Rhydian is a great talent find but his talent is completely different that Leon's or any other contestant on the x-factor this year. He stands on his own and will certainly make it on his own. I feel Leon's appeal is he's just an ordinary guy who can sing and those who voted for him are ordinary people who like what they see. It's a talent show for sure but it's the public that have the final say and it looks like they wanted Leon. If those of you hear who didn't like Leon voted for someone else maybe your pick would have won.
51

WKKB,

03/01/2008 15:18:04
you don't have to sing on x-factor to know music. I've been working in the music industry for 25 years in one of those behind the scenes positions. I've seen loads of musicians come and go, some who went who deserved to stay but didn't for one reason or another and some who stayed but had little real talent just persistance. If I wanted to be pi**y about it I could ask you the same thing. What have you miss rubyred sung on the x-factor lately that makes you such an expert about such things? I was actually agreeing with you about your friend Rhydian.

My real disagreement is with people like "Miss" MacDonald who can open her mouth and allow such rubbish exit from it. Her's is definitely a case of sour grapes and she in my opinion is only slightly talented, she's one of those with persistance and more power to her for it.
52

WKKB,

03/01/2008 15:22:36
More from Michale Buble after singing with Leon at Wembly:
Michael said: "You're going to make it with or without The X Factor.

"You've got tons of charisma, you're a great kid - I voted for you.

"You're as good as or better than any one of us," (referring to himself, Harry Connick Jnr and others in his genre of music).

"We need you and there's always room - carry this on for me. You have a beautiful voice and killer control."

It's the second time a singer giving a masterclass on the programme has praised Leon. He was also Celine Dion's favourite.

Remember this is a young lad who is just starting and has the sky as his limit. He's going to be great once he gets his barings. Give the lad a chance. Just because he caught a huge break or he isn't your favourite doesn't give you the right to trash him. He'll be just fine and Edinburgh fans will forgive him for being smart about taking care of his future. Sometimes stars have to cancel, I've known bigger stars who have cancelled huge concerts for more than one night and for lesser reasons. Don't knock it until you've walked in his shoes for a while.

53

RubyRed,

03/01/2008 15:43:40
#49

The x-Factor as a show is really suspect! I dont know how they get away with parading people with mental health problems in front of the camera, laugh at them and consider that to be entertainment. I think it is shocking! The x-Factor should be banned.
As for Leon it must be obvious to everyone that this young man is not ready for the spotlight. Winning the X-Factor may end up being the worst thing that has ever happened to him - he may well end up being a 'Hasbeen' before he has even started. Michael Buble may have to eat his words or perhaps he was only being nice to increase his own popularity!!!
54

charly,

edinburgh 03/01/2008 15:52:09
can u lave leon alone i was ment 2 be there hearing him sing but i dont give a damm that he cancelled ome on it LEON! hes well worth the wait and if u want 2 get physical i have tonsillitios at thee moment and i cant talk scream or sing. did some 1 say jelousy!
god hes amazing ! can i say i know theres millions of people who love leon but im deffinately his biggiest an nno doubts! leon is amazig !amy you cant song he can get over it your pathetic and so childish anything 2 keep your name in the paper cause no 1 likes your music any more and you had 2 slash sum 1 slash amy wine house or ryhdian who hates leons music god you are all so childish and thats coming from a 13 year old amy leave him alon you loser!
55

RubyRed,

03/01/2008 15:56:22
#52

I was responding to your previous post. We seemed to have gotten our wires crossed.
I just wanted to check your credentials to see if you were worth taking seriously. Its Mrs RubyRed not miss. In answer to your question I have never sung on the X-Factor I would in fact discourage people from even watching the X-Factor never mind taking part.
56

dingaling,

Glasgow 03/01/2008 17:54:01
Perhaps Amy Macdonald should catch her tongue before she starts mouthing off about others!
It wasn't so long ago that she was auditioning for X-Factor now was it? And I'm sure she wouldn't be slagging it off had she done well in it!
Also, for the record, tonsilitis can affect the voice, having had it on numerous occassions, I know that it made my voice sound croaky and it was extremely painful to talk let alone sing.
Maybe Amy should focus more on her own career (what numbers did the last 2 singles get into the charts at again?!) instead of criticising others. Sounds like the bitchy queen has returned.
57

kimba,

03/01/2008 17:54:33
More like a hangover!
58

kimba,

03/01/2008 18:11:47
RubyRed. you seem to have a bee in your bonnet about the x-factor,why would that be?
59

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

03/01/2008 18:42:55
Can i just state that the only constant winner from x factor is Simon Cowell.

Oh , and i think youre all abunch of halfwit.

Most of you that support this dressed up Bultins Talent Contest frankly deserve all the trouble you will get in life as you clearly havent got two brain cells to rub together.

I class musci as an art form. The xfactor form of it involves parading peple with mental problems for your enjoyment , and people like Leon who clearly cannot be bothered fulfilling his commitments.

Not that you care.
60

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

03/01/2008 18:45:50
sorry for the typos but GRRR Im angry. you probably think im a snob for saying this.

Correct.
61

RubyRed,

03/01/2008 19:02:10
# 59-Kimba

For the reasons stated in post. No hidden agenda?
What is yours???
62

wearrapeepil,

Ibrox, Glasgow 04/01/2008 11:47:52
I don't want to knock wee Leon, as all he did was audition for a talent/karaoke show, and he won it. Fair play to him.

Amy has a point though, in that "real" artists are placed on the back burner while people like Leon are exploited for commercial gain. That's the way I see it anyway.
63

Lynn Smith,

04/01/2008 14:15:11
I still cannot believe people are going on about this.
Not one of you have answered my question.

What is so bad about saying that it's shocking for someone in his position to cancel such a high profile performance? It simply doesn't bode well for his future.

I feel this has little to do with the 'tonsilitis' thing as pictures in todays paper show leon looking a little worse for wear the night before the gig.

I agree that real artists are forced to work alot harder than glorified karaoke singers and lets face it that is all they are.
Go into any pub anywhere in Scotland and i guarantee that you will hear someone singing who is just as good as leon, if not better.

Amy's gripes were nothing to do with Leon as a performer simply Leon as someone who as taken advantage of his situation.

Like i said before, he hasn't proved himself and maybe Edinburgh hogmanay was his chance.

I am quite frankly disgusted by some of your comments.
You keep stating that people can have an opinion on Leon when they've been thru the x factor well my answer to that is you can comment on Amy's talent when you write your own album and be recognised on your own merit at 20 years old.

A fact that young Leon will never achieve.
64

Lynn Smith,

04/01/2008 14:16:42
I still cannot believe people are going on about this.
Not one of you have answered my question.

What is so bad about saying that it's shocking for someone in his position to cancel such a high profile performance? It simply doesn't bode well for his future.

I feel this has little to do with the 'tonsilitis' thing as pictures in todays paper show leon looking a little worse for wear the night before the gig.

I agree that real artists are forced to work alot harder than glorified karaoke singers and lets face it that is all they are.
Go into any pub anywhere in Scotland and i guarantee that you will hear someone singing who is just as good as leon, if not better.

Amy's gripes were nothing to do with Leon as a performer simply Leon as someone who as taken advantage of his situation.

Like i said before, he hasn't proved himself and maybe Edinburgh hogmanay was his chance.

I am quite frankly disgusted by some of your comments.
You keep stating that people can have an opinion on Leon when they've been thru the x factor well my answer to that is you can comment on Amy's talent when you write your own album and be recognised on your own merit at 20 years old.

A fact that young Leon will never achieve.
65

VickiluvzLeon,

Hampshire 04/01/2008 14:36:30
If it was the doctors advice then i'm sure it was the right step to take. He's been forced not to sing for two weeks... forced isn't the same thing as Leon deciding not to do any performances for two weeks.

He's just getting used to everything.

And Amy is just jealous.
66

Lynn Smith,

04/01/2008 15:22:38
i'm sure she is jealous of a mediocre singer who won the most pointless competition on the tv, infact one he didn't deserve to win.

You're probably right.
She did spend the last 5 years righting and recording a platinum selling album.

Of course she'll be jealous of someone who was thrust into the spotlight and forced to sing mediocre songs.

You're right.
67

MoiraMac,

05/01/2008 13:34:16
Amy McDonald is completely justified in what she said. Well done Amy and everyone else on this post who has defended her.

Perhaps a bottle of Buckie would have been a better suggestion than anti-biotics, that would have as he states in the following article in the Sun kept him going through the night.


http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/showbiz/bizarre/article599169.ece#comment-rig

He said: “I’m not shy of nipping to the corner shop to get myself a cheeky half bottle of Buckfast.

“I like to drink my beer but if it’s not going down well I like some vodka Red Bull. It gets me steaming then keeps me going through the rest of the night.”

Is this what you learn at Karate? He must have had a crap teacher.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.