Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Hidden epidemic of 33,000 ADHD children

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 26 April 2008
TENS of thousands of children in Scotland are suffering from hyperactivity and behavioural problems but have not been diagnosed, experts have warned.
A report by the health watchdog NHS Quality Improvement Scotland (NHS QIS) said that at least 7,000 children with the most severe form of attention deficit and hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) were currently undiagnosed and could benefit from drug treat
ment.

Altogether, more than 33,000 under-18s are thought to have ADHD – from mild to severe – but have not been identified.

Just 4,539 schoolchildren are diagnosed with ADHD in Scotland, the report said. Experts said undiagnosed youngsters could benefit from help, ranging from simple advice to improve their learning skills to drug therapy.

Some have criticised the increased use of drugs to tackle conditions such as ADHD, branding it the "chemical cosh". But experts yesterday said that, when used appropriately, they could dramatically improve the quality of life for families.

NHS QIS found that just 0.6 per cent of school-aged children had been diagnosed with ADHD. But international studies have suggested prevalence of severe ADHD is at least 1.5 per cent, while all forms could affect as many as 5 per cent of children – some 38,000 in Scotland.

Diagnosis rates across Scotland varied from just 0.2 per cent in Ayrshire and Arran and Lanarkshire to 0.8 per cent in Fife. The report found at least two-thirds of children with ADHD would continue to have symptoms into adolescence, and this may persist into adulthood.

But no NHS board has any protocol in place to ease the transition of young people with ADHD into adult services, and there are no established services for adults with the condition.

Stimulant medications, such as Ritalin, were recommended as the first-line treatment in 82 per cent of Scottish cases of ADHD.

Non-stimulant drugs were used in around 25 per cent of cases at some point. Dr Fiona Forbes, a consultant psychiatrist at NHS Lothian, said the under-diagnosis of ADHD was a "major concern". She added: "This means that families are not benefiting from access to appropriate help."

Jan Warner, director of performance assessment at NHS QIS, said it was reassuring that ADHD services across Scotland were generally of high quality, but added: "What is worrying is that society as a whole is failing to recognise many children with ADHD. We will now work with children, parents, carers, clinicians, social services and education services to tackle under diagnosis."

Andrea Bilbow, the chief executive of the Attention Deficit Disorder Information and Support Service, said:

"We also need to make clear that these children are not just naughty. ADHD means they are unable to control their emotions and that is all the time. It is not just a willful, one-off act of naughtiness."


TURNING HER LIFE AROUND

GRACE Mitchell knew she had serious problems with her anger and aggression. But when her mother took Grace to see a doctor, bad parenting was blamed for her behaviour.

Grace, from East Ayrshire, was not diagnosed with ADHD until she was 16.

Now 18, she has turned her life around with the help of medication and other support.

"I was always angry and just being bad," she said. "I was just fighting and being aggressive to my family all the time."

After leaving school at 15, she has now returned to complete her final year.



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 25 April 2008 11:52 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 26/04/2008 01:00:50
"But when her mother took Grace to see a doctor, bad parenting was blamed for her behaviour."

So are we saying our £100K'rs are to Blame for the miss diagnosis,?
...(sorry its out of hours)

Maybe that's not fair, but who is number one for looking after family health,?

OK maybe it difficult to diagnose and is a specialist subject.
2

Guga II,

Rockall 26/04/2008 03:08:27
The greater majority of these so-called ADHD cases could be easily solved by giving obstreperous children a clout on the lug, or a swift boot up the bum.

Maybe it's time they started having compulsory "parenting" lessons at night school, for the benefit of these so-called parents that haven't a clue how to control and discipline their children.
3

Sally Hindley,

USA 26/04/2008 03:16:36
Do NOT fall for this propaganda! It's being pushed by the drug companies to put HUGE amounts of MONEY in their pockets. It's already started in the states. Do NOT let it happen to your children. These drugs are making children commit suicide. Be informed! Do research on the side effects. Do research on the stories of children dying from liver cancer and suicide.
4

Jeeemy,

St Andrews 26/04/2008 06:51:50
Problem could be solved quite quickly, remove from the supermarket shelves all the sweets and food containing these stupid colouring additives.
The evidence has been shown in research repeated time after time, with the volume production of these chemicals now at record levels now wonder we have chemical companies producing statistics to prove just about anything and everything.
Was it not the tobacco industry that was found to be putting addictive substances in there products.
Mind you with DEFRA looking after us nothing is safe neither you or me.

5

Nirvana,

26/04/2008 09:18:36
Not only do the kids receive Ritalin some are prescribed Adderol. In predisposed kids to Mental Illness, these drugs can bring out psychosis. Sally #3 is correct these drugs are pushed by the drug companies.
6

Unimpressed one,

26/04/2008 09:22:09
"Do NOT fall for this propaganda! It's being pushed by the drug companies to put HUGE amounts of MONEY in their pockets."

Don't forget that the parents of ADHD kids are eligible for Disability Living Allowance (DLA) and they will then be entitled to a concessionary bus pass too.
7

Douglas,

Bathgate 26/04/2008 09:30:05
A bit reactionary there Googs. We might try a wee chat and a bit of positive reinforcement on a regular basis first (or as we used to call it, being a family). I'm sure there are people with real, actual problems but never forget there is a ton of cash to be made from fear, laziness and the desire for instant results.
Save the physical stuff for adults who can't be @rsed.
8

scottish person,

paisley 26/04/2008 10:02:30
So it has nothing to do with all the artificial sweeteners in kids drinks like Aspartame, which is a known killer. Dont take my word for it, Google it and you will be amazed.I will not allow my kids to drink anything with artificial sweeteners in it.
9

Rattyhorses,

scotland 26/04/2008 10:37:17
My son was diagnosed with ADHD when he was 6 years old and that was after the autism diagnosis as well. He eats home cooked meals without preservatives, only drinks fruit juics, water and milk and doesnt eat sweets only home made fudges, toffees and the likes. so where does your cut out the preservatives figure in our lives.

my son has a real problem and is only at the stage of a P1 at school and due to start S1 in august. he also has a severe learning disorder. he was diagnosed in England and when we moved to scotland was striped of all his diagnosis even thoguh no other tests were carried out and he was on medication which made a real differance to his life as well as his siblings.
10

Stratty,

26/04/2008 13:33:31
There's an excellent short video about disease mongering to the point of manufacturing mental disorder 'epidemics' here:

http://healthyskepticism.org:80/gallery/data/502/A_New_Epidemic_Large.wmv
11

Stratty,

26/04/2008 13:44:58
Here's the BMJ article (note the DATE) that went with the video:

http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/extract/332/7544/745-a
12

S MacLeod,

26/04/2008 14:00:18
Stratty,

Very frightening,

This link is not about the drugs given out but maybe linked with some of the causes...

http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=-566922170441334340&hl=en-GB



13

S MacLeod,

26/04/2008 14:24:49
RITALIN:

http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=5989146416818579730&q=ritalin&total=899&start=0&num=10&so=0&type=search&plindex=2


Should we trust drugs salesmen?

http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=-2495731561770063764

http://www.antidepressantsfacts.com/Bush-Lilly-CIA-serotonin.htm
14

Stratty,

26/04/2008 15:01:31
S MacLeod

Thanks for the link to Sweet Misery. Certainly could be one of the reasons. I doubt we'll ever find out for sure what environmental/food/physical disorders/emotional factors play a part in a diagnosis of ADHD, because the 'big research money' and the key 'experts' involved in promoting diseases lie towards the goal of making a profit from 'chemical' cures ("mind altering" drugs) rather than researching the root causes.

There are sites that list 50 things (many possibles - such as exposure to high levels of heavy metals down to intestinal worms and all sorts inbetween) that can bring a misdiagnosis by way of a 'mimic' of ADHD, and here's one of those sites:

http://mutters.invisionzone.com/index.php?showtopic=8858

There's also a US based website with a lot of links to information about ADHD - it also covers some issues we don't YET have, such as compusory drugging of children and schools' involvement in diagnosis and treatment -
but these too make interesting reading, particularly given the efforts such as the one in the Scotsman article we're commenting on look to be leading us slowly but surely to the same tragic situation as the US are already in and where millions of their children are on psych drugs.

http://www.adhdtesting.org/compendiumpage.htm

If you've already posted either of these while I've typing this out, sorry :)
15

Stratty,

26/04/2008 15:16:13
As for ADHD 'support groups' like ADDISS and ADDERS, there's an old article by the Telegraph under the heading:

"ADHD advice secretly paid for by drugs companies"
(thats drug companies which make drugs for ADHD of course)

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2005/10/09/nadhd09.xml&sSheet=/portal/2005/10/09/ixportal.html

The drug companies and their 'experts' are targetting our children. Before we find ourselves (or more to the point, our children) in the same place as the US has found itself, maybe we need to 'know' about the drugs they're promoting, learn from the US experience (as in how the drug companies and their 'key' experts magaged to achieve the mass drugging of children) and then - I think this is a US term when talking about the non-approved/illegal mind altering drug business - "SAY NO to drugs".

Before its too late for choice.
16

Stratty,

26/04/2008 15:21:39
Before logging off, in his book "Dose of Sanity", Neuro-psychiatrist Sydney Walker says

"The similarities between street drug abuse and psychotropic prescription drug use are disturbing. Both types are toxic. Both can cause psychosis, damage the brain and other organs, and even cause death. And neither type of mind-altering drugs, legal or illegal, treats disease. It’s important to recognize that the only significant difference between many prescription psychotropic drugs and street drugs such as “speed” and “downers” is that prescription drugs are legal."





17

Stratty,

26/04/2008 15:35:40
I forgot to mention that we know at least that the NHS QIS (the group in the article by Scotsman above) are to be paid £80,000.00 for 'identifying' the 33,000 children in Scotland who "could" (but equally could not) have undiagnosed ADHD.

http://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/news-feed/2008/04/26/33-000-kids-with-adhd-86908-20395084/

That is the money they'll get from HOLYROOD - who are

"...Scotland’s leading political publishing and communications organisation. Our flagship title Holyrood magazine has acquired a reputation for objective, non partisan and authorative reporting of Scottish and UK Government, the Scottish Parliament and Scotland’s Unilateral Local Authorities. Today we stand on the leading edge of information delivery publishing in both print and online platforms..."

http://www.holyrood.com



18

Stratty,

26/04/2008 15:45:04
Re Holyrood - is it too closely tied to the pharmaceutical industry and lobbyists?


"Criticism over relaunched Holyrood business scheme
Sunday Herald , 3 June 2007

"A HOLYROOD business scheme criticised for giving lobbyists preferential access to MSPs has run into further trouble after an industry insider was appointed as its interim director..."

"...It encountered another difficulty after one of the MSP participants, Labour's Margaret Jamieson, signed a 10-year confidentiality agreement with pharmaceutical giant Pfizer as a condition of accepting a placement.

A report by the Standards Committee criticised the exchange and described its lack of legal accountability to Parliament as "unacceptable". Around £100,000 of public money was also given to the organisation.

However,the Sunday Herald can reveal that the relaunched SPBE has failed to address the key problem raised by its critics, namely its closeness to Scotland's lobbying fraternity..."

Extracts from: http://www.spinwatch.org/content/view/4241/9/







19

S MacLeod,

26/04/2008 16:13:11
Stratty,

thanks for the info, it is VERY interesting.

;-)
20

Voldemort,

Edinburgh 26/04/2008 17:00:02
Jaysus, how pathetic the world is becoming ... I agree with Guga - a swift clout round the lug will solve alot of problems with these kids - they have no discipline in their lives and the symptoms are interpreted as hyper activity - into which there has to be £billions poured.

Drugs companies will be all to eager to promote this 'new' disease and to market their non-effective (or addictive) drugs to 'combat' the problem.

21

Caora Dubh,

Croit sheasgair 26/04/2008 21:46:16
I don't understand. Perhaps there is a doctor or scientist reading who could explain matters: When I was a child none of us had "ADHD". Some of us were boisterous and naughty, but some of us were also quiet and calm. Are all people in the tails of bell curve distributions of characteristics suffering from syndromes or diseases? Should geniuses receive drugs to bring them back to normal? Should outstanding young athletes be treated to make them normal? The world used to need all kinds of people, people who were physically strong, perhaps even with a touch of aggression, as well as people who were academically gifted. But "physical" people have little role in today's society apart from professional sport, so all children MUST succeed academically. Is this right? Is ADHD a real disease, or merely an extreme characteristic for which today's society has no use?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.