Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 11th May 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Asylum seeker suffers from drug-resistant form of TB



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 22 March 2008
A MAN was in hospital fighting a rare form of tuberculosis yesterday as health experts sought to reassure the public that precautions were being taken to prevent it spreading.
The patient – believed to be from Somalia – is being treated for Extremely Drug-Resistant TB (known as XDR-TB) at Gartnavel General Hospital in Glasgow.

It is the first time this strain of TB has been diagnosed in the UK since the definition of t
he infection was changed in 2006.

People who have been in close contact with the patient are now being screened for XDR-TB, which is resistant to the drugs routinely used to treat TB.

But Dr Oliver Blatchford, a consultant in public health medicine in Glasgow, said that people were no more likely to catch this form of TB than other type of the disease.

"It is no more infectious than ordinary TB but it does require different treatment," he said. "The contacts of this case are being screened in the same way as ordinary TB contacts. They will be monitored closely to ensure any further cases are identified early and treated quickly."

XDR-TB needs to be treated with a combination of antibiotics to ensure the patient is cured and to prevent transmission of the disease to others.

TB, which usually infects the lungs, is spread through prolonged and close contact with an infected person, such as through coughing and sneezing.

Normal TB is usually treated with a six-month course of antibiotics, which must be completed to stop the disease from returning or drug resistance developing.

The Glasgow patient, who is believed to have claimed political asylum in the UK, is reported to have been screened for infectious diseases when he arrived at Heathrow Airport last November. An X-ray revealed scarring on his lungs and he told doctors he had received a six-month course of TB treatment.

But after arriving in Scotland, he was admitted to hospital and was found to have the extremely resistant strain of the disease.

UK immigration officials can ask people arriving from countries with a high prevalence of TB to be tested if they suspect they are ill. But testing of every arrival is not compulsory.

Paul Sommerfeld, from the charity TB Alert, said: "This case of XDR-TB is worrying, but it is not a cause for great panic.

"There have been cases of extremely resistant TB in countries around the world and it is usually a sign that something has gone wrong in health services.

"Someone may have had TB but they have not completed their treatment or the disease has not properly been cleared, so it remains and can come back in a resistant form."

Mr Sommerfeld said the real danger from XDR-TB was to those unlucky enough to be infected. "We have virtually no drugs that are effective against this TB," he said. "The only drugs are available to treat it are going to be extremely expensive and rather toxic."

Last year, 401 cases of TB were reported in Scotland, up from 384 in 2006.





The full article contains 521 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 21 March 2008 10:07 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 22/03/2008 00:47:48
Well what do you expect,?

We had eradicated TB on British soil many years ago, becoming an, 'open bucket', has a price to pay!

Complacency, being the highest price!
2

Evia,

22/03/2008 00:50:54
Charles, you are up late tonight. Shouldn't you be in bed by this time?

Every arrival should be tested if not turned away.
3

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 22/03/2008 01:11:11
2 Evia, yes prob I should be in bed, but DYW knows I was up looking over her course work, to help her, she is an 'early-bedder' anyhows, always shattered after looking after the Babies at her place of work, she gets cuddled in though and her glass of milk and biscuit brought to her in bed, 15mins later she is zonked!

As re this subject, your comment, like mine is first thought,

NOT as an issue that maybe construed as being 'R' but to one of fact.

NO disrespect given or implied, to the "arrivals"
4

W Smith,

Middle East 22/03/2008 02:19:31
TB free Gurkhas who have fought for Britain are struggling to get British passports and proper health care.

Meanwhile, Scotland is welcoming muslims with TB.

Obviously the Gurkhas are 'asian' but not 'asian' enough for the SNP's support.
5

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 22/03/2008 02:37:19
Difficult topic to comment on!, without the fear of you comment being removed by the Moderator, but I think we are all of the same opinion!

The 'watch-word' being our, P&Q's!
6

C.U. Jimmy,

22/03/2008 04:37:55
There are many countries into which immigration is conditional on testing free from infectious or communicable diseases on arrival. These include HIV and other sexually transmitted infections, Hepatitis, and so on. It is self-evident why those countries consider this to be a basic requirement.

It beggars belief that the UK does not require the same precautions on its would-be immigrants. In effect the Government are needlessly exposing the rest of the population to 100% avoidable health risks, in the name of political correctness.

7

Rulesbutnotrulers,

Federation, not separation 22/03/2008 06:46:16
Asylum seekers should report to the nearest safe country. This person has no rights here, sick or not. Let's help him, but much nearer to his own homeland.
8

Max Born,

22/03/2008 08:12:28
I see all the usual suspects are here with thier stick on moustaches and jack boots.
Note to Editor: why did you see fit to stick the ayslum-seeker lable on this patient?This information is no more relevant to the piece than me being a one legged dwarf from Renfrewshire.
9

Max Born,

22/03/2008 08:14:06
No offence intend to amputees of small stature living in the West of Scotland.
10

Hermitage,

Edinburgh 22/03/2008 08:17:07
1) Come here as asylum-seeker, carrying an infectious, drug-resistant disease.

2) Remain here and be treated on OUR NHS at vast expense, while our own folk struggle to get treatment.

Send him back to where he came from.
11

Gdgy,

dundy 22/03/2008 08:24:26
So this is "bad" drug resistant TB because he is an assylum seeker - reminds me of the bad AIDs sketch from brass eye...
I suppose it would have been better if this guy had died abroad - then we could have really taken the moral high ground

BTW it is no easier to catch than TB and those people ranting about assylum seekers are at least risk because they will NEVER come in contact with an assylum seeker....
BTW great colleciton of IMNOs
BTW2 dwarfs are actually at greter risk of TB because their lungs are closer to the source of infection.....
12

Max Born,

22/03/2008 08:39:06
#11Gdgy.
IMNOs?
13

C.U. Jimmy,

22/03/2008 08:50:10
Oh dear, now the bleeding hearts and failed comedians have arrived. #8 and #11, so sorry for mistakenly assuming that you could beyond the end of your knee-jerk reactions.

Try not to dwell on an individual case. Think about the big picture. It's a competitive world out there. The UK owes nobody a living, least of all sick foreigners. As I said above, a lot of (probably most) other countries require their immigrants to be healthy, and often require them to possess a marketable skill or profession that is in short supply locally. Why shouldn't we?
14

somerferg,

Perth 22/03/2008 09:02:48

#4 - usual anti-SNP pi$h from you I see!!
15

Max Born,

22/03/2008 09:24:47
#4
Where in the piece does it state that this man is a Muslim?
The reporting on the "story" is shabby in the extreme, full of "believed to be from" and "believed to have claimed political asylum " this is pandering to the lowest common denominator. The lable Asylum Seeker is used in place of the N word.
16

,

22/03/2008 09:55:34
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
17

Griffe,

22/03/2008 10:53:22
This is biological warfare in its simplest form.
18

Horrible Cankers at the Cyber Shebeen,

22/03/2008 12:25:16
Could have been worse...could have been Ebola...then ye's wid hiv sumthin tae shout aboot!
19

Robert,

Kirriemuir 22/03/2008 13:06:18
Let us be grateful at having detected this infection! Let us also give consideration to those who accompanied him on his journey (was it on a plane) and those who are currently engaged in treating him and let us hope it can be contained and the guy's infection cured. TB has been on the increase in Scotland for probably in excess of 25 years and seems to have no connection to immigrants.
20

sam the god,

22/03/2008 13:35:14
close the doors round up all the illegals and boot them out of the country
21

hassan i sabbah,

edinburgh 22/03/2008 14:12:21
Not like Scot never travel to other countries to better themselves,Pretty pathetic that the majority of posters on express jingoistic fear,hatred and loathing about this
I never knew there were so many potential BNP voters with computers.Hateful and sad.
By the way Sam yer no a God.Just a scared fearful wee man.sorry about that.
22

Methalions,

22/03/2008 14:52:49
4

You are a racist pathetic fool. Grow up and stop infesting these boards.
23

Digory,

Narnia Scotland 22/03/2008 15:59:11
Here prisoners are allowed children as pen pals in the Community. Best to avoid those who are "experts" on young people now being sent into Schools and their "bespoke" Scottish Executive mentored partners they simply introduce children to the other side of Life and those whose lives they have influenced before.
24

Digory,

Narnia Scotland 22/03/2008 16:04:15
Correction Scottish Enterprise mentored
25

Digory,

Narnia Scotland 22/03/2008 16:05:43
Meantime Local Doctors remove them from their books and pretend that they no longer exist.
26

Digory,

Narnia Scotland 22/03/2008 16:09:06
Resettlement camps.
27

Digory,

Narnia Scotland 22/03/2008 16:13:06
Mirroring the movement of Administrators and other planned developments.
28

Big Willie Winkie (Wee was already taken),

22/03/2008 16:35:37
#23-27.
Somebody must have left your cage open.
29

,

22/03/2008 17:11:30
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
30

sam the god,

22/03/2008 17:17:33
#21 hassan i sabbah


All I can say is I want the best for MY birth country can you say the same *** passport*** if that makes me rasist then I am a rasist

Where were you born? PS bet he would spounge of us tax payers
31

The Bear with Teeth,

22/03/2008 17:50:43
And I thought the Scottish education system was second to none....

This is a really sad set of comments on this article. It's TB for goodness sake. The poor individual. And I agree with Max. Why mention he was an asylum seeker in the headline? No good reason. Shame on you Evening News.
32

The Bear with Teeth,

22/03/2008 17:55:41
Oops I should have said shame on the Scotsman :-)
Apologies. Probably all the same anyway
33

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 22/03/2008 17:56:37
#31

"Why mention he was an asylum seeker in the headline? No good reason."

Because he is! and why mislead the public to the contrary,?

Fact is TB was eradicated here in the UK years ago, reason must be given if TB shows its 'ugly head' again.
34

Digory,

/ 22/03/2008 18:02:42
33
Which course is it that your wife is taking?
35

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 22/03/2008 18:18:53
#34,
Expliquez-vous,?
36

The Bear with Teeth,

22/03/2008 18:21:06
33

Eradicated? Lord Darnley pub ring any bells???
White, male, Glaswegian by birth suffers from TB. Not a headline we would see really is it?
37

hassan i sabbah,

edinburgh 22/03/2008 18:56:31
Sam be rasist if ye want its just a word that only exists in yer ain heid ya big daft RACIST ye
Bye the way Bangour hospital is where I was born so,unfortunately i have to share MY country with vile wee punters like you

P.S Get spellcheck Then you will only look like a simple racist not a racist simpleton.
38

giuseppe de santis,

london 22/03/2008 19:16:37
Another of the "benefits" of mass immigration.
Apart the cost what about the risk for native Britons to be infected?
It's time to vote for the British National Party and take control of our country.
39

,

22/03/2008 19:18:48
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
40

Big Willie Winkie (Wee was already taken),

22/03/2008 19:28:24
#38 Giuseppe,
You can vote for the BNP (or Boris Johnson) in your Country, and while your at it keep your nose and your jack-booted feet out mine.
41

Big Willie Winkie (Wee was already taken),

22/03/2008 19:43:27
33 Charles Linskaill,
I will deal with you later.
42

Big Willie Winkie (Wee was already taken),

22/03/2008 20:26:59
In very public fashion
43

sam the god,

22/03/2008 21:17:34
#37 hassan i sabbah

Well I can trace my ancestry back 12 generations (and still counting) in this country can you say the same?
We have limited resources without it being squandered on illegal immigrants who mainly come from Asian and African countries so I stand by my statement “close the doors round up all the illegal immigrants and boot them out of the country”.
44

truthsleuth,

22/03/2008 22:08:47
Yet another cultural benefit.
45

truthsleuth,

23/03/2008 00:34:45
Latest down here (reported in evening newspaper)is that a parent whose child was in contact with suspect tb sufferers took the child to the local GP to get the child immunised.
The child was refused when the parent asked why the parent was told 'because your child is white'.
46

hassan i sabbah,

edinburgh 23/03/2008 14:11:27
12 centuries and ye still canne spell for toffee.So are ye of Pictish , Irish,or Viking descent? Mr true blood, or just a joke?
47

sam the god,

23/03/2008 14:33:12
#46 hassan i sabbah

I am of pictish descent which is indigenous to this country what part of the middle east melting pot are you descended from? When did your ancestors arrive in this country?.
Either way this country is full to the brim with these illegal immigrants and something has to be done like forced repatriation to the country of origin.
If you are not aware to request asylum status you must ask for it in the FIRST safe country from where you are fleeing so the person that has TB should have asked for asylum in Somalia. How many countries has this person travelled through to get to here so he can sponge off the UK taxpayer. He should be put on the first flight back to Somalia as he has no legal status in this country.
48

slimemold,

england 23/03/2008 16:05:17
The government is importing loads with TB (not this particular strain) and HIV.
49

hassan i sabbah,

edinburgh 23/03/2008 16:58:11
So yer genealogy was mapped out in a carved stone?where aboot Aberlemno?Kemnie?
How can you prove that you are descended from a society that left no records? Stop this now,yer making an erse oot ay yer sel'.There is a fair chance that your pure blood was "corrupted"by some incomers over the years so am sorry the chances of ye being pictish are slight to say the least.Anyway if yer wee fantasy keeps ye happy so be it ,just don't let it allow yersel tae be a silly wee fearful bigot.Just go awy happy in the knowlege that you are a "TRUE" Scot!Celebrate yer culture!
Go eat some shortbread 'n' listen tae some Fran an Anna
and feel genetically superior ya deluded wee mannie! Thanks for the laugh....
50

sam the god,

23/03/2008 20:10:23
#49 hassan i sabbah

Well I take it your bloodline is corrupted by Christian crusaders and probably some Jewish blood as well.

However it does not alter the fact thiscountry is infested with asylum seekers
51

Stefania Alvarez,

23/03/2008 21:23:11
Somalia is a Muslim country
it is located near Kenya in the horn of Africa
... probably safe to assume he is Black then too ... yes??
... so people can logically draw the conclusion that this guy is a Muslim

... let's call him a Health-care Seeker rather than asylum seeker
... he came cos he knew he would get free treatment for the disease he probably already knew he had anyway.
52

Jock MacTamson 2,

Highlands 24/03/2008 10:23:39
Why is it the responsibility of the UK taxpayer to accept (at risk to the general population) a very sick individual with no previous contribution to our country or system from anywhere.

I do not care if he is black, brown, yellow or day glow pink.

He is a parasite.

The facts as I see it are, he had already received TB treatment in Somalia, entered the country via Heathrow exposing all other passengers to resistant TB, knew he had the disease and wilfully risks all others he came into contact with, entered the UK for free treatment, cost the UK taxpayer a several hundred thousand pounds in treating the drug, cost the NHS time and resources in keeping him isolated, cost our government more money, time and resources tracking down all he has exposed to this disease.

Yet all you PC nut jobs want to protect his right to come here and share our provisions. It is not called sharing it is called being a parasite. Contribute nothing and take everything you need regardless of consequences for others.

What if it was your child he was sitting beside in the train or plane from London to Glasgow that now needs to stay in hospital for 6 months.

The world is full of sad situations and desperate people. If you are that concerned for them. Get on a plane and go there and risk yourself to help. But do not expect everyone else to pay for your emotional weakness. Life is cruel and we cannot save everyone. Lets start by focussing on our own problems. Not bankrupting our state to keep people from countries that would gladly see our destruction.

If I am labelled a Racist fine but more importantly I am a realist not a dreamer, and your dreams are going to be nightmares for your children and future generations. If they survive.
53

Jock MacTamson 2,

Highlands 24/03/2008 11:25:14
In Reply to: The Bear with Teeth, hassan i sabbah,Big Willie Winkie

In order to avoid any further claims of racisim lets pass this one over to the experts.

Answers provided by the Academy of Medical Sciences to the House of Lords Ad Hoc Committee on Intergovernmental Organisations

"16. Within the UK, the likely pattern of spread of TB will depend to a large extent on
the political commitment to focus on issues such as diagnosis, control programmes,
treatment regimens and poverty. The frequency of migration of individuals from
areas of high endemicity to low endemicity may also affect further spread.

25. Cases of TB fell progressively in the UK until the mid-1980s but started to
rise again in the early 1990s. Around 6,500 cases are now reported each
year, an increase of about a quarter since the early 1990s. What are the
main factors of the revival of TB infections in Britain? And how could
intergovernmental action help to reverse the trend? (8)

Within the UK, immigration and international travel strongly influence TB infection
rates. For instance, rates of infection between 2000 and 2004 increased in the non-
UK born population but remained stable in the UK-born population. The majority of
cases were reported in individuals from South Asia or sub-Saharan Africa."

I know its a global conspiracy of racists telling lies about immigration and nothing to do with the truth.

Immigration dramatically increases HIV & TB inflections in this country, Immigrants make up the largest number of people with these infections, This costs the NHS a fortune, We are paying for it, They come here rather than other countries due get free for all NHS.

The truth should never be called racism or intollerance. The truth should always be out for debate free from politically correct prejudice.

If you PC luvvies spent more time solving problems than denying the problems then we would get some progress.

54

Evia,

24/03/2008 13:23:44
Jock MacTamson 2

Excellent posts.

Like you, I don't care what colour a person is. I also don't care what their nationality a is. If these people are here to sponge off the British taxpayer, I do object to their being here, particularly when they are bringing disease with them.

We need to have strictly controlled immigration, with proper medical checks and all costs paid for by the applicants. The applicants should be of good health and jobs waiting for them. Better still would be to get our own lazy, work-shy off their backsides and into work.

This country is becoming unfit for our future generations, due to resources being spread too thinly.
55

Jock MacTamson 2,

24/03/2008 14:10:27
In Reply to: The Bear with Teeth, hassan i sabbah,Big Willie Winkie

In order to avoid any further claims of racisim lets pass this one over to the experts.

Answers provided by the Academy of Medical Sciences to the House of Lords Ad Hoc Committee on Intergovernmental Organisations

"16. Within the UK, the likely pattern of spread of TB will depend to a large extent on
the political commitment to focus on issues such as diagnosis, control programmes,
treatment regimens and poverty. The frequency of migration of individuals from
areas of high endemicity to low endemicity may also affect further spread.

25. Cases of TB fell progressively in the UK until the mid-1980s but started to
rise again in the early 1990s. Around 6,500 cases are now reported each
year, an increase of about a quarter since the early 1990s. What are the
main factors of the revival of TB infections in Britain? And how could
intergovernmental action help to reverse the trend? (8)

Within the UK, immigration and international travel strongly influence TB infection
rates. For instance, rates of infection between 2000 and 2004 increased in the non-
UK born population but remained stable in the UK-born population. The majority of
cases were reported in individuals from South Asia or sub-Saharan Africa."

I know its a global conspiracy of racists telling lies about immigration and nothing to do with the truth.

Immigration dramatically increases HIV & TB inflections in this country, Immigrants make up the largest number of people with these infections, This costs the NHS a fortune, We are paying for it, They come here rather than other countries due get free for all NHS.

The truth should never be called racism or intollerance. The truth should always be out for debate free from politically correct prejudice.

If you PC luvvies spent more time solving problems than denying the problems then we would get some progress.


56

The Bear with Teeth,

24/03/2008 20:42:12
Jock

Post made better for reading it twice. My comments were more relating to poor journalism.

However I am always amused to be called pc as if it were, well like having a rare strain of TB. The ethos of healthcare in this country is that we dont judge, we treat and I'm proud of that.

One last thing to remember is that the UK and Scotland are different in terms of healthcare but other things also. the statistics relating to TB might be a bit different in Scotland. Go have a look....

And I truly love a conspiracy......

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.