Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


You lived the dream Brooks, now why let the nightmare happen? - An open letter to Gretna owner

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 03 June 2008
Dear Brooks, IT'S BEEN quite some time since we were last in correspondence. This note is written in the hope that you are approaching better health and on the back of some difficult times for Scottish football.

I hope it reaches you but understand this is unlikely, since even Ron MacGregor, the man who was chairman of your club and whose wife was a long-time secretary, admitted on Sunday that he has been left in the dark about your current condition. And
note the past tense. MacGregor was chairman of the club. His wife, Helen, was a secretary. This might be employed a lot in this letter, since Gretna have to all intents and purposes been returned to their pre-1946 status. They don't exist. But football might at least continue at Raydale Park if you can make one last grand gesture and purchase the ground as a gift for the locals, to allow a new football team to rise from the club's ashes.

Although I am sure you know all of this.

Your health problems are your own private concern, of course. However, you were prepared to offer detailed accounts of the ailments which were attacking your body during those times when it was desirable to have a high profile. And now we have knowledge of a note you presented to the Scottish Football League management committee. It was included in the submission prepared by the consortium who were generally credited with being Gretna's last chance of survival. In actual fact it was the last but one. You remain the locals' one hope for football to still be played in the town in the months and years to come. Perhaps not as Gretna FC. But as representatives of a proud town, and in whatever league they can gain access to.

In this note, that was described as being handwritten, you expressed a desire for your shares in Gretna to be transferred to the consortium headed by Paul Davies, a Glasgow-based football agent. But at the club itself, where more than 70 people have been made redundant, there has not been so much as a word heard from you, or your family. Your son, Craig, was even still working at the club when the first ominous portents were heard, but remained an enigmatic, peripheral presence. It is hard to escape the conclusion that responsibilities have been shirked.

Gretna have been left high and dry in circumstances that are admittedly difficult, as well as sensitive. You have spoken openly about your respect for those who shunned the lure of major clubs to support teams at the other end of the spectrum. But in the recent silence from anyone connected to the 'Mileson camp' there is an alarming level of scorn for those who you once claimed were your type of people.

The club's history isn't the most gilded, nor is it the longest. But it is worth protecting. The story of Gretna is not just their recent exploits. It's also cracking tales of derring-do in the early Nineties, when a side then in the second tier of the Northern League came through five qualifying rounds to qualify for the first round of the FA Cup, where they almost defeated Bolton. During a 45-year stay in the Carlisle & District league, Gretna won the title on 28 occasions.

You gave them much, Brooks. But in return, they gave you all they had to give, and perhaps more. The ground now looks set to be sold to help pay creditors. There was one Gretna local I remember meeting on one of many trips south to Dumfries & Galloway to report on a tale given fresh momentum by your financial input. He was a circumspect type, who refused to get carried away by the hype. He stressed that he simply wanted the club to be left as it had been found – at worst. Even this modest desire has been made to look wildly optimistic.

You enjoyed a very warm relationship with the media, and other fans of clubs who saw in your ungroomed style a kindred spirit. You handed out contributions to supporters' groups at Dundee United and Ayr United, among other clubs. There was rarely a bad word said about you, and few questioned your love of grass-roots football. Nobody could feign interest in teams such as Whitby Town for so long, they reasoned.

Indeed, your heart proved an easy conquest. And surely, we pondered, the Scottish football world is not so harsh a place that there is no room in it for Brooks Mileson and his band of Gretna over-achievers. But now it appears there is no room. And this is something which provides a lot of ache for the fans of Gretna, who have now had their football club summarily torn from them.

There were doubters. One I recall clutching a pint in the Gretna social club, pressing the pads of a battered looking one-armed bandit. He was a former player for Gretna. A goalkeeper. "There was once a football club there," he motioned in the direction of Raydale Park. "Now it means nothing to the people of Gretna. It's gone to one bloke. What happens when he pulls out?"

Now we know. The answer arrived in a stark email released by the administrators yesterday, advising recipients – perhaps you were on this email list too – of "recent developments". It was everything that had been feared.

You adored your time on the fish supper 'n' Lucozade tour of Scotland. We lapped this up too, and feasted on other colourful aspects of your life, including the animal sanctuary established on the land surrounding your Cumbrian home. You would have something to say about a dog left abandoned shortly after Christmas by its owner. Gretna and the club's fans deserve at least a note of explanation for what has happened in the course of the last year. Otherwise Brooks Mileson, man of the people, will be remembered as just another of football's bogeymen. No one wants this, Brooks.



Yours in sport,

Alan Pattullo

apattullo@scotsman.com





The full article contains 1034 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 02 June 2008 10:47 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Gretna FC
 
1

kiwidoug,

22 In A Row 03/06/2008 01:48:34
Really good article this. There are so many parallels between Brooks and Vlad. One of their shared traits is the ability to exercise silence when people are desperately seeking answers.

Surely Brooks would feel that the townspeople and supporters deserve to hear his perspective on this sad demise.
2

,

03/06/2008 02:32:15
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
3

Jon Bon Jovi,

03/06/2008 03:18:23

its never been made clear has it... has brooks run out of money or is he your typical dictator who doesnt give anything back once pulling out of a project???

for any jambos reading this could easily happen to you!!
4

Van City Hibee,

03/06/2008 06:49:03
its his son, Craig, safeguarding his inheritence.

in my opinion of course
5

flecktimus,

Notts 03/06/2008 07:00:38
This event with Gretna was predicted to me more than 2 years ago.Apparently any Scarbourgh Town football fan could have told you all about Brooks.

6

Brown Dirt Cowboy,

St.Andrews 03/06/2008 07:35:09
Don't think he has run out of money yet #3. Hence the get out quick routine before he does. Great article. Sorry for the real fans.
7

Ichabod,

03/06/2008 07:37:42
Van City Hibee,

I tend to agree. I get the feeling he does not want to get involved any more, nor lose more cash. I wonder, if anew Gretna arrive, will he look for the cash apparently owed to Brooks?

Not sure what the next comment re Scarborough means, but they have died! They once were a 4th div side who were badly run, now no more!
8

Star o' Rabbie Burns,

New Cumnock, CUMNOCK 03/06/2008 07:58:03
The last time I saw Brooks Mileson at a Gretna game, during their season in the First Division I thought I had never seen a greyer, more ill man. To me, some 15 months ago, he was a dead man walking - so his ill-health is no smoke screen.

But there were even then as he first took ill and even before the whole Rowan Alexander thing kicked off, optimistic noises in the media about putting in place a structure which would allow the club to continue even if Brooks was no longer fit and able to run it - the legacy was being safe-guarded.

Clearly this was bull and if Ron McGregor and the other directors couldn't ensure these big promises were kept, then they were at best puppets, more likely muppets.

The SFL, SPL and SFA have all been remiss in their duty of care to the good name of football. Or does football still have a good name?

All a very sad tale. Good open letter by young Alan though, as a Dundee fan, he knows all about big promises leading to a big let-down.
9

SHANGHAI SCOT,

SHANGHAI 03/06/2008 08:06:01
The writing was on the wall last year when Craig was placed in charge, his first action was to shut down the youth development team coaching at Penrith.

At one time the Gretna coaches and players took time to visit schools with the message that sport was good,drugs bad, infact there was a much effort by Gretna staff to support local communities in the Gretna and Annan area.

It was a dream, I attended the semi and final in that year, great atmosphere.

The promotion to the SPL was well above their caabilities given the ground capacity and the realatively small fan base.

Ground sharing at Motherwell was the nail in the coffin

I would like to think that Brooks or his son issue a statement to the good folk of Gretna, if not an apology at least some explanation of why this dream ended in a nightmare
10

Targy,

Livingston 03/06/2008 08:14:31
An extremely well written open letter, let's hope it is somehow brought to the attention of Brooks and prompts a response.
11

flecktimus,

03/06/2008 08:43:59

#7 Not sure what the next comment re Scarborough means, but they have died! They once were a 4th div side who were badly run, now no more!

Just like Gretna! You may find a common denominator between the 2 clubs!!!!!!!!!!
12

J.A.,

03/06/2008 08:52:00
As someone with only a passing interest, it looked to me as if this whole escapoade was doomed from the start. What did people think was to become of Gretna FC after Brookes Mileson’s millions eventually ran out? Yes it is a terrible shame on those who are left to pick up the pieces but what on earth were they thinking was going to eventually happen?
13

Bobby, Glasgow,

03/06/2008 09:02:25
I noticed that Rowan Alexander is 'owed' £800,000. I believe he and Brooks Mileson were not on the best of terms.

Perhaps this was the last straw for Mileson - he may have been prepared to keep the club afloat at SFL level - but maybe not if it meant giving Rowan Alexander £800,000.
14

,

03/06/2008 09:11:32
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
15

Ron the Dem,

Cumbernauld 03/06/2008 09:12:01
Scottish football's BIG problem is that we are too SMALL.
When the Premier League was started we had criteria that said you had to at least be of a reasonable size with ground capacity to allow Celtic and Rangers, Hearts and Hibs, and Dundee Utd and Aberdeen fans to be able to travel and watch their team's matches in proper surroundings.
Falkirk was denied promotion several times until they were able to bring their stadium up to scratch.
St Mirren went into debt to bring their ground into specification.
St Johnstone, Dundee, Dunfermline and Livingstone were able to play at good grounds and paid money for improvements that would otherwise been used for player investments.
However the weak willed spurred on by the Scottish Media forced the SPL to change the rules after the aforementioned clubs had put their investments on their grounds in place.
We reduced the criteria and allowed fly by night teams driven by over investment in players and under investment in facilities to rise unchecked through the leagues.
This foolishness has not only shown the SPL in a poor light it has also shown the world that we are incompetent.
If say St. Johnstone, Dunfermline, Livingstone or Dundee were in the place of Gretna we would have had a proper competition instead of the shambolic situation that has existed this season.
I would call upon the SPL to replace the present criteria with the original rules as all of the major teams now comply with them except perhaps Hamilton and they can be given time to comply.
Some say farewell to Gretna I say Good Riddance, you have taken the SPL back years.
Bet you the league Sponsors and Setanta are not too pleased and It will be brought home when the next round of Sponsor Talks are taking place.
16

CBJambo,

03/06/2008 09:33:49
#17
I'm guessing there is only really one man fit enough and in control of the purse strings now that is in a position to answer the various questions that are arising.

I'm also guessing it was him who pulled the plug as soon as he was given control of the Mileson millions, whilst still taking a paycheque from the club!
17

Johnny Jambo,

03/06/2008 09:41:10
A very good article, written as an open letter to Brooks Mileston, but my only question is why not sooner?
18

Swordsman,

Dublin 03/06/2008 09:52:22
#8
"The last time I saw Brooks Mileson at a Gretna game, during their season in the First Division I thought I had never seen a greyer, more ill man. To me, some 15 months ago, he was a dead man walking - so his ill-health is no smoke screen.."
Given the man smokes upwards of eighty ciggies a day,I suggest that it WAS a smoke screen....
19

Cathcart Boy,

London 03/06/2008 10:05:24
Sorry to repeat from another thread, but Alan Patullo is spot on.
Gretna is in Administration, ie insolvent (clers that up for #18, I hope).
Net of amounts to Mileson and Alexander, with Alexander's being negotiable as anything is better than nil and he's only at the claim stage, not agreed, debts fall to £1.4m
A liquidator in my opinion is likely to conclude that Gretna traded whilst insolvent and that the directors are obligated to contribute to the deficit
So - £2m from Mileson, write-off £1.8m, negotiate Alexander's claim and the crisis is ended.
20

Celtic Bhoy,

Carlisle 03/06/2008 10:29:00
I think Brook at the very least should make some kind of statement, the club is in a worse state now than before he came.

The Scottish League must also take some of the blame.
21

Ian.M,

North Ayrshire 03/06/2008 12:03:28
The behaviour of Mileson is mystifying. Even allowing for his health problems his total silence is the strangest part in all of this. He never came across as a fly-by-night, albeit a little eccentric. It's a real shame for people who have supported Gretna for years.
22

Highland Wasp,

Inverness 03/06/2008 12:11:34
Good letter albeit a few years too late. The "There was rarely a bad word said about you" line is way off as loads of people in Scottish football were predicting this ever since Mileson started throwing cash at Gretna. Sadly the Scottish media preferred to ignore the obvious fact that the whole thing was built on shifiting sands and instead embraced Brooks as a charming eccentric.
If the thing was ever about Gretna FC rather than one mans ego then Mileson would have developed the ground first and made it a proper community structure which could help sustain Gretna long term. Instead he poured all the cash into the first team to maximise publicity.
The 'Living the Dream' claptrap in the media was a farce. There was no dream, it was hollow success paid for (or not as it turns out) by Brooks. The real dream at Gretna was a club who through sheer hard work rose from park football to play in the FA Cup then attained SFL status in Scotland. That was achieved over a period of around 50 years. Mileson killed it all off inside 5.
23

ian k,

Edinburgh 03/06/2008 12:23:33
I hope all the Hearts Fans read this article it should make them think long and hard , It could read VLAD instead of BROOKS
24

Stoobing,

London 03/06/2008 12:34:50
What has also not been mentioned was the sheer incompetence of the administrators.

Gretna have quite obviously not been financially viable for months but, perhaps overwhelmed by the 'romance' of the situation, a firm of professional administrators have let the club continue operating at an escalating debt.

It's obvious no feasible buyer was about so will anyone 'fess up to the additional debt incurred since mid Feb when the club first bounced payments to players?

Ridiculous situation, handled entirely by amateurs.
25

busbyfh,

03/06/2008 13:24:35
The huge amount of money WASTED to keep Gretna afloat throughout the last three months could have been used to pay off some creditors that are owed large amounts of money.
What good did playing their last ten games do ?
26

Highland Wasp,

Inverness 03/06/2008 13:55:50
The administrator isnt stupid. He knew the SPL were desperate for Gretna to finish the season so as to not damage the image of the league further. As such he milked them for all it was worth and took a hefty sum. The bare minimum required to pay players etc went on that, the rest to the administrator. The creditors wont see a penny of it.
27

Star o' Rabbie Burns,

New Cumnock, CUMNOCK 03/06/2008 13:58:38
I was half-hoping Rowan Alexander would take over ownership of he ground, in lieu of his £800,000 settlement, then put together a team of journeymen to start in Division three and progress.

Now THAT would have been living the dream, but not even the Ego would pounce on that tit bit.
28

Osama Bin Liner,

edinburgh 03/06/2008 14:25:32
Is this really such a big mystery? Mileson junior, quite reasonably not wanting to see his inheritance disappear down a black hole, used his power of attorney, or some similar device to stop throwing good money after bad. Probably nothing to do with Brooks.
29

JB2003,

03/06/2008 14:30:48
I'm amazed that the SPL allowed this to happen. Surely a club must have to prove it has appropriate financing in place? All that would be needed would be a Guarantee from the financier (in this case Brooks).

I can easily see the directors being sued for losses incurred by creditors (including former staff) as they can't have been acting in accordance with their fiduciary duties to Gretna as a company if they were agreeing such hefty contracts without securing concrete financial backing to ensure that the club could wash it's face.

Awful circumstances for the Milesons but they should have been true to their word and treated the club, it's staff and fans with respect and bowed out with a bit of dignity.
30

Zambrosia,

Scotland 04/06/2008 00:28:20
I'm afraid it's not much of an "open letter". It is in fact, a begging letter.....and all the more tawdry for that. Heavens sake, Gretna have been "buying the dream" for four years or so, and here we have a journalist (of all people) calling them a band of "over achievers". Absolute nonsense. They were a collection of footballing mercenaries paid SPL wages in the Scottish 3rd, 2nd and 1st divisions. How the hell was that "over achieving"? Now you have the nerve to ask Brookson to buy Raydale for the fans. Please please please, have a bit of dignity and perspective. Not a single mention of a creditor.....the people who genuinely got shafted......just a "poor old us, the fans" whimper. Alan, your a journo for heaven's sake. The tooth fairy came to town and bought "success". Then that self same tooth fairy decided to extract every tooth in the Gretna gob. Do us all a favour, and play the man. Don't go whimpering back telling him how sad you are, and then ask for the begging bowl to be topped up once last time. Not only does it smack of desperation, the sentiment behind is every bit as odious as the manner of Mileson's leaving. Time to reap what you collectively sowed. Time to suck it all up. Time to quit being a junkie for someone else's cash.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.