Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


'Let everyone have a vote on assisted dying'

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 14 January 2009
A PENSIONER yesterday called for a referendum to be held on assisted dying.
George Anderson, a member of the Militant Retired group, is also urging the Scottish Parliament to hold a debate on the issue.

He made his case to Holyrood's public petitions committee just weeks after the independent MSP Margo MacDonald launched
a consultation on legalising assisted suicide.

Ms MacDonald launched a consultation on plans to make assisted suicide legal.

The Lothians MSP, who suffers from Parkinson's disease, has already said that she would like to be allowed to bring about her own death if her condition deteriorates.

Yesterday Mr Anderson said: "I'm asking people whether they want help at the end of their lives, if they want to get out of it. If Manchester city can hold a referendum on traffic congestion charges, it will seem perverse if this place treats assisted dying with less serious intention."

Mr Anderson said that, because assisted suicide is illegal in Britain, "terminally ill people were being forced into exile – like lepers in medieval times".

He suggested that the number of people forced to travel to clinics in countries where assisted suicide is legal might rise as the population of the United Kingdom aged.

He told MSPs it was a "phenomenon that can only increase if the ageing demographics are to be believed and the laws remain as they are".

MSPs on the committee agreed to raise his petition with the Scottish Government but they questioned the appropriateness of a referendum on assisted dying.

Bill Butler, Labour MSP for Glasgow Anniesland, pointed out referendums were usually held on constitutional issues.

And the SNP's MSP for North East Scotland, Nigel Don, said the issue was a "difficult one for MSPs and others to get to grips with".

But he added: "I've got to the point of recognising we need to have a debate about this."

In a submission sent to MSPs ahead of yesterday's meeting, Mr Anderson said he had spent two years as a student nurse and "experienced the reality of caring for the terminally ill".

He "formed the view that there must be a better way of facing our last days".

Mr Anderson added: "We need a whole rethink about end of life care and, to achieve it, it is necessary that the problem is widely aired.

"A nationally conducted referendum is probably the best way to achieve this, with assisted dying being one of the options made available."





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 13 January 2009 10:55 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Euthanasia
 
1

Horrible Cankers @Cyber Shebeen,

14/01/2009 00:17:46
Absolutely...I second that!
2

Wardog™,

14/01/2009 00:51:32

I'm for it but I can understand the concerns that many have that people start 'opting out' at the slightest sign of a debilitating disease when there is hope.

How can we ever hope to really legislate for this other than loopholes that are accepted.

3

Ewan Randall,

14/01/2009 01:41:13
Would someone who wasn’t suffering from psychological problems brought on by the revelation of their illness or state consider ending their own life?
4

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 14/01/2009 01:45:51


Here we go again on this subject!

If one had the intelligence, of the deviant People in our Lives, one would realise why this Law is not passed!

Our Ministers of Government are not stupid, they Know, if passed!, the Law on "Assisted Dying", would be abused!

I for one, don't want to see, in our News,...

..."Well old Aunt Mary, wanted to Die", because WE Wanted to claim on her £500k, Insurance Life Policy!


And it is quite simply this reason, "Assisted Dying", is not allowed in Law! (in our day-and-age, that is.)

I think 'Religion' has very little to do with this subject, more-the-likes, to what I said!,,..

"Aunt Mary" was,....'Bumped-offed', for her Insurance!

But she wanted to Die, Didn't She?












5

Anonym,

14/01/2009 05:51:57
Chuckles, if 'Aunt Mary' wants to die, then her insurance company might have a quible with the 500k life insurance.

Not that it would be any of your business.
6

tartan army 2222,

14/01/2009 07:51:22
I disagree with holding a referendum on this. Your vote should be the one where you choose whether to die an assisted death or not. This is a secular society, I am an athiest, so why should religious groups be telling me whether I can or cannot die when I am in pain beyond what they can comprehend.
7

Stan Butler,

14/01/2009 09:57:33

Christ on a bike. How difficult is it to kill yourself?

8

Walter Ego,

Durness 14/01/2009 10:15:25
This deserves serious consideration. Margo is right.
9

Observer,,

Glasgow 14/01/2009 10:30:36
2 Agreed Wardog - as much as I support the individuals desire for a good death, it would be incredibly difficult to legislate for. But that doesn't mean we shouldn't try.
10

ddmc,

14/01/2009 10:59:20
#4 the system should be you have to prove to at least 3 independant doctors including a psychatrist that a) your incurable & b) of sound mind, then you should be allowed to decide where & when you want to go, safe in the knowledge that no one will be prosecuted for helping
11

resident edinburgh,

14/01/2009 11:36:32
The debate on this must purely be on the sbuject of assisted suicide/ helpnmg someone to die.
Money does not come into it as insurance companies will not pay out on suicide and anyone who helps someone to commit suicide cannot benfit financially from the estate.
As long as this part does not change or is not changed then lets see how many want to continue the debate!
12

Churchill W.,

14/01/2009 11:54:20
If Margo MacDonald wants to kill herself, then so be it, there are ways and means. But, why are people like her so keen on taking others with them?
13

,

14/01/2009 19:11:35
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
14

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 14/01/2009 20:49:36


Alasdair mac Alasdair ~14,

Not ready to "Kick the Bucket", yet ya ken!

Afterall you would miss, the colour I bring you all!

As re: 'The Insurance Jobs', what I was talking about was,,

"Aunt Mary" Is a merry 'old soul', with plenty of life in her yet!

Her 'EVIL', 'Sister-in-Law' wants her DEAD!, for the Money!

She 'Drugs', "Aunt Marys" 'cuppa tea', and tells everyone, "Aunt Mary" wanted to Die!

'Of-Course' This is a simplified version, to show yo what may happen, if they pass this Law!

Hence LAW NOT PASSED!!!!,......FULL-STOP!!



 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.