Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Byrne still fuming about 'censorship' of smoking ban in theatres

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 20 April 2008
SCOTS playwright John Byrne has continued his campaign for an exemption to the smoking ban for theatres.
Byrne claims that the ban on lighting up on the stage is "censorship" and makes performances of plays unrealistic.

Although the smoking ban was brought in by the Labour-Lib Dem coalition more than a year before the SNP came to power, the legislati
on had cross-party support.

Byrne, whose partner is Oscar-winning actress Tilda Swinton, said: "One of the things which they have not acted on is reversing the ban on smoking on stage during plays. I wrote to Alex Salmond after the election asking him to change the law and I received a reply from a civil servant saying they were not going to change. It's a form of censorship and it's wrong."

In Ireland, which brought in its smoking ban before Scotland, performers are allowed to light up with herbal cigarettes on stage, but no such exemption applies in Scotland.

Ministers rejected herbal cigarettes claiming that some theatres in Ireland had been forced to abandon them as the overpowering smell meant actors could not concentrate. They have suggested alternatives which involved stunt cigarettes and talcum powder, but these have been derided by actors.

During the golden age of Hollywood, smoking played a part in some of cinema's most romantic scenes, such as Bette Davis receiving a cigarette from Paul Henreid in Now, Voyager.

Smoking in public places and the workplace is banned in California, but film and TV companies have obtained "industrial exemptions" to depict characters who smoke. In theatres on the west and east coasts of the United States, however, warnings must be put up in the foyer if an actor is to smoke on stage.

A Scottish Government spokesperson said: "The ban on smoking has proved overwhelmingly popular and beneficial to the health of the nation. John Byrne is absolutely entitled to put forward his point of view, but the law has to treat everyone fairly and equally, so there are no plans to amend it to allow smoking on stage."



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 19 April 2008 7:44 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
 
1

Tim85,

Lancs, England 20/04/2008 01:59:42
Anticipates anti-smoker response ... "If I'm watching a play featuring Winston Churchill, why should I have to put up with breathing in 'Winston's' filthy cigar smoke? Sod artistic concerns. What about my right to breathe clean air? Historical accuracy my foot! On-stage characterisations of real (Winston Churchill) or fictional figures (Sherlock Holmes) should give up smoking for MY health!"
2

tomi,

20/04/2008 03:46:28
Since plays are "make believe" anyway, why can't the actors make believe that they are smoking?

They use other props, why not a fake cigarette?

Why do they need to actually smoke a cigarette?
If the scene calls for a shooting or a stabbing or murder by a blunt object, they would not think of actually killing someone for the sake of reality, would they?
3

Belinda-2,

20/04/2008 10:34:49
A poor comparison, Tomi: improvising and creating illusion when it comes to killing is necessary for obvious reasons. If theatre directors regularly allowed actual murder on stage I would see a case for government intervention. Most improvising is left to the directors' discretion. If smoking on stage is so harmful why are actors working in England not all suing their employers for exposing them to life threatening danger whenever anyone lights up?
4

Andrew,

20/04/2008 10:40:13
You don't see actors going to the toilet on stage, do you and when they "drink" tea, coffee, whisky, wine etc (on stage), is it real or just coloured water?
5

Belinda-2,

20/04/2008 10:52:08
Show me a scene in drama that is set in a toilet!
6

Boy Wonder,

20/04/2008 11:53:31
#4 and #5 Apart from "Trainspotting"?

There are several films with toilet scenes.

And for plays ... there's "The Floating Bear" ... "Biloxi Blues" (which is also a movie) ... "The Man of Mode" ... need I go on??

I am completely with Mr Byrne is his assertions. For at least 200 years, smoking was an intrinsic part of our culture, less so today ... but actors and writers should be able to continue to reflect real life on stage.

I am not and never have been a smoker ... nor do I allow visitors to smoke in my living room especiall when my daughters are at home ... but a theatre is a different propostion and should be excluded from this unwarranted total ban!





7

Calum Crubag,

20/04/2008 13:28:13
What next Byrne? Legalised snuff movies? Gotta keep it real maaaan.
8

tjinphilly,

Greenock 20/04/2008 15:51:13
As an actor, who is NOT a smoker, and as a regular theatre goer, This is utter garbage! When I have played roles that required the actor to smoke, it helps the actor get into the character. The audience rarely if ever smells the smoke as the fly loft above the stage has negative pressure and draws the smoke and odor straight up. As for "stunt" cigeretters, many of us refuse to use them. If you want to know why, go into your loo and inhale a handful of talcum and tell me how you feel. Yeah, thats healthy for you! A magician friend of mine does a routine with a cigerette, he does not smoke, but the constant emission of smoke is necessary for the trick. You can't do that with a fake a cigerette. Think about this, I can burn incense, burn paper, burn lots of things that are more caustic on stage, but I can't light a cigerette? This on par with EU type regulations. I support smoking bans, I enjoy them when I at the pub and trying to enjoy the night out, but in such a large space as a stage, I don't buy this law.
9

Douglas,

Bathgate 20/04/2008 21:56:36
This could be challenged under sex discrimination laws.
Smokin' lesbians like kd lang and Portia diRossi are allowed in theatres so why no smoking fags? ;o)
10

english charlie,

suffolk 21/04/2008 20:23:31
Should we have the crucifixion without a cross, or a shooting without an immitation gun?
11

marmalade sandwich,

scotland 29/04/2008 09:44:05
Anyone going to see Nova Scotia at the Traverse, Byrne's truly excellent 4th part of his Slab Boys trilogy, will absolutely get what he is talking about.
12

matt02,

12/08/2008 19:38:00
I am a smoker and i bought an electric cigarette from www.friendlysmoking.com and it allows me to smoke back in the pub or any public place.

If you are a smoker and you miss having a cigarette indoors you should use one of these.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.