Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


School security review after city's £50,000 flood bill

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 02 June 2008
AN urgent review of school security has been ordered across the city after the damage caused by a flood at Portobello High was priced at more than £50,000.
Hundreds of children were sent home earlier this month after the flood was discovered on the sixth floor of an eight-storey building, with only senior pupils sitting their exams allowed to remain.

A sink in an art room was deliberately blocked wit
h a sheet of perspex, and the hot water tap turned on sometime over the holiday weekend at the start of May.

Council leaders today revealed that the flood caused widespread damage to light fittings, ceiling tiles and floor coverings over all six floors, as well as damage to physics equipment, books and other teaching materials.

There were no obvious signs of forced entry, and police are still investigating the incident, which is being treated as vandalism.

They are trawling through CCTV footage, but they are hampered by an old system with no fast-forward facility.

Education leader Marilyne MacLaren has ordered a review of janitorial duties in a bid to ensure there is no repeat of the incident at any Edinburgh school.

The £50,000 bill to the council is equivalent to 160 per cent of the average yearly maintenance budget for a high school.

Cllr MacLaren said: "This was an act of vandalism. Cupboards were also kicked in and vandalised in the same room. I will be calling for more janitorial cover, because from either the Friday or Saturday morning until the Tuesday, there had been no patrols at the school. This (review] will look across all schools, because I need to see what's happening."

Cllr MacLaren said the level of damage could have happened at any school in the Capital. However, Mike Robb, vice-chairman of the Portobello parents council, said the design of the building exacerbated the problem.

The school is on the waiting list for replacement, but there is still a lack of funding.

At a full council meeting last week, Mr Robb was joined by parents from Boroughmuir and James Gillespie's high schools in calling for a way forward on the city's £165 million school rebuilding programme.

Mr Robb said: "People are beginning to question just how serious the council treats the education of its young people."

City architect Malcolm Fraser, whose daughter attends Boroughmuir High, added: "We are all very frustrated by the politics of the situation. We don't want to see a scrap (among politicians].

"We are all looking for the city council to move things forward."

Cllr MacLaren said she was committed to all five "wave three" schools – including St John's Primary and St Crispin's Special School – and will present a business case next month.

The Labour group called for local school building trusts to be set up, while the Tories want external funding models such as "pioneer" schools to be investigated.





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 02 June 2008 11:47 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Potter,

Edinburgh 02/06/2008 12:52:21
Funny that. How can Marilyn MacLaren be so certain when the police are still investigating? It's still an open verdict. And the point still stands that the damage would not have been so extensive - whatever caused it - if it wasn't an EIGHT STOREY TOWERBLOCK.

This flood story has grown arms and legs in the telling. What the Senior Management Team of the school believe is:

It is more likely that a hot water tap was inadvertently left on in a sink on the Friday and ran for several days. In the sink was a small piece of Perspex, normally used for mixing paint and – probably - it slipped to cover the drainage hole. This was an art classroom, on the sixth floor, with a large array of ceramics which were undamaged.

The cupboard doors, which Marilyn MacLaren says were kicked off, had - in fact - come off cleanly. School staff did a practical experiment and showed that it was impossible for two grown men to rip them off like that, even using tools. On further close inspection, it was clear the glue had dissolved, probably due to the steam and the heat.

There was no trace of any intruder on camera, and no sign of anything untoward.

The vagaries of the School’s hot water system are such that you can turn on the hot tap and nothing happens, then a few minutes later, it starts to flow. A similar thing may well have happened here, but that small piece of Perspex had slipped to cover the drainage hole and the resulting flood wasn’t discovered for several days.

This flood could have been caused by someone filling a bowl of a bucket, or finishing off clearing up, oblivious of the idiosyncrasies of the hot water system.

Once staff had looked at the scene and the situation more closely, there was no sign of a malicious act.

The school has had absolutely fantastic support from officers in the Council and from all the contractors who put the school to back to rights in just one week – which was a tremendous feat. The school staff and pupils hav
2

Jakey Rowling,

02/06/2008 12:57:53
"Cllr MacLaren said she was committed to all five "wave three" schools"

I'd have though wave free would be a better approach.
3

school_ON_SITE,

Portobello 02/06/2008 12:58:54
Portobello parents should make them selfs aware of the risk involved in pursusing a school on the park. The council cannot guarentee this outcome even when the money becomes available. The option for a rebuild on site is being pursued by other school and would provide a very good option for Portoibello High which can delinately be deliverd. We need to get started ON_SITE to avouid endless delays. It looks like PPP2 for Portobello High failed as a result of the council desire to take Portobello Park. get a proper design and build it now!
4

Unimpressed one,

02/06/2008 13:27:45
Was any one caught for causing the flooding? Or is that just a mere detail lost in the politics?
5

Storky,

edinburgh 02/06/2008 13:35:41
#3 what relevance is your comment to this article?

Also, were you the clown that made this suggestion at one of the public consultation meetings (at Porty high if I remember correctly) and was laughed down?

Can you imagine a full high school building program, in an already small site with 1600 pupils - unbelievable.

I assume you live on Stanley Street or Duddingston Crescent? Bit of advice - prepare for the inevitable.



6

Potter,

Edinburgh 02/06/2008 14:06:13
Wakey Wakey #4. It's Cllr MacLaren that says it was vandalism and deliberate. Teachers don't think so, and the police are still investigating.
Change the script #3. It's boring boring boring
7

alex patersons English teacher,

02/06/2008 14:16:41
Doh,i hope it is finished in time for you leaven primary,im applying for assistent head.
8

,

02/06/2008 16:32:26
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
9

archie12,

02/06/2008 17:39:50
#1 Brilliant post from someone who obviously knows the true story from the inside.
Marilyne MacLaren is a lifelong bully who, since she "came to power" has found that her wee brain and her big mouth are a complete mismatch. She was much better off on the outside, in a minority, when she was able to hold influence over several like minded officials in public service. Blast! My memory's going, they've all taken retirement and headed for the hills, haven't they? Ah well, she'll just have to think for herself. Oh dear, another problem there, then.
10

Finbarr Saunders,

02/06/2008 18:58:24
Whether or not it was an accident or a deliberate act is almost irrelevant, it beggars belief that the School did not identify the risk of these sinks overflowing and causing such devastating damage in their property risk assessments.

They should have ensured that the all sinks in the Art Department had overflows or some other control measure. Hardly rocket science!

But it's easier to blame some stealthy, invisible intruder and deflect the blame away from the School or the Council, I suppose.
11

micky,

edinburgh 02/06/2008 19:37:00
The rebuilding on Portobello golf course/Park is not yet a done deal, planning has still to be sought and approved and it may be tougher than you think Storky.
Perhaps some people would be best to keep their mouths shut & thought of as idiots rather than speak & remove all doubt !
12

Head of Current Affairs,

Portobello 02/06/2008 20:46:57
At the risk of repeating myself, there are NO plans to build anything on Portobello Golf Course. If anyone suggests otherwise, you can safely assume that they are misinformed or a member of PPAG. Or both. It's a bit like a hoax virus. Pass it on.
13

Life of a Liberal?,

Portobello 03/06/2008 02:22:52
Seems as though the Police have not concluded the investigation. An art class which Cllr MacLaren states was vandalised and was full of ceramics had no damage except the two doors which may have come of as the glue was steeped in water from the sink.

Why did she say it was vandalism. I hope Alan Roden has the opportunity to redress the balance with a new article.

Perhaps the kids should take out a class action and sue the incapable MacLaren and the EEN.
14

Head of Current Affairs,

Portobello 03/06/2008 06:21:28
Even the Lib Dems must now see that Cllr Maclaren is a liability. It is only seven days since she incensed Portobello parents by failing to turn up for a meeting at the Town Hall, sending a pathetic Powerpoint presentation in her place. Kenny MacAskill has demanded her resignation. Elizabeth Maginnis says she should go. She owes the teachers, parents and kids at Portobello High an apology.

Then she should pack her bags.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.