Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Pupils win £125,000 in claims for school accidents

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 01 July 2009
A TOTAL of £125,000 has been paid out to school pupils in the Lothians in compensation claims ranging from ripped trousers to serious playground accidents.
Children have received as much as £10,765 in injury claims from local councils in the Lothians following accidents resulting in head injuries, trapped fingers and broken legs.

Local authorities have also been sued after pupils' property – including jewellery, mobile phones and school uniforms – was lost, stolen or damaged.

Edinburgh City Council paid out the most in claims, shelling out £62,825 in the past five years for 28 injuries and four incidents relating to property.

West Lothian paid out just over £38,000 to pupils, while Midlothian Council compensated children to the tune of £23,900.

Pupils in East Lothian have received just £90 in compensation payouts from the council, despite 31 claims being made for a range of incidents, including missing gym shoes and tripping in the playground.

However, the council has estimated that it could have to pay out just over £19,000 in outstanding claims for injuries including a child's finger being trapped in a fire door, hockey goals falling on a pupil, and a five-year-old girl being scalded when soup was spilled on her.

The Evening News recently revealed that £200,000 had been paid out to teachers and school staff in compensation for accidents including slipping on food and tripping on a school bag.

All four Lothians councils have paid out thousands of pounds to employees claiming for injuries suffered in the region's schools.

The city council has paid out the most over the past four years – a massive £106,650 to just 13 employees, averaging out at £8,200 per claim. But Edinburgh solicitor Angus Logan believes payouts for injury claims are often higher than they need to be as a result of councils dragging their feet.

He says solicitors often have to result to raising court proceedings due to the length of time taken by councils to resolve a claim. Mr Logan, who works with Ritchie Neill on Brougham Street, said: "I find council insurers to be terribly slow.

"They don't admit liability and take months to make a decision. They would pay out less if they settled cases early and they did not invite litigation. I think it's probably a misguided attempt to save money in the wrong places."

A city council spokesman said: "Health and safety is taken very seriously across our school estate and that's why the number of claims has been low.

"However, with a large schools estate, claims are brought against us from time to time."


Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 01 July 2009 10:25 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Schools in Edinburgh
 
1

alfonsa pedrosa,

embra 01/07/2009 12:02:44
Thats because the kids are as wide as the Forth Bridge,and the council are not,its called hush money.
2

Vivas,

Edinburgh 01/07/2009 12:08:58
I have 2 unsightly gouges in my right knee sustained in Longstone Primary school playground in 1965. And let me tell you it nipped like buggery at the time.

Where do I get my retospective claim form !
3

Foo,

01/07/2009 12:21:26
'A child's finger being trapped in a fire door, hockey goals falling on a pupil, and a five-year-old girl being scalded when soup was spilled on her.'

It's like a violent Benny Hill.
4

Sarcasm,

01/07/2009 12:28:30
That boy is an unlucky but well off little person.
Throw in the catalogue fee for the photo and he's doing OK.
5

Vivas,

Edinburgh 01/07/2009 12:35:36
I was also belted by the headmaster in 1968 for being a few seconds late in getting into line at the school doors after lunch.

I still bear the mental scars...caused me no end of loss of self-esteem over the years.

However. A one-off payment of between 5 or 10K will take the pain away.
6

fat lord prodder,

somewhere in alba 01/07/2009 12:48:42
foo ben elton says no to benny hill,so you will have to use buster keaton,or ronald mcdonald,no wait ronalds earmarked as the councils next leader
7

fat lord prodder,

somewhere in alba 01/07/2009 12:59:15
#5 a few seconds late!,my you were lucky,i got the belt every home time,saved the lazy git of a teacher doing it in the morning
aye we are told all personal property brought onto council premises,is done at owners risk,the council will not accept responsibility
my late mother tripped over a large blob of set concrete left on the pavement by council workers,no compo given as theey denied it was theirs
8

Diana,

Edinburgh 01/07/2009 13:09:48
Normally I'd find the council in the wrong, but why on earth should they have to pay compensation for ripped trousers or lost/stolen mobile phones? If you choose to bring your phone to school and lose it, that's your own fault.
9

hibsRgid,

01/07/2009 13:24:40
my son got hit on the head by bottle at TYNIE HIGH SCHOOL a few months back,he is now scarred for life.

CAN HE MAKE A CLAIM ?
10

A Friend of Fernando Poo,

01/07/2009 13:28:13
When I were a lad we 'ad t' get up in t' midddle o' t' night. We 'ad t'eat t' school fence for breakfast. Then we 'ad to write our own school books usin' our own blood for ink. For sports we 'ad t' run around until our legs fell off and even then we 'ad enough 'omework that we 'ad to dream 'ow to calculate 'ow many 'ours a man would take to dig a ditch if his train was comin' at 30mph from Grimsby an' it 'ad left just as the bath wit' t' 'ole in it started running.

An' you tell that to t' yout' of today an' they won't believe you.
11

Bill MacD,

01/07/2009 13:53:30
Whatever happened to parents and kids taking responsibility for their own actions? The idiots who always need to blame someone else for their accidents should be fined for their stupidity, not rewarded at the expense of the rest of us.

We've all seen these parents, almost always with the loudest, ugliest, stupidist kids, who won't accept even the slightest criticism of their "darling" kids. These horrible kids are deluged with junk food and trash tat consumerism, and never denied a thing, turning them into greedy fat monsters. They should be taken into care, to save them from further such abuse.
12

Blondie,

01/07/2009 14:12:08
I must have missed out on a fortune then - my daughter's still got the scar on her forehead from where a school door hit her in the face, while I've lost count of the amount of ripped pairs of trousers my son notched up at primary schoo.
Never occurred to me to claim for any of these though - sometimes an accident is just that, an accident.
13

hibsRgid,

01/07/2009 14:18:04
correct Blondie
14

fat lord prodder,

somewhere in alba 01/07/2009 15:30:27
#10 my you luck lucky barsteward,we could only dream of those things,eating cold frosty gravel i can tell you,walking 20 miles in bare feet,through fields of broken glass,and teacher roasted us with a flame thrower
aye kids ,dont know their born these days what
15

A Friend of Fernando Poo,

01/07/2009 15:48:54
Gravel? We used t' dream o' gravel. When our school bus were broken, we 'ad t' carry it t' school on our backs. Then the teacher used to whip us wi' canes, an' that were a double-period. For mornin' break we 'ad t' clean t' loos wi' our hair. But we were 'appy. They say they're the best days of our lives, but you tell that t' t' yout' of t'day an' they won't believe you.
16

A Friend of Fernando Poo,

01/07/2009 16:13:13
As I recall school dinners, there'd have been a class-action suit in the purple blacmange alone on the grounds of cruel and unuual punishment. Then there was Bill McLaren making us do gym in our underpants when we forgot our shorts. I'm sure a lawyer would get me serious money for what that may have done to my psyche.

As for injuries, there's three scars on my head where I was hit with stones (stone-throwing was an unremarkable feature of playground life). I was also knocked unconcious once in an after-school ambush. I got a broken arm once falling from a school tree. We were also belted, which is probably against the Geneva Convention these days, and I got cramp writing many hundreds of lines.

Then there's the trauma induced when I watched a classmate stab my teacher. I'll forgive having to watch my teacher beat up a school bully, pretty much on the basis that he had it coming.

Honestly, if a kid at our school had sued for snecking his finger or for getting a cut that (ooooh) required medical intervention in the form of an elastoplast, he'd have been teased so mercilessly for ever that his entire family would have had to leave town for a school they hadn't heard of anything so ridiculous.

That the Council don't have the balls to tell them to sod off indicates that they're a big part of the problem too.
17

fat lord prodder,

somewhere in alba 01/07/2009 16:21:49
oooooohh hark at tony hmmmm took it like a man,what kind of man was that lol
yes this weeks contestant in ccelebrity saviours is gorgie tony
tell us tony ,before we "Crucify" you 10ft up this wall with 8" nails,whats it like to be the most hated and reviled person on the scotsman/EEN/scotland on sunday newspaper forums?
will your friends Sillius Soddus or Biggus Dickus."
come to wave at you,or perhaps your Incontinentia Buttocks in reality
ah i know now forgive me,why its Mr. Creosote,himself,been throwing up lately sir,mustnt overdo it on the chips sir,even if they are thrown by kids from your fan club
from ze alley i heard a scream!,who put sand in gorgie tony,s vasaline
18

The Ayrshire Bard,

01/07/2009 18:21:14
I can only guess that a lot of these kids will grow up to become MP's. Their parents are certainly pointing them in the right direction.
19

DRZ400,

01/07/2009 18:32:09
No wonder the worlds in the state that it is. Where there's a blame there's a claim culture has put us in this state and left the authorities scrimping for others. Wonder how much money is paid out on staged incidents.
20

leithlink,

01/07/2009 20:07:00
#18 - Have you got a problem?
21

blackley,

Edinburgh 01/07/2009 20:11:26
Damned scroungers.
22

No pay in Gorgie,

Wellington 01/07/2009 22:06:37
I could've made a fortune at school in the 80's and 90's it seems!

I remember slipping on ice in the playground and losing a tooth! That would've surely been worth a bit. Tooth fairy only gave me 20p I think??

I also recall having a head on collision with a mate in the playground, I got a sore head and he got a black eye for his troubles.

I lost a football up on the school roof once as well.

There must be countless other claims I could make.

Pay up ECC!!!
23

Foo,

01/07/2009 22:19:26
Christ, you lot must be an ugly bunch with all your scars and grotesque injuries from school.
24

Make Mine a Half,

Polwarth 01/07/2009 23:03:00
If you look at the full length picture in the EEN, ripped breeks and scraped head are the least of this unfortunate young man's worries.....his FEET are on the wrong way round.
25

A Friend of Fernando Poo,

01/07/2009 23:26:02
By the look of that haircut, he's recently had nits too.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.