Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Parents' fury as bacteria found in school's water



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 01 December 2008
Bacteria has been discovered in the water supply at the crumbling Portobello High.
The city council insisted last week that the school's fountains were out of action simply because they were not working.

But it has now emerged that they were shut off because of a "persistent level of bacteria" in the school's water. Staff and pupils are being told to use bottled water until the problem can be fixed, though council chiefs insist there was never any risk.

The school's swimming pool, which is also used bylocal groups , remains closeddue to an unrelated problem.

Parents today claimed they had been kept in the dark about the water problem, while staff expressed fears over the cost of bottled water.

One staff member who contacted the Evening News said: "I'm sitting looking at a memo from the headteacher saying that the water in the school has 'a persistent level of bacteria', and is advising us to boil all the water for at least three minutes before we drink it.

"At a staff meeting yesterday we were told that the provision of bottled water would have to come from the school's budget.

"I think it's a disgrace that the school budget should have to be spent on bottled water. It's a basic amenity that a school should have water, and it should be up to the council to provide the money."

There had been rumours flying around the school ever since the water fountains were taken out of action last week, as the move came after a condition survey of the building was carried out.

Jackie Brock, chair of Portobello For A New School, said there was a lack of openness between the council and parents over various issues affecting the school.

She said: "We want reassurances that this report is going to be included in the condition survey when it is published next month.

"The council has been promising parents an information newsletter on a variety of issues, including the new school and condition of the school, since October and it's yet another example of a lack of communication between the council and parents.

"Parents will be demanding reassurances that bottled water, which is a basic right for children, will not come from the maintenance budget which has already been cut, when we have already had delays in getting the lift and boiler fixed and the windows replaced because of budget issues."

Parent council member Willie Wilson said: "It's really annoying that just because the building is in a bad state they are going to have to eat into their budget even more, which is fundamentally unfair. Our pupils are penalised because the building is rubbish."

A council spokeswoman said the bacteria had been discovered after routine testing: "The water tanks were chlorinated for hygiene reasons after routine samples found levels of non-harmful bacteria which would affect the taste of the water. There was no risk to health and the water was perfectly safe to drink.

"At present, a permanent solution is being investigated in order to upgrade the water supply."


The full article contains 519 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 01 December 2008 2:19 PM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Head of Current Affairs,

Portobello 01/12/2008 12:16:35
"At present, a permanent solution is being investigated in order to upgrade the water supply."

A permanent solution would be to stop wasting time and money on a building that is quite clearly falling apart and get on with building a new school for the 21st century. Portobello teachers, parents and kids aren't going to put up with this any longer. Give us the school our children deserve!
2

Peekay,

01/12/2008 12:24:45
I doubt that this would be tolerated in council offices. Why should school children and teachers be asked to put up with it?
3

Jenny Mac-Mac-Mac-Mac-Mac-Mac-Mac-Mac-MacArthur,

01/12/2008 12:26:53
Obviously these bacteria were injected into the water supply by Christians. As usual.

I say enough is enough. Leave the cruel and deluded Church and follow the Way of The Tram!!
4

Edinburgh's Leith All Stars,

Portobello High School Pupil 01/12/2008 12:32:19
I wonder which teacher is the mole... Ach i love good ole porty, i'm guessing there is no news if the paper is focusing on old news which isn't supprising. try actually spending four years in the school with two left, doesnt affect my day to day life. I can deal with steps and i drink bottled water anyway.. Oh the banter
5

Porty Pirate,

The Beach 01/12/2008 12:58:54
Yet more double-speak from the Council:

"The city council insisted last week that the school's fountains were out of action simply because they were not working".

Now we find this is patently untrue - just like when our beloved Marlyn said that there was incontrovertible proof that vandals had caused all the recent water damage!

6

alex paterson,

edinburgh 01/12/2008 12:59:40
There is only one answer to this problem and we all know what it is,fingers out and give the school a make over from top to toe.
7

Lionking,

WA the sunshine state 01/12/2008 13:01:28
# 3 what drivel you talk
8

alex patersons English teacher,

01/12/2008 13:11:06
4.
im glad you can cope with steps.
portys better best forgotten. im not one for sorrow, it the last thing on my mind,but its a tragedy.

5,6,7,8
who do we appreciate
porty.

keep the school,better the devil you know
9

alec splode,

Edinburgh 01/12/2008 13:17:08
I thought pupils went to school to get an education, not to drink water.
Stop moaning and get on with it.
10

I love to eat Sellotape,

01/12/2008 13:26:32
Well, I went to school explicity to drink water. The more I drank, the more often I could be excused to go to the toilet.
11

I love to eat Sellotape,

01/12/2008 13:26:59
[explicitly]
12

Edinburgh's Leith All Stars,

Portobello High School Pupil 01/12/2008 13:38:25
9: Exactly, if people want water they can buy it themselves. There is a drinking fountain in PE and clean water in Home Economics and the medical room. whats the big issue, i bring my own water, why can't everyone else.

10: Not all teachers let you out now, you have to time your drinking in coordination with the specific period, subject and teacher. All very complex....
13

Bill MacD,

01/12/2008 13:54:17
The porty parents campaigning for an unfair slice of OUR tax money to be spent on their wee brats have got a hysterical PR machine going. But if they get our money, other needs elsewhere don't. It's pure queue-jumping greed. And the Evening News is as usual playing along as they love any stick to beat our elected representatives with. But the Council should just continue to allocate resources according to a professional assessment of prioritised public needs, and regardless of publicity-hungry lobbyists like these self-regarding graspers. They should ignore this stupid campaign and get on with their job of improving schools and other public resources in a sensible objective fashion, as we've elected them to do.
14

Douglas,

Bathgate 01/12/2008 14:52:22
Water, water everywhere, except in Porty High.

#12: The Big Issue is a magazine sold by dog lovers.
15

Fifi la Bonbon,

01/12/2008 15:01:32
I can't help but agree with Bill MacD.

The SNP and Lib Dem Council leaders, under the benign leadership of Cllr Cardownie and Cllr Dawe, are making a brave break with the tired old Labour priorities of decent schools where children won't get poisioned, and they deserve the respect of all right thinking citizens.

The publicity-hungry parents - self regarding graspers, in Bill's well chosen words - are just being selfish.

Money spent on schools and clean water, and other fripperies, would substantially detract from the budget for flags and trips to India for civic dignitaries. I understand that there is no shortage of children, on the other hand, and many of them make a mess and use up resources that could be better spent on other things.

Here's one example.

Right now, I think the hearts and spirits of the citizenry would be uplifted if giant statues could be erected at either end of Princes Street, Cllr Cardownie at the Leith end, bestriding the street like a collossus, and Cllr Dawes at the other. The statues could be so big that trams and other vehicles would travel through their legs. Alternatively, to save money, you could just have Cllr Cardownie bestriding Cllr Dawe like a collossus.

This spectacle would create employment, and prove to be a major tourist attraction, maybe even employing children from the Portobello area once they'd left school. It would certainly enhance the reputations of Cllr Cardownie and Cllr Dawes.
16

Fifi la Bonbon,

01/12/2008 15:13:58
I just realised that I left out Cllr Marilyne MacLaren from plans for public works to raise the spirits of the people. She should get a statue too.

I propose a massive bust on a plinth, to go outside St Giles, in which she is portrayed apologising to parent representative Lynda Flex, whom she kicked off a forum looking at school closure plans. The Evening News has a great photo of her loing mortified with her hand in her gob and that could be the starting point for the whole artisitic endeavour.

I am sure most right thinking citizens woulld recognise that such a display of public art would be a better use of money than a pathetic school for the weans of Portobello, whose pushy parents quite frankly are a disgrace with their constant demands for a decent place for their kids to learn without being poisoned. Our leading councillors were quite clearly poisoned frequently as children, and it certainly did them no harm.
17

Porty Pirate,

The Beach 01/12/2008 15:39:08
Bill MacD says "But the Council should just continue to allocate resources according to a professional assessment of prioritised public needs"

And what makes you think that this this is not what they will be doing? The Council meeting in December will decide on the phasing of the 'Wave 3' schools, one of which is Portobello High. You can even read the criteria they will be uusing if you are that worried.
18

Stevie Mac,

Edinburgh 01/12/2008 16:22:49
Bill Macd says "The porty parents campaigning for an unfair slice of OUR tax money to be spent on their wee brats have got a hysterical PR machine going"

You are a bit mixed up Bill. Porty parents are campaigning for £37m less the cost of the sale of the existing school site. There is another porty group (PPAG)campaigning for a smaller school on a smaller site but the cost is £55M. Porty parents value and appreciate the City's effort to spend £30m on their and future kids. We see no need for the city to spend an additiona £25m for an inferior facility. Fair is fair.
19

Andrew,

01/12/2008 16:48:09
Dead pigeons or seagulls in the water tanks perhaps. It's been know at other schools!
20

gus1940,

Edinburgh 01/12/2008 17:47:19
Surely drinking water should be coming direct from the mains and not from a tank.
21

elayne,

01/12/2008 20:16:09
i thought most schools had these water dispensers nowadays
22

is it me?,

Edinburgh 01/12/2008 20:35:31
There's more "bacteria" in bottled water than in mains supply. Anyway bacteria is good for you.
When I was wee, we (put a comma in there to confound the flibbertigibbets!)used to sook the water frae dubs created by the store horse.
Never did me any harrumph.
23

is it me?,

Edinburgh 01/12/2008 20:43:51
21 Elayne,
The weather forecast for Fife isn't too good.
Don't eat any yellow snow. Especially round about the pub.
24

elayne,

01/12/2008 21:34:57
#23,yellow snow,mmm you been listening to too much zappa matey!(true the weather forecast is p*sh though)
25

PhiNess,

England 02/12/2008 10:02:52
If there were bacteria in the fountains the council should have considered installing modern plumbed in water filters. Tami4 dispensers filter out limescale, cysts and chlorine and even blast the water with ultraviolet light, ridding the water of all bacteria.

“Water For Health Hydration Best Practice Toolkit for Hospitals and Healthcare” produced by the RCN and the NHS advises that plumbed in water coolers cost less than 2p for every 19 litres dispensed. When we consider the cost of bottled water, it's clear that a plumbed in filter/dispenser would be a lot more cost effective than buying bottled water over and over again until the bacteria are removed, or Portobello High moves to new premises.

26

PhiNess,

England 02/12/2008 10:07:11
If there were bacteria in the fountains the council should have considered installing modern plumbed in water filters. Tami4 dispensers filter out limescale, cysts and chlorine and even blast the water with ultraviolet light, ridding the water of all bacteria.

“Water For Health Hydration Best Practice Toolkit for Hospitals and Healthcare” produced by the RCN and the NHS advises that plumbed in water coolers cost less than 2p for every 19 litres dispensed. When we consider the cost of bottled water it's clear that a plumbed in filter/dispenser would be a lot more cost effective than buying bottled water over and over again until the bacteria are removed or Portobello High moves to new premises.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.