Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Maths can be fun – if only it's taught properly

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 13 May 2009
MATHEMATICS should be one of the most useful subjects children learn in school – yet thousands leave school each year unable to use simple mathematical methods. Or, worse, they are traumatised by their experiences in maths classes.
This unacceptable state of affairs means that many adults are left vulnerable, not only to financial ruin, but in any situation involving mathematical thinking or reasoning.

It should be the right of all children to be given a basic but sound mat
hematical knowledge and understanding. Yet thousands of students finish classes annually fearing or hating maths.

The reason for this is the way mathematics is usually taught in schools. Students spend hundreds of hours being shown a dry and narrow version of the subject that is nothing like the mathematics of the world and nothing like the mathematics used by mathematicians.

Maths exists in the petals of flowers, the rhythms of raindrops and the social networks that connect us; it is at the core of scientific and medical breakthroughs and it is a diverse and varied subject.

Ask mathematicians what mathematics is and they will generally tell you it is the study and exploration of patterns. Ask schoolchildren what mathematics is and they will usually tell you it is a vast collection of rules that have to be remembered.

Why are their descriptions so different? The reason is this: schoolchildren rarely experience real mathematics. Instead of posing questions, solving real and interesting problems, using and applying methods, and investigating patterns and relationships, children spend their time watching a teacher demonstrate methods and then practising them.

It is important for children to learn standard methods, but this is just one small part of a very broad subject, and it is the breadth of the subject that is generally denied to children, at great cost.

Children also suffer because they come to believe that maths achievement equals intelligence, and to fail at maths is a sign of being stupid. This idea serves to erode children's confidence in their ability to think, and it is the reason so many children feel traumatised when they don't do well in maths.

In fact, not wanting to engage in the narrow, fake version of maths often taught in schools is perfectly reasonable, if not commendable. Children who are subjected to dry and narrow maths classes need to know this and they need to be introduced to the real mathematics – the varied and exciting subject that will help them for the rest of their lives.

Fortunately, parents (as well as teachers) can be powerful in introducing children to the real mathematics that they will enjoy and take with them into their adult lives.

Sarah Flannery, the young Irishwoman who won the European Young Scientist of the Year award for the discovery of a "breathtaking" new mathematical algorithm, revealed that her mathematical success was due more to the puzzles that she worked on at home with her family than all the years of maths classes she experienced in school.

There are many ways in which parents can help their children meet the real and exciting maths that exists in the world, and do well in maths at school. Here are just a few:

&149 It is really important that children know that everyone can be good at maths and everyone can reach high levels.

There is a pervasive view in the UK that only some children can do well in maths; this is wrong and damaging. Encourage and support children and never say "I was terrible at maths at school". Research found that when mothers said this to their daughters, their achievement went down.

• Introduce children to maths puzzles and games such as sudoku (there are many children's versions around), snakes and ladders (for early number work), Rubik's cubes, jigsaws, draughts, chess, dominoes, Connect 4 and any logic puzzles. They will all help enormously with mathematical work.

• Talk about maths together. Find a puzzle or problem that involves maths and discuss it with your children. Many parents read books to children every night but never discuss maths with them. My friend used to put a maths puzzle in her son's lunchbox each day. He is now a mathematician.

• Encourage children to develop a flexible view of numbers. For example, think about adding two numbers such as 96 and 17 in your head. This may seem tricky, but if you break the 17 into 4 and 13 then the sum becomes 96 + 4 + 13, which for most people is much easier.

Low achieving children do not treat numbers flexibly – they try to count carefully, even when this usually results in mistakes, as they don't think they are allowed to break numbers apart. Give children lots of these kinds of problems that encourage the breaking apart of numbers. They can be addition, subtraction or multiplication problems, and they should be thought about mentally, without using pen and paper, with children being encouraged to find different ways to solve them. This has many benefits – children learn a flexible view of maths, they learn that maths problems can be solved using different methods and they develop sharpness in mental maths.

• Ask children questions as they work on maths, but when they say something incorrect, try to find the logic in their answer, even if it isn't the answer you were looking for. Rather than saying "No, that is wrong" find the logic in their thinking and build on it, saying "Oh, I see what you're thinking – you're looking at it as if …"

If children are simply told they are wrong, they are likely to feel disheartened, whereas if they hear there is some logic in their thinking – and there will be – they will gain confidence, which is critical to success.

• Encourage children to see the maths that is everywhere in the world: explore petals and pinecones, try to find sequences of numbers on car number plates when on journeys, work out the time it will take to get to destinations using the speed and the distance, discuss the different shapes and patterns in your garden or park. Maths is all around us.

• Encourage children to think of themselves as great problem-solvers, and to see any maths problem as a puzzle they can solve through exploration and persistence.

• Last, but not least, if your child is not spending time in school working on diverse and varied mathematics, discussing ideas and problem solving, arrange to talk to your child's teacher or the school's maths co-ordinator and express your support for a problem-solving approach to maths.

Sometimes, this is all the teacher needs to hear to move to a more active, exploratory and real version of the subject.

• Jo Boaler is the Marie Curie professor of mathematics education at the University of Sussex and author of The Elephant in the Classroom. Helping Children Learn and Love Maths (Souvenir Press).





The full article contains 1160 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 12 May 2009 6:42 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Teaching
 
1

,

13/05/2009 07:12:16
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
2

wheels5894,

Fife 13/05/2009 15:00:58
I am one who left with little math knowledge but come from a time when years were spent on the 4 rules no just with numbers but yards, feet and inches - stone, pounds and ounces etc. Solid grind and no fun.

Surely now children and adults can have computers do the hard work we would be able to improve maths knowledge and its popularity.
3

KWC,

Edinburgh 14/05/2009 23:39:25
I benefitted enourmously from a wonderful set of Maths teachers at Glenrother High School in the late 60s/early 70s. Oh, how I wish that others could have that experience. My Latin teacher predicted a dire future for me, though I went on to a successful academic career that lasted over 40 years.

I do wish that Maths could be seen as more useful, interesting and valuable by today's students.

Thank you Messrs Smart and Murray.
4

Hanz,

logtastica 15/05/2009 11:35:52
The article is right Maths should be about problem solving and investigation. However at high school there needs to be a certain level of understanding. Many Students arrive without even a basic grasp of the times table, which means teachers have to devote time to the basics which then bores students.

It does not help when the the government minister for justice Shahid Malik is talking on breakfast news about being 1 million % honest, 110% is bad enough.
5

Gaspy,

Romania 15/05/2009 16:20:49
I loathed maths in high school. It seemed so... meaningless.
It was only in college (I have a BD in engineering) that I discovered how calculus for example has real-world usage and it can make my life easier.

I think many mathematicians who study maths fail to understand that for the majority of people (including kids) maths is not a goal in itself, but merely a tool. If you describe a tool to someone, but you don't explain what's for, don't be surprised no one will appreciate it.

As the article suggests, it's useful to teach maths to kids as if it were a puzzle -- they will love it. In fact, there's a whole market for this kind of products, with site like www.whizz.com or www.dreambox.com offering online lessons. Pretty cool compared to the way I used to be taught...
6

moxie,

everywhere and nowhere 18/05/2009 13:37:59
never mind my friends - the cavalry is coming!!!!

92 new maths probationers from Glasgow and Edinburgh, so just think what we can do with them, cut class sizes, have early intervention for pupils struggling in maths?????

Or will they end up on the scrap-heap like many other NQT.s

A total of 644 NQT's will graduate this year and at least 350 primary teachers, so why are teachers getting made surplus? And why are there primary composite classes?

Money thats why, put our children's education before trams?????

7

moxie,

18/05/2009 13:44:08
Number 8, yes you are correct, but maybe we should ask labrokes,plumbers etc to come up with some good lessons or ideas that we could use in the classroom.

Teachers do try to bridge the gap, but we are short of time and are constantly developing lessons that will inspire pupils.

Oh but wait - experienced teachers could do development work for a year and we could use all the NQTs that are graduating this year?


8

Mathmojo,

Upstate NY 19/05/2009 02:43:21
Thanks for one of the best articles about this complex subject that I've ever read in a mainstream news venue.

The website http://mathmojo.com/chronicles has been dedicated to making math meaningful for years. It's an uphill battle, considering the fact that school policy-makers do their best to strip math of anything recognizable as math. They could take the fun out of an ice-cream and mud-wrestling party.

Your point about puzzles is right on target. I've spoken to a woman who was a contender for the Fields Medal, and she said that she and many of her colleagues were more inspired by books by Martin Gardner and Sam Lloyd then by anything they'd learned in grade school.

9

Transparent?,

Scotland 19/05/2009 19:36:23
Try this hoary puzzle:

Let x = a

Then multiply both sides by x and

x² = xa

Subtract a² from both sides then

x² - a² = xa - a²

Factorise the LHS and simplify the RHS then

(x - a)(x + a) = a(x -a)

Now divide both sides by (x - a) and

x + a = a

But x = a, therefore:

2a = a

Divide both sides by a and hence:

2 - 1.

Where is the fallaxy?
10

Transparent?,

Scotland 19/05/2009 19:40:52
#9
Second last line should read:
2 = 1 and not 2 - 1.
11

Klaatu,

UK 22/05/2009 16:46:45
The reasoning in Transparent's proof is wrong

Let x = a

Then multiply both sides by x and

x² = xa

Subtract a² from both sides then

x² - a² = xa - a²

At this point 0=0. Manipulation after this step is meaningless because in reality what you're now saying is

0=0 => 2=1

The problem is that your 'unknown' x is given as a (known) and then you've pretended its an unknown to allow you to use standard algebraic manipulations.
12

Klaatu,

UK 22/05/2009 16:47:57
Fallaxy should be fallacy
13

Klaatu,

UK 22/05/2009 16:58:57
You can teach children as young as six basic algebra. My favourite trick is with sweets. Mark a large X on the back of one hand. Take some sweets (10 for simplicity) and put some in one hand and the rest in hand X. The child knows there are 10 sweets in total. Open the non X hand and let them count the sweets in it and ask how many are in hand X. Gradually wean them away from hands and sweets to pencil and paper.

It may seem extremely simplistic but what is being introduced is the abstract notion of X being the holder for a number we don't know but that still obeys all the usual rules of arithmetic. You get the answer and you now know the value of the place holder X.

Any child that can count to 10 will love both the interaction with you and the joy of getting the sums correct.


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.