Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Big idea for new school makes the grade with city parents



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 19 March 2008
THE first images of how a refurbished Boroughmuir High School would look were revealed today – much to the delight of parents.
The project to carry out a major on-site refurbishment of the school – drawn up by city architect Malcolm Fraser – would see classroom provision at the school rise by almost a third.


And despite the fact that the main complaint about the school on its current Viewforth site is that it is too small, the refurbishment will also see a new sports block, more facilities and extra playground space created.

Along with the on-site refurbishment, the council is considering two new-build options – one on Scottish Water-owned land at Fairmilehead and the other on the Astley Ainslie Hospital site in The Grange.

But parents believe these options would be years down the line, and their main aim is to see Boroughmuir refurbished in the quickest possible time frame.

Polly Purvis, chair of the Action for Boroughmuir campaign group, said: "We would absolutely love to have a brand new school on a new site, sitting with its own playing fields surrounding it. The issue is that practically, it's a bit of a pipe dream.

"This is a pragmatic solution. Malcolm Fraser has come up with really creative plans in terms of giving the school more space."

City author Ian Rankin – whose teenage son attends the school – has backed the "ingenious" plans for an on-site refurbishment, particularly welcoming the extra sports facilities. The option for a rooftop basketball court is included in the plans.

Mr Rankin believes Mr Fraser's plans to refurbish on-site are the most "realistic" option.

He said: "The priority for the parents is to know that something is going to happen, that their kids aren't going to be squeezed into a building that's far from ideal.

"One of my big bug-bears as a parent is that to do PE, they have to jump on a bus and go elsewhere, so it would be great for them to be able to do more on-site."

Boroughmuir school has a school roll of just over 1100 pupils but was designed to deal with some 900. Parents say it does not meet the requirements of the Disability Discrimination Act, and gym, recreation and communal areas are "severely restricted".

Mr Fraser's plans, which he drew up in conjunction with fellow parent Neil Smith, would transform the school's existing one-storey technical building into a five-storey classroom block.

A new dinner hall and the creation of a "street" within the grounds is intended to give children somewhere to socialise during lunch breaks.

Mr Fraser, who lives opposite the school and has a daughter there, said: "It would break my heart to see the school not well used, not repaired, and to see the building fall into disrepair.

"They're just not getting the potential out of what is a rather good building.

"Why abandon a building like that when a small amount of money could secure its future for hundreds of years?"





The full article contains 515 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 19 March 2008 11:44 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Schools in Edinburgh
 
1

Colin G,

Edinburgh 19/03/2008 12:12:25
I take it that this picture is a joke?

Is the Council so wedded to the developers of the poor quality flats springing up all over the place, that it cannot insist that one of the areas at Fountainbridge, 'Springside', the Canalside etc would provide the space for a new Boroughmuir?

Last week there was a piece of news on this site that the Council had been cracking down on satellite dishes on Viewforth. And this crackpot architect wants to put more glass boxes in front of the beautiful Boroughmuir school?
2

Pond Hall,

19/03/2008 12:14:14
Refurbishment......Not recommended.

East Lothian Council done the same...

One school still had snagging issues 4 years after it should have been finished.
It still looked like the old school that had been tarted up, some bits hadn't changed since I was at it.

Other problems that they had during exams was the noise caused by contractors working, despite assurances that it wouldn't happen.

Its quicker building a new school.

If they do go for a refurb, they kids should be decanted to some other building.
3

Pond Hall,

19/03/2008 13:02:28
no1 ....amazing when it comes to Council Projects...suddenly the planning restrictions are removed.

even last week a Pub building that dates back to the 1800's? at Haymarket is getting demolished for the Trams.

Want to change your windows...Nae chance
4

the good doctor,

19/03/2008 13:03:29
#1 did an architect sleep with your wife?
5

blackley,

Edinburgh 19/03/2008 13:07:35
Not the beautiful Astley Ainslie PLEASE!!!
6

,

19/03/2008 13:26:40
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
7

alec splode,

Edinburgh 19/03/2008 13:31:06
I like the trees.
8

H. Black,

19/03/2008 13:38:07
If they give school buildings an overhaul, is there any chance of them doing the same to the pupils' behaviour?
The pupils seem to spend a fair proportion of their school day wandering Viewforth and the surrounding streets, which are then jammed by groups of kids forcing elderly people off the pavement, throwing litter and chewing gum on the pavements, and generally making life difficult for residents. The school refuses to take any responsibility for any of this.
The artist's impression appears to be building on a fair area of the playground, closing in the street even more, and probably the kids less 'play' area for their break - so, presumably, wandering the streets even more than at present. It would also involve the removal of all the trees along the Viewforth side of the school.
No problem for the powers that be if that's what THEY want, of course but, as Pond Hall says - just try changing your windows - nae chance!
9

I Dalhousie,

Edinburgh 19/03/2008 13:54:24
The trouble with the "beautiful Boroughmuir school" is that it is not fit for purpose. For decades a search for an alternative site has come up with zilch. Good to have feedback on drawbacks to refurbishment, Pond Life. As for H.Black, if you have ever reported problems to the school rather than just coming over all Victor Meldrew you will know that they not only take responsibility but act very promptly. If there were better dining facilities on site, maybe fewer pupils would be forced to trawl for lunch in Bruntsfield.
10

Paul Voltiare,

19/03/2008 16:35:11
Whatever happened to the Balfour Beatty(aka Consort, Haden Building Management Ltd) school tender corruption investigation ?
11

H. Black,

19/03/2008 21:31:50
Response to I.(Isobel?) Dalhousie - when a group of neighbours in a street adjoining Viewforth approached the school about mess and disruption, they were told, quite clearly, that the school have no control or jurisdiction over the actions of pupils once they are outside the school grounds, even if this is in the course of normal lesson-time, so could not get involved in the problem.
12

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 19/03/2008 22:58:12

Is it not a 'Disgrace' that the EEN did not even give us a line in their Paper, that the,

'Cowgate Nursery'.... Edinburgh!

Got the top award for Excellence in Scotland today!

To which was televised on BBC1 Scotland News and to which, The Children's Minister visited Today!
13

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 19/03/2008 23:04:23

Back to topic

"much to the delight of parents."

But NOT, 'to the delight' of the 'moaning residents' that continually complain about our young! in Viewforth!
14

,

18/04/2008 15:54:57
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.