Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Neighbours cry foul as park is lost to stadium

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
27 January 2007
THE Capital's planned multi- million pound athletics and rugby stadium has sparked protests from residents angry it will be built on their only green space.
Community leaders said the development would "wreck" the neighbourhood and leave young people in Sighthill out in the cold.

They said youngsters would have to pay to play on pitches at the new sports centre when they can use ones on the existing park for free. There are also concerns a skatepark on the site could be axed.

Council leaders say the stadium is part of one of Scotland's biggest regeneration programmes, which will "transform" the Sighthill area.

High-rise flats are to be demolished and replaced with new homes. The centrepiece of the development will be the stadium, which the council says will be "international class".

But community groups in Sighthill said they fear people living in the area will suffer once building begins in January 2009.

Ron Cairns, chairman of the Sighthill, Broomhouse and Parkhead Community Council, said: "A lot of young people use the park and play football there.

"The council are talking a lot about the great facilities, but they won't be so great for people around here.

"The pitch that's there now is free to use at night but the new one will need to be booked and it will cost money. Kids around here can't afford that.

"There's not a bit of green in this whole area apart from that park. If it goes, there's nothing. They wouldn't let that happen to other areas, so why should they here?

"It's going to have a real impact on the area and the only impact as far as we can see is negative. They're tearing communities apart, not building them."

Mr Cairns said there are also fears the neighbourhood will be swamped by visitors to the stadium parking outside their homes.

The existing proposals contain parking space for only 376 cars, when the stadium has a capacity for crowds of 6000, rising to 10,000 for special events.

Keith Bell, secretary of the community council, said: "At the moment, the negatives outweigh the positives. The loss of green space is a major worry for residents, as is the loss of some of the free facilities.

"If the council are prepared to talk with us, rather than to us, and to discuss the problems and come up with realistic solutions to them, then we will be happy to work with them.

"Hopefully then we might be able to turn it around and make the positives outweigh the negatives."

Councillor Donald Anderson, the city's culture and sport leader, strongly defended the council's overall plans for the area.

He said: "This is part of one of the biggest regeneration projects in Scotland at the moment because it involved the demolition of the high-rise flats and their replacement with family homes, as well as the creation of this sports centre. It will result in Sighthill becoming one of the most improved areas in Scotland.

"We will look at the provision for a kick-pitch for the local area and we want to make sure the football club based there is either relocated on site or moved to improved facilities.

"Green space will be built into the development and we will look at the issue of kids having somewhere to have a kick-about. In my view, that is something we have to achieve."

Cllr Anderson added that the 376 parking spaces are seen as sufficient because the area will be served by the tram network.

Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 27 January 2007 11:19 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Edinburgh planning issues
 
1

Paul Voltaire,

www.paulvoltaire.spaces.live.com 27/01/2007 12:33:32

Thank heavens for the trams.

2

Statsman,

27/01/2007 12:47:00

This is just selling off more playing fields for housing. Meadowbank is going to be sold for flats and the sport arena moved to playing fields elsewhere.

There will be no green space left in this city soon.

3

,

27/01/2007 13:05:37
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
4

Scaramouche,

27/01/2007 13:44:20

They're all at it. Full of great intentions when they get in ...... then the disappointment starts.

Then the graft comes in, quickly followed by brown envelopes.

Meadowbank will be demolished within 10 years. You saw it here first!

Sighthill WILL be built and the residents will need to apply to use what used to be THEIR park!

5

The Judge,

27/01/2007 13:56:08

Cllr Anderson added that the 376 parking spaces are seen as sufficient because the area will be served by the tram network.

Will you please stop calling it a tram network. It is a single tram line.

6

jabberjocky,

edinburgh 27/01/2007 14:33:47

eh ? the areas going to be wrecked ?
one recent assault on a woman when her nose was bitten off , a teenager murdered at the base of the high flats, even the local church gets its windows smashed in and called f**** b*st*rds on a regular basis, a teenage girl taking a fatal methadone overdose.......

and Bob Cairns thinks the areas going to be wrecked by a tram and a sports stadium ?

You were kind of quiet on those issues bob.

Perhaps the disease known as paul nolan syndrome is spreading further than we thought........

7

J,

Edinburgh 27/01/2007 14:48:35

"Will you please stop calling it a tram network. It is a single tram line."

Hear, Hear!

8

Toast,

27/01/2007 15:54:10

The stadium will be shared by the Edinburgh gunners and Hearts [don't laugh] this was always chris robinsons plan,now Mr Romanov has the school site in McLeod St he can sell the whole site to Stuart Milne and walk away with a nice profit

9

Aitch,

27/01/2007 17:01:25

Don't know about you but I always look forward to local news stories in many newspapers with pictures of someone looking forlorn/upset/concerned. Sadly this one doesn't feature a local councillor or candidate helpfully pointing to nothing in particular or also looking forlorn/upset/concerned. Missed opportunity here to take a pullitzer winning photo of an urchin looking miserable on their BMX or summat.

10

Blondie,

27/01/2007 17:20:39

Surely we should be doing all we can to encourage young people to become involved in sports of all types, and if that means having modern up-to-date facilities, then why not? Have you seen the state of some of the playparks and pitches in this area? Young footballers are being asked to play in pitches which are little more than mudbaths, and that's without mentioning the additional hazard of dog poo! And let's not get started on the sorry state of the changing facilities.......

11

H C Andersen,

27/01/2007 18:24:38

Is it true that the Gyle playing fields are next for the chop?

12

Jayess,

Marchmont. 27/01/2007 22:15:31

#6.jabberjocky
What has it got to do with Cllr. Bob Cairns?

Read the article - the name is Ron Cairns, convenor of the local community council, no relation, and presumably in a much better position to have a view on the matter than you have, but I expect you had your other glasses on.

13

Pilrig,

Livingston 27/01/2007 23:48:09

Nope - Anderson, Aitken, Burns & co are next for the chop.

14

weescottie,

28/01/2007 10:18:25

Our family have used this park for 40 odd years so please leave it as it is

15

Skinnybob,

Nowhere near Sighthill 28/01/2007 13:14:52

The locals are only upset cos they'll have to find somewhere else to take the dog for a walk in the lobby.

16

Nick (Foul Play),

28/01/2007 15:04:36

The only reason why the council with the backing of the Scottish Executive are re-developing Murrayfiled stadium into private properties is because they will get more cash for private properties along with the revenue. This explains why the council with the backing of the Scottish Executive have deliberately stalled any work on the Water Of Leith Flood Defenses by holding it back with appeal after appeal. This article just adds to the over whelming incompetence of these authorities.

We are now approaching the 7th anniversary of the floods and still the Scottish Executive have been delaying and holding back the work. The costs have risen from the original 25Million to more than double. and will continue to sprial into private hands.

The Scottish Executive have failed the public in getting their priorities right and we are continually being plagued with articles on their money spinning fantasy schemes at our cost.

17

scottishcoffindodgerno1,

Edinburgh 29/01/2007 08:50:30

Anderson,Where in sighthill are these trams going to run.The plans i'm looking at don't go anywhere near Sighthill.DO YOU EVEN KNOW WHERE SIGHTHILL IS.Try walking from Edinburgh Park station through the smelly Industrial sight

18

ddmc,

29/01/2007 09:44:21

where are edinburgh going to get the leccy for the trams, we are struggling to supply scotland as it is with longanett & hunterston out of action !
I havent seen any plans to run a tram into the burbs except the fabled waterfront scheme, for £700 million (or £7000 an inch) we could build wembley all over again, or have no council tax for a couple of years, convert all the buses to cleaner fuels etc etc.
HC , a large chunk of the old gyle fields already have been sold off & flats built on it.
Jayess I'm sure Bob & Ron Cairns are brothers.

19

jaad,

29/01/2007 10:12:27

This stadium will be fantastic for the local community. Currently this area is not the most desirable area. So if I lived there and found out the council were going to spend Millions rebuilding, creating jobs and making my home better I then I’d be happy. Having football, rugby and athletics teams on your doorstep to support will create a great community feeling. However if everyone one goes into the project with negative feelings them you’re missing the point. How about looking at the positives and making the best out of it. You’d be equally angry if they pulled the plug and did it in Glasgow or another area of Edinburgh. They’d get a fancy new community with housing etc and you’d have the old sighthill.

20

jaad,

29/01/2007 10:17:57

On an actual “Stadium” point of view. I hope they design it creatively so the stands are not miles back from the pitch. This was the problem with Meadowbank (and Murrayfield) as a sports supporter you want to be as close to the action as possible, this creates atmosphere etc…. lets just hope they design it well and do a proper job with corporate areas bars etc….because we all know this is where the money is made. If they don’t make extra money then we all know who’ll have to pay for the running etc…. Us, the tax payers.


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Today's Vote

Are Edinburgh’s planning regulations too strict on the city’s business community?
Yes - everything should be done to help businesses in a recession
Yes - they pale into insignificance when compared to the tram works
No - the city’s heritage and appearance can’t be compromised

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.