Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


DVD of classic Glasgow comedy 'desecrated' by Morningside dub

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 25 September 2009
IT IS regarded as a forgotten classic of Scottish cinema and helped launch the career of legendary director Bill Forsyth.
Now a new generation is set to enjoy Forsyth's debut feature film That Sinking Feeling with its first release on DVD.

But fans of the film will be taken aback to find the distinctive Glasgow accents of the cast have been replaced with Morningside
ones.

It was thought that American audiences would understand the cut-glass Edinburgh accents but not broad Glaswegian ones.

The move, though, has annoyed at least one member of the cast, Edinburgh arts impresario Richard Demarco who described it as "the desecration of a masterpiece".

Forsyth's 1980 film was shot in his home city of Glasgow, with a then record-low budget of £6,000.

A tale of four unemployed youths who decide to rob a sink depot, it was thanks to its success that Forsyth was able to make his 1981 hit Gregory's Girl.

The huge popularity of that movie, and its follow-up Local Hero, led US distributor MGM to buy up the rights to That Sinking Feeling.

Its executives decided American audiences would have a problem with the thick Glasgow accents of the Glasgow Youth Theatre cast, including Gregory's Girl star John Gordon Sinclair.

They ordered the "Morningside dub", using actors whose voices would not be out of place in Jenners' tea room.

The dubbed version is being used for the release because a high-quality version of the original soundtrack cannot be traced.

Mr Demarco, who played a gallery owner in the movie, said: "I can remember well making the film – I was only there for a day, and so my scene was done without rehearsal and without a script.

"It was all very low budget, but we could all see even then I think the genius of Bill Forsyth.

"I really do think That Sinking Feeling is as good as any of his other work.

"I think the decision to dub it was wrong, and hopefully someone will find a good quality un-dubbed version out there that can get a wider release.

"

The DVD is being released by 2Entertain, which released a statement, explaining: "The DVD was created from the only masters available to us. Unfortunately the DVD master of the original version is of a significantly poorer quality than that released and it was not feasible to restore it.

"





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 25 September 2009 9:41 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

SandyBottoms,

Edinburgh 25/09/2009 12:14:23
I know that Weegie accents can be hard for Americans to understand, but why not just have a subtitle option?
2

JT,

25/09/2009 12:42:18
Thats just plain wrong, what about the dire yankie accents that mumble through programmes from the US.
3

alfonsa pedrosa,

embra 25/09/2009 12:51:30
Crazy,whats the difference between us listening to a Yankee droll that we cant understand,not the same impact.
4

Mallory,

Edinburgh 25/09/2009 13:34:31
You don't get Weegie accents on BBC Scotland or STV News so why should yanks be expected to try and understand it? At least we have years of Jerry Springer show re-runs to get used to speech from the Southern States.
5

Starkravingsane,

Edinburgh 25/09/2009 15:35:44
Robbing a sink depot? Morningsiders??? Skip diving more like - and too posh to shovel doggy poo!
6

McEwan,

Edinburgh 25/09/2009 16:15:38
An old Viennese friend of mine used to describe the German he grew up speaking in Austria as being, not an accent, nor a dialect, but a disease of the mouth.

As an Edinburgher, I'll say no more.
7

Flopski2,

Edinburgh 25/09/2009 17:24:12
I remember seeing the original having just moved to Edinburgh from Leeds and had no trouble with the acccents. I thought at the time the film were much better than Gregory's Girl but it would be interesting to compare it now with the dodgy accents!
8

Zemi,

EDINBURGH 25/09/2009 17:42:00
@ McEwan : I'm nicking that. I grew up in Dundee.
9

glaswegian at heart,

florida 25/09/2009 19:39:36
It's not the glasgow accent it's the glesga dialect..
10

redcliffe62,

26/09/2009 09:20:17
the yanks will not be happy until we all speak in some mid atlantic twang.
11

Front Street,

Relugas Road. 26/09/2009 14:29:35
#4..You don't get Weegie accents on BBC or STV? Good grief..you hear very little else.. How many dramas - supposedly set in Edinburgh - have been wrecked by Weegie accents? Edinburgh accents are clear and concise delivered from the mouth and not nasal driven River City style.
12

Horrible Cankers @Cyber Shebeen,

27/09/2009 12:43:50
I dont think the accents are that strong actually...Edinburgh accents! are you having a laugh??

This film is so sweet and funny..shame on you for spoiling it, much better than Gregory's girl...sure I have the video kicking around somewhere...

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.