Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Saturday, 30th August 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Clash of the architects as underground cinema comes to Edinburgh



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 11 April 2008
A LONG-AWAITED new home for the Edinburgh International Film Festival and Filmhouse would be built under one of the capital's main public squares under plans drawn up by the city's design champion.
Terry Farrell, the architect who designed the original phases of Edinburgh's financial district in the 1980s, is proposing a "Louvre-style" glass entrance be created to the film complex from the square, which would also be used to house open-air fil
m screenings.

His plans have been unveiled more than three years after the film festival's chiefs said they hoped to build a cinema complex on top of Festival Square. The proposal received a hostile reception from the city council and the five-star Sheraton Hotel.

The £20 million scheme has been given fresh impetus after Sir Terry recommended the development could help transform Festival Square if it is created below ground and linked with a scheme to improve the public "piazza."

However, rival architect Richard Murphy, who designed the original film centre, was scathing about the new vision for the area.

Sir Terry, recently retained by the council for his "design tsar" role, envisages the area between the Usher Hall and the Sheraton Hotel becoming a new open-air piazza with pavement cafes and event spaces.

He has urged the council to redesign the entire roads network in the area to help bring his vision to reality, describing Lothian Road as "one of the worst examples of suburban highway planning foisted on a town centre."

Sir Terry, who designed the MI6 headquarters in London,

envisages a whole new cultural quarter being gradually developed to link the new-look Filmhouse and film festival base, with the nearby Usher Hall, the Traverse and Royal Lyceum theatres, and Festival Square.

Sir Terry said: "We've proposed a new cinema, which would be set below ground, with a Louvre-type pavilion entrance, along with cafés on the square, offering the opportunity for outdoor film screenings.

"The most significant urban improvement is the connection of the Usher Hall with a wide pedestrian crossing to Festival Square, thereby linking a major cultural venue with the square itself."

Ginnie Atkinson, managing director of the Filmhouse and film festival, said: "We are very keen to pursue plans for a dedicated centre for the moving image, which would be a home for both the festival and the Filmhouse. These are very interesting proposals by Sir Terry."

However Mr Murphy, who has been responsible for designing Edinburgh's Fruitmarket Gallery and the Maggie's Cancer Care Centre at the Western General Hospital, said: "Having an underground cinema below Festival Square would do nothing for this area at all.

"You only have to look at the impact the Traverse Theatre has had on the area outside. You wouldn't know it was there at all."





The full article contains 475 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 11 April 2008 12:38 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

S'me,

Edinburgh 11/04/2008 00:59:25
Can see both arguments, it would be a shame to take away any of the few public squares we have in Edinburgh by the building of an overground building. However the square is so dead, it would need clever planning to place something underneath but bring life to the square.
2

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 11/04/2008 01:18:28
You will Never find me at a, "underground cinema"

I mean to say,

What would you do if the,,'Seweres Break',?

Or do they give you a free,..'Snorkel Tube',?
:-))
3

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 11/04/2008 01:32:54
NOT Joking!

Scottish Water, do very little for this area in the town, but charge plenty!

Morrison Street, for example,..'Stinks in the Summer'

Its been like this since the likes of the ECC, Scottish Widows and the, Standard Life, buildings were built, (over 10 years now)

Top of Morrison Street, smells of the antiquated pipe system, that is the cause!

But 'fix-it', 'NO CHANCE'!

My advice! for your personal safety!

Never go to anything ,,"underground" in this area! of Edinburgh.!
4

Hmm ...,

11/04/2008 03:20:52
... if they build the cinema underground, where will they put the car parking? The article doesn't say but the development of a major entertainment and arts area will need some pretty significant parking provision.
5

paulr,

edinburgh 11/04/2008 08:14:10
"the city's design champion"??????????
In his own mind maybe...
6

Boy Wonder,

11/04/2008 08:24:34
So this is what Terry Farrell has being doing since Star Trek: Deep Space 9 ended? Given up acting, hen??
7

Andrew,

11/04/2008 11:16:43
Maybe they can extend it to a proper UNDERGROUND (ie Subway/Metro) whilst they're at it!! You wouldn'd need a cinema for all the adverts on the walls!
8

Loki - The Scourge of the Schemies,

EH1 11/04/2008 11:55:11
#3 Morrison Street, for example,..'Stinks in the Summer'

Agreed and all the more annoying as most houses in that street surely have baths or showers.
9

Loki - The Scourge of the Schemies,

EH1 11/04/2008 11:56:20
Above ground in Festival Square is the blindingly obvious solution. How else are we to mask the hideous Sheraton Hotel?
10

I should be studying,

Edinburgh 11/04/2008 15:02:19
I think the only reason Festival Square is "dead" is because the ground floors of the surrounding buildings are mostly blank dark offices. These ground floors should be converted to shops, cafes, bars and restaurants. Then there will be people walking through the Square with a purpose - this is what gives "life" to public spaces. Once there is activit then people will want to stop and sit and people watch. At the moment, there's only one bar, and the restaurant for the Hilton hotel is above ground level so it is disconnected from the space below. I don't know who didn't allow the ground floors to be cafes etc.
11

Ard Righ,

The Rock Of Edinburgh 12/04/2008 00:53:57
It is interesting that yet another foreigner wishes to "improve" the mess made by other previous "improvers" who have all got the re-routing of roads in and around Edinburgh so very, very wrong.

One obvious rule applies, the lay of the land and working with that.

We won't have much of an Edinburgh left if more of these nasty, angular, steel and glass monsters are sanctioned by ignorant visionless planning councilors, obliterating the grace of Edinburgh and the magnificent beams of vistas.

12

Gordon Barr,

Glasgow 12/04/2008 08:36:27
There's a ready made dedicated site to the moving image just waiting for someone to come along and bring it back to life - for a fraction of the cost of these proposals - already featuring 5 screens, a dedicated cafe bar, lots of circulating space, land at the back giving room for future expansion, and lots of experience in hosting film festival premieres.

Yes, it's the old Odeon on Clerk Street.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.