Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Saturday, 10th May 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Bridging the gap between city's past and future



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 24 March 2008
Massive change is under way in industrial heartland once home to everything from brewers to boot makers.
FACTORIES belching out smoke, noxious smells and thousands of workers at clocking-off time, a stinking rat-infested stagnant canal and tenement homes barely large enough to swing a cat in.

Ruby Norman moved to the edge of Fountainbridge into a first floor, two-bedroom flat bought for the princely sum of £2000 and reckoned she would just have to make do.

Click here to see PDF picture of the area

Five children and eight grandchildren later, 41 years on and it's still home for her and husband Jack. And never before has she witnessed change on such a dramatic scale as she is seeing now.

Today the first floor flat in Viewforth Square which the couple bought in 1967 is reckoned to be worth around £190,000. Its value might soar even higher as the area around morphs from an industrial heartland – at one time producing everything from whisky to Wellington boots – into offices, townhouses, tree-lined boulevards and leisure attractions.

"It's happening so quickly," says Ruby, 71. "Is it all for the better? I suppose we'll just have to wait and see."

Indeed, the scale of what is happening at Fountainbridge is stunning – from the commercial and residential quayside at the Tollcross end, along the Union Canal towards the rapidly disappearing brewery sites on Dundee Street.

Gone are many familiar landmarks from the area's industrial past, replaced by rubble and a patchwork of shiny new buildings.

Today, five cranes tower over the skeletons of new buildings on the former site of Scottish & Newcastle's bottling and distribution plant, site of what will become "Springside", dubbed by its developers as a new "urban village".

On the opposite side of Dundee Street, where brewery workers' haunt the Tartan Club once stood, hoardings declare the imminent arrival of a Buredi development of homes and offices.

Further down, the familiar McEwan's symbol – a cheerful "cavalier" character supping from his pint – still stands guard over the entrance to the former S&N brewery. Beyond the gates many of the towering buildings remain. Their days, however, are numbered.

Progress, mapped out in the city council's 2004 masterplan, is unstoppable. Yet even now the fine detail of how the area will appear seems to change from week to week.

Most recently it emerged HBoS had "gazumped" a string of other developers to snap up the 12-acre former S&N brewery site, reportedly for more than £100 million. Its plan is to turn the land into a single base for its 6000 Edinburgh finance workers, and instantly, it seems, scuppers hopes part of the site might house a rebuilt Boroughmuir High School.

News of that came just days after councillors approved plans for a four-storey office block on Dundee Street, and confirmation that a third of the 58 flats at Springside had been reserved on the first day of going on sale.

Change is rapid – perhaps too rapid for residents like Ruby.

"I don't really want them to take everything away," she says, sitting in her home on the edge of Fountainbridge and Bruntsfield. "These new buildings all look the same to me. I don't like everything the same, I'd like something of the area's heritage to be kept – just to give it some kind of identity.

"Look at the McEwan's brewery sign. Once that is gone, then part of the area's history is gone.

"It's like the North British Rubber Mill," she continues, referring to a once bustling factory which employed hundreds, making anything from Wellington boots for First World War soldiers to golf balls. "Over the main door it said North British Rubber Mill. It goes and part of the area's history goes too, a place that employed so many people will be forgotten."

Even the most prominent reminder of one of the area's most famous sons has disappeared.

A plaque marking Sir Sean Connery's birthplace has gone for now, although the developers plan to replace it on the side of an office block set to rise on the site once occupied by his family home.

Unlike the hundreds of incomers expected to snap up the new homes, Ruby's links with the area are anchored in the past. She lived in Springwell Place just off Dalry Road – a stone's throw from the bustling breweries – with Jack until they sold their tiny room and kitchen flat for a mere £300.

They ended up at Viewforth Square with its one bedroom and boxroom – a far cry from the townhouses with underground parking planned for the Tartan Club site.

The area, she recalls, was steeped in industry – the distilleries and breweries, MacKay's sweet factory, and the rubber mill – their presence creating a pungent blend of aromas.

"The smells in this area were very distinctive – some days you had to keep the windows shut because the smell would be sickly," Ruby says. "There were brewery lorries up and down Viewforth, every hour of the day. The telephone exchange had just opened, the place was bustling. It's certainly going to be different."

That's something Sir Sean is on record as agreeing with. He lived at 176 Fountainbridge in the shadow of the rubber factory. His home was demolished in the 1960s, to make way for the expanding brewery.

The new Springside district will be a world away from the working-class neighbourhood where the screen icon grew up.

"Growing up in Fountainbridge played a major part in my early experiences of Edinburgh," he said recently. "Its industrial legacy left an important imprint on my life. I am pleased now the walls are coming down, and the area will be opened up to be part of the city.

"I remember the community spirit and that will now have a place to thrive. I hope that the better housing and open spaces will improve the quality of life there and give the community, and the rest of the city, a neighbourhood it can be proud of."

Over the canal in Grove Street at the one-time brewery workers' doss house which is now the Herald House Hotel, manager David Knox also relishes the changes.

He says: "It's all going to do a lot of good for the community around here," he says. "There's a lot happening, it gets busy with lorries and there's a lot of dust just now, but the changes are going to make a huge difference

."

As well as laying claim to the birthplace of Sir Sean Connery, Fountainbridge also boasts the foundation site of the Co-operative movement at St Cuthbert's, where the dairy horses continued to work until the 1990s.

Long gone too are Asa Wass, the rag and bone man, whose scrap business operated from around 161 Fountainbridge; Tom Boni who ran an ice cream shop at 134 Fountainbridge; Aitken's home bakery and Murdoch's paper shop, where in years long gone locals would visit to recharge wireless batteries and buy mantles for gas lights.

Antique furniture restorer Tom Donaldson, 60, set up his business, Siller & Donaldson, in Grove Street some 30 years ago, when the scene over Fountainbridge was dramatically different from the one he sees unfolding today.

"It used to be nice to see the horses and cart from the dairy – and you could always pick up some useful fertiliser for the garden," he laughs. "The St Cuthbert's bakery was along where Marco's is now, and of course the breweries were at the centre of everything in the area.

"I suppose it's good to see it changing, although my worry is that all these new buildings tend to just look the same. But nothing can stay the same forever."

His son, Douglas, 39, joined the family firm 23 years ago – and he too remembers a busy area where day to day life revolved around the hub of industry.

"When I joined the business, this area was just like a little village, even though it is in the centre of Edinburgh it had a community feel of its own.

"It was a bustling place. Not everyone likes the smell of the hops but it didn't bother me – I like a pint!

He welcomes progress, but adds: "It would be nice if something is kept to reflect the brewery history – such as the old McEwan's clock.

"I do feel a bit sorry that Edinburgh did have such a strong brewery history but it's almost completely gone now."

Old Tartan Club: Buredi has earmarked the southeast area around the former Tartan Club for an £80m development of 171 homes, underground parking and 8500 square metres of office space.

There will be a mixture of two and three-bedroom flats, duplexes and penthouses, built on the former brewery social club site.

A tree-lined boulevard dubbed New Freer Street is envisaged at the heart of the scheme, and a mini canal basin is planned for the centre of a courtyard area.

Springside: A £200m, 32-hectare "urban village" spanning the north side of Fountainbridge stretching from Grove Street to FountainPark which will feature 600 homes, offices, shops and an underground car park.

New roads will link the area to the West Approach Road and south towards the rejuvenated Union Canal and around a third of the area is earmarked for green space. Artwork and fountains are included in the landscaping plans.

Also included within Springside is an £8.5m project, already underway, to construct a 314-room, seven-storey high student residence, expected to be completed this September.

Edinburgh Quay: Phase one of this development has already been completed, with new offices, restaurants and luxury apartments transforming the canal basin area.

The second phase, of 55,000sq ft of offices and 6000sq ft of retail along with 60 apartments is already partially occupied.

Homes developer Mactaggart & Mickel has started work around what will be an extended canal basin, with around 130 new high quality apartments at Lochrin Place.

Nearby, the former Fat Sam's restaurant and meat market is being transformed into offices and restaurants in a £50 million scheme by Scottish Widows

HBOS HQ: The sprawling Scottish & Newcastle brewery stood by the Union Canal for around 150 years, however, much of the site took barely weeks to clear.

HBoS has agreed to buy the 12 acres of land with a view to creating a global centre, similar to the Royal Bank of Scotland's sprawling headquarters at Gogarburn, it emerged last week.

The offices would become the base for 6000 workers currently spread out across 16 different buildings in Edinburgh, although HBoS would keep its imposing headquarters on The Mound.



The full article contains 1778 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 24 March 2008 12:02 PM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Jenny MacArthur,

24/03/2008 12:38:21
Come on people! This story has been online for half an hour already. And the anti-tram moron obsessives haven't yet found a way to turn it into a whine! You really should do better...
2

bluehead,

edinburgh 24/03/2008 12:40:51
edinburgh is turning into a gigantic human sardine tin
what a state the place is in ! ,when I think of my edinburgh from years back and see it now, I am horrified,the city is now a concrete jungle made even worse by the maniacal tram system.
edinburgh is full up,leave what spaces are left for people to enjoy,stop building,and bring the place back to sanity,the only people who are winning are the ones
who are building these awfull strutures,not to mention making a fortune at the same time
3

bluehead,

edinburgh 24/03/2008 12:43:35
edinburgh is turning into a gigantic human sardine tin
what a state the place is in ! ,when I think of my edinburgh from years back and see it now, I am horrified,the city is now a concrete jungle made even worse by the maniacal tram system.
edinburgh is full up,leave what spaces are left for people to enjoy,stop building,and bring the place back to sanity,the only people who are winning are the ones
who are building these awfull structures,not to mention making a fortune at the same time
4

eric,

Lothian 24/03/2008 13:43:53
We were ALL horrified at Glasgow doing this ,For last 30yrs !Glasgow can get away with it ,Edinburgh cant,It will really stick out like a sore thumb this sort of development.
5

Andrew,

24/03/2008 14:11:22
Of course, the '"Western Approach Road" was once a vital rail artery into Edinburgh (Princes Street). How about returning it to rail use with a tram line to serve this development! Why is it that suitable public transport infrastructure IS ALWAYS AN AFTER-THOUGHT with such developments (if indeed considered at all)? Just look at the myriad of out-ot-town shopping centres build, almost solely, for the car user!!
6

Mallory,

Edinburgh 24/03/2008 14:16:21
How many of the first block of Springside flats remain unsold? What price was paid?

How much commercial property remains unlet in Edinburgh?

What effect will all these flats and offices have on the traffic flows in the west of the city?

How many more lunchtime sandwich bars will be required?

Lots of questions and we have not mentioned economic slowdowns, the collapse of the buy-to-let market and how much green public space will be made available for people to enjoy their 45 minutes breaks.
7

barra,

Edinburgh 24/03/2008 15:06:08
Wasn't the sign known as the Youngers Cavalier before it was taken over by S&N ?
8

Bald Eagle 40,

Corstorphine 24/03/2008 17:11:13
I grew up in Gibson Terrace when the Brewery owned virtually everything in sight. The truth is, what else are they going to do with the area? If, like me, you remember back to the slums along Dundee Street and the uncared for Union Canal, you might agree that they are improving the area? Even the Dundee Arms changed its name a few years back!
9

mad moo,

edinburgh 24/03/2008 17:15:00
The comments from locals say it all!
"I don't really want them to take everything away," she says, sitting in her home on the edge of Fountainbridge and Bruntsfield. "These new buildings all look the same to me. I don't like everything the same, I'd like something of the area's heritage to be kept – just to give it some kind of identity.
AND
"I suppose it's good to see it changing, although my worry is that all these new buildings tend to just look the same.

No doubt this will be respun as 'locals support development' by the developers pr boys
If any dare to speak up and object they will immediately be accused of being NIMBY's or standing in the way of progress.
10

mad moo,

edinburgh 24/03/2008 17:21:28
7# You are of course correct
McEwan's merged with William Younger's Brewery (founded in Edinburgh in 1749) in 1931, becoming Scottish Brewers. The company merged again in 1960, joining with Newcastle Breweries to form Scottish & Newcastle.
11

Steve-o,

Fountainbridge 24/03/2008 20:54:08
Just PLEASE no more buildings like the office block at Edinburgh Quay, and the GHASTLY HBoS one over the road on the site of Alexander's used car dealership... they all look so blah.
12

Julian,

EDINBURGH 24/03/2008 22:21:36
#2 Bluehead,

You must be a great laugh down the pub.

The new developments here, in case you didn't read the article, are nearly all replacing old brewery buildings. That's progress as far as I'm concerned.

Although I do think it's a disgrace that they were allowed to demolish Fat Sams. Somebody told me they were going to rebuild the old facade. Does anyone know if that's true?
13

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

25/03/2008 09:09:18
Of course it is progress. Conservative isnt the word for you lot, moaning about the loss of a smelly brewery site. I do object to the boxy little houses that will replace it , though we live in an age where laminate flooring is de rigeur...
14

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

25/03/2008 09:09:49
12 as fas as I heard The Wids have to retain the facade of Fat Sams (but if its already gone..)
15

Azdak,

25/03/2008 11:24:05
I watched the old meatmarket arch at Fat Sams being carefully dismantled. It will be rebuilt, but not in exactly the same place.
16

Erica from East Kilbride,

25/03/2008 11:43:06
#4 - do I detect a note of terror, there? Desperation, even? Well sorry, but welcome to the REAL world, a world in which Edinburgh has a confident economic future and where regeneration and renewal is sustainable ... unlike the token attempts at urban regeneration in other parts of Scotland. In some places you really would struggle to make old sh**e look like new.
17

Shug the Dug,

Edinburgh 25/03/2008 12:28:36
"As well as laying claim to the birthplace of Sir Sean Connery, Fountainbridge also boasts the foundation site of the Co-operative movement at St Cuthbert's....."

Did the reporter mean that this was the foundation of the entire Co-operative movement? If so the research was clearly too scant to be accurate!

The beginnings of the movement actually lie with the Fenwick Weavers Co-operative Society established in 1769.

Many other co-operatives were formed in subsequent years with varying degrees of success. The more important dates and occurrences being:

Rochdale Pioneers Society established in 1844 started a period of phenomenal co-operative growth. Based on their eight 'Rochdale rules', including distributing a share of profits according to purchases that came to be known as 'the divi'.

The Industrial and Provident Societies Acts (I&P Act) 1862 for the first time gave co-operatives corporate status providing a proper legal framework for co-operatives. The first I&P Act had been enacted in 1843.

The following year, 1863, the Co-operative Wholesale Society (CWS), originally called the North of England Co-operative Wholesale Industrial and Provident Society Limited was established; the Scottish CWS followed in 1868.

The St. Cuthbert's Co-operative Society, taking its name from Saint Cuthbert of Lindisfarne, didn't open its first shop (in Edinburgh) until 1859 as a Consumers' cooperative;part of the movement started by the Rochdale Pioneers in 1844, following the Rochdale Principles with the aim of providing decent food at affordable prices in a shop controlled by its customers as a Cooperative.

It expanded to become one of the largest societies in Co-Op UK before amalgamating with the Dalziel Society of Motherwell in 1981 and being renamed Scotmid. Its dairy used horse drawn delivery floats until 1985, and between 1944 and 1959 employed as a milkman one Sean Connery who later became very famous.

Hope this snippet makes up for the article's la
18

Annoyingboi,

Emptybra 25/03/2008 13:38:12
16, A very naive post. Son you have clearly missed the point again. Edinburgh is good because of the way it is, it looks, it feels. Bit by bit our town is being chipped away and is beginning to look like every other town in Britain. Then why would people visit, invest, live in Edinburgh? Progress is fine but we must be very very careful or its going to go all to the dogs!
19

Julian,

EDINBURGH 25/03/2008 14:48:33
Mario and Azdak,

Thanks for that. You're right, they're definitely not building it in the same place as the picture on the billboard does not show it. Good to hear that it's going to be put back somewhere, although I'm a bit of a purist and would like to see it back in the same place.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.