Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Joy as South African graduate told she can stay in UK with her family

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 11 July 2008
A YOUNG South African woman who was facing deportation from Scotland wept with joy yesterday after winning the battle to stop her family being torn apart in an immigration mix-up.
Josie Pasane, 25, a graduate of Abertay University, rushed into the arms of her relieved mother and sister as she came out victorious from a meeting in Glasgow with UK Border Agency officials.

The agency admitted they blundered four years ago whe
n they wrongly advised her she could wait until 2008, when her visa expired, before applying for permission to stay in the UK.

Ms Pasane has lived in Broughty Ferry, near Dundee, since the family arrived in Britain seven years ago.

She acted on the official advice and did not apply for permanent residence when her mother, Catherine, and sister, Mammie, each paid a £500 fee to have applications processed.

But following her meeting in Glasgow, she confirmed officials had now offered an apology.

She said: "They apologised for the wrong information given to my family in 2004, and for them to acknowledge their mistake meant a lot to us all.

"I am allowed to stay with my mum and sister. I feel wonderful. It's been a great day. I had left room for disappointment if things did not go my way. But I was able to remain optimistic thanks to the support of the community and my family and friends.

"Even people who did not know me have given me their support – that's just amazing."

People in Broughty Ferry had rallied round the family and last month a petition with more than 4,000 signatures, calling for Ms Pasane to be given the right to remain in the UK, was given to Liam Byrne, minister for borders and immigration.

It was handed over by Stewart Hosie, the SNP MP for Dundee East, who yesterday praised the decision to allow Ms Pasane to remain in Britain. "I am delighted for Josie and her family," he said. "I know how hard this period of uncertainty has been for her. I am certain this is down to the hard work and support of the local community and the many local people who signed the petition. All those involved deserve a pat on the back."

Mr Hosie added: "She was following advice that was fundamentally flawed and people saw the natural injustice in this and rallied to her cause.

"The Home Office, as I understand it, have apologised for any misinformation and reversed the decision. It was just so blatantly unfair."

Ms Pasane's mother, Catherine, spoke of her relief at the news. She said: "We had fantastic support from the MP, from the church and from the community. I don't even have the words to say thank you to everyone."

Earlier this year, Ms Pasane had to give up her sales job at H&M after being told she would have to leave the country.

She said: "It has been difficult for me not to be able to work, because I'm an ambitious person, but now this is over I can concentrate on my career."

A spokeswoman for the UK Border Agency said: "We do not comment on the details of individual cases. If appropriate, in exceptional cases, we may reconsider our decision."

IN NUMBERS

190
people awaiting deportation can be held at any one time in the Dungavel removal centre, Glasgow.

270
Afghan people were removed from the UK between January and March this year.

283,500
failed asylum seekers are in Britain, according to the Independent Asylum Commission.

63,140
people were removed from the UK last year by the Border and Immigration Agency.

1
person is deported every eight minutes.

4,200
criminals removed in 2007.

1,640
asylum applicants were detained by the Home Office in the first quarter of this year.



The full article contains 649 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

Fanling,

Switzerland 11/07/2008 00:37:36
This is a heartening story. Stupid, faceless bureaucracy defeated by the indomitable will of a community that cares. Josie arrived in Scotland by legal means. She has graduated from university locally, earned her keep and deserves her right of stay. Unlike some - too many - from societies with an agenda alien to Scotland and the UK as a whole.
2

,

11/07/2008 04:02:28
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
3

cabrach loon,

inverness 11/07/2008 07:47:36
how come nugov are so keen to deport the innocent but reluctant when they are muslims with ties to terrorism - there is something not right in the immigration procedures and their application.
4

M.Corleone,

2nd Vatican State...... Coatbridge 11/07/2008 08:14:56
I'm pleased for her too
5

,

11/07/2008 08:15:42
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
6

Boy Wonder,

11/07/2008 08:45:06
#6 Sam, sometimes you come across as a real ar5e!!!
7

Media 1,

cape town 11/07/2008 09:06:24
She's South African, that alone suggests you have an addition to Scotland that will work hard, take nothing from the state and will give back as much as she can to the community.
Well done lass....
8

voltaire's janny,

11/07/2008 10:38:47
Although governance here was in error, it was neither stupid nor faceless and the just outcome transpired.

Ms Pasane, no doubt like any of us would, prefered to defer paying her 500 quid until as late as possible. However anyone who relies on advice from a civil servant that is not cross checked with the relevant rules/website or provided in writing is leaving themselves open to bureaucracy's interminable wheels.

The stress of potential deportation is at least partly her own fault. With government trust but verify!
9

voltaire's janny,

11/07/2008 10:39:17
Oh and congratulations, and welcome, by the way....
10

Graham Barnes,

Gravesend 11/07/2008 10:58:18
Well said, no 4
11

sam the god,

11/07/2008 11:17:53
What is wrong with South Africa that they want to come here and live?
Does South Africa not have a welfare system?

12

sam the god,

11/07/2008 11:19:48
#7 boy wonder
it makes a change from you typing david nish.

13

dma47,

DUNDEE 11/07/2008 11:20:02
Again well said No4. How is a situation like this allowed to happen. P.S. Broughty Ferry is pretty close to Dundee being well within the City boundary
14

,

11/07/2008 12:44:11
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
15

sam the god,

11/07/2008 13:07:19
#16 jazzman

well said never a truer statement
16

Kiwi in Scotland,

Edinburgh 11/07/2008 13:23:44
Yet another example of the Home Office giving wrong advice and then penalising the individual.

I have finally gained Permanent Residency after being told that I was not eligible for a Marriage Visa when I originally entered the UK (since apparently my husband was unable to prove he could support me but I have since been told this was rubbish and that I should have applied for this). It has cost me nearly £2000 so far (due to the cost of extensions to my Ancestry Visa and an application for residency that they rejected as my situation was neither "compassionate nor compelling enough"). They told me at one point that if I quit my job, returned to NZ and applied from there I would immediately get residency, when I argued that wouldn't it be better for me to keep my job and be able to apply within the UK they didn't care. When I got Permanent Residency the first thing they told me was "don't leave the country for more than two years and you are now eligible for benefits".

I now know not to believe a word they say on the phone (the advice is incredibly inconsistent) but at the time of originally applying I had presumed that the individuals giving advice would have been trained in the rules.If not they should just refuse to take calls and refer everyone to their website with the actual legislation...
17

Media 1,

cape town 11/07/2008 14:23:47
sam the dog

No welfare system here. You work hard or you die! Simple, the way it should be. Nothing for nothing san!
18

sam the god,

11/07/2008 15:20:32
#19 mediam

that is probably why this country is seen as a soft touch. come to the uk the tax payers will look after you you can even say you hate this country and still get the hand outs
19

Steve McGregor,

Dundee 11/07/2008 15:51:49
A white south african wouldn't have faced any threat of deportation. A Vivid example is Natasha Kaplinsky of channel 5.
We are a narrow minded and RACIST country.
20

Memyself&I,

11/07/2008 15:59:31
#21 I'm not sure why this is even in the news.
Oh yeah, and what a stupid baseless comment to make.
21

,

11/07/2008 17:11:36
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
22

Richard Taylor,

Aberdeen 11/07/2008 20:10:12
#4 thirded - well said. And good for the lass, she's a credit to herself & her family.
23

Media 1,

cape town 11/07/2008 20:56:50
Steve McGreogor

You're not very good at disguising your hate! lol

F@kc you make me laugh, lmao hahaha!

The caring McGregor who is really Steve the monster...lmfao
24

Jed Zeppelin,

Dundee 11/07/2008 23:15:00
Broughty Ferry near Dundee? It's a ruddy suburb of Dundee. Nothing near about it.
25

Jock Tamson,

Scotland, Caledonia, Alba 12/07/2008 00:10:00
26, Jed Zeppelin, like Longforgan, eh? Imperialist Dungdee?
26

Dòmhnall,

Dalguise (mispronounced by the incomers) 30/07/2008 11:38:21
I am deeply dismayed some on this thread have raised the issue of skin colour, just because this delighful, intelligent young lady happens to be black. Depressing...

Why do the people who concern themselves with skin colour not bother to raise the issue of the c. 45,000 English immigrants (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/scotland/7523192.stm)
who move to Scotland each year ? Note the economic and cultural implications these English immigrants have on this country.

#13 sam the god,11/07/2008 11:17:53
"What is wrong with South Africa that they want to come here and live?
Does South Africa not have a welfare system?"

SAM the God: whether deliberate or not, I believe your comment is inflammatory. If Josie Pasane is representive of the whole family, they evidently DIDNA come here to claim off the the state.

Congratulations Josie ! Good luck to yourself !
27

paulmort,

Quezon City 11/10/2008 16:17:14
I thought everyone was leaving the country by the dozens
because of the price of commodities and the weather plus
who could stand seeing all that snow in winter. There must be something that Ive missed.Good luck to the wee girl and hope she has a wonderful life in Bonnie Scotland
I miss it myself.
28

paulmort,

Quezon City 11/10/2008 16:20:59
I was going to say the price of beer is much cheaper down here in the Philippines. Now I know why I live here

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.