Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Trump dismisses fears that £1bn golf resort in Scotland is at risk

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 03 December 2008
THE Trump organisation yesterday strenuously denied it was scaling back on developments – including its luxury golf resort in north-east Scotland – because of the credit crunch and a series of legal and financial battles.
It dismissed reports of the billionaire's fortune dwindling as "speculation", and said none of the issues facing the company would affect its plans for a £1 billion golf development at Menie Estate, Aberdeenshire.

The project team for Menie –
which got the go-ahead after the Scottish Government "called in" the plans – will be announced this week and the organisation says it remains committed to the project.

Mr Trump is said to be worth about $3 billion (£2 billion) but a report yesterday claimed his organisation was under pressure from work stalling on a skyscraper plan in Dubai and apartments in Philadelphia.

It is also claimed Trump Entertainment Resorts (TER) missed a $53.1 million interest payment relating to casinos in Atlantic City, while Trump was being sued by Deutsche Bank over a development in Chicago.

The claim has led to rumours about the health of Trump's finances and speculation about whether the Aberdeenshire resort will progress.

However, George Sorial, the manager of the Menie project, said TER was a publicly traded company in which Trump had a minority position representing less than 1 per cent of his overall net worth. He had nothing to do with the management.

He told The Scotsman from New York: "There has been a heightened sense of some problems within the Trump Organisation which would prevent us from doing the job in Scotland.

"It's simply not true at all. Obviously, like any developer now, we are facing challenging times, but that is not unique to the Trump Organisation.

"At the same time, there are significant opportunities in the market and we have taken advantage of that by making a number of key acquisitions."

These include a troubled golf course project near Manhattan which Trump has taken over.

He added: "As far as real estate development globally goes, did we have a bad year? Yes. Will next year be bad? Yes, it will be challenging. But bad times are usually followed by periods of aggressive growth, so I think we are nicely positioned in Aberdeen and we are in good shape to get through it.

"As an organisation we have done well and one project has nothing really to do with another. The news for Scotland is good. This week we will announce our entire development team. We have been spending money consistently in the North-east over the last three years and continue to do so."

He said Menie House and Menie Park Lodge were being refurbished, while architects had been commissioned to devise the masterplan and design the clubhouse.

"It should go a long way towards demonstrating that we are not playing games here. We are ramping up now to get this project started.

"If you speak to anyone, we are not doing anything to show signs of slowing down. We want to start this project.

"People can speculate, but when we have equipment rolling on to the site and work is starting, critics will be silenced.

"The proof will be if we get on with the job and I don't think we have done anything but indicate we are extremely committed to Aberdeen.

"You don't spend tens of millions of pounds on a site that you don't intend developing."

He said the dollar had recently gained on the pound, while the price of oil and raw materials had dropped, all of which helped developers.





The full article contains 607 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 02 December 2008 10:50 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Donald Trump
 
1

jerrymanders,

03/12/2008 01:34:35
Is Trumptown a busted flush?
2

alba nach,

Tarbert 03/12/2008 03:23:41
As they say, the Dollar has gained over 25% on the pound since June. That means the development that means what was a $2 billion USD project is now 'only' a $1.5 billion project.

Other costs in construction will probably come down too due to lower fuel costs and lower labour costs from the downturn in building.

As long as he has access to the cash, now would seem like a really good time to be building a project like that in order to have it ready for delivery when the market is heading upwards.
3

Snuffy Ivy,

Aberdeen. UK 03/12/2008 05:23:24
However, as clever as the Donald thinks he is, he needs to anticipate the true Scots work ethic: Strikes!
The unions should keep the overspend going very nicely.
I don't think the poor man realises the problems he's going to run into with Scots workers. Sorry folks.
4

Anonym,

sceptical and sarcastic 03/12/2008 07:45:36
Aye, there'll be challenging times ahead for Trump and his multi-millionaire chums.

I'm quite worried about TER's profit margins. Fearful even.

Thanks goodness somebody had the good sense to produce a report expressing those fears.
5

ZipptJeffrey,

Castle 03/12/2008 09:27:58
I see the witches curse of the Trump golf course is taking affect. Trump's investments will continue to go into administration. Also Aberdeen council will probably have no money in its coffers by next April. Aberdonians need to understand that there are somethings that cant be bought.
6

ddmc,

03/12/2008 10:12:26
Trump is skint & who will lend him money when he cant pay is existing creditors
7

salmondella,

Uk 03/12/2008 10:26:58
This guy sounds very much like Vlad Romonov.
8

Rasco,

03/12/2008 11:00:04
Trump will go to Ireland where he will be made very welcome,he will still own the Estate he then might try to charge the bird watchers and dog walkers or he could offer to sale it to Mr Forbes or the Lib councillors who was against the plan.
9

Jimmy Le Pie,

03/12/2008 11:10:31
I find the New Labour Sleaze apologists so hypocritical. If Wendy or Gray were First Minister (God help us!!), they would have been all over Trump like a rash.

They still find it impossible to accept they are in opposition and are unlikely ever to get in again.
10

Jimmy Le Pie,

03/12/2008 11:10:31
I find the New Labour Sleaze apologists so hypocritical. If Wendy or Gray were First Minister (God help us!!), they would have been all over Trump like a rash.

They still find it impossible to accept they are in opposition and are unlikely ever to get in again.
11

Number 6,

Germany 03/12/2008 13:08:53
So despite this being a "Rumor" of undetermined origin,
the Scotsman translates it into "Fears".

Pathetic. For all you unionistas and invertede snops, read it and weep. Trump is here to stay. Conditions are financially better for him than when he started this project.

A series of envy fueled inquiries have failed to come up with a reasonable argument for stopping this huge investment into Northern Scotland.

An investment that would never ever have happened under a unionista goverment. The rent a mob will still
do what they can to obstruct this project, despite the jobs etc it brings to Scotland.

It's the old unionista Self-Loathing rearing it's repulsive head once more. The very thought of Trump allowing himself to be dictated to by the peasantry is laughable.

Remember, this was going to be a Liebour project until they realised there were no Brown envelopes on the table.
12

livilion,

livingston 03/12/2008 14:03:33
From The Times
October 29, 2005
>>
Cringe – but at least travelling salesman McConnell is trying
As the First Minister returns from his trip to North America, our correspondent looks beyond the embarrassments to the lessons of selling Scotland abroad
By Angus Macleod
His visit to Trump Towers in New York where he met Donald Trump — “half man, half brand” as one observer memorably put it — became the abiding image of Mr McConnell’s trip and succeeded only in deflecting attention from the real meat: the First Minister’s attempts to win investment for and interest in the old country from the Scottish diaspora in North America.

When Mr Trump trumpeted his wish to “maybe do something in Scotland sometime”, it wasn’t a pinch of salt you needed it was the whole salt mine. He might have said the same, with the name of the country changed, if he been meeting the President of Upper Volta or the Prime Minister of Rockall. They at least, we hope, would not have looked as grateful for small recognition as Mr Mc- Connell succeeded in doing.

And the over-the-top Mr Trump compounded the cliché-ridden summit with the Scottish apprentice by going on interminably about his “Scotch mother”. Mr McConnell, meanwhile, didn’t get a word in and could only look on, perhaps secretly hoping that Mr Trump might soon shut up and he could get the hell out of there. That meeting was about Trump, not about Scotland and no amount of spin about winning influence and exposing Scotland to an American television audience alters that.<<

13

57vintage,

Keith 03/12/2008 14:09:37
#14

Jobs?

Given that they are in Scotland, I suppose the term "McJob" was never more appropriate.

There will be a few hotel managers, some maintenance people and some greenkeepers required.

The others will be for catering and housekeeping staff. Aye, that'll save the economy whilst we're lumbered with hundreds of 21st century Barrat-esque chicken coops and an infrastructure struggling to cope.
14

livilion,

livingston 03/12/2008 14:37:10
#16 57vintage,Keith

Aye and while you're at it can we not get rid of resort hotels like Turnberry, Gleneagles and the Old Course at St Andrews?
The infrastructures struggle to cope there too do they not?

Who needs green keepers, hotel managers and maintenance people,eh? and who needs customers coming into this country wanting to buy things and pay money to use these facilities?

'Proper' tourists come to Scotland to stand in the rain, watch the scenery, live in a tent, and be eaten by midges while looking for a tea room that's open where they can use a toilet.

FYI Hospitality is the biggest employer in the UK, with support industries radiating out from each resort. Go online now and try to find accomodation in Aberdeen this week.

Get used to it, since Maggie shut down the mines, the yards, the steelworks, the fisheries etc it is hotel and restaurant workers' NI contributions and income tax that is paying to keep your schools and hospitals running.
15

Number 6,

Germany 03/12/2008 15:22:33
#16 Classic self-loathing unionista spiteful garbage.

Well done Sir, you encapsulate EVERYTHING we always knew about unionistas.

You would rather the area was left as it is, desolate and stagnent rather thean see over a Billion pounds being pumped into the area.Some thing unthinkable under your London based heros.

Your "point" about what will be created wreaks of unionista ignorance. Shame on you.
16

57vintage,

Keith 03/12/2008 15:47:46
#18

You make an affa assumption that I am a "unionista". It doesn't relly become you. You would do well to accept that the constitution is not yet a black and white issue.

You remind me of Old Firm fans who assume that if you don't support their team of choice you must support the other.

As far as independence/the union/separatism is concerned, I'll await the arguments before any referendum before finally making up my mind. I voted Yes (twice) in 79 and Yes in 97, incidentally.

If your hectoring and insulting behaviour towards my opinion, however, are typical of those who will be attempting to persuade me to vote in favour of independence in a referendum, I'd be unlikely to support the cause of which you seem so certain. The same attitude displayed by Trump and his minions towards the planning process and any opponents with a legitimate opposing viewpoint have put many backs up in this locality.

The same attitude saw the voters of Glenrothes boorishly derided by keyboard control freaks when they did not elect the Nationalist in the recent by-election. How very enlightened.

I'm sorry if this view does not fit with your New World Order, but that's how it is.

4 legs good 2 legs bad?
17

Jimmy Le Pie,

03/12/2008 17:11:24
I hear from the BBC radio news that the Herald is paying off most of their journalists (I thought, like the Hootsmon, they didn't employ any!)

Hootsmon next????
18

Tim C,

Southern England 03/12/2008 17:54:52
Number 16, 57Vintage gets my vote. Odds on, this is a housing scam. Golf course will be left "under construction" for the next ten years, while they trouser some money for chicken coops. The golf course site is a convenient place to dump spoil under the guise of "landscaping"; the plan will call for executive houses to be built and sold first. Where I come from, the watery south, I can show you a site that was earmarked for 'factories' and a few houses; now it's thirty (+/-) upmarket houses and two big sheds. One shed is occupied.
If Mr Turnip builds the golfy course first, I will apologise.

Wish I could find an English paper that lets me post my childish remarks, but here they censor about 98% of comments.

19

dido-bendigo,

Scotland 03/12/2008 18:16:55
#21 Tim C

Try the 'Daily Telegraph' it is the only quality paper left that enjoys tackling 'establishment' issues, ie it does not 'suck up' to our Whitehall masters.
20

Tim C,

Southern England 04/12/2008 12:21:26
Thanks dido-bendigo, but the commentary on the Scotsman has a
bracing, sharp edge that is lacking amongst english webpapers. And it is good to hear from those Scots who aren't living in the luxury fantasy hotel known as Whitehall.

21

Myosotis,

05/12/2008 20:21:23
The exchange rate may help save the project, but Trump will need to spend many millions before he can start to cash in on the housing.

So it looks like there will be slippage in the building of the golf course, due to the present financial squeeze. I also notice that Aberdeenshire Planning only has a part-time person looking after the development now, while we mark time until the Trump organisation sends in its detailed plans.

Then the battles will begin all over again, fuelled by the Inquiry reporters who saw plenty of scope to adjust the course design to conserve the environment.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.