Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Expenses row: Tory MP resigns as Cameron's aide

View Video
Download Video

Video

David Cameron on Andrew MacKay's resignation
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 14 May 2009
ANDREW MacKay has resigned as Conservative leader David Cameron's Commons aide over "unacceptable" expenses claims, the party announced today.
The MP voluntarily submitted his claims to party officials.

A spokesman for Mr Cameron said: "That examination of Mr MacKay's past allowances revealed an unacceptable situation that would not stand up to reasonable public scrutiny.

"Although Mr MacKay maintains that those arrangements were agreed by the Fees Office, he resigned this morning with immediate effect.

"Mr MacKay has also agreed to appear in front of the scrutiny panel to discuss how much of the allowance should be paid back."

Bracknell MP Mr MacKay, who is married to Bromsgrove Tory MP Julie Kirkbride, claimed the full second-home allowance for interest on their joint mortgage for a London home until April this year.

But at the same time his wife also claimed the full annual sum for mortgage interest on a constituency home – meaning they appeared to have two second homes but no main home, sources said.

Mr MacKay will now appear before the internal review panel being set up by Mr Cameron to review "excessive" claims.

There is no question of him having the whip removed.

Ms Kirkbride, who was previously a political corespondent for the Daily Telegraph which has sparked the latest furore over expenses by printing leaked details of claims, registers the London property as her main home and takes second home allowances for the Bromsgrove home they also share.

The resignation appears to suggest that the newspaper may be preparing to focus its next set of disclosures on the various pairs of married MPs in the Commons.

Previous controversies have surrounded claims by Tory couple Sir Nicholas and Ann Winterton, married cabinet ministers Ed Balls and Yvette Cooper, Labour backbenchers Alan and Ann Keen and Northern Ireland first minister Peter Robinson and his fellow DUP MP spouse Iris.

The Tory panel, which is awaiting the appointment of one further independent member before starting work, was set up by Mr Cameron earlier this week to examine "excessive" claims.

He has vowed to strip the party whip from any who reject its findings and refuse to make repayments.

Mr MacKay later apologised for his actions, saying it had never previously occurred to him there was anything wrong with the arrangement, which he claimed had been suggested to them by the Commons Fees Office.

"I had taken advice from the most senior person at the time in the Fees Office and they had suggested to me that I elect our family home in north Worcestershire, in my wife Julie's constituency," he told Sky News.

"My second home that I claimed on is our home in Westminster, near to the House of Commons. Equally Julie was advised to claim the main home in London, the second home in Bromsgrove.

"This was all transparent, it was all approved and frankly until it was drawn to my attention it did not occur to me that it didn't pass the reasonableness test.

"I must say when it was drawn to my attention my first reaction was that the right thing to do was to resign my post, which I did very first thing today with David."

He said: "Looking back now, it does look strange, I have clearly made an error of judgment for which I profusely apologise and I've done what I think is the right thing."

He promised to pay back however much a new Conservative Party scrutiny committee decided he should.

Mr Cameron, speaking during a visit to Cornwall, said the arrangement had been discovered by the party after Mr MacKay submitted his claims for examination.

He said: "The examination revealed a state of affairs which I don't think is acceptable. He will go before a scrutiny panel to determine how much of this needs to be repaid."

The Tory leader admitted that the expenses scandal had damaged his party.

"Clearly all parties have been damaged by this. We have to put our hands up," he said.

"Every party has taken action to try and sort this out and I have set out what my party is going to do."

All the latest on the expenses row

Page 1 of 1

 
1

Alan B,

14/05/2009 10:41:24
Should be resigned or sacked as an mp not just as an aide while remaining an mp.

As such Camerson needs to remove the whip from mps guilty of seriously abusing the expenses system.

2

Vivas,

Edinburgh 14/05/2009 10:54:01
At any other time, this kind of thing would have been good news for Labour.

At this time though the Tories are winning the propaganda war in terms of delivering their own personal levels of justice in this saga. Morley, Blears and McNulty also need to walk the plank to show they understand the gravity of their situations. Writing cheques - an admission of guilt - is one thing. Taking the punishment for the original offence is quite another. Where is their punishment ?

3

Elephant,

Linlithgow 14/05/2009 10:58:29
This is all good. After Goodwin and the fat cats were hounded out and defrocked by a union of public and media scrutiny, the MPs will face the same. The gravy train has been chugging for too long in this country and it is us lot picking up the bill - so at least we should get the pleasure of booting them out. That Cameron is hastening the process is to his credit, regardless of your political view. The other leaders should follow suit, including at Holyrood where the revision of property rules for MSPs be hastened and back-dated less they appear out of step.
4

,

14/05/2009 11:07:28
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
5

karin.m,

14/05/2009 11:11:25
by the way very annoyed at the hootsman turning this into a purely snp witch hunty thing. they are all at it its the degrees of at it ness that im concerned with. there is a heirarchy of offence here.

doing the double bubble is a major offfence in my book
6

Class On Grass,

Grassy knoll 14/05/2009 11:34:25

Sack the couple, and all others who show questionable morals. On the brew with them. Sack the incompetents in the fees office as well - it is not doing its job (and shouldn't even have to)

Line them up alongside the investment bankers against the wall of public humiliation, private prosecution.
Fire away!!!!

7

Ewan Randall,

14/05/2009 12:06:40
Are these reviews on these expenses not a method of sidestepping the issue of morality and only concentration on there legality when things quiet down?
8

Tartan Viking,

14/05/2009 12:18:21
Was the "Tory couple Sir Nicholas and Ann Winterton" the same couple who were found out last year to have claimed over £130,000 in mortgage payments for a house they already owned, whilst filtering the money through a trust or something to avoid paying tax?

Devious cheating of tax-payers' money. If so they deserve to be treated like the criminal scum they are and get a stretch in prison. Only then will things start to improve.

9

Brodric,

14/05/2009 12:23:18
Does something not smack of the same conditions that pre-empted the French Revolution?

Those in power, abuse it, and leave us (the masses) to suffer - no cake, mind you, only cold toast.

Off with their proverbial heads - 'Madame Guillotine' (otherwise known as the power of the people) awaits you.
10

Brodric,

14/05/2009 12:28:35
In actual fact, though I said 'power of the people', this is not true in the UK.

What is wrong with us? Look at the French with the support they have given to the New Anti-Capitalist party. And their charismatic leader, French postman, Olivier Besancesnot.

Being anti-capitalist is not being anti-democratic. I am no commie, but it is quite evident that we need a change of political leadership and change of ideals.

Capitalism, in its monetarist form in the UK, has lead to the current collapsing of the house of cards as one domain after another suffers scandals of mis-management, poor leadership, self-interest and even fraud. This will be the downfall of us all.

Think I will go and join the French.
11

Dún Aenghus,

14/05/2009 12:35:01
What utter corruption! Rule britannia! britannia rules the slaves,(thats us).
12

joppie joppie,

Aberdeen 14/05/2009 12:38:59
Come the election the same pratts will be voted in by the same pratts who vote
13

steve 1511,

aberdeen 14/05/2009 12:44:41
why is comrade broon the eeejit with the big banana smile not sacking his ministers and mps who have the morals of politicians in a banana republic,is it because lybour have reduced this country to banana republic with lies sleaze and corruption the norm in their daily lives.

THE HOUSE OF COMMON THIEVES REQUIRES A NEW OLIVER CROMWELL TO CLEAN IT OUT
14

A Friend of Fernando Poo,

14/05/2009 13:29:23
If Brown goes down the route of sacking the greedy and guilty, he won't have enough MP's left to fill a taxi, let alone the Cabinet.
15

Hmm ...,

14/05/2009 13:50:02
... so are this guilty couple to resign their seats?

I hope so - we need some honesty in our politicians and they wouldn't need a Bromsgrove "home"; they could just live in London if they can still afford the mortgage. And his wife wouldn't need her"constituency home".

I am REALLY looking forward to seeing Ed Balls and Yvette Cooper's expenses, though! They don't understand the concept of truth, let alone honesty.
16

Bejjy,

Europe 14/05/2009 13:58:18
There is no question of him having the whip removed.


I think that MacKay like a lot more of his fellow corrupt MP's should be whipped for this abuse of the expense system.
17

WSS,

14/05/2009 14:31:22
The WORDS of RABBIE BURNS

O wad some power the gift tae gie us
To see oorsels as others see us
It wad fae monie a blunder free us

Words written by Scotland’s National Bard over 200 years ago and very relevant in to-day’s climate of Parliamentary sleeze. The excuses given for over claiming expenses are beyond belief of the ordinary man,
“ I forgot that my Mortgage was paid up” - Morley
“ I was abiding by the rules” - so I didn’t pay any CGT - Blears
“ I had to remove the sludge from my moat” - Hogg
“We had two family homes so we claimed for both” - MacKay
If all our MP s had been as careful with taxpayer’s money as they have with their OWN then the country would be in a far better economic state. They should have spent their time(which we were paying them to do) attending to matters of state instead of feathering their own nests. How many MPs were millionaires before they went into Parliament and how many are in that category now.
Burns was but a simple and not too successful a farmer but he clearly he understood the greed of man.
The poem by the way is “ TO A LOUSE” how fitting
18

connaughtboy,

stonehaven 14/05/2009 14:40:08
I notice that he didn't resign his MP job.
19

Iainbroch,

14/05/2009 14:41:17
re 14

What is the bet that they will even claim the taxi fare and oh imagine the horrendous bill if they take it to an employment tribunal armed with thier expensive lawyers paid for by us.
20

Iainbroch,

14/05/2009 14:43:33
re 12

Sad but true. A few postal votes and a few more there will speed them on thier way onboard the train again. All aboard - train leaving no stops promised Michael Martin is driving!
21

Iainbroch,

14/05/2009 14:45:39
re 12

Oh I forgot it is no longer a train - they will all be in for Lear Jets after 2010 if not sooner.
22

Iainbroch,

14/05/2009 14:47:13
re 9

Bring back the Maiden!
23

Iainbroch,

14/05/2009 15:17:43
Why isn't the Hootsman asking WHY NO ONE HAS BEEN ARRESTED AND CHARGED YET? I guess the question is a little uncomfortable for them!
24

Cabbage'n'Ribz,

14/05/2009 15:29:17
Don't know what part of the iceberg this story is but it's the same iceberg.

British politics is rotten to the core, corrupt as any they decry.

The British people will do nothing except continue to be ripped off by those supposedly serving.
If only we could vote mp's out instead of in, what is the point of changing one corrupt party for another?

They think by arguing this is all within the rules and that some will pay back money, everything will be ok. jeez what planet are they from?

I have always voted but next time will use it for the most obscure party. May be wasted but it's mine to waste.
Rather that than Democratically elected Autocrats.

25

Alan B,

14/05/2009 15:38:44
#10 Brodric

I would say the opposite. It is the failure to adhere to some sort of monetarism that has caused the failures in the UK economy.

France by dint of being in the euro have a more clear monetarist approach by comparison.
26

Brodric,

14/05/2009 15:48:21
25 - AlanB - the fact that the EU has accepted the euro doesn't mean it has a more clear monetarist approach. It is how the currency is supported that matters. And I was referring to the US/UK model, rather than the EU one which has a tighter leash on controls.
27

Farmernot,

14/05/2009 16:16:40
At the next General Election when your MP is doorstepping why not ask his opinion and whether he broke the rules.........think he or she might get away quickly. Also Morley should be charged with Fraud
28

Alan B,

14/05/2009 17:43:41
#Brodric

My point is monetarism is the economic philosophy that believes in controlling inflation by controlling the money supply. In it true form you would set targets for the growth of the money supply. Money supply growth is largely made up of the growth of credit.

To control the money supply you would either do so via quantative credit controls or/and using the price of credit ie interest rates.

One of the core failings within the uk is the failure to control the growth of credit in the economy. It is the excessive credit that funded the massive property inflation and has played it part in destabilising the banks.

Europe with a few exceptions like ireland have controlled the growth of personal debt within the economy. My point regrading the eu was the fact that the european central bank does consider the growth of the money supply which is rooted in monetarism where we have not.

Previous to monetarism was the keynesianism. This believed that to deal with levels of unemployment government should just spend money or/and tax cuts to boost aggregage demand. It failed in the uk when the idea of a trade of between inflation and unemployment showed both were growing (late 60s).

Allied to monetarism is supply side economics. The idea that to grow the economy and improve levels of employment you need to improve the competitiveness of the economy; investment, training, education etc to boost productivity growth etc, ofter tax cuts are seen as a way to improve the supply side.

29

Alan B,

14/05/2009 17:46:35

"the fact that the EU has accepted the euro doesn't mean it has a more clear monetarist approach"

the uk has a simple cpi inflation target the european central bank also targets cpi inflation but also considers the growth of the money supply (monetarism). The uk has not money supply targets and has encouraged uncontrolled growth in credit ie money supply.
30

GOODBYE LONDON LABOUR,

Aberdeen 14/05/2009 21:01:19
The Unionist twins, Labour and Tories, mired in London sleaze. Come on, Scotland, let's rid ourselves of these parasites.
31

connaughtboy,

stonehaven 15/05/2009 13:57:42
"Expenses row: Tory MP resigns as Cameron's aide"

but keeps his job as an MP. What a sacrifice!!
32

JCA REID,

Annan 16/05/2009 13:03:56
They'll "resign" from various positions they hold...but when will they resign from Parliament?

As the ABBA song says...."....it's the only game in town."
how these folk can walk in the public street with the feeling that is running through these lands it won't be for long that they are publicly attacked! They'll have to be transported to/from Westminster in armoured trucks!!

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.