Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Last flight of the hen harrier as killings leave just one pair alive in the east

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 15 November 2008
JUST one pair of adult hen harriers remains in the entire Lothian and Borders region, research has revealed.
It has been estimated the area's expanses of moorland should be able to home 50 pairs of the birds of prey.

However, this year just two nest sites have been occupied and of two pairs alive at the start of the year, just one now remains, accordin
g to a draft report by the Raptor Study Group.

Illegal persecution has widely been blamed for the drop in numbers.

There are currently about 800 pairs of hen harriers across the UK, the majority being found on the west coast of Scotland, where managed grouse moors are uncommon.

Robin Harper, Green MSP, has lodged a motion with the Scottish Parliament calling for the government to urgently investigate why the breeding population of hen harriers has collapsed in Lothian and Borders.

He is also asking for sufficient wildlife crime detection and enforcement resources to be provided throughout the country.

He told The Scotsman: "These depressing figures show the war on wildlife is continuing across Scotland, even when species are meant to be protected.

"It is clear that our defences are not just under pressure, they're down altogether."

He accused the SNP government of putting the self-interest of grouse shooters ahead of birds of prey, and of failing to act effectively on illegal poisoning and shooting.

Mr Harper said: "Last year I called for a review of the resources available to tackle wildlife crime in the full knowledge that they were insufficient.

"(Ministers must] make absolutely certain that our wildlife crime officers are given the support and encouragement that will allow them to do their jobs properly."

Keith Morton, investigations officer with RSPB Scotland, said hen harrier persecution is rife on grouse moors in the Lothian and Borders area.

He said: "Hen harriers are to all intents and purposes pretty much absent as a breeding species from eastern grouse moors. I don't think it's any secret that hen harriers get routinely removed illegally on grouse moors. Grouse moor owners are continually lobbying to be allowed to do it.

"It's been pretty much the situation for decades. The hen harriers were at one point excluded entirely from the Scottish mainland by illegal persecution."

One member of a group that studies raptors in the region, who did not want to be named, said hen harriers were constantly vanishing: "A pair of birds turn up and pair up and display and then disappear. It's happened again and again.

"The trouble is you can't actually prove it (that they are being persecuted]. It's very, very hard to catch them doing it."

Michael Russell, the environment minister, hit out at the perpetrators of wildlife crime. He said: "The Scottish Government believes that crimes against wildlife in general and birds of prey in particular are absolutely unacceptable and demand that all perpetrators are brought to justice for their disgraceful actions."

And he strongly rejected Mr Harper's accusations, saying: "Given that this is one of the issues on which I have been most vocal since taking office, to say that Scottish ministers have remained silent is completely untrue.

"It also devalues the collaborative and co-operative approach which is the only possible strategy to change behaviours.

"Alas, Robin Harper displays an untypical arrogance in running down the efforts of so many people who are determined to eliminate wildlife crime. Robin should stop squawking from the sidelines and join the fight."





The full article contains 593 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 14 November 2008 6:42 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Birds of prey
 
1

sergiesmax,

15/11/2008 08:48:52
Well its about time that private grouse moors came to an end in Scotland.We as a people should stand up to these bullys.March on there land during the shooting season in our hundreds to show them that we as a nation will not continue to sit back and let them destroy our national herritage,our wildlife Yes our wildlife.Why does one man need so much land and why does it have to be managed? Nature has done a verry good job by herself for millions of years let her do it again!!!!!!!!
2

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 15/11/2008 09:29:09
Maybe it is because there are private grouse moors in Scotland that they have been allowed to breed and survive.

#1 sergiemax

Are you recovering from last night or starting early with your "wee drams" because your posting is just a vitriolic rambling and babbling and incomprehensible nothing.

3

The wilkman,

Isle of Skye 15/11/2008 09:47:43
"""""2
TimW1234,
Ottawa, Canada 15/11/2008 09:29:09
Maybe it is because there are private grouse moors in Scotland that they have been allowed to breed and survive."""""

Not so.

A few decades ago they were surviving only in tiny numbers, mainly on Orkney and a few in the west, all and only in places without commercial grouse shooting.

The recovery had a lot to do with conifer afforrestation, the first few years of each new sitka plantation gave ideal conditions for breeding and hunting. This, and better law enforcement, allowed them to spread into areas where the grousemoor keepers had been getting rid of them.

New forestry planting has faltered in the last few years, the plantations are now too tall for hen harriers, and the poisoners have got bolder - or more deperate, the economics of grouse moors are not in good nick.
4

Douglas,

Bathgate 15/11/2008 15:01:24
"The trouble is you can't actually prove it (that they are being persecuted]. It's very, very hard to catch them doing it."

Maybe they just want to be as far away from trams as possible or, perish the thought, the environment doesn't suit so they move on leaving commentators scrabbling to keep their (paid?) positions.
5

yockel,

15/11/2008 16:30:21
You all know its about public access and the right to roam so stop whinging about grouse moors
6

sam the god,

15/11/2008 18:11:36
#6 yockel
you are right the countryside is awash with people that cause untold damage due to lack of knoledge about the countryside they think it is all right just to throw thier rubbish anywhere.
7

Endemoniada,

15/11/2008 18:39:09
Sam - missed you on Monday when the poisoned White-tailed Eagle was reported. Wonder why?

The people who cause untold damage to the countryside are those who think its alright to leave poisoned baits lying around to kill indiscriminately. Or perhaps those who deliberately and illegally wipe out some of our most magnificient wildlife so that they can maintain artificially high numbers of grouse or pheasants.

Hen harriers live and breed on moors, So do grouse. How come all the moors of eastern Scotland have grouse, but very few have successfully breeding harriers. Sam, please explain.....
8

sam the god,

16/11/2008 12:32:45
#7
as stated by yockel it is the public access that is affecting thier existance how come that before the right of access their were far more harriers so with more people wandering about where they please surley more of the so called posionings whould have been found? Do you think that keepers would put out posions knowing that there are far more people wandering about that might find it? get real and waken up to the facts.
9

Embaba,

scotland 16/11/2008 13:10:48
Sam the god,

when was the last time you were in the countryside? Almost all rubbish is agriculture rubbish caused by SOME lazy farmers and landowners, disguarding huge quantities of plastic, old wire fencing, etc.
Fewer people now believe the old 'you don,t understand the ways of the countryside' lies that people (including yourself)use to enable illegal practices to continue.

Poisoning, shooting of raptors , illegal traps are antisocial crimes ,no different to that of any other. The persons responsible should be dealt with accordingly.

A smashed window or stolen radio can be replaced the damage to the environment is not so easily repaired.

To allow Scotlands most fragile habitats to the hands of commercially driven, knuckle dragging apes.... the results speak for themselves!
10

sam the god,

16/11/2008 15:39:45
#9 Embaba

Well I took the last week off to create wildlife habitats on the farm that I go to we created two new duck ponds. With the wire that was left from re fencing (due to vandalism from these people that say it is there right to go into the countryside and do what they want) We used it to create natural field edges in other word grass and plants grow around it giving cover, breeding areas and food sources due to the insect life that are attracted to them. There was very little agricultural rubbish lying around unlike all the beer cans plastic carrier bags empty food bags . Yes some of us that have been used to the countryside since we were children care more for the environment than these people that use the right to roam. Where I go the countryside practices have not changed with the exception in the numbers of people using the countryside but what has changed is the reduction in wildlife. So how do you account for that?


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.