Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Drink Driving, Don't Risk It!

Aidan Smith | SPL2: just when you thought the league couldn't be worse

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 22 February 2009
IT'S OSCARS NIGHT and the frocks have all been hired and tried, returned and swapped, then checked and double-checked for exclusivity. Soon the red carpet will be rolled out and the winners' envelopes stuck down. But what's this? A late, late bid for nomination ... it's a sequel ... the original is still showing in some outlets but it's dire ... why, then, would anyone want to watch (cue flatulent fanfare) SPL2?
Before we go any further, let's be clear: we're not talking about Citizen Kane 2 or The Treasure Of The Sierra Madre 2 or Sunset Boulevard 2 or Duck Soup 2. We're not even talking about Police Academy 8. No, this is SPL2, a spin-off from the longest,
grimmest, stupidest league in all football.

You might remember the Scottish Premier League's proposals for a second tier; I'd almost forgotten about them. It was way back in August 2006 that they were contested by the other divisions – the Scottish Football League – and passed to an independent arbitration panel. Incredibly, it's taken two and a half years for the answer to come back that the proposals are permissible. I say "incredibly" but the panel was clearly working to SPL-time where everything is dragged out, especially the too small, too repetitive, too unintentionally hilarious (viz: the split), league season.

So what happens now? No-one is sure, exactly. The SPL will hold talks, and after a refresher course on what SPL2 was about in the first place, the top 12 will decide if they still want to go ahead with the wizard wheeze. The SFL will hold talks, too, but I'd seriously advise the small clubs to think long and hard before getting involved with anything that has the letters S, P and L in the title, and especially after last Sunday.

The Old Firm derby is the SPL's showpiece fixture. No, it's the SPL's reason for being. For completely self-serving reasons, the Glasgow supremacists wanted to play each other four times a season instead of two, and the rest of us had to lump it. To continue with the film analogy, Celtic v Rangers is the main feature, we're the B-movies, to which the correct audience response is chatting loudly and throwing food.

The latest Old Firm encounter was under some pressure to be more than half-decent. Our clubs had been booted out of Europe and the national side were struggling. Please Celtic, and please Rangers, deliver unto us a stormer so we can briefly forget about our miserable, credit-crunched existence! The Old Firm would have fancied they could rise to this challenge because modesty doesn't become them.

The build-up to the game was the usual considered hype. Former stars were wheeled out to talk it up. Giovanni van Bronckhorst – who left the mighty Rangers to play for some diddy team called Arsenal and then an even diddier one, Barcelona – was among them. He was extremely polite to his panting radio interviewer, but didn't quite convince me that his world stops whenever the Old Firm resume hostilities. Recently he'd been on holiday with Henrik Larsson. Did they – gasp – discuss the Old Firm? "No," confirmed Van Bronckhorst.

Then, the match. The anti-footballists vs Lee Naylor and chums. What a shocker! And what a week for that arbitration panel to, in effect, send out a ringing endorsement of the SPL brand! The decision was as well-timed as a Naylor tackle or – let's even this up – a Dirk Bigfoot attempted trap, first between toe and shin, then on to the back of the neck.

Even if the big clubs still fancy the SPL2 sequel, most of the smaller ones will miss out on the dubious stardust. If you think of the SPL as being like an ocean-going liner, winching down the lifeboats, then it will be Dundee and Dunfermline Athletic first, and stuff the rest. If I think of movies about big boats, then Titanic hoves into view. Of course that was a terrible film, directed by a lunatic.

This lunatic would save oor fitba by creating a top division of 18 teams playing each other twice. Of course, the Old Firm would never go for that – millionaires must always triumph over slumdogs. But on the evidence of last Sunday's "blockbuster", my old friend Bobby Williamson may be right: if you want entertainment, go to the cinema.





Page 1 of 1

 
1

Grimble,

The wastelands outside the SPL 22/02/2009 17:44:49
Okay dokey, how about a different view? The SPL 2 proposal might not be perfect, might not solve some current problems, and might create some problems of its own.... but surely it's better than the status quo? Scottish football is sustaining a smaller and smaller number of clubs capable of staying reliably in the current SPL - and those who drop out: the Livi's, Dundee's, Dunfermline's and St. Johnstone's of this world quickly become so impoverished that if they're then promoted they struggle, and quickly drop back down again.
The aim of any re-organisation should be to increase the pool of clubs who can thrive and make a real challenge for the Cup, for UEFA places etc (let's be honest, the Old Firm have the SPL sewn up till the end of time, or until they find an escape route).
It sounds very harsh, but is indisputably true, that the clubs from the lower end of Div 1 downwards are too small, too poorly resourced and have too small a fanbase to ever make it into the current SPL. If we don't identify the clubs which can realistically mount a challenge with a bit more dosh, and concentrate resources on helping them, then they plus the rest of the SFL will go down the toilet.... and probably much sooner than many people think.
2

AndyMacF,

Saltcoats 22/02/2009 21:21:38
No mention of the unsustainable debt being carried by clubs like Hearts, Kilmarnock, Rangers yet you talk about getting some SPL2 clubs some extra dosh. From where exactly? You say that "clubs from the lower end of Div 1 downwards are too small, too poorly resourced and have too small a fanbase to ever make it into the current SPL". Really? - there are at least 2 clubs in Division 2 (Raith and Ayr) plus all of the clubs in Division 1 who've all got a bigger fan base than one current SPL club (Hamilton). And it didn't stop Gretna getting to the promised land (how ironic, given what happened to them after one season in the SPL).

The thing that needs to happen in Scotland is back to two leagues of 18 with 2 up, 2 down plus play offs. That won't please the Greed League but there you go. We certainly don't need another SPL creation - afterall their record of innovation is appaling (the split, stadia criteria, winter break, etc etc). Yes, something has got to be better than the status quo but this certainly isn't it.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.