Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Students and faculty force Pope to cancel university visit

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 16 January 2008
POPE Benedict XVI has cancelled a scheduled speech at Rome's most prestigious university after protests by students and professors over the Church's views on science threatened to overshadow the event.
The protests had begun with a petition by 67 professors who portrayed the Pope as a backward theologian who put religion before science.

After resisting calls from protesters to scrap the visit to La Sapienza university, the Vatican said the Pope
had decided to postpone the trip.

It is the first time within living memory that a papal visit within Italy has been cancelled.

The protesters cited a speech the Pope gave nearly two decades ago, saying it showed he would have favoured the Church's 17th century heresy trial against Galileo for teaching that the Earth revolved around the Sun. The Pope's supporters denied that.

Opponents said they do not want the German-born pontiff at the university because he is "too reactionary" and they are against his views on abortion, homosexuality and medical research.

Professors from the medical faculty had signed a petition calling on the rector, Renato Guarini, to cancel the visit and they have been joined by hundreds of students.

Protest organisers had said that they would disrupt the visit by playing dance and garage music at full blast from huge speakers that went up outside the university.

Galileo infuriated the Vatican in the 17th Century with his theory that the Earth revolved around the Sun – contrary to Church teachings. He was tried for heresy as part of the inquisition by Pope Urban VIII and sentenced to house arrest.

Yesterday, in the wake of an occupation of the university by more than 300 students, Domenico Giani, the Vatican's chief of protection, held an emergency meeting with the rector and interior ministry officials.

One Vatican insider said: "The tension was getting too much and there were real security fears. It's amazing because the Pope has been to Turkey, which was considered even more dangerous.

"He went there in a bullet-proof car and wore a bullet-proof vest – yet he can't even visit a university in the centre of Rome."

The debate drew unusual allies for Pope Benedict. Dario Fo, a Nobel prize winner and an outspoken critic of the Church, defended the Pope's right to speak.

"I'm against any form of censorship because the right to (free] speech is sacred," the writer told the daily newspaper La Repubblica.

Some students staged a sit-in yesterday, occupying the offices of the chancellor. They declared an "anti-clerical" week and hung banners protesting against the Pope's visit.



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 15 January 2008 10:54 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Duncan in Edinburgh,

16/01/2008 08:34:25
This is fantastic. Of course, the Catholic church is not yet listening to reason, but it does finally appear to have realised that reason exists.
2

Lock,

16/01/2008 13:54:24
Bigots!

On a serious note though - could you imagine anyone tried to do what these students have done in Scotland?
3

Media 1,

cape town 16/01/2008 14:31:19
Well done to the students!
4

FLUB,

a rocky outcrop in eastern central Scotland 16/01/2008 16:00:00
Good.
5

Medicalmicro,

U.S.A. 16/01/2008 16:30:39
Is the Inquisition far behind ?
6

Hibee in Italy,

Florence 16/01/2008 16:54:23
Hmmm, I guess both sides have missed a chance of a wiser behaviour. The University of Rome managers should understand that Ratzinger's views on many sensible matters (esp. Church positions on Scientific Research) could sound like an offence in an Academic Year opening ceremony and maybe they could avoid to invite the Pope. This remarks another time again the deep distance of Italian managers and politicians from the people of the institutions they rule.
Nevertheless, I'm on Dario Fo's side: the right to free speech is sacred, even if sometimes is used with poor wisdom. Voltaire said "I agree not any word of what you say, but I'll fight to death for your right to speak." I think the students should let the Pope speak, as bad words immediately qualify who's speaking. If the students deny the Pope's right to speech he can act himself as a martyr.
Maybe the Vatican chiefs should reflect a bit more about it. The exceptionality of the event is not given by the students' behaviour but rather Ratzinger's one. Many other Popes visited the University of Rome and no one of them received such a treatment. Is it too much demanding their conscience to consider that Benedict XVI's positions on Scientific Research could have provoked such an obvious reaction?
7

Duncan in Edinburgh,

16/01/2008 17:35:34
#6 The Pope pulled out, the University didn't cancel, therefore to my mind there can be no complaint from Papa Ratzi. The Vatican took the decision because (very valid) protests were planned. So no-one has infringed his right to free speech - as if the Pope could possibly be infringed given that he runs his own theocratic state!
8

Duncan in Edinburgh,

Edinburgh 16/01/2008 18:08:28
#8 It's the rhythm method perfected...
9

Horrible Cankers..dans le Cyber Shebeen,

16/01/2008 19:42:07
Pious Interruptus....
10

Yankee girl,

USA 16/01/2008 20:00:22
Pious abstinence...
11

weeshooie1,

Australia 16/01/2008 20:10:18
HC #10,

Whit ah'd gie fur some interruptus.

Other #'s above,

Surely the students are exercising their own rights towards free speech in legally voicing their valid objection to the Papal visit? Perhaps the view's held by the current Pope two decades ago could also be construed as heresy. One must always move with the times or be forever trapped in antiquity.

Mind you, when it comes down to music, I'm afraid that I am guilty of being trapped also :o(
12

Calum Crubag,

16/01/2008 20:28:51
religion before science???!!!

If people listened to reason then there would be no religion.

I like the bit about Galileo. Whoever said that religion was backward?!!
13

Itchy,

16/01/2008 22:41:31
"The protests had begun with a petition by 67 professors who portrayed the Pope as a backward theologian who put religion before science."

That's his job, isn't it?

The Pope's views on economics are a load of b*llocks as well.
14

JV,

17/01/2008 07:44:18
It is clear to me, having read the comments posted on this site, that no one who has an opinion on this matter knows anything about the trial of Galileo or of Pope Benedict’s (then Cardinal Ratzinger’s) comments on the trial.
The Church asked Galileo to present his support of the Copernican system as a scientific hypothesis; to make scientific arguments only - not theological ones. This Galileo refused to do until he went on trial - for his theology, not his scientific observations. In fact, the Church supported Galileo when he first published his book, Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems.
Pope Benedict’s statement was that the Church’s policy of treating Galileo’s theory as a theory “remained more faithful to reason than Galileo himself,” because Galileo’s proof was not yet conclusive. By the way, these are not the pope’s own words. He was quoting Paul Feyerabend (1924-1994), a professor at the University of California, Berkeley.
At no point did Pope Benedict say that it was right to suppress science for the sake of theology or to persecute people for their beliefs.
It would be good if people got informed before forming opinions - isn’t that what they accuse the Church of doing?
15

digitalbutterfly,

Texas, USA 19/01/2008 20:13:32
Is this the same Italy that elected several members of the Communist Party to the Parliment? Communist Party members (every bit as murderous as Nazis) are allowed freedom of expression in Italy, but the Pope can't talk in public without intimidation?

The Church considers abortion, embryonic stem cell research, and euthanasia to be grave sins. Leftists can scream about it from now until the 2nd Coming, and the Church won't change.

Wouldn't it more productive for the Pro-Choice students to ask the Pope hard questions, to invite him or his representatives to a public debate, to publish an open-letter in Rome's newspapers?

But the Italian Leftists aren't really concerned with freedom of communication and ideas. Nor are they interested in reproductive freedom or the advance of science. They want abortion and euthanasia on demand as a form of population control. Socialism promises help to all people, then redefines "people" as those who need the least help. The system eliminates those who can't work or vote to support it.

Long live the rights to life, liberty, and property!

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.