Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Once upon a time, PC parents killed off fairytales

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 06 January 2009
PARENTS are rejecting traditional bedtime stories because they believe they are too scary or politically incorrect.
Children's fairytales are being phased out in favour of modern alternatives, as research published on a parenting website reveals one in four parents or carers has ditched old classics such as Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs and Rapunzel, in favour o
f The Very Hungry Caterpillar or The Gruffalo.

Snow White has fallen by the wayside because the Wicked Witch is deemed too frightening – but a handful will not read it because they feel the dwarf reference is not PC. One in ten politically correct parents even say Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs should be re-titled Snow White and the Seven Vertically Challenged People.

Rapunzel is also considered "too dark" and Cinderella has been dumped because she is forced to do the housework and sit on cinders.

The poll of 3,000 British parents, conducted by www.thebabywebsite.com, revealed that 66 per cent believe traditional fairytales have stronger morality messages than many of today's popular bedtime stories. But many parents feel this type of reading is inappropriate when the aim is to comfort children before bedtime.

A spokeswoman for the website said: "Fairytales take children to a land of make-believe where they can use their imaginations and where generally the goodies beat the baddies.

"Children love being read a variety of stories and it's a great shame that so many of today's PC mums and dads are rejecting fairytales which have stood the test of time, entertaining children for hundreds or thousands of years.''

The survey finds a third of parents will not read Little Red Riding Hood because she walks alone through woods and finds her grandmother has been eaten by a wolf.

And almost one in five adults says they have steered clear of Hansel and Gretel because its subjects are abandoned in a forest.

A fifth of parents don't like to tell their children about The Gingerbread Man as he gets eaten by a fox.

However, education experts say it is crucial that a child is introduced to darker aspects of life as a normal part of development. Sue Palmer, a child development expert and author of The Toxic Childhood, said: "Bedtime stories like these are an ancient custom.

"The world is not all brightness and light and children need to know that. An obvious one is 'don't talk to strangers', so they (parents] can't shield children completely from these things. These stories have been used throughout all cultures to help children get to grips with the world."

Julia Donaldson, author of The Gruffalo, which came third in a poll of the most popular children's books of 2008, says traditional stories continue to play an important role and she would hate to see them replaced because of political correctness.

"I think the stories that have lasted for generations have some resonance. They have something more powerful about them. I'm really against political correctness … it's so deadening. I would just choose a variety of books. The question is whether they are a good story or not."

A fifth of parents say fairytales are no longer politically correct, whilst 17 per cent worry the traditional stories will give their children nightmares.

It also emerged that 65 per cent of parents prefer to read their children gentler tales at bedtime, such as the Mr Men and Winnie-the-Pooh.

The most popular book read at bedtime is now The Very Hungry Caterpillar by Eric Carle.

The simple tale, of a greedy caterpillar eating too much food, was written in 1969.


HANSEL AND GRETEL: A tale of two hoodies who are given an asbo for throwing litter in the woods. The local press reports a "scene of destruction" after they are found with hundreds of discarded pizza boxes, leaving a trail of litter to their drug den. Things go from bad to worse when they start experimenting with psychedelic drugs at the "House of Sweets". They pull off a pensioner's front door, which they claim resembles a giant Liquorice Allsort.

PG rating: six. Warning: violent scenes, including decapitation of a jelly baby.

CINDERELLA: Cinders leave home in Romania in search of a better life, after answering an internet advert for a cleaner. Her dreams turn sour when she is forced to work 14 hours a day on the minimum wage. Her fairy godfather comes good with a ticket for the ball. The horse-drawn carriage is replaced as the council says the use of Shetland ponies breaches health-and-safety rules. Instead, she walks to the ball, raising £5,000 for charity and highlighting the problem of childhood obesity.

PG rating: eight. Warning: parents may find scenes of domestic servitude disturbing.

LITTLE RED RIDING HOOD: A teenager decides to visit her grandmother on the other side of town. It's far too dangerous to venture out alone – after all, she is only 14 – so she is accompanied by her parents who guide her through the woods.

Although they do see a Big Bad Wolf on the way, its owners complied with health and safety legislation and the animal is kept muzzled and on a leash. Grandma has a good innings and enjoys her final days in the Shady Pines retirement home.

PG rating: ten. Parents should have no worries about nightmares with this one.

RAPUNZEL: A beautiful maiden with long, blonde hair is trapped in a tower by an evil witch. With only her pet dog for company, she wiles away the hours brushing her golden locks. She had considered lowering her hair down and showing it off to a handsome prince. Sadly, braiding her golden hair and dangling it down to her hero would be too hazardous and may give children dangerous ideas. Rapunzel cuts it into a short bob and starves to death.

PG rating: two. Warning, not for those of a nervous disposition.

SNOW WHITE AND THE SEVEN DWARFS: Snow White is an idle teenager who spends all her days gazing in the mirror. Obsessed with her looks, she heads for London in search of a modelling contract. She finds work in Pantoland and stars in Snow White and the Seven Vertically Challenged People. After rave reviews the show is cancelled following complaints from the Disability Rights Commission. The commission threatens legal action after a number of tall men failed to get an audition.

PG rating: Seven. Not suitable for small children.



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 05 January 2009 9:56 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Dragonhead,

Dalian,China 06/01/2009 01:51:44
NO Fairy stories necessary, life in UK is now one big Fairy story.Besides parents are too bl***y idle to have any "quality time" with their offspring.Used by many only as BGU's BENEFIT GENERATING UNITS,to be ignored, deprived of love affection and left to fend for themselves. Fairy story? Sadly not,but reality in many parts of caring,sharing UK!
2

Angoos,

Baku, Azerbaijan 06/01/2009 05:22:18
Couldn't agree more #1. Sad, but generally true !!
3

donald,

glasgow 06/01/2009 07:06:27
How about the fairy story of Labour being a "socialist" party and "Scottish" Labour being a Scottish Party.

Stretching incredulity too far?

Crooked man on a crooked style is based on the crooked Unionist politician crossing Hadrian's wall.
4

Porry,

06/01/2009 08:14:33
Pixies and dwarfs of olden times that have been part of European imagination for centuries do not have anything in common with the 'vertically challenged' of the PC generation, perhaps with the exception that they are not much shorter than your average adult Pict. Therefore, how can respectable people be scary to anyone, especially to hundreds of thousands of children who consume 'Harry Potter' stories with the consent of their parents? Let alone all those ridiculous film sagas that show the 'greenhouse effect' in action, big waves eradicating cities as the expected consequence of global warming that hits within a few hours.
5

Chuck.U.Farley,

06/01/2009 08:17:40
#1.
And how would you know?,having deserted these shores years ago to become a PSB mouth (or is it ring)piece.
6

For Scotlands Future,

Vote for the SNP 06/01/2009 08:19:32
What about JKR's latest book? About the British Labour Party, ruled by Superhero Maggie Broon, being the only ones to be trusted to help the poor and needy in the country. So all the rich people give them millions of pounds and then are all totally surprised when King Gordy gives them a title.
7

,

06/01/2009 09:55:52
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
8

I should be studying,

Edinburgh 06/01/2009 10:09:57
wow. It never ceases to amaze me how people can comment on a story and completely go off topic and start having a rant about politicans and the Union. Get a grip people. Your comments may be valid, but not on this thread.
9

charlie25801,

USA 06/01/2009 11:24:20
OMG, what is this world coming to? Everytime I turn around I have to listen about something innocent being PC. I'm a preschool teacher and my children love the traditional fairytales. True, I sometimes alter some of the wording but overall there is nothing wrong with these stories that were read to me and I read to my children and grandchildren. Many of the fairytales have already been edited. When I read these tales to my children we dicuss the bad and the good. I read various versions of the same story, then let the children vote on their favorite tale. The gingerbread man is one of their favorite...for goodness sake he's a COOKIE who is suppose to be eaten! Red Riding Hood we discuss the importance of listening to parents and not to trust strangers, etc. Rapunzel...who the heck can grow hair that long? Chidren need to know fact from fiction. Give me a break. Read to your children and develop their trust in you, as a parent. Give time to discuss stories, whether they are these fairytales or not. That's why I don't have a TV in my room, I would rather read to the children whose parents won't and help them develop a love of books and reading. Give me a break!
10

AbandonAllHope,

06/01/2009 12:08:00
#1 Well its still better than the horror story of oppression and control of life that occurs in China.
11

Lianachan,

Highlands 06/01/2009 12:10:18
Fairytales? That's a VERY non-PC term. We should call them p00fstories.

There's a very amusing little book called "Politically Correct Bed-time Stories" which has ultra-PC versions of all the classics. Highly recommended!
12

Partan,

Fife 06/01/2009 13:37:09
My wife was brought up on German Childrens'Stories. If folk think Goldilocks & Co. are scary, they should have a keek at "Struwelpeter" or "Max & Moritz" (rewritten in Scots by J.K.Annand as "Dod and Davie").
13

Donnie Murdo,

Western Isles 06/01/2009 14:08:05
Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs. What else should it be?

Melintoninally challanged non male and an unaffiliated and independent grouping of vertically unabled non female persons?

Still draws the same picture.....1 white chick and 7 short men.
14

Robb,

06/01/2009 14:13:50
I reckon the findings of the survey might be more of a reflection on the types of parents who visit thebabywebsite than the majority of the population. The parents who are interested enough to read their kids bedtime stories will know that these stories are timeless and harmless. Generations of children have grown up with them. The babywebsite parents probably also advocate the use of Flashcards at age 3 months, brocolli smoothies, and spending time on the naughty step.
15

Donnie Murdo,

Western Isles 06/01/2009 14:16:40
14

Aye, and it's the same with the song Hokey Cokey. Harmless unless told/sang by racist bigots who tell thier kids the significance of the words.
16

Joe Macdelta.,

06/01/2009 15:05:35
#6 That book will never sell, too far fetched, nobody would ever believe it, good try though.
17

,

06/01/2009 16:31:59
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
18

Navvy,

06/01/2009 20:13:07
we are breeding a generation of complete wimps who will grow up (or will they) to watch over the final decline of a once proud nation.

Children shoul
19

Navvy,

06/01/2009 20:14:56
we are breeding a generation of complete wimps who will grow up (or will they) to watch over the final decline of a once proud nation.

Children should have the opportunity to learn not to gas or electrocute themselves bark their shins and graze their knees as I did
20

Dragonhead,

Dalian, China 07/01/2009 02:16:22
#5 and #10 Not the sharpest knives in the drawer are you?Typical 2volt brains with 9volt systems.
For your further edification oh! stunted ones:
In China children (like the elderly) are cossetted and revered.They are taught right from wrong and the whole family is involved in guiding and teaching them.Outside where I sit (weather permitting),there are families playing and looking after their younger and older family members.From Grandpa and Grandma down to babes in arms, laughing and having fun.
See the smartly dressed (blue and white tracksuited)children being TAKEN to school and brought back from school EVERY DAY by one or another of the family group.Straight to their homework, then they can chill out.Today being Wednesday they have a half day and so there will be sounds of laughter (and the odd firecracker, with the impending Chinese New Year approaching)with children being children.Skating on in-line skates and generally having fun. Sound like where you live????? As for being a communist mouthpiece, were you to utter those words to my ugly mug, I would educate you further in the Chinese arts!
China is turning out a generation of smart,intelligent and worldly wise children. Oh and they are even teaching them GOLF too! How about that numbnuts?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.