Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Fairytale not to be as Watson is denied historic win

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 20 July 2009
GOLF fans were on the edge of their seats, pinching themselves with disbelief. Even those not versed in the finer arts of the great game were caught up in the drama and knew something very special was happening.
It was 32 years ago that he won his famous "duel in the sun" with Jack Nicklaus at Turnberry – and here was Tom Watson, six weeks short of his 60th birthday, striding down the final fairway of the same Ayrshire course, and leading the field.

He had been at the top of the leader-board from day one and needed only a par to win his sixth Open and his first for 32 years – but as he was willed on by almost everyone, the steely nerves of the 59-year-old finally failed. Watson dropped a shot at the last and was forced into a play-off with fellow American Stewart Cink.

It was Cink who held his nerve to deny Watson the fairytale of another Turnberry win. He would also have been the oldest Open champion by 13 years; Old Tom Morris was a mere 46 when he won back in 1867.

It would not only have been a great moment in golf, but one of sport's great victories, yet it was not to be.

At about 7:30pm, one of the most remarkable championships ended as Cink lifted the claret jug.

He said of the experience: "Extraordinary just tips the iceberg. Playing against Tom Watson, this stuff just does not happen. I grew up watching him.

"My hat's off to Tom. He turned back the clock and did a great job, and it was fun watching you all week."

It was his 14ft birdie putt on the final green, however, that gave Cink his chance to deny Watson, who 30 minutes later bogeyed the same hole to join him on two under par.

"It's the most crucial putt I've ever struck in my life – just a sweet feeling," Cink said.

Despite a hip replacement last October – and odds of 2,500-1 to win the tournament – Watson started with a superb 65, which delighted his Scottish fans.

He followed that with a 70 on Friday and 71 on Saturday, which gave him a one-shot lead overnight before being overhauled early on Sunday by Britain's Ross Fisher – who fell away but managed to complete his round without his wife going into labour. He had said he would leave the course when her contractions started.

Fisher said: "He (Watson] is just a legend, a great player."

As all other challengers fell away – including England's Lee Westwood, who had looked good value at one stage – Watson had his destiny in his own hands. Yet he hit his approach to the 18th through the green and then three-putted from the fringe – his putt for victory from 8ft never threatened the hole.

Cink then won the play-off by six shots, playing the fifth, sixth, 17th and 18th in two under par as Watson stumbled to four over.

A win would have put Watson alongside Harry Vardon with a record six British Open titles, as well as becoming the oldest player to win a major championship – a record held by Julius Boros, who won the 1968 PGA Championship at 48.

Jack Nicklaus, who won the 1986 US Masters at the age of 46, was supporting his old rival throughout the tournament. He said: "I watched quite a bit, actually. Like everybody else … I had some tears in my eyes. What he has accomplished is a phenomenal achievement."

There was huge support for Watson and his calm, gentlemanly approach to the game, throughout the tournament – but it reached fever pitch yesterday. Away from the course, many who had backed him as his odds plunged over the days, were cheering him on.

In the end, the years caught up with Watson in the play-off. But Turnberry 2009 will be remembered not for his poor shots at the very end but for the way a great golfer rolled back the years over four days and 72 holes – and almost created one of the greatest ever sporting stories

AGE NO BARRIER

TOM Watson's attempt to become the oldest winner of a major golf championship was dashed, leaving the title with Julius Boros, who won the 1968 PGA Championship aged 48 years, four months and 18 days.

Other older sporting heroes include boxing legend George Foreman, who became the oldest man ever to win a major heavyweight title with a win in 1994 at the age of 45. He knocked out Michael Moorer, 26, in the tenth round.

His one-time rival Mohammed Ali, fought until the age of 39, losing his final fight, after ten rounds, to Trevor Berbick in 1981.

British 100m runner Linford Christie defied the odds by picking up gold at the Barcelona Olympic Games in 1992, aged 32. He took another gold two years later at the Victoria Commonwealth Games.

Tour de France champion Lance Armstrong has overcome cancer to try for his eighth victory in the race at the age of 37.

Italian Luigi Fagioli is the oldest winner of a Formula One Grand Prix. He was 53 years and 22 days old when he won the 1951 French Grand Prix.


Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 19 July 2009 9:31 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Scotaway,

Wanchai 20/07/2009 00:50:01
Tom Watson is an inspiration to his generation. So often people of our age are written of as being "past it". This will certainly put a spring in my step as I too approach my 60th!
2

Astarte,

Giffnock 20/07/2009 04:03:23
A true gentleman on the Links and off. I was rooting for him and I wept a little too. It may be that the Royal Bank of Scotland will strike a Five Pound Note to commemorate this man, after all they did it for Jack.
3

John Cameron,

St Andrews 20/07/2009 06:32:57
I felt rather sorry for Stewart Cink who is one of the nicest guys on the American tour. Nothing has ever came easy for him. He was at Georgia Tech at the same time as David Duval and, being two years younger, was very much in his shadow. However, after Duval graduated Cink battled on finally winning the Jack Nicklaus Award as the best college golfer in the USA in his last year. After turning professional, it took Cink years to get established but he is no bum. He has finished 3rd in the Masters, US Open, and the PGA and had played in the last four US Ryder Cup teams. He has earned some $28 million across the 13 years of his professional career and this "Major" win has been on the cards for some time. I thought his behaviour was absolutely impeccable. It cannot have been easy to have finally achieved your dream in front of a crowd most of whom hoped you would lose. He married his college sweetheart and it was nice to see that she and their two sons were present on his great day.
4

UrbanFox,

Edinburgh 20/07/2009 07:16:10
Oh Tom, why were you out there really? Five Open wins, sparkling career, golden memories to bask in, nothing to prove, and now you are destined to rerun that putt for the rest of your life, hoping this time it will go in. Why did I quit on it? Why didnt I chip the ball?

Whatever, you are an inspiration and example to us all.
5

Black Five,

edinburgh 20/07/2009 08:35:45
The saddest golfing experience I`ve ever witnessed.So sad he didn`t make it.Without doubt the cruelest of games.
6

Rev. S. Campbell,

Bath 20/07/2009 08:48:17
@3 "I felt rather sorry for Stewart Cink... He has earned some $28 million across the 13 years of his professional career"

The poor dear.
7

AJ Fife,

20/07/2009 09:31:26
What was really really really sad, was the fact that Cink turns out to be another American bible thumping sportsman!

8

Rednose Harry,

Wallasey 20/07/2009 09:41:20
#7 Which saddens you most?The fact that he's American,a Bible thumper or a Sportsman.
Get a life!!!
9

AJ Fife,

20/07/2009 09:48:45
Harry,

It's the bible thumping thing. Isn't it against the rules to seek outside help during a round?

10

Phil C,

20/07/2009 10:13:10
Yes, 'the thank you for showing me my faith' stuff was a bit crappy, but though unheralded and now unloved, Cink deserved his win. Shame he didn't read the script though.

Watson did the same to folk like Nicklaus all those years ago, and was unloved for it, so there's hope for Cink yet. He just has to keep the faith!
11

The Former Mr. Angry,

Perth 20/07/2009 10:14:57
An excellent competition and made worthier by Tom Watson's performance and grace in defeat.
12

Hmmm!!!!,

Edinburgh 20/07/2009 10:27:39
#6 Have to agree really sad to only win $28m during your 13 year career. You'd be lucky if my entire family of 13 over the course of their lives would earn anywhere near that. Was also sad that Tom didn't win. Once he messed up on 17 I turned off. Had to admit towards the end of the final round he was looking very tired and worn out and little wonder, the pressure of the whole crowd willing him on all the way round.
13

Kenny A,

20/07/2009 13:22:05
Who knows he may be back yet. Great stuff overall.
14

maintenancejason,

Pennsylvania 20/07/2009 14:38:59
Golf is a game that wastes too much land. Killing off the natural habitat for so many animals so that a bunch of grown men can hit a tiny ball with a metal stick and then walk after it? You should be ashamed of yourselves! Golf is about as much a sport as bowling.
15

JAL,

Green Bay 20/07/2009 15:04:19
Maintenancejason - you are an idiot!Look a bit closer and you'll see that golf courses create natural habitats more than any other sport.
16

maintenancejason,

Pennsylvania 20/07/2009 18:00:14
Wide open perfect green grass with jerk offs in little white golf carts are not exactly natural habitats. Dense forests with poison ivy and mud puddles, insects and snakes are where wildlife thrive. If your going to cut down all those trees for the purpose of man, why not build houses for the homeless on all that wasted land. Wasted land just so that rich people can "play" a little game. The game of football only takes 100 yards and is much more interesting.
17

Ann D,

Scotland 20/07/2009 19:55:43
Great tournament, missed Tiger, wonder if he will ever return to his best?.
Disappointed in Westwood, it was his for the taking, especially after that superb shot, how could he miss, obviously the pressure was too much for him.
Must admit, was taken aback at the bible bashing from Cink, Lehman was exactly the same, felt sorry for Watson, his face which is usually composed, and gives nothing away, showed us pain and despair on the 18th before teeing of, was edge of the seat stuff, looking forward to St Andrews.
18

Phil C,

20/07/2009 21:50:12
#16 'Maintenancejason - you are an idiot!Look a bit closer and you'll see that golf courses create natural habitats more than any other sport'
19

Josiecamp,

San Francisco 20/07/2009 22:20:35
#17 Ann D As an American I was ashamed and disgusted by the behaviour of Tiger Woods,he is lacking in ethics and humility by club throwing and swearing. From a family claiming a long line of golfers, including Byron Nelson,we were taught first to respect one's playing partner (did you know that there are no opponents in Golf) the Rules of Etiquette, which express the Rules of Golf and Respect for the golf course. Woods's fist waving in victory is an affront to all of the above and his habitual pouting and sulking is a mark of his immaturity. There is more to Golf than striking a ball.
Our newspaper here in San Francisco has called for his repromand and thousands of Americans agree as restribution for their shame. Are you sure that your intelligence is not being smothered by your hormones?
20

Ann D,

Scotland 21/07/2009 07:56:26
Josiecamp, not hormones, I have always admired Tiger, love his golf, obviously frustrated at Turnberry, his swing is not 100%, he knows that, all I have to say to you is, you have Tiger, who usually is immaculate in his play and demeanour, we have Monty, who, who, don't have time to write the long list of things he has done, would you like to swap, please swap Josie, I am begging you, I will purchase the plane tickets.
21

Josiecamp,

San Francisco 21/07/2009 10:18:28
Ann D, the fulcrum of sustainability in Tiger's game did not begin, or will it end, at Turnberry nor is it immune from asininity. Again,the point has escaped you, it has nothing to do with your idea of a 100% swing, a Utopian dream of every golfer, or the mood of frustration, it has to do with the Honorable Gentlemans' Game of Golf as first prescribed. I have conceded that Tiger Woods can strike a ball and gain remarkable scoring and entertain by presence, but he is not a Golfer to find a place in the annuls of ethics as his predecessors have etched their names Vardun,Cotton, Hogan,Nelson,Daly,Snead and Ward.
22

Ann D,

21/07/2009 21:14:57
You mistook my admiration Josiecamp, it was for the golfer, not the man, in the man I have no particular interest whatsoever, the golfer I admire, and no, the point did not escape me, I understood exactly your meaning. I cringe at the beating of clubs on the ground, I abhor the spitting, the first time I ever saw Tiger spitting, was at Carnoustie in 1999, standing near him, watching this, was appalling, I don't think I have ever seen a golfer spit before, most of the time he acts like a gentleman, and sometimes I find watching him very disagreeable, but his golf is mostly sublime.

I understand the Honourable Gentleman's game, I understand the etiquette of golf, I have played golf since I was knee high to a grasshopper, I grew up watching Sandy, Seve, the much loved and lost Payne Stewart, Nicklaus, Couples, Azinger, Crenshaw, Woosnam, Langer, Norman et al, actually it makes you wonder, how would Tiger play with these guys, I think they would most certainly have given him a run for his money.
23

Josiecamp,

San Francisco 22/07/2009 00:18:01
Ann D, this conversation has never been about your proficiency and I will credit that the concluding paragraph in your latest post was not meant to be patronizing. The dialogue is meant to allow for the difference in a split hairline, etiquette or habit. As a College player and later as an amateur Tiger Woods chose the latter to the detrement of his character and it has followed him as a professional. It is unfortunate that the didain of the critics in those early years went unchecked. His ego is now mainly fueled by shouting,ranting followers who are better suited to the bleachers in a baseball stadium and, unfortunately, it is for them he now performs.
24

Ann D,

Scotland 22/07/2009 08:11:44
Not patronizing at all Josiecamp, I write with honesty and from my heart.

25

Josiecamp,

San Francisco 22/07/2009 23:05:16
Ann.D, I have never been in doubt! I will be teeing-off in exactly one hour from now.I play in a standing foursome, all gals, and the guys at our CC named us the 4x4's, since we have a fixed Friday 4:00pm starting time. Then we have dinner around eight and do what golfers do, talk about our game. Very, very hot today so I may be tempted to take a cart although I prefer to walk. Must rush and have enjoyed our exchange. Have a nice summer. Josephine Campbell
26

Ann D,

Scotland. 23/07/2009 21:58:41
Sounds like bliss Josephine, my idea of a wonderful time, without the heat of course, red headed Scots don't do heat, anything over 20, and I am like a snowman in summer.
I very much enjoyed our exchanges, look forward to more of them.
You too have a great summer.
Ann.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.