Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


'Tescoland' fears over store's new branch plan

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 13 March 2009
TESCO is aiming to open its third store within one square mile in the Capital, sparking new "Tescoland" protests from traders and community leaders.
The supermarket chain has targeted a site on Picardy Place for a new Tesco Express and lodged a planning application with the city council.

It would be the third store in the immediate area, prompting fears the supermarket chain is swamping the ne
ighbourhood.

Similar fears sparked a concerted, but ultimately unsuccessful, protest against so-called "Tescoland" plans for a third store within two square miles in Craiglockhart two years ago.

A leaflet campaign has been mounted against the move amid fears it will damage the strong mix of independent shops in the area.

Tesco is in talks with the owners of the building which houses the Reid Bed Store, although the bed shop says it has no plans to move.

Local traders fear the extra competition, at a time when shops are suffering the twin effects of the recession and the tram works, could force some out of business.

They argue Tesco already dominates the area with an Express store on nearby Leith Walk and a superstore on Broughton Road.

Sharon Nugent, owner of the Narcissus flower shop on Broughton Street, said: "Broughton Street is a nice place to go shopping, with lots of individual shops.

"Most of them would lose some business if Tesco opened. However, in my experience, the council does not do much to help local businesses. I do not know if they will be concerned about us in this case."

Ben Raffles, assistant manager of Real Foods, on Broughton Street, stressed the area thrives on the number of independent shops.

He said: "I just think this end of town has suffered enough recently and there are already two Tescos nearby."

Leaflets circulating in the area are urging people to object to the planning application before next Friday's deadline.

They cite concerns about the traffic disruption and increased deliveries disturbing neighbours. Business competition is not considered a valid ground for objecting to a planning application.

Leith Walk councillor Angela Blacklock said she was concerned about the impact on the local independent shops.

She added: "It would be terrible to see this disappear for the sake of a supermarket."

A Tesco spokesman confirmed it was "in discussions with the landlord" of the building.

No-one at the Reid Bed Store was able to say how long it still had to run on its lease on the property, but a spokesman said: "Tesco approached us a while ago, but as far as we're concerned we are not closing.

"We have had no further discussions with them."





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 13 March 2009 10:48 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Tesco
 
1

MyricaGale,

Angus 13/03/2009 11:04:09
Thought we lived in Tescotland now - not Tescoland.

Our new national flag is the Tesco red, blue and white.

But remember "Every little helps" our new leader, Sir Terry Leahy, to become a multi- multi- multi- millionnaire and we must support him to make our new country strong.

Pity Alex Salmond and the Holyrood bunch haven't realised there has be a coup....

2

MyricaGale,

Angus 13/03/2009 11:05:06
..has been a coup.... (Must wear the right specs in future!)
3

alfonsa pedrosa,

embra 13/03/2009 12:24:58
Well done Tesco,they are excellent stores with great staff.
4

steve 1511,

aberdeen 13/03/2009 12:44:48
the more tescos the better,they have done more than any government could do to rid this nation of the wee manky vermin infested rundown corner shops who are only intrested in rip off prices,the good wee well run hygenic corner shops will survive,the poorly run manky
one will go to the wall,every community should have a tesco, i see their share price is on the up today a good sign for this forward thinking global company
5

elayne,

13/03/2009 13:33:49
tesco is ok,,pretty well stocked,my only complaint being,our local tesco is full of smelly people who cash their money on a monday,not very pleasant when one is browsing round the organic veg section
6

cm,

edinburgh 13/03/2009 13:37:46
T. Cipriani, comment 5. your comment scares me it, it is tesco that produces unnatural food. You are buying their food for looks rather than vitamins. how many pesticides and chemicals do you think it takes to makes every piece of fruit look the same.

7

Bill MacD,

13/03/2009 13:58:18
What chance is there of them being turned down, when it's well known that Tesco generously "supports" our impoverished Councillors on the right commttees. They ride roughshod over community interests, and let them away with outrageous infringements of the law. This corrupt company cares not a whit for anything but profits, and do whatever it takes to squeeze every penny out of local communities. Anyone who shops there is an idiot.
8

Logie Almond,

13/03/2009 14:01:14
Any planning application must be for the external appearance of the shop, signage etc since in planning terms a bed shop is the same use as a supermarket. Nor can planning authorities take any account of who the operator is for any particular premises, so the protesters are wasting their time.
9

Euphemia Groynes of that Ilk,

13/03/2009 14:15:41
How well I recall Tescoland as it was in the days of my girlhood, so long ago now, alas!
10

Leila,

Edinburgh 13/03/2009 14:21:25
Objecting to this application is pretty much a waste of time, because there are no material planning grounds on which to object, and something the story doesn't say is that these premises were already a Co-op store in the 1980s. Objecting on the grounds of "traffic disruption and increased deliveries disturbing neighbours" isn't convincing: this is Picardy Place, full of pubs, clubs, restaurants, a theatre and a cinema complex, not some quiet residential backwater. Also, the roads at Picardy Place will be reconfigured for the proposed tram/bus interchange which I think will be right outside the door (this may be Tesco's main motivation for wanting to locate there) and that will cause far more disruption that any Tesco Express.
11

PaulB,

Edinburgh 13/03/2009 14:41:49
Bring it on! Realfoods won't suffer because of Tesco - they have totally different customer bases. This used to be a min-mart before so can't see any problem. I intensely dislike people who jump on the anti-Tesco bandwagon - must be nice to have all day to visit individual shops for all your groceries - most of us live in the big bad real world and Tesco does the job!
12

upthehill,

Leith 13/03/2009 15:42:43
a Facebook group "keep stockbridge local" formed by the community council has joined up with the Broughton campaign, it's going on across the city/country...
13

Leila,

Edinburgh 13/03/2009 16:31:25
"Leaflets circulating in the area are urging people to object to the planning application before next Friday's deadline."

It's a pity the author isn't identified on the leaflets, because no one knows who it is "urging people to object". Is it a local resident? a local shopkeeper? a local community association? an anti-Tesco group? All these would have different agendas.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.