Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Red alert over release of 250 grey squirrels

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 02 January 2008
Government is encouraging the spread of grey squirrels in England, say worried campaigners
IN SCOTLAND, they are treated as an invading enemy – hunted down and killed to save our native red squirrels from extinction.

But, to the horror of campaigners for the reds, the government has licensed the release of more than 250 grey squirrels, which are originally from north America, back into the wild in England.

Now the European Squirrel Initiative (ESI), which obtained the figures, is warning the red "will soon become extinct in Britain" if its fate is left in the hands of government and calling for a volunteer army of "grey squirrel control groups" to be set up by country people.

However animal rights groups said if it was acceptable to release grey squirrels in England, the authorities should look at transporting – rather than killing – those caught in Scotland in order to "save the pointless killing of a perfectly healthy wild animal".

According to the Wildlife and Countryside Act, non-native, invasive species should not be released into the wild but this can be done if a licence is issued by the relevant authority, which is Natural England south of the Border.

Andrew Kendall, of the European Squirrel Initiative, said: "We've got a government agency whose job it is to protect the biodiversity of our countryside and what are they doing?

"What they are doing is seemingly making a political judgment, not a scientific judgement."

ESI used the Freedom of Information Act to discover that 257 grey squirrels had been released over an 18-month period.

However Ross Minett, campaigns director for Advocates for Animals, pointed out that red squirrel numbers were low because of persecution by humans.

"We don't believe it is acceptable to kill one species of squirrel in an attempt to try to conserve populations of another species of squirrel," he said.

"The squirrels are generally being killed by being bagged and bashed over the head with a piece of wood."

Dr Mairi Cole, of Scottish Natural Heritage, said it would not be possible to send Scotland's grey squirrels to England.

"It's just translocation of a non-native species, which is against any policy or sensible guidelines," she said.

"There's also the issue of squirrel pox virus. If you translocate there is a risk you would be introducing the disease to areas where it isn't currently."

Natural England said grey squirrels were not allowed to be released in areas close to red squirrel populations, including Northumberland and Cumbria on the Border with Scotland.

Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 01 January 2008 9:35 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Squirrels
 
1

JG,

Fife 02/01/2008 01:06:35
Oh well, let's hope the grey squirrels can read the "No entry" signs then. What a bunch of idiots these people are. The grey squirrels are American tree rats, the red squirrles are natives to this country.
2

Plodjfriss, Hammer of the Numpties,

Edinburgh 02/01/2008 01:34:06
This story isn't as informative as it might be. Where were these 257 squirrels before they were released? Were they in captivity for some reason? If so, where did they come from and who was looking after them? Why were they released?
3

Ross Fyffe,

Scotland 02/01/2008 01:48:46
# 2 exactly, this is ridiculous,

However Ross Minett, campaigns director for Advocates for Animals, pointed out that red squirrel numbers were low because of persecution by humans.

I don't think so
4

Lanna,

02/01/2008 03:33:23
#1 JG
well, we all know, that those deported and illegal in the first place have no respect for the border nor its signs!
5

weeshooie1,

Australia 02/01/2008 04:15:16
Lanna #5,

A bit tongue in cheek there Lanna :o)
6

Boy Wonder,

02/01/2008 04:53:57
#4. News4u ... I can tell you that the weasels have set themselves up at Westminster by the score!
7

Boy Wonder,

02/01/2008 04:54:29
(Walked into that didn't you!)
8

Mercutio,

FALKIRK 02/01/2008 06:47:15
That's a STOATer
9

Geoff,

South Africa 02/01/2008 08:51:42
I am amazed that a first world country like the United kingdom can be so backward when it comes to matters environmental. What an incredibly stupid move-to release an invasive alien that is known to outcompete its indigenous cousin! We are behind Europe in many fields but when it comes to the environment, South Africa is light years ahead of you guys. A case in point-we spent much time and money eliminating the Himalayan Tahr from Table Mountain as it ws a known threat to the vegetation and indigenous mammal species notwithstanding opposition from"bunny huggers". In addition our Government are spending huge sums in the fight against alien plant invaders. We dont have the same prob with alien mammals as we have some super efficient predators here!
10

Geoff,

sa 02/01/2008 08:55:47
Had another read of the above-awesome ignorance-unbelievable!! Like releasing more Rabbits in to Australia.
10 Nomada-hits the nail on the head"...understanding of ecology is zero!" That about sums it up!
11

Geoff,

02/01/2008 09:07:09
1 and 3 JG and Ross-good posts. Human predation is probably the least important factor. Habitat loss and competition from the bigger Grey squirrel are the main reasons for the decline of the Red Squirrel
12

Beth Boyle,

Rural New York 02/01/2008 09:21:48
Send the varments back over here to North America and I will make some squirrel soup! They are pests even here when not kept in check they are horrible in some cities. 250 squirrels are a nightmare.
13

ignorant townie?,

Scotland 02/01/2008 09:39:54
Agree its daft to release greys back to wild anywhere in Britain...[and by the way, these will have been abandoned or orphaned young, hand-reared, or injured animals] ...this is an obvious case of a government agency afraid of losing popular support...

but I continue to despair about the "tree rat" comments....this is "give a dog a bad name" territory....or that disgusting word "vermin". Used whenever someone needs an excuse to kill any living creature. All animals should be given some dignity - from rats to whales.

Im sure red squirrels were referred to as "tree rats" or worse, by those who slaughtered them by the tens of thousands during the first half of the 20th century, [all on record with bounties paid] in the Highlands of Scotland and elsewhere...because of alleged damage to commercial forestry.

This is the wildlife equivalent of racism...give a species an ugly nickname and that makes it easier to justify persecution.Take a look at yourselves!!..

Oh yes...why are there so few weasels...well, one place to look would be the industrial scale trapping that takes place anywhere near a partridge or pheasant shoot....although Im sure a lack of mice and voles due to farming methods will be to "blame" also.
14

Chris,

Edinburgh 02/01/2008 11:10:19
Ross Minett says: "The squirrels are generally being killed by being bagged and bashed over the head with a piece of wood." By whom? What evidence do you have?
The man needs a reality check.
15

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 02/01/2008 11:32:58
#11 Geoff, said,:

"I am amazed that a first world country like the United kingdom can be so backward when it comes to matters environmental."

You are right to be amazed Geoff: many of us living here in this benighted country are amazed as well! Attitudes in many other countries in Europe are also streets ahead of the UK as well. It's good that SA is doing well.

There is a possibility that one of our own native "super efficient predators" may also help in protecting the red squirrel: there are signs that the pine marten may predate grey squirrels, but not (so much) reds. Unfortunately, this "first world country" also just about wiped out the pine marten, and they are only recently recovering from their last redoubt in the NW Highlands to come to into contact with greys. See
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/earth/main.jhtml;jsessionid=JEWVX2A2K2ZJHQFIQMFSFGGAVCBQ0IV0?xml=/earth/2007/12/30/eapinemartin130.xml

A similar thing appears to be happening with the native otter (that was also almost driven to extinction by persecution, habitat destruction and pollution) that is now taking on the American mink (the mink were released in their thousands from fur farms by misguided fools from the animal liberation movement)

16

OscarMacApfel,

Dumfries 02/01/2008 11:44:08
Who are these squirrel bashers?

Where can one purchase a squirrel bashing sack?

Gobsmacked that the European Squirrel Initiative actually exists.

Here in the sticks of Dumfropolis a daily delight is watching red squirrels lollop around in the garden,well until we let the cats out.
17

Geoff,

sa 02/01/2008 12:12:38
.14 Beth boyle-Happy New Year Beth!Even in their native habitat indigenous species can become invasive-this is normally due to the absence of some recently extinct plant or mammal that either preyed on the species in question or had a symbiotic or other relationship with the organism . Local example-we have a forest pioneer in our grasslands that is normally browsed by black rhino and buffalo but these are now only found in one small reserve in the City so this plant has become a prob..In the case of your Grey squirell there is obviously some missing predator or an abundance of food/habitat left by some other locally extinct competitors niche that has caused numbers to explode. Also in nature there are some species whose cycle is boom-bust. Lemmings for example!
17 Slioch-thanks for your interesting comments. Happy New Year. Pine Marten is an incredible little creature-reminds me of our local Honey Badger which is a larger and fiercer version of its Northern hemisphere cousins. We also have two otter species locally-the Cape and spotted neck and a Water Mongoose that occupies a similar habitat.
18

Douglas,

Bathgate 02/01/2008 13:07:57
#18 Oscar: They're available on the internut. Check out eDrey. :o)
19

Unimpressed one,

02/01/2008 13:09:08
#17 Slioch, entirely agree with you on this issue. The latest stupidity by the animal rights idiots was to release 100 wild boars from a farm in England. The destruction caused to our native wildlife by introduced and released vermin such as mink and grey squirrel is incalculable. As for Ross Minett, don't get me started....
20

Lora ,

Cleveland 02/01/2008 13:17:21
Why on earth do they have to be killed by skull smashing? In this day, why can we not give them a painless injection? Just because they aren't a cat or do they don't qualify to feel pain?

I understand why they can not be transported and why protecting Scottish red squirrels is important. Why be barbaric and cruel?
21

Dumb Eye @,

02/01/2008 14:11:56
While we're on the subject of invasive non-native species, can we have a campaign to rid the country of rabbits?
22

ignorant townie?,

Scotland 02/01/2008 15:00:20
One of the more sensible discussions going on here for a change!

but...a couple of factual errors needing pointing out..re grey squirrels, these arent all over the UK because some animal rights protestor let them go..they were introduced by landowners who thought they would look nice on their estates and in their parks

re mink...although undoubtedly some have been let out by animal rights people [an act of vandalism and stupidity but at least with a motive of pity for appallingly unnatural caging] the majority are the progeny of animals which escaped from fur farms which were poorly maintained or were deliberately released by the owners when such farms went bust...

these arent simple issues...we have to clear up the mess weve made but lets do it in a civilsed and humane fashion...and for gods sake, stop letting go plants and animals in places where they dont belong...[I of course included hedgehogs in that plea]
23

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 02/01/2008 16:23:28
#25 ignorant townie

Agree with your comments in #25.
24

Angus,

Alexandria 02/01/2008 17:35:46
They were quite right to release the grey squirrels rather than kill them or keep them in captivity for the rest of their lives. They are interesting, amusing and friendly little animals and should be left in peace without persecution.

Also, Ross Minett is quite right. We should not be acting like some kind of God by killing members of one species to enhance the prospect of others.

If you want to read more about grey squirrels, Google "Professor Acorn" to find his website.


25

ignorant townie?,

02/01/2008 18:39:42
Angus of Alexandria says...

"Also, Ross Minett is quite right. We should not be acting like some kind of God by killing members of one species to enhance the prospect of others."

Doesnt it occur to you that you are acting as some sort of God in taking them out of the wild in the first place...and then choosing, no doubt in a god like fashion, as to where and when you release them..

or are the grey squirrels, like Douglas Adam's white mice, actually running everything and telling you what to do?

in which case Methalions, the squirrel cooker, is in for a spot of bother when they catch him...
26

WL,

livingston 02/01/2008 20:17:49
The only way to solve this problem with grey squirrels (and protect the native red squirrels) in Scotland is to kill all grey squirrels.
27

sam the god,

02/01/2008 20:41:07
#30 wl

could not agree more get rid of these vermin
28

yoric,

02/01/2008 22:34:19
Why should we kill the Grey Squirrel, that we have all become so familiar with, just to keep alive the myth of the Red Squirrel, that virtually no one anywhere has ever seen.
If we kill all the Grey Squirrel we just dont see anymore Squirrel, we wont see Reds everywhere, we just wont see any Squirrels anywhere.
29

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 02/01/2008 23:41:06
#32 yoric

Actually, some of us, myself included, are lucky enough to see red squirrels every day. But the main answer is that, even if the whole of the UK were to be suddenly cleared of grey squirrels, the reds would rapidly re-colonise, particularly if re-introductions were made to create many "islands" from which the reds could spread. But that won't happen: the best we can hope for is that the greys will be removed from the front line, so as to allow the reds to move forwards. Thus a shrinking grey area would be gradually replaced by a growing red area. There would still be plenty of squirrels.
30

Lanna,

03/01/2008 01:21:20
#28 Methalions,
haha..I see ya've been in Appalachia recently; have some hillbilly cousins, do ya!! ;)
31

MaxVoltz,

Perth 12/01/2008 00:40:26
I thought we had laws to stop illegal release of non-indigenous species.
When i went ferreting and lost one i had to report its loss to the police as it was not indigenous
32

Wildlife Ranger,

Wales, UK 21/01/2008 12:03:35
The Welsh Assembly Government has also been licensing release of grey squirrels, within red squirrel populations, as part of a 'research' program, despite the fact that there are only a few hundred red squirrels left. This questionable 'research' has also been undertaken in other areas of Britain where greys are invading red populations. It is to be hoped that this will not be sanctioned again, as the risk of disease transmission is very real, and the data obtained dubious in the extreme. It is an act of supreme irresponsibility to undertake such 'research'.
Wales has the honour of holding a remnant red squirrel population on Anglesey that was saved from imminent extinction by the removal of grey squirrels in 1998/99, and there is now an ongoing reintroduction program underway.
The killing of grey squirrels by a blow to the head is a method approved by the RSPCA. It may be unpleasant, but it is not cruel; it is quick and efficient, and by far the simplest and most humane way to despatch them.
As for 'Professor Acorn', this website is run by a simple-minded idiot who is either unable to accept that grey squirrels are systematically replacing red squirrels by out-competing them, or more likely doesn't care. Stating that red squirrels will become immune to Squirrel Pox virus is insane, as it is lethal to all red squirrels. The only way red squirrels will survive is if grey squirrels are kept at bay, thereby preventing the grey squirrels out-competing the reds, and preventing transmission of disease from greys to reds.
Red squirrels will quite happily live in our countryside, provided they have trees and hedgerows, so long as they don't meet grey squirrels. If we don't stop the march of invading grey squirrels, the reds will simply become extinct in Britain and Ireland.
Of course, in Europe the red squirrel is safe and widespread, but grey squirrels have been introduced to Italy, so when they get through the Alps they can happily invade the whole of Europe, replaci
33

Wildlife Ranger,

Wales, UK 21/01/2008 12:05:29
ng the native squirrels as they go.
The total extinction of the red squirrel on the British and Irish mainlands is very likely, unless enough is done to stop the greys (which is, sadly, unlikely). The extinction of red squirrels throughout Europe is also possible in the future - that would mean global extinction for the red squirrel (what would Beatrix Potter have to say about that??).
Read about the Anglesey red squirrels at www.redsquirrels.info

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.