Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Hideouts give red squirrels a chance of surviving the grey invasion

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 03 November 2008
NEW tactics are to be implemented in the battle to save one of Scotland's most treasured native animals from a growing army of its invading American cousins.
Grey squirrels, carrying a deadly pox, are advancing ever further into Scotland, putting the survival of native red squirrels at risk.

Despite sustained efforts to cull the greys in the UK – with 20,000 killed in Northumberland alone – the animals have continued to spread, with the first spotted in the Highlands earlier this year.

Now protective forest strongholds are to be created across the country where the smaller, native red squirrels can hide and live in safety. About 20 red squirrel refuges will be established by Forestry Commission Scotland, covering 80,000 hectares.

The list of areas, which has not yet been finalised, is likely to include a woodland site on Arran, which, as an island, will afford the red squirrels extra protection.

Grey squirrels, originally from America, drive the smaller red squirrels out of their native habitats by eating all the food. They also carry squirrel pox, which leaves them unaffected but is lethal to the reds.

Jo Ellis, who is heading the programme at Forestry Commission Scotland, said culling greys must not be the only tactic to protect reds.

"The stronghold approach is an insurance policy in a way," she said.

"We don't want them to only live in these places, but it's about trying to give reds places where they can thrive.

"It doesn't mean we are giving up on grey-squirrel control but if we just try and cull grey squirrels and that doesn't work, then reds will have very little chance."

The chosen areas of forests will be heavily planted with conifer trees. Mrs Ellis said: "In these forests reds seem to be able to thrive but greys don't go there.

"They are not interested. They are going to be so unfriendly to a grey squirrel that they won't want to be there."

Ironically, more conifer forests will have to be planted to provide for the native animal. Grey squirrels prefer the broad-leafed trees, such as oak, chestnut and beech that typify Scotland's native woodlands.

Dr Mairi Cole, red squirrel advisor at Scottish Natural Heritage, supports the procedure.

She said: "Everyone wants to use grey control as the main tactic but that's not the backbone of a sustainable strategy. This has to be done as well, as an insurance policy."

Meanwhile, Scottish Natural Heritage is preparing to apply to the Scottish Government for about £1.3 million to carry out a three-year study to find out how effective culling grey squirrels is likely to be in the fight to save the reds. There is currently little evidence to show whether this approach will work, and some groups, such as Advocates for Animals, think it will be futile.

Ms Cole said: "The anecdotal evidence shows that if you take greys out at significant levels then it works, but we want the evidence to show that. However, if it takes an awful lot of effort to get a few grey squirrels and the reds don't respond, then we have to make a decision as to whether it's a beneficial thing to do."

IN NUMBERS

5 million
Grey squirrels in the UK.

120,000
Red squirrels in the UK.

75
Percentage of the UK's red squirrels that live in Scotland.

15
Number of days it takes a red squirrel with pox to die.

530 grams
Weight of a grey squirrel.

300 grams
Weight of a red squirrel.

Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 02 November 2008 9:16 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Squirrels
 
1

Finlang,

Switzerland 03/11/2008 00:26:30
They're not exactly "cousins", but never mind. I saw one of the grey invaders last year in my native part of Scotland. A couple of miles away from a red squirrel habitat known to me and half a dozen others.

The "20,000 killed in Northumberland alone" tells its own story. Greys are unwanted and unloved in Scotland and England. When I lived in Florida our fruit trees were plagued big time from this oversized species. Waging war with a shovel was a waste of effort. Elimination by sterilization might be the humane method.
2

Ninian Reid,

Edinburgh 03/11/2008 06:15:24
Am I completely alone in thinking grey squirrels are pretty cute also ? I find the discrimination against them both puzzling and a trifle disturbing.Ethnic cleansing? Anti-American ?
3

Dave,

Western Isles 03/11/2008 07:43:16
Squirrel Abuse, there's no Excuse!
4

Sioux Man Chu,

03/11/2008 07:57:40
~2 - No you're not, I also find the greys cute. I'm all for finding a solution where both species can live in peaceful co-existence. However the greys must be made of sterner stuff than the reds!
5

Dave,

Western Isles 03/11/2008 08:05:06
2 + 4

Do you know what more than decimated the Easter Island population way back then? Visitors carrying disease that the locals had no immunity to.

Same difference here.

the Red squirrel is the epitomy of Scotland. Wee, ginger and the sick man of Europe!
6

Douglas,

Bathgate 03/11/2008 08:26:48
Red squirrel, grey squirrel, it's all just nuts.

7

Sioux Man Chu,

03/11/2008 08:45:58
Dave - thought that was because they cut down all of the trees to roll their stone heads hither and yon?
8

Boy Wonder,

03/11/2008 08:50:24
Death to all greys!
9

Dave,

Western Isles 03/11/2008 08:53:35
Sioux Man Chu,

Not sure if you are talking about the Easter Islanders or the Scottish there! ;-)
10

Ananurhing,

03/11/2008 09:00:16
Apparently the greys are good to eat. Maybe SNH should publish a recipe book. Get Gordon Ramsay to give demonstrations in Edinburgh's Botanic Gardens. Or have a "pick your own" policy and free BBQs in parks. The looming hoards of unemployed financial services workers would soon wipe them out.
Crispy squirrel anyone?
11

sam the god,

03/11/2008 09:05:47
I was out at the weekend and gave a few of them the good news. I cannot wait for the leaves to come off the trees makes hosing them down far easier time we had a bounty on them.
12

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 03/11/2008 09:07:46
Two agencies, The Forestry Commission and Scottish Natural Heritage, and two agendas. Neither agency has as its prime concern the protection of red squirrels.

The Forestry Commission wants to continue to do what it likes doing best: ploughing and draining the land and creating dense plantations of exotic conifers. The peril of the red squirrel is a convenient smokescreen for business as usual.

Scottish Natural Heritage wants to continue to do the only thing it dares to do: keeping its head down, not causing controversy, not standing up for any aspect of Scotland's natural heritage, not saying boo! to a goose or even a grey squirrel. And if something awful happens, like an apparently successful way of protecting some aspect of our natural heritage that will cause dissent amongst the nincompoops and cuddly animal brigade, then bunker down and call for more research. That is what Mairi Cole is doing, no doubt on instruction from above: the Andrew Thin effect.

The awful thing that has happened is this: just two men and an army of enthusiastic volunteers, working with a grant of just £148,000, have in the last year or so killed twenty thousand grey squirrels in Northumberland, where they are now almost eradicated. They are now moving south into County Durham.
see:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2008/jun/25/conservation
http://www.yorkshirepost.co.uk/country-view/Squirrel-cull-could-extend-.4629110.jp
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/earth/main.jhtml?xml=/earth/2008/08/10/easquirrel110.xml

So, what is SNH's response? To spend nearly ten times as much (£1.3million) over three years "to find out how effective culling grey squirrels is likely to be in the fight to save the reds." In other words, kick the problem into the long grass and do nothing, whilst ensuring the funds keep rolling in. Meanwhile, SNH does not even object to planning applications for housing estates in native pinewood that are the last stronghold of the red squirrel in Scotland.

Are
13

Ananurhing,

03/11/2008 09:12:39
Magpies are also spreading over the country, and they will chase out reds and greys. I wonder if SNH have thought of that. I have a family of reds around the house. Magpies have been spotted within 20 miles of here for the first time.
You can imagine a situation where the "grey" problem is eradicated, only to have magpies finish off the poor reds.
Remember we're talking about a govt agency here. Not known for joined up thinking!
14

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 03/11/2008 09:52:46
Contd. from #12


Are you listening, Environment Minister, Mike Russell?

You've made a good start in your new(ish) job. For the first time that I can remember we actually seem to have an environment minister who cares about the environment. So, Mr Russell, are you going to pick up SNH by its scrawny chicken's neck and give it a good
shake to rid it of its wormtongues (you should know who they are by now) and tell it to start employing people of integrity and courage as well as scientific rigour?

And specifically, are you, Mr Russell, going to throw this pathetic excuse for inaction back in SNH's face and tell it to come up with a plan for the eradication of the grey squirrel from Scotland that takes as read the indubitable success of the Northumberland action?

Do that, Mr Russell, and we could be free of this pest in five years. And you would have earned the respect and gratitude of every tufty in the land. As well as a few of their real human friends.
15

Sioux Man Chu,

03/11/2008 09:53:29
Quite clearly nothing can and should be done until Charles Linskaill has issued his edict on this matter!
16

WL,

livingston 03/11/2008 10:06:13
#2
Ethnic cleansing indeed, by the grey squirrel.
The grey squirrel should be eliminated from Scotland sothat the red squirrel can be saved.
17

hertscot,

03/11/2008 10:17:42
If the red squirrels want to avoid being eliminated by its' US 'cousin', they should ask Osama Bin Laden.
18

Navvy,

03/11/2008 10:42:28
148,000 to kill 20,000!

There are people outthere who will pay for a day's squirrel shooting
19

Miss Pixie,

formerly of Dinleyhaughfoot Cottage, Roxburghshire 03/11/2008 11:51:44
Canada has grey squirrels as well. Why not point the finger at them? Better still, just to be fair, point the finger at North America?

I adore all squirrels but the greys must be eliminated in the UK! They do not belong and their continued presence is killing off the native reds.
20

57vintage,

Bridge of Don 03/11/2008 11:59:39
#10 "Apparently the greys are good to eat."

Did you not see Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall's fine programme on C4 last week.

Trapped a bagful of the blighters and served them up to his guests.

"Very gamey" accoring to anecdote.
21

donald anderson it's me,

03/11/2008 12:00:05
Is Ian Grey squirrel extinct?
22

57vintage,

Keith 03/11/2008 12:23:01
#21

Well, in line with his other Labour colleagues, he's certainly not red. Not any more.
23

sam the god,

03/11/2008 13:20:54
#20 57vintage
yes they are very tasty eaten quite a few of them in the past also good to train youngsters to the shooting game
24

Natureman,

Linlithgow 03/11/2008 13:35:08
Please can article authors and corespondents have a reality check?
1.Greys do NOT kill reds by aggressive activities! (Yes, they are are aggressive to each other, especially in parkland where stupid humans feed them artificially and they become overcrowded))
2.Greys do NOT eliminate reds by eating their food!
(greys are scavengers, furry tailed rats, if you like and therfore eat just about anything; reds are highly selective feeders)
3.Reds live in coniferous woodland , greys in broadleaf woodland so they do not meet. HUMANS have destroyed the natural environment of the reds and allowed the greys, who being more adaptable in feeding & nesting can multiply in our semi-urban world. Reds are specialist animals with specialist needs.
4.Yes, greys carry squirrelpox- lethal to (most) reds who lack relevant immunity. Greys also carry a variety of organisms of public health interest to humans. You ever get bitten by a grey, go to A & E, like NOW. Ditto rats, foxes, dogs, bears etc etc etc
5.Alien species are successful because they are ALIEN!- Rabbits in UK, Europe, Australia etc, Japanese knot weed just about anywhere, HIV in humans, just about anywhere.
6. Squirrel recipies available on-line- just ask Google.
OK? Any more problems?
25

Northumbrian Squirrel,

Northumberland 03/11/2008 14:08:11
20,000 dead in Northumberland??? Don't make me laugh - don't believe everything you read in the press just because the claims are made by some chap with a title.

Those of us living here know the reality is very different - more grey squirrels being seen further north than ever before, and more cases of squirrelpox.

There's been no proof that the figures are true - and claims in the press that Northumberland is clear of grey squirrels are, quite frankly, bowlucks.

Easy enough to kill lots of grey squirrels when you're trapping them in areas which are saturated, and where no-one has seen a red squirrel for about 5 years. Much harder when you're up country - and the success rate there is much lower (or so I hear from people in those parts).
26

Jacqueline Hyde ,

On the shelf 03/11/2008 14:11:49
#24
Yes.

What about the effect that Greys have on woodland birds - especially woodpeckers and owls? They are voracious egg raiders.

But (as you seem to be an authority) is there any documented evidence of interbreeding between Reds and Greys? I used to live in an area where Greys moved in on a once large population of Reds. The Reds all but disappeared but, after a few years, so did the pure Greys. All the squirrels in the area were by then a greyish red (or reddish grey) and unlike any that I've seen anywhere else. They had the traditional white bib and very sparsely bushed tails.
27

Natureman,

03/11/2008 14:42:35
#26
Yes, greys being omnivorous and scavengers will take any birds eggs available to them.
Interbreeding? I do not know of any evidence in either direction, but it seems highly unlikely since they very rarely actually meet physically. More likely explanation is that greys have a variable genetic background, typical of adaptable species (which is exactly why they are adaptable!) and that coat colour is simply another example of that variability. Reddish tinting in greys is pretty common, again especially in urban animals (or have we just seen more urban examples?). Their tail bushiness, being more structural than superficial colouration, is a better indication of their species identification as grey.
All invading species have interesting ecological genetics.
28

Geoff,

sa 03/11/2008 15:01:05
2 Ninian reid- there cuteness is not an issue. The issue is 5 million versus 120 000 with the former alien species threatening the latter with extinction.
29

Geoff,

sa 03/11/2008 15:05:42
4 Su man-they can not live in peaceful coexistence. The Grey outcompetes the Red-alien invasives are a threat worldwide and if left unchecked, leads to massive loss of diversity where alien plants/mammals/insects outcompete natives normally due to a lack of natural controls in their new habitats. When for eg cats and rats are introduced to small islands, native fauna-particularly birds, are exterminated
30

Northumbrian Squirrel,

Northumberland 03/11/2008 16:48:21
Sadly greys and red do not have any chance of living in peaceful co-existence for one reason - the squirrelpox virus.
Grey squirrels carry the virus with no external or internal symptoms - in fact it has no more effect than the common cold. However, when a red squirrel comes into contact with an infected grey, the red will be dead within 2 weeks. And it is a horrible and painful way to die.
Red squirrels are lost from the environment between 17 and 25 times quicker in areas where grey squirrels carry squirrelpox - and there is scientific proof that grey squirrels transmit squirrelpox virus to red squirrels.
At the last count, around 80% of all greys tested in Northumberland were "seropositive", in other words carrying the virus - and all it takes is one infected grey to start an epidemic of horrific proportions - google red squirrels and Formby if you want to see how bad it gets.

Sadly, despite the claims of clearing Northumberland of grey squirrels, there has been continued outbreaks of squirrelpox in at least 5 locations - all covered extensively by the local press, but funnily enough not by the nationals who choose to believe that there is no longer a problem here, as one man and his band of volunteers have saved the day...

The sad fact is, if you want to continue to see red squirrels in Scotland, it has to be zero tolerance for greys - and you guys still have a chance to make this happen. The other sad fact is that it is going to take at least the amount of money currently committed by your enlightened (and I mean that) administration to ensure your reds have a future. Would that the numpties in Westminster had the same approach! £148k plus some vols (used in the way that it's been used here) is not going to make any difference...
31

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 03/11/2008 19:55:30
Northumbrian Squirrel

I would certainly be disappointed if your pessimistic view of the Northumbrian squirrel cull turns out to be correct. Do you have any sources of information, other than anecdotal evidence, to support it?
32

Angus,

Alexandria 03/11/2008 21:42:33
I wrote to Lord Redesdale some time ago asking him if he could evidence that the then 15000 had been killed. He didn't reply.

The pathetic Lord and his fat Rambo sidekick have been disowned even by the local wildlife trust.
33

Angus,

Alexandria 03/11/2008 21:43:29
There is no evidence that greys are transmitting squirrel-pox virus (SQPV) to reds as the presence of antibodies in greys merely means they have been in contact with the disease, most probably by associating with reds or possibly other rodents. Research by McInnes et al acknowledges “the possibility that the virus is endemic to the UK and that other rodent species inhabiting the same woodland environment could be harboring the virus”.

The Forestry Commission have admitted under a Freedom of information request that “no routine testing of live red squirrels is undertaken” and they “are not aware of any scientific evidence one way or another as to whether or not there is a resistant population of reds out there”. So it is quite wrong to say red squirrels have no immunity to the disease, when the truth is nobody knows. Indeed, the population could well have been wiped out long ago if there were not some form of resistance present.

Early in the last century, out of forty-four districts in England where red squirrels had the disease only four districts had grey squirrels present. This suggests that SQPV has been within the red squirrel population for around a century at least and that grey squirrels are victims of a campaign of unfair vilification. Some people even have the audacity to claim that SQPV somehow arrived around the time it was discovered in 1983 but that is about as ridiculous as claiming America didn’t exist before it was “discovered” by Leif Ericson – centuries before Christopher Columbus was born.
34

Angus,

Alexandria 03/11/2008 21:44:41
Immunocontraception was deemed immoral in the 1930s in mainland Europe, when it was proposed against sectors of the human population. It is equally immoral to use it against wildlife, as it could affect non-target species and introduce a significant risk of unintended consequences. Unscrupulous conservationists and others could also use it as a weapon of destruction of any species in an attempt to control nature. How long before this dangerous technology, if perfected, could be used against the human population? It is not a route that should be considered by right thinking people.
35

Angus,

Alexandria 03/11/2008 21:45:25
Culling doesn’t work except in closed environments such as islands. According to research it would cost £200,000 per annum to control grey squirrels in Northumberland’s Redesdale Forest alone. - Rushton et al (2002) – and would require to be repeated endlessly as greys will quickly re-colonised voids, sometimes within a few weeks. Culling greys in Scotland will be an expensive and futile exercise requiring to be continued for evermore.

“Squirrel culling is not a new phenomenon. Some 60 years ago the Ministry of Agriculture started to encourage people to kill squirrels, offering—I remember it only too clearly—a shilling a tail. I became a very wealthy young man at that time, as we had a lot of grey squirrels in the area and I did not need a lot of encouragement to do something about them. When the government at that time had paid out some £250,000, they decided that that was enough. There was no perceivable difference to the squirrel population.” Lord Plumb, March 2006
36

Angus,

Alexandria 03/11/2008 21:45:56
Make no mistake, clubbing a grey squirrel over the head is an act of violence and is being promoted nation-wide by government and red squirrel groups. Scientific evidence shows that those who have little regard for the welfare of animals are likely to have a similar attitude to their fellow human beings. Abuse breeds abuse and in our ever-increasing violent society, what example is it to younger generations that violence and killing is an acceptable solution to a perceived problem of not being native to this country?

In reality, rather than in the arbitrary world of conservation, all squirrels born in this country are as “native” by birth as we are, irrespective of our colour, background or success. To expect tolerance within our own population but condemn these animals on the basis of their ancestral background is extremely hypocritical and perhaps only one step removed from racism.
37

jerrymanders,

03/11/2008 22:52:05
#36

You need to go out more often.
38

The real dracula,

03/11/2008 23:06:34
Live and let live.

We should stop interering in the animal kingdom.

We have no right , it is arrogant of humans to think they are superior and have the right to decide what species can exist and what cant.

We dont own animals we coexist with them
39

Brian Hill,

Edinburgh 03/11/2008 23:56:12
This is an excellent idea. It ensures that colonies of reds thrive whether or not the grey cull is successful or not until we can find other ways of controlling the greys....I presume finding a disease suited only to their body chemistry is being sought?

I love grey squirrels I might add but I also love the indigenous Scottish reds which I feel are more in need of our intervention.
40

daveserviceman,

edinburgh 04/11/2008 00:08:04
The Danger of the grey suirrel was recognised way back in the 60's when you were paid 1 shilling(5p) per grey tail. and all this time later noone has come up with an answer to the problem it just gets worse we should continue to shoot and trap and as addition use birth control methods so that it also slows up the breeding
41

Nellie,

Liverpool 04/11/2008 00:25:47
Hmmm.... if Grey's don't like Pinewoods, how come the Reds in the Pinewoods of Formby (Lancashire) are dropping dead with the pox?

(Not that the Red's are actually indigenous to Formby, no more than the Greys - in fact, the Reds in Formby are actually feral, descendants from a population of captive Reds that were released into the woods sometime before WW2, I think it read.)
42

Nellie,

Liverpool 04/11/2008 00:27:36
Birth control for Greys? They tried that in Formby but the little beggers kept making balloons out of the condoms.
43

Northumbrian Squirrel,

04/11/2008 09:24:50
Slioch (31)
Yes - I do have more than anecdotal evidence, I've seen the maps of grey squirrel sightings in Northumberland, and I know that Save our Squirrels (www.saveoursquirrels.org) is getting about 200 sightings a week of squirrels in the North of England, especially Northumberland - and many of these are greys.

Nellie (41 & 42) - the reds are dropping dead of pox in Formby because one or two greys got through a very tight cordon of monitors and trappers. The red population was artificially high because of supplementary feeding (which is what attracts and supports any greys that get through), and the normally solitary red squirrels congregated together in large numbers (I've counted 40 at a time there). This has allowed the pox to spread like wildfire.

BTW the reds in Formby are not feral captive releases of this century - prior to 1948 Lancashire was virtually grey-free, as was most of England. They ARE are a reintroduction (not a captive bred release), but an early Victorian one, when the local landowner felt bad that they had been almost hunted to extinction. Formby's squirrels originally come the dense pine forests of Northern Scandinavia, hence the dark coat coloour many of them exhibit.
44

greenbean,

Jersey 04/11/2008 22:46:02
I am somewhat surprised that the Forestry Commission Scotland regards beech trees and chestnut trees as 'native' to Scotland as both these species are NOT native to Scotland!!
Beech is native to southern UK and Chestnut was introduced to Britain.
If people such as Jo Ellis are unaware of this basic ecology then this strategy is doomed to failure from the start! What else are they ignorant about?
It smacks of the Forestry Commission using this to bamboozle people into accepting more conifer planting which is a money-spinner for the Commission!
I am certainly not against protecting truly native woodland in Scotland and indeed there is thousands of hectares of conifer woodland in the Highlands and maybe protecting this would be far more beneficial to wildlife in general rather than upsetting the ecology of more southern deciduous woodlands?
The one Highland sighting mentioned was believed to be due to a 'hitch-hiking' grey that does not satisfy the criteria for a true record.
The Highland pinewoods are there now and maybe these should be concentrated on as a 'protection stronghold' especially as grey squirrel are now quite widespread south of these areas!
45

Mans a Man,

Scotland 11/02/2009 16:12:43
We killed the native reds in America...I mean Indians, and there was no one to cull us!We will kill all the grey squirrels and will then realise that the reds are still dying from pox becuase all the vectors are not known. On the TV a few nights ago I was horrified to see that near Nazi guy and his Lordship "friend" lementing that he had only killed over 2000 greys.We humans are the main destroyers of habitats but we are good at scapegoating and killing or lyching the prejudged outsider... viz, human, animal or plant...

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.