Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Fury over city's squirrel cull

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 14 March 2007
GREY squirrels will be trapped, put in sacks and clubbed to death as part of a controversial cull of the animals in the north-east of Scotland.
Aberdeen City Council yesterday became the first local authority in Scotland to declare war on the grey with a trap-and-cull scheme to form a buffer zone on the city's outskirts.

The aim is prevent grey squirrels that have already gained a footho
ld in Aberdeen from spreading further north into the last strongholds of the endangered red squirrel in the Highlands and North-east.

Scottish Natural Heritage has warned that Scotland's estimated population of 121,000 red squirrels could be completely wiped out in 50 to 100 years unless action is taken to combat the spread of the alien greys.

The grey, which is larger and more aggressive than the native red, also carries the squirrel-pox virus which does not affect them but is deadly to red squirrels.

Yesterday, as the first traps were laid in Hazlehead Woods on the outskirts of Aberdeen, animal rights groups condemned the cull as unethical and ineffective.

Ross Minett, director of Advocates for Animals, said:

"It seems one of the main animal welfare precepts is being ignored - that female adults should not be killed during the breeding season, as this is likely to leave dependent young to starve to death, causing unnecessary suffering. In addition, major questions remain over the humaneness of the method of killing.

"We, of course, support efforts to conserve remaining red squirrel populations but surely this must be done in an ethical and humane manner."

The council claims the squirrels will be humanely killed.

Dr Mairi Cole, of the species advisory office at SNH, insisted that while some people are not in favour of killing grey squirrels, culling was necessary if the reds are to be saved.

Ian Talboys, the council's countryside officer, defended the £8,000 red squirrel conservation project: "

It is our responsibility to protect our native species for future generations."

NETWORK OF HIDDEN TRAPS


THE Aberdeen trap-and-cull scheme involves up to ten cage traps, baited with food which is attractive to grey squirrels, being hidden at ground-level in vegetation and timber away from footpaths, covered with plastic, and then camouflaged with bracken and brushwood.

The cages trap the animals alive and protect them from wet weather and hot sun until the cages are checked.

Red squirrels or other species that are trapped accidentally will be released unharmed.

A city council spokesman said: "It is an offence under the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 to release grey squirrels once they are trapped."



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 13 March 2007 11:21 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Squirrels
 
1

druidh,

14/03/2007 02:12:13

Can we have a similar cull of Labour councillors in May - after all, they'll not be needed.

2

Voldemort,

Edinburgh 14/03/2007 02:18:20

Grey squirrels (and Pidgeons) are vermin, much like MSP's and SNP/LIB/LAB councillors.

What is the problem with getting rid of Grey Squirrels - they're not supposed to be here in the first place!

Club away Grey Squirrel culling hero's - get the pidgeons next!!! and then ......

3

Conan,

Here 14/03/2007 04:33:58

Yes, clubbing them to death.

So much more considerate than shooting them.

Clubbing = good = slow death = politically correct.

Shooting = bad = instant death = politically incorrect.

How you liking your brave new world so far?

4

why can't I use my own name???,

14/03/2007 06:27:22

The squirrels won't go near those traps: they'll be empty, for the locals will have scavenged the bait from them!

5

Guga,

Rockall 14/03/2007 06:43:21

I'm all for culling them, but could they not just shoot them, or gas them, rather than clubbing them to death?

6

musicismylife,

14/03/2007 06:54:36

The cull is necessary to protect the Reds and their habitat from an invading, alien species.

So how do Advocates for Animals want the reds protected by not culling the greys? They offered no suggestions on TV last night. This is just typical of Animal Rights groups.

If it were up to me, I'd cull these invaders from the US right out of the country. They are diseased!

7

SouthernSkye,

Currently Köln 14/03/2007 07:12:19

culling=good
clubbing=bad
A method that would minimise suffering should be used.

8

Conan,

Here 14/03/2007 07:20:41

There is a more cunning and scientific solution to this problem - its a long shot, but it might just work. here's the plan;

First, we select a number of red's, preferably volunteers sworn to absolute secrecy, and after a thorough background check we introduce them to intensive breeding, cloning and genetic engineering for the purpose of creating a master-race of superior reds. What Nature has neglected and Man has set out-of-balance, Man must correct. It is our destiny!

Next, we continue this programme - just as shown on that documentary a while back .... Jurassic Park .... until we get our reds up to the size of Alsatians.

Then, we turn them loose and let nature take its course.

I am certain that within days of their release there will be bus loads of greys arriving at Glasgow Airport, packing every flight west until they're all gone.

Its worth a try - what have we to loose?

Certainly not our minds.

9

steve 1511,

14/03/2007 07:39:34

are they edible, they could be made into fast food for clubbers on their way home at night

10

Gnasher,

14/03/2007 08:19:51

I wonder if any Labour councillors think Conan #1 should be culled.

11

Gnasher,

14/03/2007 08:20:42

Sorry Conan, I meant Druidh.

12

JIB,

London 14/03/2007 08:33:00

Those ignorants who favour culling or bludgeoning to death innocent animals, and birds are nothing but weak-minded, callous cowards. Most of them get their "kicks" from crying wolf, and advocating slaughter - because the bravest thing they have done in their uneventful lives is to squash an ant!
Councillors and MPs are no different - recall that David Cameron has bragged that he likes to kill defenceless stags for sport. All life is precious, whether grey or red squirrel - killing them serves no purpose at all!!

13

Andrew ICT,

Aberdeen 14/03/2007 08:54:14

Personally I agree with the culling but not with the method being used. I had previously heard it was going to be some form of lethal injection. Clubbing is just barbaric and is no better than those Canadian (?) seal clubbers.

14

stonepark,

Lanark 14/03/2007 09:05:40

As someone who supports and actively takes part in culling humanely, the ideal method of dispatch is to use an air pistol or air rifle while the squirrel is still inside the trap. Its effective and cheap.

With regards to #12, the only ignorant people are those who don't recognise that as humans have severely disrupted ecosystems (elimination of large predators, introduction of non-native species) and that it is up to us to restore the status quo as best possible.

If #12 believes we should not harm animals they should be running around naked eating leaves and roots and nothing else. Any other action, clothes, possessions, servics all harm animals some way whether it is to protect crops, removal of habitat, pollution etc. Or better yet actually understand what your talking about!

15

Fred,

14/03/2007 09:32:55

#12 Does anything live in London ?

16

JRT,

Aberdeen 14/03/2007 09:35:51

As long as they are not wasted who cares how they get dispatched. Craiginches will save a bundle on the catering budget!

17

Theo,

Richmond, Va. USA 14/03/2007 10:00:05

To #9

They are good to eat! If you want to make a stew cut the legs at the hip and remove the skin and bones. Add a bunch to onions, carrots, and potatoes and slowly cook until done. If you want to grill or fry just remove the skin and fur and carefully grill or fry in a small amount of oil. Salt and pepper to taste.

Many people like the brains but I never got into that. I am sure a check on the internet will turn up some recipes.

If you have the time some extra meat can be gotton off the body but it really is not worth the time.
If they are to be dispatched you might as well enjoy the "fixings'" that way one can say they enjoyed the usefulness of the animal after dispatching.

18

not allowed my name anymore,

14/03/2007 10:41:29

#9

durring the miners strike we had many a squirrel pie. it was a tastey meal.

19

AJ,

Fife 14/03/2007 10:56:26

Captured squirrels, hessian sack, concrete slab, bridge, river and bingo - deid squirrels!!

This is a tried and tested method, perfected in Fife, for getting rid of greyhounds that fail to make the grade!!! Also it's a popular method for off loading unwanted puppies and kittens!!

20

Neil,

9% Growth Party 14/03/2007 10:57:04

I suspect Aberdeen Council will manage to do this considerably more cheaply than the £1,100 per head SNH have spent on getting rid of hedgehogs.

21

marrianna,

K. 14/03/2007 11:22:15

Culling red deer, hedgehogs, grey squirrels and other non native 'introduced' species is not something we embrace willingly. I am fortunate to have 'reds' in my garden. But I observe 'greys' in my son's neighbourhood; and hundreds of deer on a weekly basis on the mountains - a delightful sight, but I think that culling is necessary as a means to a good end.

22

F.R.E.E. Mason,

Brisbane 14/03/2007 11:37:42

Is this a colour thing? Didn't our forefathers get in trouble for choosing to cull one colour over another! Can't we cross breed them and simply have "GREDS"

23

AJ,

Fife 14/03/2007 11:50:10

HC#21,

Aye it's nae laughing matter, but a suspect the practice is also carried oot in darkest Lanarkshire and the east end of yer beloved Glescae!! A bet if they dragged the Clyde, as well as aw the human body parts, they would also find a guid few unwanted pets!!!!

24

Wee gurl,

14/03/2007 11:55:12

Surely in this day and age, so-called politicians should be able to come up with a much more humane way of doing this. Clubbing greys to death seems to me like a "no-brained" solution to the problem. Clubbing these animals is sick and unnecessary. It just seems as if they are opting for whatever is the easiest without putting any consideration into it at all.

25

Allan(handofgod137),

14/03/2007 11:57:49

#25 shooting them would be much more humane, perhaps we could encourage people to us their air rifles.

26

jim lad,

the capital 14/03/2007 12:04:03

I am sure the reds and beaver outaws would be singing Leaving On a Jet Plane as they left.

27

musicismylife,

14/03/2007 12:19:17

#27. Jim lad ... You have a point, but Scaramouche says he's not writing it since he's being "moderated" and can't post anything!

28

G,

dundy 14/03/2007 12:26:33

This is a disgrace!

Joined up government my bottom

Just think of all the healthy meals that could be made from this free range meat!

If the SE just gave out recipes encouraging squirrel stew or cous cous with steamed grey then the Aberdonians (never known to miss a freebie) would cull them in no time

29

AJ,

Fife 14/03/2007 12:34:17

Music is my life,

I was being moderated yesterday, but they lifted the restrictions last night. Get Scaramouche to have another go!!!

30

jim lad,

the capital 14/03/2007 12:48:27

#28 Scaramouche oops Musicismylife
Get back asap and hope your feeling better, Musicismylife has beeen doing a gand job in your enforced rest period.

31

jamesfm,

14/03/2007 12:49:16

The term "clubbing" is used to elicit an emotional response.

A single, sharp blow to the head, just as used when killing rabbits for the pot is humane, quick and very effective. Using a gun is potentially more painful to the animal, as the shooter needs to know what he or she is doing. Gassing with CO2 means the animal is captive for longer and therefore more stressed.

If you can't face that reality, you need to grow up.

32

KATIE MAC NAUGHTON,

Edinburgh 14/03/2007 12:55:02

Clubbing them ,is a medieval way to get rid off them, but what else can you exspect from idiots.

33

Louisa,

Perth 14/03/2007 13:27:41

Hurrah!!!!!
I've been waiting for ages to get back to the important issues of the day. I was beginning to think I'd never laugh again on reading this site.

What happened to the idea of squirrel contraception?
Forcing these poor wee beasties to go clubbing is just inhuman and will probably lead to soaring rates of unplanned squirrels. Dancing in these cages in some of the clubs I've seen is just embarrassing exploitation. It's no life for a grey squirrel.

34

Unknown Masses,

14/03/2007 14:15:13

What is it with the Scotsman and Squirrels. two articles in three days.

35

Miss Jean Brodie,

Squirel in a human skin 14/03/2007 15:05:49

I have been breeding killer grey squirels and have a plan to get them to the top of the food chain - never mind cooncilors and parliamentarians - we are planin on wrapping the human race in a sak and blugeoning it to death - c’mon you know it makes sense - after all humans are a threat to all life! A cancer!

36

Wee gurl,

14/03/2007 16:15:29

#32 Surely the clubber would need to know what they are doing too (lets just hope they do!), and as for holding squirrels captive for a period of time causing them distress, they are already being held captive by traps that are set by the Aberdeen trap-and-cull scheme. The main point here is, surely there is a more humane way of culling/controlling grey squirrels, as culling seems as if it would only work in the short-term.

37

jamesfm,

14/03/2007 17:11:58

Yes, the person killing the squirrel does need to know what to do - though a sharp tap on the head is technically uncomplicated. I would agree that cage trapping does cause a dgeree of stress, but transporting the squirrels to another place for killing is likely to add to this.

It might be more appropriate to use the Fenn Mk 4 trap as a method of control. It's a recommened legal method. The fenn trap is rather like a large mouse trap and kills the squirrel instantly, though it isn't too pretty and the squeamish may object to that too.

38

educational snob,

Edinburgh 14/03/2007 17:34:45

Clubbing to death one of God's creatures is sinful, and will be just another indictment against the human race at the Grand Assize. We are to be good stewards over the world, and that may involve culling, but there is no way that the indiscriminate use of a club on squirrels in Scotland, or the ice-axeing of seals in Canada, or the bloodbath of dolphins in Japan, can ever be condoned. That is tyranny, not stewardship! We are exercising an evil domination in the way we treat animals, never mind our fellow humans. "Not a sparrow falls to the ground without the knowledge of your Heavenly Father" (Matthew 10:29) God cares for what happens to the sparrows, so we should care about what happens to the squirrels. As I say again, a cull may be necessary for the greater good, but we can at least do it in a merciful manner! We have a delegated sovereignty over the Earth, not an absolute one, and are still accountable to our Creator.

39

AD,

sunny Livingston 14/03/2007 17:40:53

#39 - what if the squirrels aren't religious????!

:o)

40

Allan(handofgod137),

14/03/2007 17:58:00

#39 The fact that you have a vote shows a fundamental flaw in our democratic system. I believe that your bible tells you that man has dominion over the animals.

41

Ken M,

Stenhousemuir 14/03/2007 19:38:22

There is an irony in this as the greys come from north America and wipe out the indigenous reds with their aggresion and viruses.

Whites came from Europe to N America and did the same thing to reds around 4oo years ago.

42

Theo,

Richmond Va., USA 14/03/2007 21:33:54

On an additional note it is to bad the hunters are not given the chance to help with the "cull". They know how to take each culled critter and turn it into a real treat. Much better to honor the animal this way then to just put them in a waste pit. Our American Indians honored each animal that they took for food to survive and many hunters in America say a short thanks to the animal for his life.
We also have Hunters for the Hungary where deer, bear, turkey is donated to centers that will process the animal and the meat goes to feed the hungry.

43

Mart on Skye,

15/03/2007 00:26:18

If they are in a sack they won't know what hit them!

#39 One hard blow is instantaneous and as good and 'merciful' as any other method.

Greys also do a great deal of damage by bark stripping broadleaved trees.

44

COLONEL BLIMP,

KHARTOUM 15/03/2007 06:46:42

This is not a new issue. I remember during the war we'd problems with the Yanks coming over here and putting the locals' noses out of joint. Those chappies definitely preferred clubbing to shooting!(or anything else useful, by Jove!

45

COLONEL BLIMP,

Khartoum 15/03/2007 07:15:18

p.s. they brought squirrel pox, too.

46

Aberdeen,

Plymouth 15/03/2007 10:25:36

Surely there must be a more humain way to deal with this problem.

47

JIB,

London 15/03/2007 13:39:38

Some of the comments above betray their owner’s lack of experience, knowledge, arrogance, ignorance and littleness as human beings.

Does anyone like them?

My guess is that these people (above) are loners, and get their thrills from causing pain to others, and in particular like to hurt innocent, defenceless creatures like the grey squirrels! Again, they should remember that 'what goes around' normally 'comes around', and normally happens to them personally, or indirectly (family members).

I have been a soldier in war and know how precious life is - killing defenceless animal(s), bird(s) or human(s) serves no purpose at all. The only justification for taking another’s life is if it is to save your own, or another(s). Animals, birds etc. are no different to humans (contrary to what some people may believe, or have read) - some have individualised and many have a group soul, and all have a spirit (united with ourselves).

The grey squirrels are not killing the reds - it is the virus they are carrying (see http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/scotland/5069276.stm)! Consider this: If we have such great scientists and doctors in the UK and in this world, why don’t we find a cure for the disease, than take the easy option and cull a defenceless animal? Wouldn’t you expect a cure if you, your brother, sisters or children were carrying the disease?

48

educational snob,

Edinburgh 15/03/2007 20:35:48

No. 39, I appreciate your point about one hard blow, but how could that be administered with any accuracy if these creatures are in a non-clear sack or bag where their form cannot be seen?

No. 40 - Squirrels and religion? Maybe not, but on the day you meet your Maker, don't expect the excuse "But, I'm not religious!" to be acceptable.

No. 41, yes, you know one of the words of Genesis Ch.1 - 'dominion' - but this word in Hebrew ('radah') does not mean tyranny, but 'rule over wisely'.


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.