Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Is umami the secret to help potatoes pass the taste test?

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
27 December 2007
UMAMI, a 100-year-old Japanese concept of flavour, may hold the key to breeding the perfect potato.
Favourite varieties contain higher levels of the compounds linked to umami flavour
Favourite varieties contain higher levels of the compounds linked to umami flavour
Experts at the Scottish Crop Research Institute (SCRI) at Invergowrie near Dundee have discovered which compounds give potatoes their distinctive "umami" taste.

The scientists are hopeful that their study will be used to create new varieties even more tasty than their predecessors.

Umami has been scientifically accepted as one of the five individual tastes sensed by receptors on the tongue, along with salty, sweet, bitter and sour.

Although there is no equivalent word in English, umami has been used to describe the slightly savoury taste that people encounter when they eat ripe tomatoes, parmesan cheese, cured ham, mushrooms, and various types of meat and fish.

Dr Mark Taylor, the SCRI scientist who led the research, said: "Umami is almost a savoury-like flavour and that is obviously considered to be important when it comes to judging the taste of a potato. It was certainly the case in our taste trials.

"There was a suggestion back in the 1970s that umami was important for potato flavour, but there was never any evidence to back it up until we did our trials."

The potato varieties that score highest when it comes to flavour have higher levels of the compounds known to give rise to the umami flavour – specific chemicals, which include some amino acids and "ribonucleotides" that are formed during cooking.

The research team conducted taste tests to compare traditional Solanum tuberosum varieties, including Montrose, Pentland Dell, Maris Piper and Record, which are widely grown in Scotland, with new, Andean-style varieties of so-called Phureja potatoes, which tend to be thinner and longer. The new varieties tested included Mayan Gold and Inca Sun – which derive from the Peruvian homeland of the potato. The Peruvian potatoes came out on top.

"We found that the Phurejas always had more of the umami compounds and that there was a correlation with the taste-panel score," said Dr Taylor.

"It is probably not the only story because the potato has a pretty complicated flavour, (but] it may be the key."

He added: "Ultimately, we would like to know which genes control the process that leads to the formation of umami compounds and these genes could be used in breeding programmes to generate a tastier potato."

SOMETHING TO SAVOUR

• Umami was first identified as a taste in 1908 by Dr Kikunae Ikeda, a scientist at the Tokyo Imperial University while researching the strong flavour in kombu, a seaweed broth.

• Many scientists argued that umami was not a separate sense, but simply a combination of the other four tastes – salty, sweet, bitter and sour.

• In 1996, a team of researchers at the University of Miami discovered separate taste receptor cells in the tongue for detecting umami.

They also found that animals were able to savour umami.



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 26 December 2007 8:40 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Boy Wonder,

27/12/2007 00:58:37
Dunno about "Umami" ... but my mammy made GREAT mash tatties and chips no-one has ever bettered! :)
2

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 27/12/2007 09:03:08
The suggestion that ALL flavours can be characterised as some combination of "the four pure flavours" - salt, sweet, bitter and sour (and now perhaps a fifth, umami) seems to me to be perhaps the most ridiculous example of extreme scientific reductionism. This manifest nonsense is still (I think) taught in secondary school biology classes by unthinking teachers who dole it out to unthinking pupils.

Yet, I have never found anyone who can tell me what the taste of chocolate is - (is it 10% salt, 40% sweet, 30% bitter and 20% sour??? - or some other combination?). And of course the same can be said of countless other unique tastes - coffee, mangoes, strawberries, Rioja, fresh bread, lychees, camenbert etc. etc. ect.

Is there anyone - perhaps Dr Mark Taylor of the SCRI - prepared to defend this nonsense?
3

Selgovae,

Scottish Borders 27/12/2007 09:52:48
#2

I'm no expert, but I think those four (or five) "tastes" are what can be detected by the tongue. Other elements of taste are detected by the nose. (olfactory system??) I think that's why it's hard to taste some things when we have a cold.

As for umami, I was led to believe this was the taste supplied by monosodium glutamate.
4

Filosofo,

Kirkcaldy 27/12/2007 10:02:50
Gosh
5

Gothic Rose,

27/12/2007 10:03:52
Whatever.!!!
6

fred bloggs,

Edinburgh 27/12/2007 11:08:13
It would appear that there are five kinds of taste receptors which are activated to a greater or lesser extent by the compounds in different foods. Hence every taste relates to different combinations of stimulation of these receptors. This is analagous to the way an infinite range of colours is experienced by only five kinds of light receptors (rods and cones) in the eye.
7

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 27/12/2007 11:58:26
#6 fred bloggs

I don't believe it!

The analogy with light is not good, since that relates to a continuum on a linear scale of varying wavelengths of light. Thus any particular colour is a mix of lights of varying wavelengths that can be accurately represented by a graph. You can't do that with chocolate!

The four basic flavours postulated, (salt, sweet, sour, and bitter) can each be accurately represented by one particular substance (sodium chloride, sucrose, citric acid and something like quinine), which are each 100% of the particular flavour. Are you really maintaining that you could make something indistinguishable from chocolate (or whatever), by mixing the correct relative amounts of these substances together?? And if so, what are those amounts??

#3 Selgovae mentions smell, and I'm sure that HELPS with flavour, but I'm equally sure I can taste different tastes even with a clothes peg on my nose.

This hypothesis is so commonly stated it has become like one of Richard Dawkins' memes: but I think it's absolute bunkum: but if anyone can point me to an convincing argument to the contrary, please do so.

8

Gothic Rose,

27/12/2007 12:04:28
This conversation is,beginning to hurt my head.I`m of for a recuperating cup of tea.
9

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 27/12/2007 12:16:01
We have "world-class" potatoes growing in our Canadian province of Prince Edward Island and they stand up to any in other parts of the world, so there.
10

fred bloggs,

Edinburgh 27/12/2007 14:59:29
7. Slioch:

This topic seems to be a very complex area. The best I can do is refer you to:

http://www.sciam.com/article.cfm?articleID=000641D5-F855-1C70-84A9809EC588EF21
11

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 27/12/2007 17:01:44
#10 fred bloggs

Thanks for that fred - I'll have a read. But not tonight - things to do.

But I'm sure you are right that it is very complex. I think we understand very little about it. Makes climate change seem like a doddle.
12

Mcsnagpile,

27/12/2007 17:10:32
There are six tastes. The deep fried mars bar discovered by Jock Mactastebuds in Shettleston.
13

tomrober,

Edmonton 27/12/2007 18:08:09
Everyone
Hope it's a sign of the times. No-one appears to be promoting the SNP or slagging the Scotsman this morning. Lang may it continue, thanks to the humble tattie!
14

weeshooie1,

Australia 27/12/2007 19:44:42
Talking about spuds, can anyone tell me when Smiths stopped puting the wee bags of salt in their crisps?
15

Mirrorman,

In the night garden 28/12/2007 08:23:34
So that's what all this 'scientific whaling' crap is about. The Japanese holy grail...a whale flavoured crisp.

 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.