Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Scotland's Alcohol Shame: Experts target women as middle-class drinkers face health threat

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 07 May 2008
WOMEN who overindulge by consuming too much wine are to be targeted in efforts to tackle Scotland's dangerous alcohol culture, it emerged yesterday.
Scottish Government officials and health experts are keen to highlight the problem of women who may be drinking over recommended limits without realising it.

They want to show that alcohol misuse is not just a problem affecting teenagers and poore
r people, but also has an impact among middle-class women for whom wine-drinking has become part of daily life.

Experts warn that alcohol can cause a wide range of problems among women.

These include an increased risk of breast cancer, fertility problems and a high calorie content, with implications for weight.

The Scottish Government hopes that by highlighting these messages, which are of major concerns to many women, people will start to think more carefully about their drinking.

News of the advertising campaign comes after The Scotsman yesterday revealed that alcohol misuse is costing Scotland £2.25 billion a year – double the previous estimate of the scale of the problem.

Shona Robison, the public health minister, said women had become the "new drinkers", abusing alcohol much more now than 30 to 40 years ago.

She said links to breast cancer, fertility and other health and wellbeing issues needed to be urgently highlighted.

"We are very keen through our campaign to really spark that debate among women," Ms Robison said.

"One of the world's largest studies of drinking behaviour and breast cancer found that the risk of breast cancer increases by 6 per cent for every extra alcoholic drink you drink every day over the sensible limit.

"Clearly we need to get messages across that it is not just things like liver cirrhosis, which is important, but there are also these other links to things like breast cancer."

In recent years, it has become more acceptable for women to drink wine in larger quantities, perhaps sharing a bottle every night over dinner with their partner and at lunch with friends.

But over the course of a week, this can mean many exceed the recommended limit of 14 units.

Surveys have revealed evidence that while men are still on average drinking more, women are catching up.

In 1995, 33 per cent of men reported consuming more than their recommended weekly limit of 21 units, but by 2003 this had fallen to 29 per cent. However, among women, drinking over the recommended limit increased from 13 per cent in 1995 to 17 per cent in 2003.

The Scottish Government said that teenagers alone could not be blamed for the rising levels of drinking.

Research has shown that women working full-time in professional and management posts are the most likely to develop a problem.

Death rates from liver cirrhosis among women in Scotland have also more than tripled in the past 30 years.

Ms Robison said that people had to understand the harm they could be doing.

"When people talk about alcohol misuse, they think yes, it's a problem, but it's someone else's problem.

"People don't necessarily associate their own behaviour with hazardous drinking. But we know that people underestimate what they think they drink and if they really have a look at what they drink, it's likely that they are drinking more than the recommended limit."

Over the next three years, the Scottish Government is investing over £120 million to help prevent alcohol misuse and provide support and treatment.

A long-term strategy on how they will tackle alcohol misuse is expected to be published this summer, with radical measures promised.

The new advertising images aimed at women, to be used in magazines, posters and online, will highlight the fact that drinking more than a glass of wine a day could increase the risk of breast cancer.

They will also point out that a large glass of wine has almost 200 calories and that excessive drinking may reduce the chances of conceiving.

Jackie Harris, a clinical nurse specialist at charity Breast Cancer Care, said while it was known that drinking alcohol could increase a person's risk of developing breast cancer, whether it can actually influence how the disease develops has yet to be fully determined.

"Alcohol is just one variable that could lead to an increased risk, and it's very hard to isolate specific lifestyle factors.

"Being teetotal does not mean that you'll be free of breast cancer, nor does drinking alcohol mean that you will definitely develop the illness," she said.

"If anyone is questioning the amount of alcohol they are consuming they should talk it over with someone, such as their GP or an alcohol support group."

Susan Seenan, from the charity Infertility Network UK, said many factors, including alcohol, could affect fertility.

"One in six couples currently have problems conceiving and while pregnant women have for a long time been told to avoid alcohol, cutting down on alcohol is also good advice for those trying to conceive," she said.

"We would advise any couple trying for a baby that both should cut down on alcohol consumption, give up smoking and follow a healthy diet and to seek expert advice if they have any concerns at all."

LIVER DISEASE

Women's livers cannot repair themselves as quickly as men's livers when they become damaged. This means that it takes longer for women to recover after a heavy drinking session. Women's livers also produce less of the substance the body uses to break alcohol down, meaning they get drunk quicker and the effects last longer than they do in men.

BREAST CANCER

It is thought that several hundred cases of breast cancer in the UK each year could be linked to alcohol. The world's largest study of women's drinking suggested the cancer risk rose by 6 per cent for every extra alcoholic drink consumed a day over recommended limits. Experts are unclear how alcohol leads to breast cancer, but are confident the link does exist.

THE PILL

In the days before a woman has her period, the effects of alcohol are felt more quickly. But taking the contraceptive Pill has the opposite effect, delaying the absorption of alcohol into the body and delaying the time it takes to leave the body.

Women taking the Pill will not be as aware of the effect of alcohol on them and so may drink more than they realise.

FERTILITY

Research suggests that women who drink large quantities of alcohol are less likely to become pregnant. With rising rates of infertility in the UK, it is feared that an increase in alcohol consumption could be partly to blame for the problem. Some experts have suggested that as few as five drinks a week could decrease a woman's chance of becoming pregnant.

EFFECTS ON FOETUS

Evidence is mounting to suggest that any amount of alcohol could affect the foetus. Foetal alcohol syndrome leads to serious mental impairment as well as physical abnormalities, and in less severe cases can cause behavioural and learning difficulties. The Chief Medical Officer advises avoiding alcohol for pregnant women or those trying to conceive.

DIET AND NUTRITION

There are almost 200 calories in a glass of red wine. At seven calories a gram, alcohol has more calories than many foods – and that is before you consider the sugar added to most drinks. Alcohol also stimulates appetite while reducing self-control, making it easy to eat too much. Women may also replace food with alcohol to control calorie intake.

DATE RAPE

Women who are drunk are less able to look out for themselves, putting them at risk of being taken advantage of sexually. Many women are worried about their drinks being spiked with date rape drugs. But alcohol is the UK's biggest date rape drug. Research suggests that up to 81 per cent of rape and sex attack victims had been drinking before the assault.

GETTING HOME SAFELY

People who have been drinking are more likely to take risks. For women, this can mean walking home alone down dark streets they would not take when sober. They may also choose to go home with someone they have just met, which is very risky. Being drunk can make women more likely to have unsafe sex, putting them at risk of sexually transmitted diseases.

FREEZING TO DEATH

Alcohol makes drinkers feel warmer, but is actually lowering core body temperature. People who fall asleep drunk outside are at risk of hypothermia and death. Because women are more likely to wear skimpy outfits, they are at particular risk. Hypothermia itself makes people feel sleepy as the body's main functions start to shut down.

Bigger glasses and stronger wine and beer adding to dangers

HAVING one glass of wine in a pub in the UK now means you could be consuming up to a third of a bottle.

Pubs and bars are also increasingly tempting customers with special offers to encourage them to buy a whole bottle of wine, by making it cheaper than buying separate glasses.

Last month, doctors warned that bars were leading their customers into dangerous drinking habits by making supersize measures of wine and spirits appear to be standard orders.

The Royal College of Physicians said the licensing industry was being "irresponsible" by reducing the availability of smaller servings.

They said many pubs and wine bars had already got rid of 125ml measures of wine altogether.

This meant customers were left to choose between 175ml and 250ml glasses only.

A 250ml glass amounts to around a third of a bottle of wine.

The Office for National Statistics (ONS) has even had to devise a new method to assess alcohol consumption which takes into account the trend for stronger wine and bigger glasses.

The main change compared with previous years is that one medium glass of wine now counts as two units instead of one. The ONS has also had to consider the growing popularity of high-alcohol beers among consumers.

Health experts have warned that the increase in wine-measure sizes is having a particular effect on women – the biggest consumers of wine.

There has also been concern that people are unwittingly exceeding the drink-drive limit by not taking into account the effect of larger measures.

Some suggest that the introduction of larger measures came as the result of pressure from consumers, who felt they were being short-changed by small glasses of wine offered in pubs.

'I had big problem but help was at hand'

CASE ONE

JUNE Kelly knew her alcohol problems were getting out of control when she could go days without knowing what she had been doing.

The 54-year-old, from Easterhouse, Glasgow, is now getting help, but she said: "Sometimes, I go off the alcohol completely and sometimes I have binges. But the people who have been supporting me are always there for you."

Mrs Kelly's problems started about 20 years ago. "I worked in a pub for 13 years and we used to stay after hours and drink," she said. "I knew I was having problems when I was drinking so much I just couldn't get back up."

Her children were only eight and 11 when her problems with alcohol became more severe – she was drinking up to a bottle of vodka a day.

She eventually found support at the Greater Easterhouse Alcohol Awareness Project, where she has been going for the past four years.

Childhood abuse started drink spiral

CASE TWO


DRINKING up to 16 cans of lager at a time left Bridie feeling depressed and suicidal.

But despite her issues with alcohol, the 36-year-old has been able to hold down a job and continue with her life.

Now she has turned her back on alcohol for good.

"I've had problems with my drink for 20 years now. I started drinking when I was 15."

Bridie, of Shettleston, Glasgow, said she started drinking heavily due to abuse she suffered as a child.

"I was drinking about 16 cans of lager. I was passing out. I would find myself up dark lanes. I had to go to A&E to have stitches in my head after falling."

Eventually, Bridie decide to get help after finding herself drinking huge amounts of alcohol at home.

Bridie, who works in mental health, has now been off alcohol for nine months.

'I was drinking cider with breakfast'

CASE THREE


JEANETTE Gillespie couldn't give up alcohol even after ending up in hospital on a drip.

The 53-year-old from Easterhouse found herself watching the clock at work, eager to get home for a drink.

But since seeking help from the Greater Easterhouse Alcohol Awareness Project she has seen her life improve. She said: "When I started working at 19 I had too much money, and my drinking problems accumulated from that.

"I used to work in a school and that could be stressful. I was going home and drinking vodka and lager. At weekends, it would get worse. I was drinking cider with my breakfast. My health deteriorated. I was drinking rather than eating. I got taken into hospital."

Mrs Gillespie asked for help three years ago from addiction experts and has never looked back.



Page 1 of 1

 
1

,

07/05/2008 00:24:54
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
2

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 07/05/2008 00:37:49

Scenario 2,, At the Restaurant with Hubby having a Meal!

Madam I can serve you Husband with another,..

"Glass of Wine", BUT MADAM!,..

"I CANT SEVRE YOU, UNTIL YOU TAKE A BREATHALYSER TEST"!

Sexist or Not,?

Try this on us, and you will soon find out, where that,

'Bottle of Wine' ends UP!
3

!Ya basta!,

07/05/2008 02:38:34
A campaign targetting us middle classes is long overdue though I wish the messages were harder hitting like in some previous road safety campaigns.
4

Hamish Simpson,

Leith 07/05/2008 05:58:22
Apparantly if you follow the wine with a kebab it negates the damaging effects. I like the effect that wine has on my bird when she comes home from a night out........
5

fife runner,

07/05/2008 06:40:04
#4 you mean you like women who overindulge. seems daft to me. #3 yes for too long we have looked on this as a problem with the less affluent. I know well off families where it seems funny to them their teenage offspring get drunk.
6

Samcafe,

Glasgow 07/05/2008 06:52:45
Wimmin's Group's are frantically writing a thesis on why this is men's fault
7

yockel,

07/05/2008 06:57:21
But you have to admit Nanny State knows best, pressure groups are unbiased and the only reason pigs don't fly is due to health and safety considerations.
8

Lanna,

07/05/2008 07:29:13
#8 Dave,
well, good morning to you, too.... ;)
9

Lanna,

07/05/2008 07:31:49
#6 Samcafe,
I blame this all on the wimmin's groups who campaigned earlier on, that 'we could have it all, baby'...

#7 yockel,
and here I thought pigs couldn't fly due to the thrust to weight ratio?
10

Lanna,

07/05/2008 07:33:06
#11 Dave,
haha...I'm doin' fine, Dave. thanks
Doin ma best to stay outta trouble. :)
11

yockel,

07/05/2008 07:41:32
Lanna lift to drag ratios do come in to it but we aren't allowed to talk about that as it's not PC.
12

Lanna,

07/05/2008 08:02:04
see, there ah go, gettin' intae trouble...
13

Lillig,

07/05/2008 09:48:30
I got worried at the beginning of the article over the bottle of wine with your meal at night stuff - until I read the case studies at the end.

These are two completely different scenarios. The shared bottle of wine and the 16 cans of lager drunk by Bridie do not equate.

Must run and let that cheeky rioja breathe for a couple of hours before lunch!
14

Lillig,

07/05/2008 09:48:30
I got worried at the beginning of the article over the bottle of wine with your meal at night stuff - until I read the case studies at the end.

These are two completely different scenarios. The shared bottle of wine and the 16 cans of lager drunk by Bridie do not equate.

Must run and let that cheeky rioja breathe for a couple of hours before lunch!
15

Lillig,

07/05/2008 09:48:51
I got worried at the beginning of the article over the bottle of wine with your meal at night stuff - until I read the case studies at the end.

These are two completely different scenarios. The shared bottle of wine and the 16 cans of lager drunk by Bridie do not equate. If you are going to warn people of the shared bottle category, please show relevant case studies!

Sorry, must run now and let that cheeky rioja breathe for a couple of hours before lunch!
16

Lillig,

07/05/2008 09:50:20
Sorry about the above. The web was so slow that I had to cancel twice.

Or, could it be the buckie I had for breakfast?
17

!Ya basta!,

07/05/2008 09:58:57
Middle class women are being targeted because their over indulgence has been overlooked in the past compared to mens over indulgence, which is already well known.

Also, changing womens attitudes is far more likely to lead to changes in childrens behaviour. Women are also more likely than men to change their behaviour for the sake of their own health and that of their families.
18

Alternative (High Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 07/05/2008 11:31:46
I am sick to death of hearing about all this hyped up rubbish.

Yes. Excessive drinking can cause health problems.

However the vast majority do not drink excessively. The so-called "guidelines on safe drinking" are a complete joke.

All this hype is going to lead to two things---increased tax and more restrictive legislation. Why can they not just leave us alone for once?
19

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 07/05/2008 11:42:04
Charles Linskaill

Calm down! You are going to give yourself a coronary and then where would you and your wife and child (hopefully) be?

Horrible Cankers

You have been warned.

Now, don't have three or four "wee drams" before your feet hit the floor first thing in the morning, don't have mid-morning "cocktails" with your scones, and hold back on those two or three bottle of wine you imbibe at supper to get you in the mood for trolling the local pubs for Daniel Craig or his simulacrum or four.
20

Victoria,

East Lothian 07/05/2008 12:48:13
Perhaps if it was a requirement to list the number of units contained on the side of the bottle people'd be less inclined to finish off the bottle - I know it'd at least make me think twice about opening that second bottle...

Also - how can you do an article about middle class women drinking too much and then finish it with case studies about women from Easterhouse - could you not find anyone in Morningside willing to tell you about the problems they'd had with their Sancerre habit?
21

John Blackley,

Florida 07/05/2008 13:41:57
I wonder how much middle-class women wine-drinkers contribute to the alleged 2.25 billion quid a year 'cost' of alchohol in Scotland? (And, conversely, how much is contributed by - say - teen-to-middle-aged men.)

I don't doubt that there are middle-class women who drink more than is good for them but is that really the part of the population where money would be best spent by those determined to teach 'a better way'?
22

Horrible Cankers at the Cyber Shebeen,

07/05/2008 16:45:19
24....Bonjour Timothy Charles....I no longer souse myself with booze...cannot handle the hangovers and the blanks that were the night before....no thank you, the odd glass of champagne, glass of wine with my grub and aperatif when friends are around is sufficient....I avoid pubs like the plague and do not like the company of intoxicated men or women...however an intoxicating man a la Daniel Craig would definitly not be refused....
23

Lanna,

S Calif 07/05/2008 16:59:15
#28 Canky,
I do agree with you there. My friend's pub is the only one we go to.
Hey, as my hubby had dinner the other nite with Gerard Butler, maybe I can arrange an intoxicating evening with Danny boy...strawberries with that champagne, darlin?! ;)
24

Nippy sweetie,

07/05/2008 18:22:14
What a load of crap as a woman I am sick fed up of being told what do to do.

I think you should start by tackling the more destructive forms of drinking. SNP are trying to find ways to grab headlines without spending any money on things that really help like support services.

This article is so obvious, ps why are two of the case studies from middle class Easterhouse.....just saying????
25

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 07/05/2008 18:47:01
30 Nippy sweetie

Sometimes, if not always, women HAVE to be told or ordered what to do because they are so disorganised and scatter-brained - or so my mother informed me.
26

Mcsnagpile,

07/05/2008 19:23:50
Now that the good weather is here, down to the summer lodge ---A good bottle of port, fresh Madeira cake, a round of small cut sandwiches, some Wifi on the laptop, a good book –ye cannae whack it. Running round the city, droopy drawered, at 18:00hrs, is a recipe for what ye deserve.
What does Miss Easterhoose have wae hur 16 canaelagers apart fae wet drawers and a sair heed.
27

Thankfully Alive,

Edinburgh 07/05/2008 20:24:32
95% of alcoholics in the US are of Northern European origins - susceptability to alcohol abuse just might have a genetic basis. Scotland was known 300 years ago as the "drunk man of Europe". This ain't new. High availability is tho.
28

John Blackley,

Florida 07/05/2008 21:09:01
#33 Thankfully Alive, do tell me where you get your numbers from.
29

Horrible Cankers at the Cyber Shebeen,

07/05/2008 22:13:53
29....Ooooh watch it there Lanna...thon Gerald Butler wan, or 'Jerry the Jemmy' as he is better known in these parts, will have your telly oot the windae afore ye know it...'es been known tae break intae a hoose, empty it, feed the cat and walk the dug afore anybody kent they'd bin robbed...dont faw fir the smile, 'e might hiv Hollywood teeth but 'es as a wee flyman him!

But if 'e hings aboot wae Daniel Craig 'e cannae be aw bad...jist tell 'im tae ask Danny boy if 'e wants 'es Calvins back....heh heh heh heh heh....
30

,

07/05/2008 22:50:24
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
31

,

07/05/2008 22:55:03
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
32

,

07/05/2008 22:59:16
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
33

,

07/05/2008 23:00:11
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
34

,

07/05/2008 23:05:09
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
35

weeshooie1,

Wollongong 07/05/2008 23:45:18
Lanna & Canky,

G'Day me darlins, still sober I see.
36

Horrible Cankers at the Cyber Shebeen,

08/05/2008 11:29:16
41..Allright Weeshooie whaur ye bin hidin pal?...long time no hear....you bin oan yer hols or whit?...had a couple o' glasses o' wine wae ma dinner last night and ended up wae a right sair heid...mind ye its hotter than July here...garden's fair parched...might hiv tae break oot the hose the night....

Anyway, how you doing pal and whit ye up tae?
37

,

10/05/2008 22:25:28
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
38

,

10/05/2008 22:28:50
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
39

,

10/05/2008 22:29:02
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
40

,

10/05/2008 22:30:39
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
41

,

10/05/2008 22:31:54
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
42

,

23/05/2008 08:02:21
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
43

,

23/05/2008 08:15:30
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
44

vladi,

lancashire 03/06/2008 09:17:48
I read someone's comment saying they were worried when they first started reading the article but then were relieved when they read the case studies. But drinking a bottle of wine a night with a meal could lead to worse. I drank quite heavily during my late teens / early twenties but then cut down to virtually nothing after I got married. Then due to job stress began drinking again on a regular basis, started as just a couple of cans of beer a night but then escalated quite quickly to half a litre of vodka a night. I found myself craving the stuff first thing in a morning - determined not to give in to this I sought prayer and support from my local church. I am now very strict with myself about my alcohol consumption. Members of my family have also suffered with alcohol related illness such as pancreatitis and liver cirrhosis - that's more than enough to make you think seriously about it.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.