Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Drink Driving, Don't Risk It!

Cancer patient's recovery amazes doctors

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 28 July 2008
A LUNG cancer patient in Edinburgh who was given just a few months to live has stunned doctors by going into remission.
The unnamed patient, a 69-year-old female ex-smoker from the Lothians, developed lung cancer in 2006. She also suffered from Crohn's Disease, an unrelated disorder which causes an uncomfortable inflammation of the bowel, and doctors suggested removin
g her Crohn's medication while treating the cancer.

Within six months the cancer had unexpectedly disappeared, leading doctors to conclude that the withdrawal of the drug must have been the cause. Edinburgh Royal Infirmary pathologist Dr William Wallace, the lung cancer specialist who conducted the woman's biopsies, said the chances of the cancer going into remission spontaneously were "so astronomical as to be almost nonexistent".

Dr Janet Ironside, consultant clinical oncologist at the Western General, meanwhile called the woman's case "exceptional".

However, Dr Wallace said there was little chance that their findings could be used to formulate a new cure for cancer.

He added: "The Crohn's drug she was taking suppresses the immune system in order to calm the inflammation. When the drug was removed, the woman's immune system would have kicked in and we believe this may have led to the cancer going into remission.

"However, scientist have tried injecting the proteins that cause the immune response into cancer cells with very little response. As a result, it is likely that this case will become little more than a medical curiosity."

While the case may not be able to help towards a cure for cancer, it may lead to further guidelines to prevent it in future.

The Edinburgh experts have written to the New England Journal of Medicine warning that there is now "real concern" over the risk of cancer associated with the woman's medication, known as anti-TNFs.

Professor Jack Satsangi, professor of gastroenterology at the University of Edinburgh, said: "The last thing we want to do is cause a scare so it's important that these findings are discussed in context.

"Crohn's disease is very serious disorder and these drugs can have life-changing effects for their users, so it will be up to doctors and patients to balance the benefits with any newly-identified risks associated with the drugs."





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 28 July 2008 10:54 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

,

28/07/2008 14:03:08
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
2

alex paterson,

edinburgh 28/07/2008 15:46:12
A very lucky person,all you smokers read and learn.
3

mac77,

Edinburgh 28/07/2008 15:48:21
1 nd 2; either of you got a car? Wheesht then.
4

Voldemort,

Edinburgh 28/07/2008 20:37:28
I am sure it did stun Doctors - they probably don't know what lung cancer is these days !?

1&2 - 'Non-Smokers mostly die horribly too' ... they should get that printed on your bran flakes or you should read about in 'sanctimonious monthly' - either way it's a peach!
5

Voldemort,

Edinburgh 28/07/2008 20:39:29
PS - 1&2 - I don't smoke - just for the record ... I just don't feel inclined to be a prat about folk who choose to ..
6

elayne,

28/07/2008 22:13:08
i am pleased for this lady,i hope continues to make a good recovery
7

celtic4,

USA 29/07/2008 04:20:24
So now what to do about the Chron's that could still kill her whether she smokes or not?
8

markh,

usa 29/07/2008 17:17:33
"However, scientist have tried injecting the proteins that cause the immune response into cancer cells with very little response. As a result, it is likely that this case will become little more than a medical curiosity."

To me (if this is properly quoted) says a lot about western medicine. The notion that "injecting proteins" is the same as the human immune system's response is seemingly typical reductionist thinking. What is it about injecting proteins that is different? Do we try to model the immune system in the form of medication, or maybe there is a way to kick start it like this? Anyway, I find that relegating this case study to the realm of curiosities, is disheartening. Perhaps it better resides in the realm of inspiration.
9

ThomasT,

Phuket Thailand 30/07/2008 03:20:20
Had these doctors bothered to go outside their allowed parameters, they would not have been surprised at a remission, as they would have by now discovered privately published work of cell biologist H R Clark. No controlled medical nor scientific journal would allow this pubication, so she published privately despite threats to imprison her in the USA if she did so. The Cure and Prevention of all Cancers, 2007 proves that science has now moved ahead of the mainstream dogma. It will be impossible for this work to be declared fraudulent, so it will simply be ignored. The cure for scurvy took over 400 years to be accepted, so how long would it take for this work to be accepted? As it would derail a trillion dollar industry, lets say it will not be during our lifetime. The solution is simply to take the responsibilty of your health and life into your own hands. As the causes of cancer are now precisely known, by accurate measurement, this means that the prevention and cure are at your fingertips. You will be surprised at the simplicity of interrupting the malignancy, only within days, and how your body will shrink the tumor. No authority can refuse you to heal yourself, though they will surely discourage you with the false hope line, and tell you to accept that your life is soon over.
10

The Laser Guided Loogie,

Greensboro, NC 30/07/2008 06:36:31
In other news, scientist still haven't been able to suppress the gene that gives rise to insufferable sanctimonious twits...

-Ken
http://www.laserguidedloogie.com
11

Samcafe,

Glasgow 30/07/2008 07:09:45
A modern day miracle, I wonder who was praying for her
12

Ian Vernon,

Oxford 30/07/2008 09:30:26
Here we have an unusual phenomenon and a hypothesis put forward to explain it. In any other science the next step would be to isolate the factors in the hypothesis and try to reproduce the phenomenon. The factor isolated by the hypothesis here is the anti-Chron's drug. Why is it not possible to try treating laboratory animals with cancer with a regime of first giving them the drug until their immune systems are suppressed and then withdrawing it to emulate the circumstances of this woman's supposed cancer cure due to the hypothetical sudden boost in her immune system? Not only could this confirm (or possibly, of course, refute) the hypothesis, it could also subsequently even lead to successful treatment regimes of all cancers.
13

Cynical,

Edinburgh 30/07/2008 11:27:02
#1, #2; and #11 if you don't have anything sensible to say, please refrain.

#12 a man has already been cured of one form of cancer by having his immune system boosted by cultured stem cells. It seems reasonable to deduce that it is the patients immune system which has effected the cure in this case also, even to the point that she might not have contracted cancer at all if she had not developed Chron's.
14

JohnBowes,

31/07/2008 09:22:25
Everybody dies. Many will end up incontinent in geriatric wards. Its not just smokers who die. Those boring mugs who eat "five a day" must also DIE.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.