Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


'Appalling' plan to kill 350 country park deer

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 16 April 2008
A FURIOUS political row has broken out over a planned cull of hundreds of deer at a Lothian a country park.
West Lothian Council has been accused of planning the "slaughter" at Beecraigs Country Park in a bid to save money.

The opposition Labour group on the council claims a herd of around 450 red deer could be culled to 100 over the next two years to s
ave the £70,000.

The ruling SNP-led administration has hit back, describing the claims as "totally off the wall" and insisting the former Labour council routinely culled the farmed herd.

That has not stopped Labour councillors calling for a stay of execution and public consultation on the issue. They have also criticised the administration for the move after it spent £70,000 on a hospitality marquee, £10,000 on a trip to Texas for a twinning venture and ended bonus payments to adults with learning difficulties.

Fauldhouse and Breich Valley councillor, Cathy Muldoon, said: "We have already seen people using adult learning centres in West Lothian lose out because of SNP budget bungling – now our wildlife is also to suffer.

"Given the choice I am sure people would rather their money was spent supporting the continuation of the herd at Beecraigs than on a big tent, which will spend most of its time in storage.

"It is ironic that the red deer stag, the iconic image of Scottish wildlife, is to be slaughtered by an SNP-led council. We are appalled by the decision to order the cull of these beautiful and gentle creatures."

The recommendation to proceed with the cull was taken at a policy meeting on Tuesday, and the decision will now be referred to a meeting of the council executive for ratification.

Council leader Peter Johnston slammed the Labour claims and said there would be almost £1.5 million invested in Beecraigs in the near future following a "decade of Labour neglect".

He added: "Labour's behaviour is becoming more bizarre by the day. The first thing that must be said is that the council has not taken any such decision." He said the deer would always have a future in Beecraigs.

"The deer herd is a highly valued asset and a major visitor attraction. However, the reality is that this is a farmed herd and venison has always been a product harvested from it," he said.

"I should point out to Labour that local farms also produce beef, pork and lamb. I think I should also tell them that the hamburgers they eat at McDonald's are distant relatives of the cow.

"It is a fact that the last Labour administration routinely culled these animals, and proudly introduced a discount for council staff who purchased venison from Beecraigs."





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 16 April 2008 11:25 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: West Lothian
 
1

Mikey,

16/04/2008 12:30:46
Sounds a bit like the Liebour Euro sausage. Just tell lies and then scream and scream until they're thick, sorry...sick....
2

Phil MaGlass,

16/04/2008 12:57:41
OH DEERY ME.
3

Hmmmm,

Glasgow 16/04/2008 13:16:03
Farmers farming animals and selling them for meat is just shocking.

This is not the first instance of Farmers behaving irresponsibly that I have heard of. I believe that some of them clear beautiful fields of carrots and potatoes, leaving great swathes of mud, on an almost annual basis. It must be stopped!

What next, stealing the milk from little baby cows.
4

ValdasTheMan,

Edinburgh 16/04/2008 13:23:45
Perfect timing! Throw another bambie-burger on the barbie.
5

Gina Gibson,

Wales 16/04/2008 13:42:28
Just one little fact missing from this "story".......the deer in this country park are actually kept in an enclosure and you have been able to buy the meat for many years. There is also a trout farm in this country park......are the labour dunderheids going to complain about the "slaughter" of the fish next??
6

Teofilio Cubillas,

16/04/2008 14:02:36
It's alway hilarious reading comments from Labour cooncillors criticising anything the SNP does (and I've never voted for either party).
50 years of Labour hegemony in West Lothian, Lanarkshire and Glasgow provides ample evidence of their abilities in local government, yet they have the gall to criticise the efforts of the SNP after one year. If the SNP can make a worse job of running the country than these dunderheids did, it would be some feat.
7

Teofilio Cubillas,

16/04/2008 14:04:10
And another thing - smoked venison with black pepper and strawberries - delicious!
8

tomias,

Edinburgh 16/04/2008 15:40:33
No 7- a person with good taste.
Animals are for consumption- Advocates for Animals are animals too but I'd make an exception in the aggrevating letter writer to the press.
9

,

16/04/2008 16:18:24
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
10

HeckFarr,

Tennessee 16/04/2008 16:46:56
Deer are vegetables. They're made out of grass and berries.
So, come on Vegans have a slab of charcoal grilled grass and berries off the hoof.
11

dido-bendigo,

Argyll 16/04/2008 17:06:58
A country park deer herd needs a cull of approximately one third of its animals every year. The people complaining were responsible for trying to stop fox hunting. My word, they really know about countryside management! Bring on the turbines and save the eagles from global warming!
12

Brian M,

Edinburgh 16/04/2008 18:05:54
what is the point of having hundreds of deer enclosed unnaturally in a 'deer park'?

If it's to let the kiddiwinkies see Bambi in the flesh then we only need about two or three 'families'.

The forestry commission shoot the beggars and sell them at a profit for the country.

The SNP are quickly weeding out unnecessary calls on council tax money

SNP people have identified yet another waste of council
13

Argyll on line,

Argyll 16/04/2008 18:50:24
As an SNP supporter and animal rights activist I am appalled at this.
14

Saoghal Beag,

16/04/2008 22:10:37
west lothian liebour embark on a policy of hug a deer, cuddle a caw and s h a g a sheep, well they have to find someone to vote for them. like the soon to be culled deer it cheerio cheerio cheerio...
15

Ard Righ,

The Rock Of Edinburgh 17/04/2008 00:21:47
State supplied venison steaks anyone of the annual 20,000 cull?

One wee suggestion though, kill them more ofter and when they are younger, they taste better.
16

Senga Jean,

17/04/2008 00:41:06
This is a deer FARM. EEN did not explain this. The LYING LABOUR COUNCILLOR knows this. The whole story is an ourageous attempt to undermine the SNP.
17

Auld Twa,

Edinburgh 17/04/2008 14:06:45
Their venison is first rate and has been on sale from the days when West Lothian was ruled by Labour.
At least with farmed deer we can be sure that all have been humanely killed not shot by somebody who has paid for the pleasure.
18

THE BPRENTICE,

20/04/2008 14:04:45
expensive? its offa deer!
19

Bravetart,

23/04/2008 20:40:19
Um I hate to break Labour's bubble but if the deer haven't been culled before then where did the venison for sale in the Beescraig shop come from?

I love how Labour now complain about things they have allowed to happen or initiated happening (such as big black holes where the budget should be.)

Venison is very nice, and lower in fat than other red meats. Healthy Scotland, there you go.
20

celtic4,

USA 05/05/2008 18:27:33
Our white tailed deer are in critical mass. In the wild. But a deer farm suits a purpose. If that many are to be culled out, why not give the excess meat to the needy? They do that here when there is a deer hit by a car. Good idea, I think, for the needy. But if it is to be sold, then...why so many being culled out?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.