Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


MMR doctor denies child experiments

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 28 March 2008
THE doctor who controversially linked childhood vaccinations with autism has denied submitting young children to painful tests just to prove his theories.
Dr Andrew Wakefield insisted all tests were clinically necessary to diagnose and treat the youngsters, who were suffering from debilitating bowel diseases and autistic-type symptoms.

The academic caused a furore ten years ago when he suggested t
he MMR vaccination, for mumps, measles and rubella, could cause autism.

Yesterday, he told a General Medical Council disciplinary panel that the children concerned did not undergo any procedures not deemed clinically appropriate.

He claimed all the tests were ordered by the youngsters' doctor, Professor John Walker-Smith, and that all investigations were stopped when they failed to shed light on what was causing the children's problems.

He said: "At all times, our foremost consideration was the well-being of the children."

Dozens of children were put through a range of tests, including painful colonoscopies, lumbar punctures – taking spinal fluid – various brain scans and blood and urine tests.

Dr Wakefield, who is an academic and not a practising clinician, has been accused of breaking rules by ordering the tests against the patients' best interests in order to further his own research.

Dr Wakefield said: "I had no role whatsoever in deciding whether the tests should or should not take place."

He claimed all the parents knew about the research programme and were "very keen" for their children to be included.

He told the GMC panel he began studying the potential link to autism in 1995 after calls from desperate parents who said their previously normal children developed autism after the jab.

That followed his research showing a possible link between MMR and chronic bowel conditions such as Crohn's disease.

He said: "They were telling what turned out to be a remarkably consistent story of a normal child who they had lost, who had lost speech, communication, play, interaction with siblings, had sometimes become incontinent … was bloated, off their food, was losing weight, was failing to thrive."

He said the children had ultimately been diagnosed as autistic and the parents had not been able to find an explanation for what had happened.

Dozens of supporters gathered outside the hearing with banners saying "Stop the witch-hunt" and "We're with Wakefield".

Dr Wakefield, Prof Walker-Smith and their colleague Professor Simon Murch all deny serious professional misconduct. The hearing continues.

PROTESTS
AUTISM campaigners yesterday protested outside the Scottish Parliament, demanding better services for children with the condition.

Fiona Sinclair, of the pressure group Autism Rights, said children are missing out because of a lack of specialist provision in Scotland.

She warned: "We are going to face the situation where we have hundreds of thousands of people with autism completely screwed up by the system and reaching adulthood without having had an education which meets their needs."



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 27 March 2008 9:49 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: MMR vaccine
 
1

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 28/03/2008 01:28:49
"Stop the witch-hunt"
Is exactly what it is!

'Hang Draw and Quarter' for he, 'that speaks the truth'!

200 years ago, if you talked 'Mobile Phones' you would be,

'Burnt at the Stake'.. as a witch!

Same analogy, same human nature!

Don't believe it,?

You!, will be the ones, were laughing at in the not to distant future!
2

Autism Rights,

Ayrshire 28/03/2008 08:45:27
This is my actual media release - which I hope may be covered on UN Autism Awareness Day:-

Autism Rights is holding a demonstration outside of the Scottish parliament on Thursday 27th March between 11.30 a.m. and 2 p.m. to mark Autism Awareness Day.

The United Nations has decided to designate, from this year, the 2nd of April as Autism Awareness Day. However, as the parliament will be in recess on that day, we have chosen this Thursday as the day for our demonstration. On this same day, parents will be holding a demonstration in London outside of the GMC Hearing that is investigating Dr. Andrew Wakefield and 2 of his former colleagues from the Royal Free Hospital in London.

Whilst the media and medical establishment choose to pursue a scientist who has suggested one possible cause for the `autism epidemic`, they ignore the ongoing scandal of the state of service provision for people with an Autistic Spectrum Disorder (ASD) in the UK. This provision, where it exists at all, is incompetent and uncaring, resulting in years of distress and struggle for most families with a son or daughter with an ASD.

Autism Rights is the only national group in Scotland campaigning for the
rights of people with an Autistic Spectrum Disorder and their families that is led by service users. We have published our `Proposals for Autism Services in Scotland` on our website at:-

http://www.autismrights.org.uk/AutismRightsProposals.html
3

Autism Rights,

Ayrshire 28/03/2008 08:49:12
(continued)
Autism Rights is emailing all MSPs, calling on them to support our Proposals, for the following reasons:-

* Since the publication of the Public Health Institute for Scotland's (PHIS) report on Autistic Spectrum Disorders (ASD) in 2001, there has been no improvement to services for people with an ASD, in spite of a plethora of `initiatives` and talking shops.

* Key human rights of both people with ASD and their families have been
dismantled. This process is detailed in the Autism Rights Briefing Paper
(see - http://www.autismrights.org.uk/BriefingPaperIndex.html )

* Nearly 7 years on from the publication of the PHIS report, there are still no standards of service provision that are specific to ASD, no enforcement of any generic standards and no accountability of service providers to service users - all of which combine to deny people with ASD and their families their human rights.

* The absence of standards, enforcement, accountability and rights have led to a massive waste of taxpayers' money on services and initiatives that are, quite simply, `designed to fail`. We know that this overall failure suppresses demand - we hope that this is not its intention.

* Almost 7 years since the publication of the PHIS report, neither central nor local government can detail the numbers of people with ASD. Without such statistics, it is impossible to initiate forward or proactive planning for people with this disability.

* We trust that MSPs will listen directly to service user groups such as
Autism Rights, who understand and experience first-hand the deficiencies of service provision. We regret that the closure of the parliament's Cross Party Group on ASD has ended direct contact between service users and MSPs and call for the reinstatement of that contact and of the Cross Party Group, to facilitate service user input to policy and legislation. It is appalling that the holistic expertise of parents and unpaid carers should be ignored by legisl
4

Autism Rights,

Ayrshire 28/03/2008 08:50:39
The European Charter of Rights for Persons with Autism is reproduced at -
http://osiris.sunderland.ac.uk/autism/aeright2.htm
5

scottish person,

paisley 28/03/2008 08:59:12
They should give Andrew Wakefield a medal. Every doctor who gives an mmr jag receives £100. No wonder they try to pressure parents into giving their child the jag. I have a friend who lost his son to a jag, a perfectly normal child, now with 80% brain deficiency.
They also dont take into consideration that autism does not show up for at least four years after the mmr.
6

seanie,

28/03/2008 09:05:51
Wakefield claimed that MMR was associated with the sudden onset of autism, not four years later.
7

jj veritas,

28/03/2008 09:07:03
What they don't tell you.

Only 4 in 100,000 children caught mumps until about 1988 and the trend was steadily downwards. With MMR about 1 per 100,000 catch mumps. MMR achieved a figure that was probably on the cards anyway. With about 700,000 babies born each year the situation was effectively under control.

However, the cost of going to the doctors three times for three separate jabs is at least three times more costly to the government than a single jab (and doctors and nurses don't come cheap). Plus think of the administration etc. So much cheaper to give one multiple jab.

And government often forget to mention that the MMR panic started well before this doctor’s piece of research.

In 1997 after reading in the national press that 2,000 mothers in the Manchester area alone whose children had been damaged by, they thought, MMR had formed an action group, my wife and I decided to go the single jab route for our child. It was available in Edinburgh but oh did the government try to stop us –however, that is too outrageous a story to tell.
8

Autism Rights,

28/03/2008 10:06:30
- continued from post 3, where the paragraph was truncated, in spite of not showing this initially:-

* We trust that MSPs will listen directly to service user groups such as
Autism Rights, who understand and experience first-hand the deficiencies of service provision. We regret that the closure of the parliament's Cross Party Group on ASD has ended direct contact between service users and MSPs and call for the reinstatement of that contact and of the Cross Party Group, to facilitate service user input to policy and legislation. It is appalling that the holistic expertise of parents and unpaid carers should be ignored by legislators, particularly when there is such a recognised deficit of professional expertise in Scotland.

* It is not acceptable to us that we should be told by politicians that the human rights of our sons and daughters are covered by current Human Rights legislation, when they are not. The Human Rights Act is dependent on other legislation for its use and there is no disability legislation or regulation that is specific to ASD to usefully support the rights of a disability that is quite different from either learning, physical or sensory disabilities. It is precisely because of the unique nature of ASD that the European Parliament decided to adopt the European Charter on the Rights of Persons with Autism in 1996, as an interpretation of the Human Rights Act for people with ASD.
9

G,

dndy 28/03/2008 11:28:43
What the main problem with Wakefield's research was that it did not provide any clear link of MMR with bowel diesase and/or autism
however it caused a media storm which led to many people not immunising their children
Research since has shown no link but now his research has achieved mythical underdog status and cannot be countermanded by any other evidence without claims of witch hunt, cover-up or conspiracy....
There may be a link between bowel disease and the onset of autistic symptoms in children who are prone to autism but belief in wakefield's flawed and inaccurate work and link to MMR may actually obscure this research...
10

Neil,

Glasgow 28/03/2008 11:37:05
The MMR autism scare is statistically wrong.

However the interesting thing is the different reaction to this & to other scare stories.

The passive smoking "evidence" is similiarly statistical fakery, as is the that for mobile phones/electricity pylons causing cancer, low level radiation doing the same, salt being harmful, ditto ordinary levels of obesity, or odinary levels of alcohol during pregnancy & of course the entire global warming (& previous ice age) scams.

The only difference appears to be that injecting children is a government business which it is inconvenient to interfere with, while all the others are individaul or corporate choices & a damn good excuse for government empire builders to regulate us further.
11

Gdgy,

28/03/2008 17:39:48
everbody I know had their children immunised with MMR - no cases of autism...does this prove anything? No.
But if you cherry pick autistic children and "prove" that they have measles virus in bowel tissue this apparently does......
12

,

28/03/2008 19:49:15
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
13

Reckless,

Corrupt EU 29/03/2008 12:20:35
Will Homeland Security (the Militarized Police State) Shock You Into Submission?

http://www.infowars.com/?p=995

BTW, most witches (likes of Hillary Clinton) were hanged. Few people were burned for witch craft.
14

fife runner,

04/04/2008 07:57:55
Wakefield was also paid by the lawyers representing anti MMR groups. Also his colleagues deserted him as they realised what he was doing. He was given air time by press more interested in scare stories then fact. He can not say single jabs are safe , just as he cannot say MMR is unsafe. Neither will anyone say for fact MMR is safe. All medicines are prone to some side effects in some. However, Japan banned the MMR in early 90s and autism shot up as did deaths from the diseases they had all but eradicated. Autism by Wakefields standards should have then gone down.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.