Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Galileo statue scrapped – does Vatican still resent man who said Earth goes round the Sun?

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 30 January 2009
VATICAN officials have scrapped plans for a statue of Galileo Galilei, the astronomer who was convicted of heresy 400 years ago.
Galileo – called the father of science by Albert Einstein – infuriated the Roman Catholic Church when he went against its teachings by arguing that the Earth orbited the Sun. The Church said the Earth was the centre of the universe, so Galileo was qu
estioned as part of the Roman Inquisition in 1633.

He went on trial and was found guilty and initially sentenced to prison, though this was changed to house arrest. As he left court he is said to have famously shouted "Eppure si muove" ("But it does move").

More than 450 years later, in 1992, after a 13-year reconsideration of the case, Pope John Paul II admitted that the Church had made a "tragic mistake'' in rejecting Galileo's views and even apologised to him.

The statue, which was due to have been placed in the Vatican gardens, was intended as part of the 400th anniversary celebrations this year of Galileo's development of the telescope and astronomical findings.

Vatican observers had said the plans showed another step towards his rehabilitation, so the announcement yesterday at the Vatican that it had been scrapped came as a surprise.

Monsignor Gianfranco Ravasi, the Vatican's culture chief, said: "The project has been shelved for the moment. A preparatory sketch for the statue had been made, but it has been decided not to go ahead."

Mgr Ravasi would not explain why the decision had been taken but added: "There was a sponsor who was then told to spend the money on a scientific project in Africa."

The statue to Galileo was to have stood outside the Pontifical Academy of Science, and Mgr Ravasi went on to say that the Church was ready to "further reconsider the Galileo case".

He said: "The time is now ripe for a fresh reconsideration of the whole Galileo case. Galileo deserves all our appreciation and gratitude."

Mgr Ravasi added that the Vatican would mark the 400th anniversary with conferences and books, including a new edition of the acts of his Inquisition trial and a critical look at its own 1992 apology.

One Vatican insider said: "It looks like the Church still has it in for Galileo even though this all happened almost five centuries ago."

Last year Pope Benedict XVI was forced to call off a visit to Rome University after staff and students accused him of defending the Inquisition's condemnation of Galileo.

They were angry at a speech the Pope had made in 1990, as Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, in which he quoted a description of the trial of Galileo as "fair and reasonable" and accused him of "despising science".

Vatican officials will also participate in a conference in Florence on the affair in May, gathering all the key Church institutions for the first time since Galileo's condemnation.

Galileo, who died in 1642 aged 78, still under house arrest, created his first telescope in 1608 and discovered three of Jupiter's moons and the various phases of Venus.

The two sets of observations played a crucial role in his conclusion that the Sun, rather than the Earth, was at the centre of the universe, as was commonly believed at the time.

The Vatican said that 2009, being the UN-designated International Year of Astronomy, represented for the Holy See an "important occasion for deeper research and dialogue".

It added: "There is a binding connection between contemplating the starred skies and religion. In almost all cultures and civilisations observing the sky is impregnated with a profound sense of religion.

"By watching the movement of the planets, Man has sought to discover the answer to their deepest questions. Even the Bible conserves this ancient knowledge, underlined by the power of God's creativity."



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 29 January 2009 9:56 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Roman Catholic church
 
1

,

30/01/2009 05:58:12
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
2

Mcsnagpile,

30/01/2009 05:58:42
Such irony, the Pope has recently been excommunicated for having a heretic bishop; who does not believe six million Jews were gassed by anti lice pellets and incinerated using millions of tons of coal.

How times change.
3

St Caledonia,

30/01/2009 09:17:13
We must remember that almost ALL religious institutions are companies.
God, Jesus and the bible is their product.
Of course if Jesus was ever to return as the bible says he will, it would ruin all of their business interests, thus they must all pray that he never comes back.
They preach that god exists because it is good for business, but if a god ever did come down from the clouds it would be the last thing they would want to see.
The Vatican probably want to distance themselves from Galileo becuase he reminds them of their infallibility.
I am not fooled for once second by the Vatican hierachy and I honestly believe that most of them are athiests who USE the god hypothesis for reasons of power.
Imagine god decided he was coming to rule? What would the Vatican do? they would be out of business
4

albanman,

30/01/2009 09:48:46
No 3 StCaledonia: Are you on drugs?
5

Oor Waleed,

30/01/2009 10:05:36
No 4:

No, but they should be.
6

Mad Jock,

East Lothian 30/01/2009 10:08:28
I see Al Gore as the Pope of the Global Warming movement. Anyone who disagrees with his dogma would be tortured and placed under house arrest, in an envornmental and green way, of course. No red hot pokers allowed, as that would mean burning fossil fuels. Of course, the hapless prisoner could be forced to use his carbon credits for this, so it might be allowed after all.
By 2099, when the world has not come to a choking, famine riddled end, the then Pope, Al Gore IVX, wearing his white snow suit, would issue an apology from his centrally heated jumbo jet, saying that perhaps, oops, they got it wrong.
The Vatican has got it wrong for centuries. This is not news. Despite all the evidence to the contrary, it continued to live in denial, and forced others to do so as well. I cannot think of a single issue where the Vatican has been proved right and the scientific community wrong.
7

FLUB,

a rocky outcrop in eastern central Scotland 30/01/2009 10:09:41
This is the start of an exercise in Vatican self-rehabilitation.

The history will be rewritten to show that Galileo was invited to participate in dialogue in a "fair and reasonable" manner and that both sides reached a mutual understanding based on their respective positions and that Galileo then 'retired' to continue his studies.

They've already done this with the documents that were mysteriously 'found' a few years ago that purported to show the then current Pope did not in fact reach a concordat with the Nazis but actively worked to destabilise the regime.

These are not for our benefit just now, but to traduce future generations.
8

Maximus,

Roberton 30/01/2009 10:19:29
No 7, you can think what you want about the Catholic Church, but it appears to be ill informed. See below two links one for Galileo, and the other on Pope Pius. I hope they help.

http://www.ewtn.com/library/HOMELIBR/GALILEO.HTM

http://www.ewtn.com/library/ANSWERS/PIUSJEWS.HTM

And yes, it is sad that plans for a statue have been scrapped.
9

FLUB,

a rocky outcrop in eastern central Scotland 30/01/2009 11:54:20
#8. Links on EWTN, the Vatican's Satellite TV & Radio station? I don't think so.
10

Jay Kay,

30/01/2009 12:37:27
If i've said it once i've said it a thousand times, why do you think chuurch goers are referred to as "the flock", it's because they are all mindless sheep, BAHHHH. Numpties every one of them, daft enough to leave all their worldly goods to the church thinking some poor person will benefit, aye right, ma errse.
11

,

30/01/2009 14:13:27
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
12

St Caledonia,

30/01/2009 14:35:32
Albaman; Why would you bring drugs into this?

Think about it - The Vatican, all powerful!
If they got wind that Jesus was on the way back they would need to make him disappear or their free meal ticket would be over.
It is not that difficult understand!
However, we all know that there will be return of any messiah because the scribes ressurected Jesus in a masterly stroke of genius. By saying he was returning they bought themselves power for eternity -
13

Matt there,

Somewhere 30/01/2009 17:01:10
"One Vatican insider"?

That's when a journalist makes up a clever remark and they pass it of as bieng from: "an insider."

Either that or it is a mate of theirs down the boozer...
14

,

30/01/2009 19:50:47
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
15

Douglas,

Bathgate 01/02/2009 17:12:38
Still attending those tolerance classes Ribbonman? 'mon the 'tic eh?
16

Billiam Wallace,

17/03/2009 09:08:17
Hilarious that the richest organisation in the world scrapped these plans because a sponsor pulled out! So they haven't enough dosh kicking about the place to pay for a wee statue to a man that they wronged. Maximus Stupidicus wishes to defend the RCC and posts links to a website written by Catholics about a comittee investigating the church's treatment of Gallileo. Only trouble is the commitee were also of the RCC, so their findings are suspect at best. Well done Maximus, an exercise in blind following of a failed religion.

Seems the flock is still full of sheep with the wool hanging over their eyes.

Saor Alba

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.