Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Nurses call for licensed brothels to protect health of prostitutes

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 11 May 2009
NURSES want councils to be allowed to license brothels in an effort to improve the health and safety of sex workers.
The Royal College of Nursing's annual conference will this week hear calls for the issue of licensed brothels to be considered by all UK governments.

Nurses believe many of the physical and mental health problems suffered by sex workers could be a
lleviated if brothels were licensed.

But previous attempts to create "tolerance zones" for prostitutes in Scotland have failed and many remain opposed to legalising the sex industry.

The RCN meeting in Harrogate, which begins today, will hear nurses outline why licensing brothels will benefit both sex workers and their clients.

Stuart McKenzie, a community psychiatric nurse in Glasgow, said he worked with women and men involved in the sex industry.

"These individuals are involved in a very risky industry in terms of their physical health, mental health and safety. They are under the radar of the law so it is a very risky industry. They face dangers from the people who organise it and their customers."

Mr McKenzie told The Scotsman some of his patients suffered post-traumatic stress disorder as a result of being badly beaten or raped, adding: "Licensing would bring it all above the radar and give them that security and safety."

In Scotland, keeping a brothel is a criminal offence, though it is not always strictly enforced, the RCN said. Sex workers can operate from saunas or from private premises. Police operations have focused on private flats where it has been alleged that illegally trafficked women are forced to work against their will.

Mr McKenzie said a regulated system could stop vulnerable men and women entering the industry in the first place.

He added that many sex workers operated of their own free will in the escort industry, earning large sums of money.

"I don't see them," Mr McKenzie said. "I see people plying a trade off street corners through the organised sex industry who present with low self-esteem, having been the victims of physical and sexual abuse, both by customers and their employers. They have potentially been victims their whole life."

Mr McKenzie admitted licensing would have to come with caveats. He said: "Would they be covered by employment law? Would they pay national insurance contributions?"

Mr McKenzie admitted that not every nurse would be comfortable in supporting the idea of licensed brothels. But he added: "A licensed brothel would be better than the situation we have now."

George Lewis, co-chairman of the Scottish Prostitutes Education Project, said he would support proper licensing of brothels by local authorities. "Mental health is an issue that is often forgotten in the industry," he said.

A spokeswoman for the Scottish Government said:

"Our strategy on prostitution aims to raise awareness among the general population to dispel some of the myths and misconceptions associated with prostitution."

PATIENT SAFETY FEARS 'IGNORED'

NEARLY two-thirds of nurses in Scotland have raised concerns about patient safety with their bosses – but more than one in three say no action was ever taken.

The Royal College of Nursing (RCN) Scotland also said almost a quarter of the 571 Scottish nurses surveyed (24 per cent) were discouraged or told directly not to report concerns at their workplace. Only 43 per cent felt confident a health board or employer would protect them if they spoke up.

A Scottish Government spokes-woman said: "NHS Scotland and the government have developed a range of policies to encourage employees to raise concerns without fear of penalty or victimisation."

"We want to do all we can to prevent individuals from becoming involved and to support those already involved to develop routes out – but legislation and enforcement are just part of the solution."





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 10 May 2009 10:40 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Prostitution
 
1

SandyBottoms,

Edinburgh 11/05/2009 09:21:28
This is sound advice, and I sincerely hope the Scottish Parliament takes heed. When any activity is forced underground because it is illegal, it automatically becomes more dangerous for the people who do it. Education and the spread of information is very important to safety, and you cannot have effective education about a matter if it is illegal.

And just think what they'd make on taxes!
2

Alternative (High-Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 11/05/2009 11:03:11
Sounds fair enough to me.
3

Teofilio Cubillas,

11/05/2009 11:29:20
I don't disagree with the idea of licensed brothels (although street prostitution will still occur because of women who are underage or wouldn't pass any health tests and men who wouldn't want to use brothels for fear of being found out) but the idea of tolerance zones is a disgrace. That said, if Margo MacDonald or Tom Wood suggest that the zone should include their home streets, I may reconsider.
4

bluehead,

edinburgh 11/05/2009 12:43:24
about time too,it' no wonder their is so much hang ups about sex,
5

Viktor Smirnoff,

11/05/2009 12:52:27
I'm sure there are some MSPs who still have palpitations when tampons are advertised on the telly. Decriminalising brothels makes a very good deal of sense, but it surely makes better sense to licence not the buildings but the brothel managers, subjecting the buildings instead to planning consent, as in New Zealand.

One has to remember throughout the process that the higher the barriers that are set, the lower the compliance rate is likely to be, so if you really want to maximise advantages in terms of HIV Aids/STI reduction, violence minimisation and improved communication over trafficking victims, it is important to keep costs and bureaucracy to a minimum.

In Scotland, a good rule of thumb is usually to find out whatever Glasgow Council is doing and do the opposite.
6

Chuck.U.Farley,

11/05/2009 13:26:17
Great idea,the MPs can then be reinbursted on expenses.
7

Joe Macdelta.,

nly coun 11/05/2009 15:30:17
I dont see why not there is a market for it, there must be or people wouldnt be doing it now, there always has, Good idea.
8

Caora Dubh,

Croit sheasgair 11/05/2009 21:19:11
This country is still living in the Dark Ages when it comes to prostitution. City councils should run legally licensed premises under strict rules: (1) No pimps or managers with criminal records. (2) All sex workers to receive regular medical check-ups. (3) Premises to be subject to sanitary and fire inspections. (4) 24 hour security to be on hand, capable of being summoned by alarm buttons in each room and remote alarms carried by each worker. (5) Regular account keeping & taxation, though arrangements should be made for taxation under anonymous codes if prostitutes so desire. (6) Safe, well-lit environment both inside and outside the premises. (7) Full access to drug rehabilitation services, as prostitution is very often linked to drug addiction. (8) Full & voluntary access to educational and vocational services to help those who wish to find other careers. (9) No council members to use the services of prostitutes working within their jurisdiction. After a few thousand years isn't it time that the government realised that criminalising prostitution hasn't stopped it, but driven it into the hands of the people-and-drug traffickers, and resulted in thousands of desperate, poverty-stricken women being brutally assaulted and killed? Frankly, I believe that successive hypocritical Westminster governments have as much blood on their hands as the pimps, misogynists, thugs and murderers who have attacked these women (and men) over the years. The ministers responsible must have been demonstrably mentally retarded not to legalise and sanitise prostitution. Give Ms Lind St Clair's prodigious efforts over the years I can only imagine that ministers were deaf, blind, and stupid.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Today's Vote

Should the police be asking the public to take note of kerbcrawlers’ registrations?
Yes, everyone should do their bit to fight crime.
No, it’s the police’s duty to police, not ours.
No, what if the wrong number is noted by mistake?

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.