Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Trams bring more turmoil for Alistair Darling

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 05 December 2008
HE may be busy bailing out banks and trying to revive an ailing economy, but just like everyone else in Edinburgh, Alistair Darling gets frustrated at being held up by the Capital's tram works.
If the Chancellor needs time to think about the next stage in Britain's recovery plan, he might find it while he is stuck in traffic at the West End.

"I went to collect someone from Haymarket station a couple of weeks ago," he recalls. "And it too
k me about 40 minutes to get from one end of Morrison Street to the other.

"I'm not going to be a back-seat driver, but all I can say is it must be possible to manage the roadworks better."

In an interview before he addressed Edinburgh businessmen at a Chamber of Commerce dinner last night, Mr Darling – MP for Edinburgh South-West – concedes some disruption was inevitable with such a major project.

"I'm in no position to tell the council which streets need to be done when," he says. "But I just think at the moment it is terribly disruptive and I do get an awful lot of complaints from shopkeepers and constituents, especially in Dalry. And the worst of it is it's not due to finish for another couple of years yet."

One of Mr Darling's previous jobs in the Government was as Transport Secretary and he hints Edinburgh could benefit from a measure he introduced down south.

"I spent four years doing transport and one of the pieces of legislation we passed, though it doesn't apply in Scotland, was to give local authorities power and a duty to manage traffic properly. It's devolved, so it's up to the Scottish Parliament to decide whether it wants to do it or not.

"But I really think officials and councillors need to sit down and see whether or not they can't phase this work.

"It's amazing what you can do if you want to manage these things. You can sit down and go through these intelligently and say 'How do we make sure we don't have too much being dug up at the same time?'. Otherwise you get gridlock."

The Chancellor is accepting rather than enthusiastic about the trams project. "Because it's devolved I've never had to look at the case for it. My view on balance is it will be good for the city.

"This city is a vibrant, cosmopolitan place, people like to live here and anything that can encourage people to come here, that's a good thing."

But his frustration at the roadworks seems to be based not only on personal inconvenience but the deterrent effect the disruption is having on consumers.

"As Chancellor I want people to be going in to shops and buying goods.

"There are all these posters up in shops in the middle of Edinburgh saying VAT's been cut and I'm keen to encourage them to go and spend their money."

Mr Darling is generally upbeat about the prospects for Edinburgh's economy despite the crisis which has engulfed HBOS and the Royal Bank of Scotland.

He says: "Although this has been extremely difficult and extremely worrying for people who work for banks, I believe we will get through this. The next year is going to be tough. But the World Bank, for example, estimates the world economy will double in the next 20 years.

"That is a massive opportunity for financial institutions – it's not just the banks in Edinburgh, you've got Standard Life, Scottish Widows, investment houses, pensions. There are huge opportunities not just to sell into the UK economy, but to sell into Europe and the rest of the world. So I remain optimistic that, despite the fact there has been a huge knock this year, the financial services industry will get through it.

"Edinburgh is the second biggest financial centre outside London and there are a lot of strengths here. Even in the dark days, we should not forget there is good quality employment here and good opportunities in the future."

As well as having to cope with the global financial crisis, Mr Darling also finds time to be a constituency MP, and recently spoke up against the council's plans to close Westburn Primary School in Wester Hailes.

And he says he is sorry the campaign to save it was unsuccessful.

"I visited the school and met the head teacher and staff and I was very impressed by the school. I'm sorry it was closed on the casting vote of the provost. I think it was a good school."

Mr Darling is also arguing against the closure of a post office in his constituency, despite the fact he was the Secretary of State who began the closure programme.

Oxgangs post office was added to the UK-wide hit list after two other city branches were spared.

But Mr Darling says: "I talked to the postmaster and also the extremely enthusiastic manager of a small supermarket in the same parade and I'll do what I would always do, put my constituents' case to the Post Office – and I hope they will look at it again.

"There are particular circumstances – it's halfway up a hill, there are quite a lot of elderly people who use it." He says when he was Secretary of State he sought to establish what size of post office network was viable, but added each case had to be judged on its merits.

He says there was never a target of 2500 closures, but rather criteria – like people in urban areas being within a mile of a post office – which led to around that number of branches being earmarked to shut.

"On top of that, we have put £1.7 billion into the Post Office to support it," he said. "It's still losing money and it will always lose money. It is a social service and that's important.

"But if we hadn't done something you would have had haphazard closures all over the place, which would have meant great gaps in provision."

The Chancellor even joined the fight to stop Tesco closing down a supermarket, which he says was a handy store for people in Wester Hailes.

"They built a new Tesco down at Hermiston Gait opposite B&Q, but that resulted in the loss of the store at Wester Hailes.

"It's a pity because a lot of people in Wester Hailes don't have access to cars and you simply can't get to Hermiston Gait without a car – even with a car, it's difficult to find."

Eight years ago, when he was Social Security Secretary, Mr Darling gave an interview talking about the strains his job placed on family life, and was later forced to deny it was a signal he might be thinking of stepping down.

And he says he has no plans to go now either. "I've been Chancellor of the Exchequer at a time of unprecedented turbulence throughout the world and I have always relished the challenge.

"John Smith once said to me a job that isn't difficult isn't a job at all."

IN HIS OWN WORDS . .

On trams
"I'm not going to be a back-seat driver, but all I can say is it must be possible to manage the roadworks better."

"As Chancellor I want people to be going into to shops any buying goods.

"There are all these posters up in shops in the middle of Edinburgh saying VAT's been cut and I'm keen to encourage them to go and spend their money."

On Edinburgh's financial sector
"The next year is going to be tough. But the World Bank, for example, estimate the world economy will double in the next 20 years. That is a massive opportunity for financial institutions.

"Even in the dark days, we should not forget there is good quality employment here and good opportunities in the future."

On the global downturn
"If we had been talking about this a year ago and you had said imagine there wouldn't be an investment bank left in Wall Street, people would have laughed.

"I said I thought it would be the worst for 60 years. The legitimate criticism that could be made is that it might more accurately have been 80 or 90."

On Westburn Primary
"I visited the school and met the headteacher and staff and I was very impressed by the school and I'm sorry it was closed on the casting vote of the provost. I think it was a good school. It was a very happy school."

On Oxgangs Post Office
"I talked to the postmaster and also the extremely enthusiastic manager of a small supermarket in the same parade and I'll do what I would always do – put my constituents' case to the Post Office – and I hope they will look at it again.

"There are particular circumstances - it's half way up a hill, there are quite a lot of elderly people use it."

On Tesco at Wester Hailes
"They built a new Tesco down at Hermiston Gait opposite B&Q, but that resulted in the loss of the store at Wester Hailes. It's a pity because a lot of people in Wester Hailes don't have access to cars and you simply can't get to Hermiston Gait without a car - even with a car, it's difficult to find."

On HBOS
"Whatever happens to HBOS, whether the merger goes ahead or whether somebody even at this stage came along, there are going to be difficult decisions to be made, simply because they built their business on a particular business model that no longer exists.



Page 1 of 1

 
1

person who's right,

Edinburgh 05/12/2008 11:47:57
Here Mr Chancellor Sir, why not have a 1000-word propaganda piece in today’s paper?

We’ll just print whatever you send us.

Cheers.

The Edinburgh Evening News.
2

The Leith Cowboy BAM BAM,

Bruxelles 05/12/2008 11:59:38
I am actually crying through the boredom of tears.

3

Brian Ferrari,

05/12/2008 12:05:40
Maybe an election in the offing?
4

Hmm ...,

05/12/2008 12:13:35
... so does Mr Darling think that everythings going well in Edinburgh?

Well, why would he? Or anyone else?

Yet "on balance" he thinks that Edinburgh's trams is good for Edinburgh - having put a stop to tram projects in England when he was Transport Secretary!
5

Amenemhat,

05/12/2008 12:25:00
Is he trying to say the Road works are the SNP Governments fault? what zombie he is
6

Bob 2,

05/12/2008 12:26:18
Mr Darling – MP for Edinburgh South-West – concedes some disruption was inevitable with such a major project.


SOME DISRUPTION - understatement to say the least

Mr Darling stick to your daytime job, mind you,
You aren't doing that too well either.

Shows you how often he supports Local Businesses, if this is the first time he's been stuck in congestion
7

Here we go again,

05/12/2008 12:35:25
Indeed #4 - Mr Darling managed to do absolutely nothing for transport during his tenure as Transport Secretary. All he was bothered about was not asking the Treasury to invest in any infrastructure; knowing the Chancellor job was his when TB stepped down. The 'Do Nothing ' Man.
8

Pai Mei,

05/12/2008 12:42:56
Strange, the trams don't go anywhere near Morrison Street.
9

Thomas the Tank,

Edinburgh 05/12/2008 12:47:07
Well, at least Badger-Face Darling now knows the meaning of the West Lothian Question. As a Scottish MP, and sometime Transport Minister for Englandshire and other bits except Scotland, he was able to pull the plug on various crackpot tramcar schemes down there. But he's powerless to prevent Embra Cooncil plunging his own constituency into chaos for minimal benefit and massive financial risk!
10

Saintee,

Edinburgh 05/12/2008 12:48:44
He was going to pick up someone from Haymarket. Why wasn't he on the bus/ bike/ walking and why wasn't the "someone" using a bus / bike etc?

It's because sometimes there is no alternative to the car isn't it Alistair? Or is it one rule for you and your kind and another for the rest of us?
11

capy,

embra 05/12/2008 12:51:23
Labour dont shut Post Offices or Schools,do they?

What was that.They do.Well i will be dammed.
12

Top Floor,

05/12/2008 12:53:54
#8 Pai Mei

Morrison St connects to Haymarket ..... where all the tram work is going on ????
13

Pai Mei,

05/12/2008 13:05:04
#12 - Aha! Buts just one bit, the very end, which is really only a couple of metres where the boundaries of the two areas meet.

14

Uncle Piehead,

05/12/2008 13:14:41
Never get out of the f****** boat
15

The Diplomat,

EDINBURGH 05/12/2008 13:19:23
Doesn't he share a constituency office in Leith Walk with Malky Chisholm MSP, the tram nutter?
16

Curious Yellow,

Edinburgh 05/12/2008 13:28:16
#13 - a couple of meters, maybe, but that's enough to snarl up the whole of the West End.
17

Arrow,

edinburgh 05/12/2008 13:40:58
i hear that they are opening a new ward in the Western for people that have been tramatised by all of the roadworks.
18

Pai Mei,

05/12/2008 13:48:24
#16 - But it still not Morrison street. Haymarket more like.
19

Skip McClendon,

05/12/2008 14:19:59
The excessive cost and shambolic management of the tramline scheme are enough to turn one's hair grey. Though not, perhaps, one's eyebrows.
20

One-man-bucket's older twin,

05/12/2008 14:20:04
18 Pai Mei - use your brain-cell - Morrison Street is nose-to-tail from about 1530 onwards. Traffic reaching the junction with the approach road is held up by the HUGE lorry delivering carpets to the shop at the end of Grove street, (parked there most days for hours) and half the drivers rat-running Grove Street don't realise they have to use the middle lane if they want to turn up Dalry Road, so they block people in Grove Street wanting to use the approach road. I'm surprised it only took him 40 minutes.
21

Doh,

05/12/2008 14:28:16


More New Labour Double Speak.

This charlatan votes to close Post Offices at Westminster then protests when one closes in his own constituency.

Just like to point out if Darling, Griffiths and the other Labour MPs had actually voted against the Post Office closure program, they would still be open.

Lets bomb Iraq.

You can fool most Labour voters most of time.
22

Toast,

05/12/2008 14:34:24
More propeganda from the Evening "labour" News,Daling has now held every cabinet post and proved to be equally inept at them all,his reduction of VAT costing the exchequer £14.2 billion and the average small business £300.00 [to implement] must go down in history as one of the biggest wastes of public money [yes remember it is OUR money] in recent history,but the evening news still tells us how wonderful Mr Darling is.
23

The Leith Cowboy BAM BAM,

Bruxelles 05/12/2008 14:46:15
Da Ling the grey heeded silver fox was later seen trying to eat a skirt in Benson and Hedges on Princess street. The Silver guy chased him away , too much shiny competition isnt good on the body popping eech nee san chee scene.

Please stop me from doing this.
24

The Leith Cowboy BAM BAM,

Bruxelles 05/12/2008 14:47:21
"He was going to pick someone up from Haymarket toilets and then go to the Fudge shop"
25

Pai Mei,

05/12/2008 14:50:44
#20 - Don't use insults to cover up the fact that you're clealry wrong.

I was commenting that Morrison street has NOTHING TO DO WITH THE TRAMS.

Next time, read, re-read, pick up hand, smack your face.
26

UPR,

05/12/2008 15:32:34
Oh dear #25. The road works at Haymarket ARE to do with the trams. It is these roadworks which are causing delays on Morrison Street, ergo the tram works are the cause of the delays on Morrison Street. If the tram works were not happening on Morrison Street the delays on Morrison Street would not be occurring. Not that difficult to understand if you have to drive there every day!
27

Duncan in Edinburgh,

05/12/2008 15:38:17
#25 Are you enjoying picking fights today?
28

Pai Mei,

05/12/2008 15:47:07
#27 - As much as you're clrearly enjoying beating off in an orgy of smug satisfaction.
29

Skip McClendon,

05/12/2008 16:05:45
Damn, I've got a training course in Morrison street next week. Was planning on getting the train, so I am alarmed to hear that Morrison Street is "nowhere near" the Haymarket crossroads. Guess maybe I'd better get a taxi...
30

The Leith Cowboy BAM BAM,

Bruxelles 05/12/2008 16:21:41
Seriously though , they do write a lot of guff in this newspaper.

Morrison Street miles away from haymarket , and foxes entering shops in broad daylight , 2 hours after it gets dark.

Theres more truth in the viz.
31

Pai Mei,

05/12/2008 16:25:14
#29 - You work at SWB then? Don't worry, yule (merry xmas!) still be able to get the trams in the future, Morrison street connects with Haymarket.

However the tram works have nothing to do with the tailbacks and everything to do with poor traffic light management.
32

Skip McClendon,

05/12/2008 16:29:13
#29

Nope, I don't work at SWB.

I would catch the tram, but my course is next week and, despite my request, they can't hold off until 2063 or whenever the tramline is finally completed.
33

Skip McClendon,

05/12/2008 16:35:26
Oops, I meant #31.

Oh, and thanks for the festive greeting! Merry Christmas / Happy Hanukkah / A Joyful Diwali/ Terrific Tet / Peaceful Ramadan etc.

Good night, and may your God go with you! :-)
34

Pai Mei,

05/12/2008 17:06:13
^-^
O
35

Euan,

Edinburgh 05/12/2008 17:08:10
The traffic on Morrison Street is an absolute JOKE just now.

A couple of weeks ago it took me 35 minutes to get from the end of Gardner's Crescent to the the lights at the bottom of Morrison Street.

The amount of time that vehicles like buses, taxis, delivery vans, lorries, trade vehicles lose sitting stuck in a jam on Morrison Street must be amounting to tens of thousands of hours of lost productivity.

This is what is being conveniently brushed aside when the silly figures of '£592 million' etc, etc are bandied around for the cost of this insane project.

The local economy is losing money hand over fist, businesses are closing, millions of pounds worth of trade is going down the pan, Lothian Buses' passenger numbers are way down, and the tram fiasco is 100% to blame for this.

The attempted creation of a tram LINE in Edinburgh is the biggest waste of public money in Scotland's history. Even if it nears completion, I think the final costs will total around £1 Billion.

All in all, a complete and utter disgrace.

Those who forced this shambolic scheme on Edinburgh and all it's citizens should hang their heads in shame.


36

cataibh,

Over the Struie 05/12/2008 17:27:29
Mr. Darling an Edinburgh M.P has been forced to admit that tram works are causing total disruption and major inconvience to the whole of Edinburgh. Thats the kind of headline this rag would have printed, if it was a SNP minister commenting instead of Darling.
37

COLINTON.MAINS,

Oakville Ontario 05/12/2008 20:55:22
trams.trams.more.trams.caos.caos.more.trams.more.caos
38

COLINTON.MAINS,

Oakville Ontario 05/12/2008 20:55:46
*Please enter your comment*
39

Ian down under,

Monktonhall Junction 05/12/2008 21:09:00
Eggs, broken eggs, omelettes.....................
40

tumshie heid,

06/12/2008 00:03:22
Eggs,broken and smelly, rotten to the core... Just like the tram scheme.
41

Jim W,

06/12/2008 00:34:40
The only thing that the City of Edinburgh Council can manage Mr Darling is manage to make a mess of things!

I heard Phil Wheeler on a local radio station this morning and he could barely complete a sentence without uhhhmming and aaahhhing and emmming!

I thought what a learned sounding fellow to be in charge of transport.
42

A Better Way,

Edinburgh 06/12/2008 04:45:39
Of course the Trams fade into insignificance when one thinks of the mismanagement of the Economy that both Darling & Brown visited upon us.

Brown did it out of his loyalty to the New World Order, whilst Darling did it by being a gutless wimp who chose his career ahead of the good of the Nation. His Nation is England, after all that is where he was born with the silver spoon in his mouth.

He wouldnt know the first thing about putting Scotland, and its peoples welfare first. He hasnt got a clue and is simply Mandelsons bum boy.
43

A Better Way,

Edinburgh 06/12/2008 04:50:08
The really sad thing about Edinburgh and in particular Darlings constituency is that the weak spined folk of the likes of Oxgangs, will actually Vote for one of the Traitors who sold our Banks Down the London River.
44

A True Scot.,

06/12/2008 07:32:49
25

Dont be stupid the tram works are diverting traffic onto the other roads such as morrison street and causing massive congestion problems. That is a direct effect of the tram works.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.