Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


University ban on Muslim comedy attacked

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
14 November 2007
MUSLIM comedians have been banned from performing at a Scottish university in a move described as "ridiculous and undemocratic".
Glasgow Caledonian University backed out of hosting Allah Made Me Funny: The Official Muslim Comedy Tour this month after complaints from its Muslim students' association.

Oceanic, which organised the tour, was told by the university that the soc
iety felt the act was derogatory to the religion.

Preacher Moss and Azhar Usman will still perform the show at Dundee University on 27 November with the full backing of its Islamic Society. Yesterday, Fozia Ali, the campaign executive with Oceanic, said she and the comics were disappointed with Glasgow Caledonian University's decision.

She said: "We are shocked that the fear of a possible student backlash from select students opposed to the event has resulted in losing the venue.

"It seems somewhat ridiculous in a democratic society, in the era of freedom of speech, that the objections of a few cause an educational institution such as Caledonian University to walk away from a contractual agreement."

A spokeswoman for Glasgow Caledonian University said: "The university's responsibility is to listen to and respect the views of all students on campus.

"When the Muslim Students' Association expressed reservations about the show, it was decided the booking would not go ahead."

Moss, an American comic and founder of Allah Made Me Funny, said he found the situation sad and criticised the society for not entering into dialogue. He said: "No-one from this organisation has bothered to reach out to us in a way that is mature and, more specifically, Islamically appropriate.

"I would challenge those particular members of this organisation to speak to us and share information or gather information about us and this tour."

Abdallah El-Awaisi, the president of the Dundee University Islamic Society, had no concerns about the event.

He said: "It is one of the best shows I have seen in a long time and there is nothing in it that I have heard or seen that is offensive to the religion.

"It is comedy from an Islamic perspective that is not just for Muslims, but for everyone, and that's why we are showing it as part of our Islam awareness week at the university.

"We want to show the comic side of Islam and show that it is not just a serious religion."

Dates at Glasgow Royal Concert Halls on 26 November and at Napier University in Edinburgh on 28 November are also expected to go ahead.



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 13 November 2007 11:40 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Muslim issues
 
1

Eric D,

Glasgow 14/11/2007 01:01:03

More uplifting stories from the angry muslims of the "religion of peace".

2

Abel Magwitch,

14/11/2007 02:19:18

For centuries in Scotland, it was unthinkable to take Christianity lightly. Times have changed and now we have "The Vicar of Dibley", "Waiting for God", "Father Ted", etc. What is sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander.

3

Guga II,

Rockall 14/11/2007 04:25:53

Religion is the joke.

4

Bad Yin,

Sentenced to 20 years of boredom. 14/11/2007 06:13:43

When I was a younh lad we used to go to the Gospel Hall 'cause they gave out free sweeties. One time the man with the sweeties asked, "Does anyone know who Jesus is?" To which my younger sister replied, "Is he no the wee man that lives at the end ae oor street?" This reply earned her nowt!

Nae sense ae humour these religios.

5

Pilrig.,

Livingston 14/11/2007 06:32:15

No doubt they'd ban Bernard Manning too were he still alive.

6

Boy Wonder,

14/11/2007 06:46:55

Muslims need a serious reality check!!

To paraphrase Neitzsche .... Without humour, Life would be a mistake!

GCU has made a very bad mistake in pandering to a minority. What small group will force them off something else next??

7

james 1st,

nz 14/11/2007 07:04:09

if this was a christain complaint the university would pay no attention, the decision makers should be sacked s they dont believe in eqality

8

Nick_Byrne,

Glasgow 14/11/2007 07:23:51

aww...I was interested in going to that.

9

hypertension,

14/11/2007 07:25:18

Religion...so not an anagram of tolerant

10

john z,

14/11/2007 07:45:25

Just the usual religious intolerance from our 'friendly' neighbourhood Muslims.

As Menzies campbell said recently about religion; we should accept the freedom of all and the tyranny of none.

Someone should explain to these people that this country is a DEMOCRACY, and not an inslamist dictatorship. Very sad to see that those in higher education can't think for themselves.

I just don't know why anybody gives any heed or respect to any of these superstitious folk who believe in a magical man in the sky. Funny thing is, their are all these different religions, yet each one of them thinks they are correct and all the others are wrong.

11

Dave From Barra,

Western Isles 14/11/2007 08:01:54

Sad sacks.

12

MadMo,

Glasgow, England 14/11/2007 08:05:41

Reality check required Mr & Mrs Muslim

Get a life & get a sense of humour - you want to live in The United Kingdom?

If not, go and live in an Islamic state..........

13

Conan,

Moffat 14/11/2007 08:15:44

The most dangerous religion is that of Atheism, followed very closely by Secularism, the two most popular religions (actually cults) in the UK.

14

donald,

weegieland 14/11/2007 08:30:52

Ban the Old Firm

15

MistaNorbo,

The Internet 14/11/2007 08:40:43

Conan - Does it hurt when you think? Were you dropped as a baby or perhaps almost drowned sometime vitally depriving your brain from oxygen.

re·li·gion –noun

a set of beliefs concerning the cause, nature, and purpose of the universe, esp. when considered as the creation of a superhuman agency or agencies, usually involving devotional and ritual observances, and often containing a moral code governing the conduct of human affairs.

If you knew ANYTHING about Atheism you might understand the problem with calling it a religion.

Don't even get me start on Secularism as a religion.

Were you high when you made this idiotic statement or perhaps you'd caught the last four minutes of a channel 4 documentary.

your sir are a tard of the r variety!!

16

Kaye,

14/11/2007 09:45:05

Interesting that it is a Muslim oriented comedy show which has ben targeted by a Muslim organization for complaint.

& ... #7 has a valid point. The University are being so PC they are meeting themselves coming back.

17

MadMo,

Glasgow, England 14/11/2007 10:09:08

The institution concerned went to considerable expense over the summer to provide a 'multi-faith' facility for use by ALL religions within it's walls. The muslims agreed to this at several meetings along with all the other faiths concerned.

They are now refusing to give up their previous facility as the new one suddenly doesn't 'meet their requirements' thus depriving the institution of some valuable teaching space.

Only at Glasgow Caledonian University..........

18

House Prices for real,

14/11/2007 10:14:57

i echo what #12 says, if you muslims dinnae like it in the uk, please leave and go live somewhere else more to your liking .................... and quickly

19

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 14/11/2007 10:17:45

My mothers-in-law are so ugly............

20

Sinnerman,

Another Planet 14/11/2007 10:20:04

Glasgow Caledonian University - isn't it just a polytechnic with a posh name?

21

pone300,

14/11/2007 10:28:01

#10
"I just don't know why anybody gives any heed or respect to any of these superstitious folk who believe in a magical man in the sky. Funny thing is, their are all these different religions, yet each one of them thinks they are correct and all the others are wrong."

Religious people do NOT believe in "a magical man in the sky" with the possible exception of children, which reflects the quality of your comment.
And many religious people do NOT believe "they are correct and all the others are wrong."

Your lazy prejuduce says more about you than religious people.

22

GP,

14/11/2007 10:35:34

Are they allowed to ban this?
what happened to freedom of speach?

23

Glenhuon,

Australia 14/11/2007 11:03:23

#13 Conan
If I remember correctly the definition of a cult is a belief that the words of one person, or particular spritual concept is correct, to the exclusion of all others. Therefore all religions are cults.

24

Boy Wonder,

14/11/2007 11:14:59

"In Japan I pulled a Burqa off a woman's head and got gubbed by a Ninja!"

Love that gag!!! :)))

25

Calum Crubag,

14/11/2007 12:53:15

Why should religious fanatics get special priveleges because of what they CHOOSE to believe in?

26

Calum Crubag,

14/11/2007 12:54:30

#18 - what about white Scottish muslims? I hate it all but it's not racial. Christianity is a middle-eastern relgion too... duh!

27

truthsleuth,

South of the Border 14/11/2007 13:47:58

Religion is very serious it is not a joke.
It has been at the centre of many if not most wars.
Just consider
Catholics have fought Orthodox, protestants have fought catholics.
Budhists have fought hindus who have fought muslims. Sunny! muslims fight Shi'ite (two many characters here) . Christians fight jews and so on.

There is one religion I understand that insists you are buried with your feet(or is it your head facing a far distant city. Now if the earth is a sphere surely if your head faces east your feet face west and both will face toward the far distant city. It's just a matter of distance. There is a graveyard 180degrees away from this city on thre surface of the earth and the poor so and so are still deciding after a thosand years.

28

truthsleuth,

South of the Border 14/11/2007 13:51:36

#27. Calum Crubag
Never a truer word spoken.

How is it we have an 'Asian Awards' presentation every year
Is there a White Police Officers Association
Can White Police Officers join the association of Black Police Ofiicers.

29

Yonthing!,

14/11/2007 15:37:32

Have a MAJORITY of students aproached GCU and asked for the ban? I think not. How many students are not going to be able to view this piece of performance art because of the ban.

Anyone want to join me in petitioning that it be allowed to proceed ?

30

Ron D,

Enybru 14/11/2007 16:45:21

As the Ayatollah Khomeini famously said: "There are no jokes in Islam. There is no humor in Islam. There is no fun in Islam."

31

Calum Crubag,

14/11/2007 18:33:01

#30 - that's the way of the world. English poems aren't rewarded at the National Mod. Orangmen don't become the Pope.

If Asians as minorities want to recognise each others' efforts then why shouldn't they. Religion however is not race, it is simply an adopted/ indoctrinated set of views on the world.

Religion belongs in the dark ages.

32

Kung-Half-Fu,

Cathay Prolific 14/11/2007 20:52:54

A spokeswoman for GCU said: "The university's responsibility is to listen to and respect the views of all students on campus.

"When the Muslim Students' Association expressed reservations about the show, it was decided the booking would not go ahead."

Really? Is that exactly and precisely listening to and respecting the views of all students on campus? Double standards with a very large dollop of cowardice are in evidence here. See how humourless Islam calls the tune in every aspect of this slowly rotting society.

#13. Conan, Moffat

You sit commanding these forums and gush forth thoughtlessly at every opportunity; but don't let your own precious religion get in the way of logic or common sense. #15. (MistaNorbo) and #23. (Glenhuon) neatly sum up your vapid "comment".

As others have suggested, if you don't like it here the Middle East is vast and empty in large part. It is not the West and is totally accommodating to the narrowest of narrow minds.

33

Conan,

Moffat 14/11/2007 21:09:07

Hey everyone ... look .....I've been promoted to 'Commander of These Forums' ...... yeah Conan ..... TY Half-Fu!

And, Half-Fu .... exactly what is my 'religion'?

You make less sense than what's usually flushed down the toilet.

34

john z,

14/11/2007 22:06:13

Can someone please explain, if Islam is so awfully good, why can it never be questioned or criticised?

What is it that Muslims are so afraid of? The truth perhaps?

Shame on the University involved.

35

Sunwatcher,

Glasgow 14/11/2007 22:27:37

It is time we stood up to these muslim fanatics. This country allows freedom of speech and the choice as to whether or not you want to listen to it.

I am sick to the back teeth listening to them whine moan and whinge. My observations suggest they use thier religion when it suits their purpose and ignore it when it does not.

To all such muslims it is time you accepted my culture.

36

truthsleuth,

14/11/2007 23:24:52

#37. J.D., Glasgow / 10:27pm

Right on the ball.

If only the Promoters of Criminality would realise it


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.