Register
Sign In
Help
Sitemap
Home
Skip Navigation
Contact Us
Disability Statement
Site
Web
Search
Home
News
Sport
Business
Your Say
Newspaper
Health Info
Money
enhanced by
Scotland
UK
Politics
International
Science&Tech
Health
Transport
Education
Entertainment
Gaelic
Opinion
Obituaries
Odd
Festivals
Lifestyle
Reviews
Columnists
Blogs
Business Club
Video Archive
Archive
Email Newsletters
Whisky
Advertise
You need to have javascript enabled to view this page correctly
Friday, 27th November 2009
Sections
Latest News
Scotland
- North East
- Edinburgh, East and Fife
- Glasgow and West
- Tayside and Central
- Inverness and Highlands
- South
UK
International
Politics
Sci-Tech
Health
Education
Transport
Environment
Arts
Entertainment
Opinion
Obituaries
Odd
Gaelic
Article Index
Other Sections
Supplements
Topics
Topics A-Z
Other Sites
The Scotsman
Scotland on Sunday
Evening News
Heritage & Culture
Living
Dating
Announcements
Money
Scotsman Shop
Scotsman Hotels
Fantasy Golf
Photos Today
Local Pages
Edinburgh Festivals
Homecoming
Whisky
What's this?
The article has been unable to display.
Bookmark:
Del.icio.us
Digg
Facebook
reddit
StumbleUpon
1
Alternative (High-Octane) Fuel Head,
Edinburgh 08/07/2008 13:29:30
Why the hell is this newspaper wasting column inches printing totally biased, bigotted and shortsighted responses to questions designed purely to elicit such responses? Dockrell knows absolutely nothing and only seeks to impose his stupid, biased and illogical opinions on everyone else.
I will provide the correct answers to the questions asked of him.
"What else can be done to stop young people seeing smoking as cool?"
Nothing needs to be done. Youngsters are far more likely to see something as cool if it becomes forbidden fruit. In any case, there is nothing "un-cool" about smoking so whay should we lie to our youngsters?
"What do you think of media portrayals of smoking in general?
No problem with that whatsoever. If a film is being made that is set in environment where people smoke, then then it is right and proper that smoking should be depicted.
"Do we need to introduce legislation to stop magazines and newspapers publishing pictures of celebrities smoking cigarettes?"
No. Of course not. If someone smokes, they smoke. Why lie and pretend they do not?
"Why is smoking seen as glamorous when it is a filthy habit that can kill?"
It is not a filthy habit and it can only kill when done to excess. This is all over-reaction from those who know nothing but want to make a name for themselves.
"Isn't reclassifying films that portray smoking just another form of censorship?"
It is precisely that and we should not even be contemplating it. There is far too much censorship in our country---for the stupidest of reasons.
Report Unsuitable
2
Alternative (High-Octane) Fuel Head,
Edinburgh 08/07/2008 13:37:02
In addition, all this rubbish about not being able to call cigarettes "mild" or "light" is absolute, complete and utter nonsense.
As someone who smokes full strength cigarettes, how the hell am I supposed to distinguish between the differnent strenghts of un-familiar brands if the weak ones don't say "mild" or "light"? Maybe the proper strength ones should say "normal"?
Report Unsuitable
3
,
11/07/2008 05:07:27
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
Comment on this Story
In order to post comments you must
Register
or
Sign In
RSS Feed of this article's comments
Delivery formats:
RSS, Atom, Javascript & Email
Email a friend
Print article
Increase text size
Decrease text size
3 comments on this article
More Film
Interview: Richard Linklater, film director
Film review: Paranormal Activity
Film review: Law Abiding Citizen
Film review: Nativity!
Film review: Bunny and the Bull
Film review: Glorious 39
Film review: I Want To See
Film review: Séraphine
Interview: Claire Danes, actress
Film review: The Twilight Saga: New Moon
Interview: Romola Garai, actress
There's something spooky going on
Film review: A Serious Man
Film reviews: The Informant! | The First Day Of The Rest Of Your Life | Southern Softies
Film review: The Twilight Saga: New Moon
More Film >>
Featured Advertising