Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Lothian Buses chief quits

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 30 October 2008
THE man in charge of Edinburgh's bus company and tram project is to leave his post, the Evening News has learned.
Neil Renilson, who is chief executive of Transport Edinburgh Limited and Lothian Buses, will retire at the end of the year.

The 52-year-old's departure was expected to be confirmed at a board meeting of Lothian Buses today.

Mr Renilson said he was retiring early to give his replacement plenty time to prepare for dealing with the new tram line.

But council sources have told the Evening News that Mr Renilson was going amid frustration at the Lib Dem/SNP administration's dealings with its bus company over the last year.

Lothian Buses has seen passenger numbers fall dramatically this year amid big delays on the city's roads caused by the tram project.

This peaked earlier this month when botched traffic management arrangements for tram works at The Mound gridlocked the city centre.

Lothian Buses and city council chiefs today paid tribute to the work he has done at the company over the last decade.

Mr Renilson insisted he was only retiring slightly ahead of schedule, in order to leave plenty of time for his replacement to prepare for the introduction of trams to the city's streets.

However, a senior council source said: "This last year has proved really difficult for him and he just felt he was getting no support from the council.

"It has been coming for a while but I think when Jenny Dawe and Phil Wheeler said senior heads should roll after The Mound problems, he decided enough was enough. He will be sorely missed and very difficult to replace."

A colourful character in the city's transport world, Mr Renilson took control of Lothian Buses in 1998 and has seen passenger numbers grow from 82 million to 114 million during his tenure.

However, the last year has seen the council-owned bus firm contend with unplanned fare increases, the axing of 16 loss-making services and an unprecedented level of roadworks across the city.

In addition, there have been spats over veiled passengers and allowing prams on buses. Mr Renilson said: "It has always been my intention to retire at 55, and I am happy to be able to take the opportunity to retire a little early, which will allow the company time to adjust to my departure well in advance of the introduction of the tram.

"I have thoroughly enjoyed my ten years at Lothian Buses, and wish to thank all the staff for their support."

Mr Renilson's annual salary, currently £250,000 a year, makes him one of Scotland's highest-paid civil servants.

The city's transport leader Phil Wheeler said: "I really respect Neil for what he has achieved at Lothian Buses and I think the city's public transport users should be grateful for what he has done at Lothian Buses, turning it into the UK's best bus operator.

"I am sorry if he does feel frustrated or feel that he has done all he can with the company but I have not had any direct contact with him on the matter so couldn't comment any further."

Pilmar Smith, Lothian Buses chairman said: "I am sorry that Neil will be leaving us, and would like to express my gratitude to him for his sterling efforts over the past ten years in modernising and reshaping the company.

"Ian Craig, managing director, has been with us for two years, and we have every confidence in Ian, the team of directors and managers will continue to drive the company forward as we enter a challenging and exciting time with the construction of the tram moving into top gear from early next year."

LIFE'S JOURNEY
BORN and bred in Edinburgh, transport has been in Neil Renilson's blood throughout his working life.

The former George Heriot's pupil started as a trainee with the City and Royal Burgh of Edinburgh Corporation Transport Department before going to Loughborough University to take a degree in public transport.

His career saw him manage a number of English bus companies, as well as stints overseas including Hong Kong, before eventually returning to Scotland in 1987 to become managing director of Strathtay Buses in Dundee.

Two years later, he was appointed managing director of Stagecoach Scotland before taking over the running of Lothian Buses in 1998.

More than £100m has been spent on new buses and the firm has won countless awards.

Trams facing further delays as costs rise
EDINBURGH'S tram scheme is set for a further delay and another rise in cost as transport chiefs cancel plans to shut Princes Street to all traffic for seven months.

The street was due to close completely from January until the start of the Festival next summer.

However, after the botched attempt to close the section of the stret near The Mound earlier this month, the city council and its transport firm TIE are expected to scrap the plan.

Now buses, cycles and taxis will be allowed to travel westbound along Princes Street throughout next year.

But the change of plan is expected to mean the date when the trams start running – which has already slipped from February to July 2011 – will be delayed again and the £512 million price tag is almost certain to rise.



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 30 October 2008 10:37 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Lothian Buses
 
1

Jenny MacArthur,

30/10/2008 11:59:32
Cue anti-tram diehard nutters....
2

Skip McClendon,

30/10/2008 12:00:23
"Mr Renilson said he was retiring early to give his replacement plenty time to prepare for dealing with the new tram line"...

Wow, talk about your picking up of a poisoned chalice.

Why do the words "rats" and "sinking ship" spring so readily to mind...
3

Skip McClendon,

30/10/2008 12:04:11
#1

Obviously, the TIE press office was tipped off in advance on this one, judging by your early appearance.
4

Statsman,

Edinburgh 30/10/2008 12:06:35
£250k a year and you want to pack your job in? It shows how bad the trams fiasco really is.
5

Boswall,

30/10/2008 12:06:43
Jenny - nice to see you've mastered irony.....
6

Brian M,

30/10/2008 12:07:42
He is 'retiring' at 52, no doubt getting a pension and lump sum straight away, then having a break in service will get another job in the public sector no doubt
7

The Judge,

30/10/2008 12:08:00
However, a senior council source said: "This last year has proved really difficult for him and he just felt he was getting no support from the council.

I'm sure the £250k plus bonuses, expenses and generous pension payments softened the blow.

One down one to go. Watch your back Tramcar Willie.
8

Incandescent,

30/10/2008 12:09:47
#3 You beat me to it!

Nice going Jenny - way to blow your cover :-)
9

Bring Back Poll Tax,

30/10/2008 12:14:49
"It has always been my intention to retire at 55" - lucky, lucky, lucky - presumably he'll be able to afford a nice wee BMW or Merc on his bloated Civil Service pension so he won't have to worry about not getting a free buss pass for a few years.
10

Franky McNostril,

Bensonhurst, NYC 30/10/2008 12:17:10
The neighborhood can't handle the mayhem.

This is likely to be a domino effect, wait and see other high profile trammers fall one by one. Even Jenny MaCarthur's beginning to sound desperate.
11

Statsman,

Edinburgh 30/10/2008 12:19:04
Is Jenny MacArthur really Tramcar Willie in drag?
12

Franky McNostril,

Bensonhurst NYC 30/10/2008 12:21:39
Is Jenny Macarthur employed by TIE for PR? If so, they're as bad at that as they are at everything else.
13

The Judge,

30/10/2008 12:22:37
I think we can all start counting down the days till the announcement that the tramLINE works will be suspended due to lack of funds and a pressing need for the money to be used for essential services.

14

The Jenny whine Mario n’ Tony net,

30/10/2008 12:24:55
Whahahahaha
15

Prin the Dissolving Donkey,

30/10/2008 12:32:39
Nice jacket, though.
16

Road Raga,

EDINBURGH 30/10/2008 12:33:40
I wish I could ''ANNOUNCE'' my early retirement.

I wonder what my boss would say.
17

Pazuzu,

30/10/2008 12:34:46
Neil Renilson "I am out of here, this Tram thing will never work. See ya!"
18

Steven P,

edinburgh 30/10/2008 12:36:31
When the going gets slightly tough, the ultimate civil service fat cat chickens out. Seeks undeserved praise when passengers up, but not his fault when they plummet. No loss and good riddance. Why not leave now instead of Jan and save us all a further £40k.
19

Sarah B,

Edinburgh 30/10/2008 12:37:26
This is not a good day for public transport in this city. I watched Neil Renilson giving evidence to the Parliamentary Tram Committees and have heard him speak at a few public meetings. I have a great deal of respect for the man. He is a down-to-earth personality who knows his business inside out and, having seen the figures for the anticipated losses to Lothian Buses for the foreseeable future, I suspect his decision to resign comes from a refusal to dismantle the bus company he and his management team have steadily built up over the years, for the loss-making tram line.

If this does not send alarm bells through to our local politicians about the pending impact on our bus services, then I don't know what will. Still, there is not one of them who has the wit or gumption to ask either Lothian Buses or TIE what the real impact is going to be, lest they then have to take responsibility for the mess they have got our public transport into in this city.

Absolutely disgraceful. The Council's decision to support TIE, rather than Lothian Buses is one which it will regret.
20

,

30/10/2008 12:40:01
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
21

Statsman,

Edinburgh 30/10/2008 12:41:56
20 Foo

You don't even live in Edinburgh. You live in some backwards town in East Lothian. Butt out.
22

Scotish Exile,

30/10/2008 12:48:40
retiring at 52, the lucky sod, no doubt with his pockets bulging with tax payers cash.
23

,

30/10/2008 12:51:18
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
24

Marathon,

30/10/2008 12:53:00
Well said #19 Sarah B.

Politicians and CEC listen up.

Don't underestimate the difference this man and his colleagues have made to Edinburgh.

Disgusting that the tram has been allowed to spoil it all.
25

Unimpressed one,

30/10/2008 12:53:11
#6, No doubt.
26

Alternative (High-Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 30/10/2008 12:56:55
Maybe now we'll see an end to the ridiculous "pram ban" at least.

The trams should be scrapped, no matter what Jenny MacArthur says.
27

Big bob 79,

30/10/2008 12:58:38
I thought Ian Craig ran Lothian Buses? after Neil moved to TIE, so what does he say about all this?....
28

Bob 2,

30/10/2008 12:58:54
Getting Out while the going is good.

Love Him or Hate Him

Prior to the Tram Porject

Lothian Buses was the envy of the majority of bus Companies in the UK

Increased Passenger Numbers
One of the Most modern bus fleets in the Country
All Easy Access within the next couple of years
Annual Investment in New Buses
Local Bus Shops
24/7 Bus Services

Low Fares

And then the Tram Project came along....

fares up
passenger numbers down
services cut

Haven't the trams done well !

Yip He is getting out while the going is good.
LB will be struggling even more over the next 3+ years , never minde the noose of the trams around their necks !
29

Leila,

Edinburgh 30/10/2008 13:02:27
#19 how true. A great bus service, well used and paying a healthy dividend to council coffers each year, is being sacrificed for no good reason.
30

Thomas the Tank,

Edinburgh 30/10/2008 13:09:44
Well, if nothing else, this story has flushed kooncillor Phil Wheeler, supposedly the city's transport leader, out from behind the settee where he's been hiding since the Grand Tramcar Vanity Project started turning to $h1t! Nice to see you back, Phil! Looking forward to seeing the back of you, Phil!!
31

Geeky Boy,

30/10/2008 13:10:49
#28, How right you are. There are already talks of lay offs within the Middle Management.

How we drivers will fare remains to be seen.
32

contradiction,

30/10/2008 13:16:33

Neil Renilson has been good for Lothian Buses.

Lothian Buses has been good for Mr Renilson's bank account.

No surprise that he may have been frustrated by the SNP/LibDem council's dealings, Cardownie's running amok and Wheeler doesn't have a clue what's happening.

33

Mr Fuzzy,

Edinburgh 30/10/2008 13:27:32
Who would want to be in charge of the Trams project when they start cutting down the trees on Leith Walk. Whoever is will end up being as popular as Beeching.
34

Craigie Boy,

Carluke (ex Edinburgh) 30/10/2008 13:28:24
The self styled "Lothian Buses" don't operate buses to one of the four authorities which make up the Lothians - ie. West Lothian. They don't even operate buses to parts of The City of Edinburgh district - places like South Queensferry and Kirkliston. Whilst they have a fairly new fleet on the roads and have relatively cheap fares, they haven't rolled out new technologies like electronic destination displays on the front of the buses or electronic stopping information inside the vehicles. They operate a myriad of different liveries and seemed to have ousted forever the easily identifiable and classic madder and white beloved of the citizens of Edinburgh from the days of trams. LB - 7 out of 10, could do better.
35

,

30/10/2008 13:38:23
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
36

Linmal,

Livingston 30/10/2008 13:47:01
Put the flags up. It's celebration time!
37

The Judge,

30/10/2008 13:52:46
Can someone at EEN Towers please ask Phil Wheeler to explain how he didn't see a £10,000 report on the movement of the Haymarket Memorial when it was his department & LIE who commissioned it?

He told us he's never seen it, I think he's telling lies. Maybe one of you scoops can nail him down to an answer on the record.
38

Willie Hutton,

Leith 30/10/2008 14:01:52
Hey Craigie Boy,
All of Lothians destination blinds are electronic controlled the reason they don't use the other kind is because they are hard to read and break down every few weeks (check First bus with wee bits of paper in the windsdreen)and by the way, the people of mid/East Lothian use the buses! West Lothian had their chance and failed to use the bus. At the end of the day you get the bus service you deserve! Use it or lose it,
39

Bob Agg,

Edinburgh 30/10/2008 14:23:56
forgive me if i am wrong. But since when did Neil Renilson become a Civil Servant?? Lothian Buses is a private company where the shareholders happen to be local authorities. Are the staff at RBS now Civil Servants?

They don't go to West Lothian because First operate there and will not compete with them!!
40

Liz,

Edinburgh 30/10/2008 14:34:09
#28
But once we get the trams everything will be great! (well at least it might be for the minority of people who are travelling from Ocean Terminal to the Gyle).

The rest of us can go hang, all we will get is increased fairs and a reduced service in order to pay for this stupid tram.
41

Bob 2,

30/10/2008 14:36:40
34 Craigie Boy,Carluke (ex Edinburgh)


and you could add the Lothian Buses have bus tracker
42

,

30/10/2008 14:43:02
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
43

James (1),

30/10/2008 14:55:24
£512 million is small change compared to what the end cost will be. Keep it coming, I want to see this tram line crash and burn at any cost.
Money is not object.
There will be quite a few changes of personnel at the top. After all you cannot stay in your job if they need someone to blame for each increase and there will be many of them.
44

Slobberchops the Aesthete,

30/10/2008 15:16:44
Have you any idea how hurtful it is to hear trams slagged off day in day out by people like you who plainly know nothing whatever about them?

After my divorce when I was clinically depressed and life didn't seem to mean anything and I was close to ending it all I met a tram on holiday in Madagascar and she taught me how to smile again & turned my life around & introduced me to crack cocaine & now we're getting married as soon as they lay a tramline to the registry office & YOU LOT DON'T EVEN CARE.
45

Bibamus,

30/10/2008 15:26:51
Am I right in thinking that 'Soapy' said, at the start of his tenure that only the money already voted for would be allocated to the Trams and that any costs above that would have to be financed from somewhere other than the public coffers. If I am right, then where will the extra money come from ? Who is buying white elephants these days ?
46

p.n.f.o.bologna,

30/10/2008 15:31:26
#44 With all due respect that has to be the dumbest thing I've ever read!
47

Brian the bus driver,

Mussellbrugh 30/10/2008 15:46:40
Neil Renalson had an interview with the Evening News when appointed chief director. One of his comments was “LRT buses in the past have been to carbolic” which I think means to clean can I take this importunate to congratulate him on a achieving this. The next point before Neil came to Lothian buses the Evening News did an article called the jewel in the crown where all the big bus companies and industry insiders said that LRT was a well run company with passenger numbers growing year on year. Neil did not create the best bus company in Britain he just inherited it and cut cost such as cleaning , staffing levels, and maintenance, this competition is fairly new and only started after Neil joined Lothian buses in some eyes he did not fill the shoes of the the last chief executive just his own pockets.
48

Man On Corstorphine Omnibus,

Edinburgh 30/10/2008 16:04:00
I believe that, deep down, Neil Renilson believed the tram scheme to be whacky right from the start. The mystery is why he ever allowed himself to get involved in TIE in the first place. Perhaps he's now regretting taking the King's shilling?
49

,

30/10/2008 16:11:55
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
50

Brian the bus driver,

musselbrugh 30/10/2008 16:18:23
"The city's transport leader Phil Wheeler said: "I really respect Neil for what he has achieved at Lothian Buses and I think the city's public transport users should be grateful for what he has done at Lothian Buses, turning it into the UK's best bus operator.*
SOME WOULD SAY IT WAS BETTER NEFORE HE CAME ?
51

The Judge,

30/10/2008 16:18:59
#48 Maybe he thought he could hold out for another 3 years and earn himself another £750k?

I think after the Princes St/Mound disaster he knew the writing was on the wall so he jumped before he was pushed. The politicos were never going to carry the can and somebody had to go.
52

Sarah B,

Edinburgh 30/10/2008 16:26:18
Judge (51) - perhaps you are right, but Neil Renilson was the wrong one to go. Since when has Lothian Buses been responsible for traffic management?

The fault lay with TIE, who appear to be well behind schedule and thought time could be clawed back by closing the Mound Junction and then Princes Street entirely, and also with the Council who went along with it. I think it is more likely that Mr Renilson got fed up trying to maintain decent public transport provision in the face of so much opposition from councillors and TIE.
53

Dick C. Normuss,

30/10/2008 16:27:04
Gie the buses to stagecoach, then we'll have something to moan about.
54

The Judge,

30/10/2008 16:36:08
#52 I can tell you moral amongst the bus drivers is at an all time low, for many this will be one more nail in the coffin.

You're right the wrong one went today but trust me Tramcar Willies jacket is on a shoogly nail. LB, TIE & CEC were collectively responsible for the mismanagement of the recent traffic problems. Nobody from the council ever falls on their sword that left Gallagher and Renilson.

Could you honestly see someone as arrogant as Gallagher doing the right thing and resigning? He'll be holding out for the golden parachute.

We had one of the best public transport networks in the country now we've got nothing less than a shambles. All because of a vanity project for some has been councillors.
55

dba,

Haymarket, 30/10/2008 17:17:50
1: THANK YOU Neil for all of the hard work you have done (with your colleagues) over the past 10 years to give the City a 'world class' bus service.
2: The fact that allusions about his treatment at the hands of the new administration is the REAL STORY.

YET AGAIN EMPRESS JENNY AND HER MINIONS, have sacrificed the public good on her alter of political expediency. YET AGAIN the nasty, petty, internicine political in-fighting have cost the City dearly.

HOW LONG are the vast silent majority of Edinburgh Citizens going to sit quietly on the sidelines while the incongruous coallition continue to run the Cikty into the sewers?

In view of the fact that the City are the MAJORITY SHAREHOLDERS in LRT - WHY DID THEY NOT increase funding to prevent the cuts? ANSWER - because the cuts did not affect vital voting areas!

56

Andrew,

30/10/2008 17:21:35
It's a thankless task - who'd want the job?
57

calum,

30/10/2008 17:25:43
#52 - Your comments on the tram project continue to be analytically sound and based on good supporting evidence, which is more than can be said of the TIE Business case or the non-existent Safety case.
That said, TIE's advisors on Traffic Management issues have all come from the City Development Department (Andrew Holmes' team) who left on a variety of severance and retirement packages after years of dealing with Traffic Management and Public Transport issues in Edinburgh. You know exactly the people I am referring to. It is unsurprising therefore that there have been so many problems as the arrogance displayed by them in their previous posts has been continued in their TIE posts.
Further, given the gushing support given to the project by EN's own columnist Margo MacDonald, perhaps she would care to comment in her "weakly" piece rather than the ill-informed diatribe on her usual topics, Come on, Margo. Tell the whole of Scotland how this seriously wounded white elephant is going to benefit Scotland.
58

Andrah,

Embrugh 30/10/2008 17:38:08
A big loss. Renilson has proved himself to be an excellent transport professional and has developed a top class bus company in Edinburgh. Many of the serial moaners here obviously have no experience of bus travel in other parts of the UK. I suspect he had grown tired of the political hassle, and the dead hand of numpties leaning increasingly strongly on his shoulder.
59

Thomas the Tank,

Edinburgh 30/10/2008 18:03:00
Very well said, Calum@54, and also to Sarah B for continuing to shine a bright light into some extremely murky corners that must be making TIE Snake Oil Salesmen and The Cooncil apparachiks squirm. I too know the useless ex-kooncil baggage you're referring to; they well may have spent years being arrogantly 'in charge' of 'traffic management' under 'Mr Bean' Holmes but we all know they never had much of a clue. All the work was done by the minions at the bottom of the tree and by the police. Most of THAT expertise has now moved on where it's better appreciated!
60

Brian the bus driver,

musselbrugh 30/10/2008 18:05:02
comment 60 : The company neil renilson work for before taking over LRT was Stage Coach fife,you would not want anything to do with any these second rate out fits, hes just a depot manager in the right place at the right time now a millionaire.
61

Way Out West,

30/10/2008 18:29:35
#38

West Lothian lost their Lothian bus service because of a carve-up between them and First.

I predict that Lothian Buses will now be split up and sold off.
62

GraemeH,

Edinburgh 30/10/2008 18:38:55
I can't help but wonder if the reason why Neil Renilson quit is because when TIE announce what routes are being cut back for the vanity tram, and that due to "unforeseen circumstances (!)" the cost has gone up and that bus fares will need to increase to cover them, he does not want to be in the firing line.

Time for our elected so-called representatives to call a halt to all further tram works and conduct an urgent review into the viability of the project and the (in)competence of TIE to run it.

We have wasted £200m already. Lets not waste a further £500m and place at risk the viability of Lothian Buses.
63

Brian the bus driver,

musselbrugh 30/10/2008 18:44:23
# 38
Here's a thought Brian Sooter backs and funds the SNP. SNP government then reduces concessioner travel money only really affects company's how are solely base in Scotland. Who cant get funding from parent company's in England. Neil Renlison rejoins stage coach and starts take over talks with Lothian buses. More millions for Neil and Brian to make.......
64

Brian the bus driver,

Prestonpans 30/10/2008 18:45:41

#63 opps
Here's a thought Brian Sooter backs and funds the SNP. SNP government then reduces concessioner travel money only really affects company's how are solely base in Scotland. Who cant get funding from parent company's in England. Neil Renlison rejoins stage coach and starts take over talks with Lothian buses. More millions for Neil and Brian to make.......
65

Bob Agg,

Leith 30/10/2008 19:25:17
#65 - Concessionary travel money in Scotland is massively higher than in England - in many cases 50% higher!! Bus companies in England taking Govt to court about lack of funding!! Scotland increased by over 10% this year!
66

Euan,

Edinburgh 30/10/2008 19:35:06
#64

Very well said Graeme.
67

Andrah,

Embrugh 30/10/2008 19:39:40
#66 Brian, Which major bus companies in Scotland with parent in England are you thinking of? Arriva is the only one that comes to mind?
Ever though of writing conspiracy novels? Much better paid than bus driving but not half as much fun!

# Bob, Correct, the English authorities are fleecing the bus companies in contrast to up here.
68

Brian the bus driver,

Prestonpans 30/10/2008 20:11:04
# 69
yea parent was the wrong word. I know stage coach is base in Perth and first in Aberdeen but they don't make most of there money in Scotland. They are multi million pound companies that make money all over the world. So the talk at work is they don't want to rock the boat in Scotland over a reduction in consecration travel money as they have bigger interest else where Lothian buses has all its eggs in one basket. Their is talk that the money that has been allocate for this year is already been used up.
69

Ach well...,

At the bus stop... 30/10/2008 20:13:05
Edinburgh will rue the day that they ruin the bus company. Lothian Buses/LRT/Edinburgh Corporation Transport has been a living breathing part of city life for decades. It's as symbolic to Edinburgh as Edinburgh Castle. Can't we, the citizens of Edinburgh unite in some way to stage a civilized and controlled demonstration in protest of the trams and the shambles TIE and the council are wreaking on our beloved home? The bus service was always fine before all this nonsense surfaced. We don't need trams...

What happens when they decide to put more tram routes down after the Ocean Terminal/Gyle one is finished?

EEN... perhaps you could lead the way in organising a campaign... Surely it's not too late to reverse what's been started just yet????
70

Bob 2,

30/10/2008 20:19:33
34 Craigie Boy, Carluke (ex Edinburgh)

when the last time you were through in Edinburgh using some of FIRSTs buses

Lothian Buses - the majority of there "modern" low floored buses

have CCTV
a ramp for "wheelchair" users - that WORKs
Warm Buses
Bus Tracking
A system on the bus that tells the Driver if he is off route or running early
Radios on all there buses
Destinations, Front, Side and Rear - unlike FIRST were half of the rear destinations are blanked off.

Or the Front Destination is different from the Side.

LB also have numerous Bus Shops in the area - FIRST have ZERO

LB has a 24 hour LOCAL TELEPHONE number, FIRST have a Mon - Fri one in LARBERT (where is that you ask)

Lothian (pre tramworks 9/10)

First (1/10)
71

Bob 2,

30/10/2008 20:22:36
70 Brian the bus driver, Prestonpans

At least LB are a locally owned and focused company

Pre Trams, profits went back into the Councils Coffers.

Unlike 1st , with its large debts and Highly paid Executives. Their families even get health care through the FIRSTs directors salaries package
72

Bob 2,

30/10/2008 20:23:21
Did someone mention SNP.

here comes Gorgie-Tony !
73

Road Raga,

EDINBURGH 30/10/2008 20:48:08
You lot should get out more, no really.

Out of your little inward thinking doom and gloom mentality ~ if it's getting built in Ediburgh then it will be a disaster~ type thinking.
Each and every one of you will be eating your words when the first tram rattles along Princes Street !

Oh, but wait, most of you will not be using the tram, as you all WANT it to fail (one of you anti trammies said these very words on here !)
74

Road Raga,

EDINBURGH 30/10/2008 20:54:27
Evening, rs

It will run to the east eventually, tramline 4 methinks.
75

Dragonlord,

30/10/2008 21:32:39
Why are tram bosses still getting bonuses? What happened to on time and within budget?
76

Sarah B,

Edinburgh 30/10/2008 21:37:38
Thomas (61) - I suspect I also know precisely to whom you refer - both the useless ex-Council baggage and the minions who have now moved on to pastures new.

I think that Neil Renilson probably falls into the second category. He is certainly not a minion, but he is a man who deals in practical issues and he is very well respected within the industry. The level of his salary aside, he has a reputation for common sense, competence and straight-talking but, unfortunately, these attributes no longer seem desirable in our officials. Only yes-men, spin-merchants and incompetents hold sway with our Don Quixote politicians and only the most accomplished of them will receive the greatest share of the £3m bonus pot!

That's the way things are run these days. Let's hope the SNP government gets a grip on this situation and starts to turn things around for the future. Bring back integrity, honesty and professional competence - they always go down well with the taxpaying public.
77

Julian.,

edinburgh 30/10/2008 22:19:47
Neil Rennison,

Maybe you could clear up a few points:-

(1) Considering the trams have been 7 years in the making, did it not occur to you before now that you should retire 3 years early for this reason?

(2) Why retire esrly anyway to give your successor a chance to bed in. If you stayed on until 2011 as originally planned you could have overseen them yourself...which is what you should be doing rather than passing the buck.

(3) If you can afford to retire at 52, doesn't that suggest you're getting paid a bit much?

(4) Are you sure this is the real reason you are retiring, or is it just a good bit spin?
78

COLINTON.MAINS,

Oakville Ontario 30/10/2008 22:20:40
for.a.city.so.small.this.shambles.should.have.died
79

Just a tax payer,

EDINBURGH 30/10/2008 22:25:47
Instead of recompensing the failures of TIE executive (bonus of £3M), the council should make them PAY for the delay and their incompetence, and finally sack them ALL and SCRAP the trams.
80

the watchfull eye,

30/10/2008 23:15:15
he will not be missed all he has done is turn a once great bus service into a total joke. with the cuts he made to services in edinburgh. goodbye and good ridance neil. whoever your replacement is he can only be an improvment.
81

Lannie,

Edinburgh 30/10/2008 23:40:51
Well done Mr Renilson, you have given this City one of the best bus sevices in GB, you said at a meeting 10 years ago that you were employed to turn the Edinburgh Transport system around, which you have done, and that you would only be with Lothian Buses for 8 to 10 years, which you have been, good luck to you in your retirement. We will just have to wait and see what happens to our wonderful bus services, this is only year 1, and I can see in 2/3 years our bus fares with have doubled, the travel time will not be that good either and the trams will still be in a mess.
82

Lannie,

Edinburgh 30/10/2008 23:43:48
No. 86
It was not Mr Renilson that cut our bus services, Lothian Buses are still owned by the City of Edinburgh Council they have a 51% share hold in the company, and they are the ones who have cut our bus services not Mr. Renilson. So if you have any complaints contact your MP or MSP.
83

Ian down under,

Musselburgh 30/10/2008 23:46:30
I'm 53, can I retire last year?
84

Big bob 79,

31/10/2008 08:44:36
#47 speaks the truth,
Lothian Buses is a shadow of what LRT Lothian was. Under Neil the company has become asset stripped, It owns NO GARAGES, RENTS MOST OF ITS BUSES, farms our Repair work and recovery
All he has done is cut the company to the bone and get it ready to be chopped up and sold off after the trams comes in
85

The Judge,

31/10/2008 09:33:45
79
Road Raga,
EDINBURGH 30/10/2008 20:54:27
Evening, rs

It will run to the east eventually, tramline 4 methinks.

------------

You could bring a tears of laughter to a glass eye.

Tramline 4? Jesus we can't even build tramLINE 1!!
86

Liz,

Edinburgh 31/10/2008 09:45:20
#77
"Oh, but wait, most of you will not be using the tram, as you all WANT it to fail"

No, I will not be using this tram as it does not go anywhere near where I live and I very very rarely go to anywhere on its route. I will though have to pay increased fares for the buses I do use and also almost certainly have to put up with reduced services on the routes that I use to pay for the b*oody things.
87

Crivvens,

31/10/2008 11:31:43
Spot On. It will not be used by most people due to the lack of stops and its only on the north side of Edinburgh. But we will all have to pay for it and suffer a poorer bus service.
88

GrahamH,

Edinburgh 31/10/2008 11:41:32
#90. Gorgie Tony. Myself, a huge, % of my neighbours are amongst the muppet voters you mention, that went from parties of all persuasions to vote SNP on one sole issue, scrapping the trams. We didn't have much choice as all other parties were pro. Salmond has let us down hugely here.

With every additinal delay, every additional revealed cost that SNP have said the council must pick up, the people of Edinburgh are being slapped in the face by the council.

None of the parties at Holyrood are now talking about trams, all are saying it's a council issue and nothing to do with them, but it must be something to do with somebody. If everyone e mails their local MP and MSP, it must get some more attention.



89

Highland Hibby,

In Stagecoach country 31/10/2008 13:04:48
I can't be bothered reading all the posts so I'll just say a few things that may have already been said:

1. He's not a civil servant - Lothian Buses is a local Government outfit. There is a major difference between local and central Gov.
2. The name Lothian comes from Lothian Regional Transport, the replacement for the old Edinburgh Corpoartion in the 70's. It was always Lothian, even when services were only provided in Edinburgh.
3. He is not a "depot manager who got lucky", he was trained under a well respected public transport scheme that no longer exists due to privatisation.
4. Don't forget, he stopped Worst, sorry, First from running Lothian Buses off the road a few years ago. Try living where First are the major operator and you'll never complain about Lothian Buses again.
5. Lothian keeps winning awards. There must be a good reason for that. Why is this company being ruined for the sake of trams that are not needed?
6. Fully agree with post #60.







 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.