Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


City cleans up with record litter rating

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
30 March 2007
EDINBURGH'S streets have been given their highest-ever cleanliness rating by an environmental watchdog.
Keep Scotland Beautiful officers secretly inspected hundreds of roads last month and rated the Capital ahead of rival Scottish cities.

The result comes in the wake of an Audit Scotland report last month, which branded the city's streets as the wo
rst in Scotland.

However, the Audit Scotland inspectors visited Edinburgh more than a year ago, and council chiefs claim a raft of new measures have since brought improvements.

The Keep Scotland Beautiful team awarded a score of 70 on the Cleanliness Index Monitoring System (CIMS) - ahead of Glasgow and Aberdeen, which both registered 66. Litter fines and the high-profile Keep Edinburgh Clean campaign were cited as two factors behind the increase.

John Summers, chief executive of Keep Scotland Beautiful, today praised the record score, adding that he believed Edinburgh had levelled at around 65 in recent years. Only eight years ago, the city was registering a lowly 57.

Mr Summers added: "It is great credit to the council and the citizens of Edinburgh that the independent monitoring of the cleanliness of the city by Keep Scotland Beautiful has resulted in its best ever cleanliness score.

"A cleaner Edinburgh benefits tourism, businesses and the well-being of its residents and I look forward to this standard being maintained and improved on."

A team of inspectors used a computer to randomly select five streets from each of the 58 council wards. The roads were all graded A through D - with A being no litter and D being heavily littered. The surveys look at a wide range of environmental issues, including dog fouling, vandalism, graffiti, weeds, fly-posting and fly-tipping, as well as the prevalence of different types of litter such as cigarette ends, fast food litter, and sweet wrappers.

The source of litter, and whether it is likely to have been created by pedestrians, businesses or domestic households, is also assessed.

The inspections are carried out quarterly, with Edinburgh recording a year-long average of 67 following the latest spot check.

Mr Summers said: "Edinburgh has reached its target to achieve the equivalent of all streets being a grade B or better, which is set at 67. It also had a few As and some Cs and Ds."

City environment leader Bob Cairns said: "We set a lot of store in these independent assessments. The Keep Edinburgh Clean campaign and the extra resources we've introduced in recent years are now bearing fruit. But I'll never be satisfied with our CIMS score until we reach the maximum."

Councillor Sue Tritton, Lib Dem environment spokeswoman on the council, said: "Parts of Edinburgh are undoubtedly much better than they used to be, but there are other areas, particularly on the periphery of the city centre, where more work still needs to be done."

Earlier this month, Edinburgh lost out to Birmingham in the battle to be named "cleanest city in Britain".



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 30 March 2007 11:13 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Litter
 
1

Paul Voltaïre,

www.paulvoltaire.spaces.live.com 30/03/2007 11:41:56

They should count pot holes as litter.
Edinburgh would win every time.

2

blah, blah, blah,

30/03/2007 11:42:01

I walked along Princes St yesterday and it is looking very dirty and run down. The people of Edinburgh should be ashamed. Chewing gum everywhere, the smell of stale piss in door ways, dog crap at regular intervals, beggars on just about every corner.....

The shop fronts are tacky, (how many mobile phone shops do we need?) and the place just generally looks neglected. And of course nose to tail buses from one end of the street to the other.....

At least it reminded me why I rarely venture into this street any longer.....

3

Commentator,

Edinburgh 30/03/2007 11:59:35

I agree with everything you say except with 'the smell of stale piss in door ways, dog crap at regular intervals'. Princes Street has it's faults, but isn't this bad. I think you made that bit up! Otherwise, good rant.

4

Outjalie,

Edinburgh 30/03/2007 12:00:05

You should see the litter in the stair opposite mines drying green. looks like a tip permanently. only time the tenants there go out is to let the dog/s out or to ad to the midden.

5

Declan,

Glasgow 30/03/2007 12:09:35

#1 - you are right, only a couple of weeks ago Edinburgh was reported as having the dirtiest streets in Scotland. It's good news if the streets are cleaner now but it makes you wonder just what drivel we are reading about in the EEN / Scotsman!

6

Young Gordon,

The Shore 30/03/2007 12:11:35

Agreed #4.

Incidentally, now I know where the money from B&Q's 5p and 10p carrier bags goes - Keep Scotland Beautiful's John Summers.

7

blah, blah, blah,

30/03/2007 12:11:59

@4.....I can confirm the odour of urine was evident yesterday morning, as was the dog crap, i presume from the beggars dogs, which were the only canines i saw.....

8

Jack the lad,

30/03/2007 12:25:39

There's dog crap all over the place.

Something is going to have to be done to severely punish their inconsiderate owners.

A recent report here said the council has 32 environmental wardens and there have been only 13 fines issued. That’s just not good enough.

9

Open Minded,

Not Edinburgh 30/03/2007 12:28:10

#2 - Paul.. Re disappearing litter. Has anyone looked in the potholes ? Under the carpet and all that.

10

The Lone Haranguer,

30/03/2007 12:31:21

#9. The council need to get wardens who are keener. How about the parking meanies? They are never slow to ticket folk and are used to the odd brawl too.

11

,

30/03/2007 12:31:41
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 488548, Article id was mapped to record!
12

alex paterson,

embra 30/03/2007 12:43:25

Edinburgh was still mucky last Monday,The Environmental Watchdog,Are they the ones with the White sticks.

13

,

30/03/2007 12:54:04
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 488670, Article id was mapped to record!
14

Wingman,

Edinburgh 30/03/2007 13:04:50

I think i spotted these watchdog chappies, they were the guys armed with a white stick and a Labrador. Someone's aving a laugh ere....

15

mv,

30/03/2007 13:16:15

#3, "I walked along Princes St yesterday and it is looking very dirty and run down."

Totally agree, its been on the downward slope for years...the standard of shops do not help! Not sure how these awards are given out but not in touch with reality!

"Keep Scotland Beautiful officers secretly inspected hundreds of roads last month and rated the Capital ahead of rival Scottish cities..."

If Edinburgh is bad then just highlights how bad the rest are! Just because the score is higher than last time does not mean its acceptable for the people who live here and pay huge council taxes....!

16

Grammar,

30/03/2007 13:58:48

#15 Is that a question?

17

Marie Antoinette,

30/03/2007 14:06:18

#18. Yes it was; albeit a rhetorical one to (hopefully) point out the missing period that should naturally have concluded your own communication.

18

Grammar,

30/03/2007 14:30:05

#19 - you can't beat a rhetorical question, can you? And you can't beat a good oxymorone too I find.

19

Andre,

Edinburgh & Glasgow 30/03/2007 14:37:24

Believe me, Princes Street is paradise compared to Sauchiehall Street on a Monday morning or after a major football game. It appears to be fun for some to down a curry or a kebab as fast as you can and then throw it up over the nearest cashpoint machine or shop window.

20

,

30/03/2007 18:32:30
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 489827, Article id was mapped to record!
21

RB2,

City Centre 30/03/2007 20:01:49

So which city have these "inspectors" been inspecting? Is it an Edinburgh in a parallel universe?? Our city is filthy manky durty! Fag ends, chewing gum, dog mess and litter EVERYWHERE..made worse by the addition of take-away and human sewage mainly at weekends! Where's the PRIDE in our city?

22

Scaramouche2,

30/03/2007 20:31:56

I think someone is sitting a dark wee room and handing out assignments to EN and Scotsman "journos" (sorry, I burst out laughing there!) and telling them "just make it up as you go along. No-one ever checks these things anyway."

23

,

30/03/2007 22:54:46
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 490279, Article id was mapped to record!
24

Julian,

30/03/2007 23:06:37

#1 and #6, common guys, read the article again. Yes, there was a report last month but it referred to a survey done 1 year ago.

#9 jack the lad:-
"A recent report here said the council has 32 environmental wardens and there have been only 13 fines issued. That’s just not good enough"

You're right, that wouldn't be good enough, if it were true. The article actually says that the environmental wardens handed out 152 fines in 6 weeks.
http://news.scotsman.com/edinburgh.cfm?id=122022007

25

Jayess,

mucky Marchmont, just outside tacky Tollcross. 31/03/2007 00:18:06

"A team of inspectors used a computer to randomly select five streets from each of the 58 council wards." ... and who would have a computer with all of Edinburgh's streets listed? The City of Edinburgh Council, that's who ... nuff said!

26

Julian,

31/03/2007 02:26:33

#29, "... and who would have a computer with all of Edinburgh's streets listed?"

The makers of satellite navigation systems, any cartographer, the makers of any website that searches addresses uk wide such as BT.com and streetmap.co.uk, any directory enquiry company, any company that can search for your address by postcode using their database.

Oh, and any one of 1 billion people who can buy software like this online:-
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Street-maps-Route-Planner-UK/dp/B...

The list of suspects lengthens i'm afraid.

27

(-_-),

Tollcross 31/03/2007 07:49:17

#28 Hey Buddy! Less of the tacky Tollcross. I know it's clarty but don't tell everyone. I went down the Playfair steps yesterday and I saw plenty of fag ends, bottles, broken glass, paper, cans, Graffiti, etc. There are some beautiful views though.
{-_-}

28

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 01/04/2007 08:26:51

Having not been to Glasgow recently I was intrigued to see this report.

Why do people in Glasgow, and other cities throughout the world think it socially acceptable behaviour to gorge themselves on food and drink and then vomit in the nearest gutter?

These anti-social persons deserve to be thrown in the gutter themselves and wallow in the puke and excrement that accumulates there.

This kind of behaviour shows a lack of civic pride and a gross (in all senses of that word) disregard for personal dignity.

Why are people like that permitted to desecrate public spaces with impunity and say that they were too drunk or stoned or whatever to remember the fouling of public spaces funded by Scottish taxpayers and the ensuing costs of on-going clean-up.

SOME Glaswegians - male and female - and others of that ilk throughout the world are inconsiderate PIGS and deserve to be treated as a species of subhuman and inferior genetic material.

Stiff fines when caught and an order to clean up their mess and community service to clean up the messes of others would be a fitting punishment buth then this TYPE will never learn and will continue to vomit, defecate, and trash any public space they deem worthy of their vomitous and defecatory excesses.

I realise this report emphasised litter but the effusions of the human kind should be a matter for further study.

I am DISGUSTEDn by the state of some streets I have encountered in my travels and think it indicative of an endemic lack of manners, self-respect and self-esteem. Perhaps I am just venting and going on one of my rants but surely others in Glasgow and elsewhere have noticed the decline in public sanitation and the increase in public littering and befouling of civic spaces.


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.