Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Tourist chiefs make waves as life in raw baffles Barra

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 04 March 2008
THE island's famous airport runway may be au naturel, but some residents draw the line when the population follows suit.
It was hoped a new tourism advertising campaign would provide images of Barra as dramatic and memorable as those of planes landing on the island's runway, which doubles as a beach.

However, the idea that Barra could be promoted around the world
by the sight of naked surfers cavorting on their celebrated sand was too much for some of the 1,200 residents and the local clergy.

Their protests have forced VisitScotland to abandon its plans to use the cheeky footage for a promotional film to highlight the adventure tourism market.

The footage was to be used to produce a viral video – footage which is spread by e-mail – to target youth websites such as Bebo, YouTube and Facebook.

The filming drew widespread attention for the island when it started last week, not least because the three naked male surfers had to endure freezing Hebridean conditions.

Using just surfboards to cover their modesty, they were filmed against the backdrop of a Loganair plane landing on the stretch of sand at Barra's beach airport at Traigh Mhòr.

But after a complaint from local priest Canon Angus MacQueen, the filming was stopped and will now not be part of the promotional material.

One islander said: "The rest of us had a good laugh. The surfers were posing and positioning the surf boards in front of themselves. They must have been freezing.

"They were hanging around the airport at Traigh Mhòr and were being filmed as the plane landed. Everybody here was laughing at it but the priest complained to VisitScotland."

The film was to back up a main cinema commercial, part of VisitScotland's £15 million UK marketing campaign, which shows a London couple flying in to the beach runway and enjoying Barra's stunning scenery and outdoor activities. The cinema advert was directed by director Peter Webber whose film Girl With a Pearl Earring was nominated for an Oscar.

A spokeswoman for VisitScotland said that the concept behind the "edgy and quirky" web video was to get a buzz going on YouTube. She added: "We did receive some feedback that some people were quite offended. The video has been destroyed and will never be shown. We have apologised. Our intentions were good but we got it wrong."

She stressed that VisitScotland worked to "deliver benefits for local communities" and acted immediately when concerns were raised.

Canon MacQueen, who has been on Barra for 56 years, confirmed he complained to VisitScotland but said: "They already had a complaint ahead of me.

"These surfers were naked and running down by the island's airport carrying surfboards. Many people were outraged. We don't want to attract this kind of tourism to Barra. We are overbooked in the summer as it is."

Canon MacQueen said the surfers had moved to the island and were involved in canoeing tourism.

He added: "They are not real Barra men. Barra people would not have done what they did. Local people were quite shocked. I had lots of complaints. I am delighted (VisitScotland agreed to scrap the advert]."

FAMOUS FOR A FILM CLASSIC
BARRA is home to about 1,200 people, most of them Catholic. It is the stronghold of the Clan MacNeil which is said to have lived on the island for nearly 1,000 years.

The island now has the only beach airport anywhere in the world to be used for scheduled airline services.

It was the setting for Whisky Galore, the film based on Compton Mackenzie's book, although the event that prompted the story happened off the isle of Eriskay.

In 2003, the ownership of the Barra Estate was passed by the owner, Ian MacNeil, to the Scottish Government.





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 03 March 2008 10:54 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

subrosa,

04/03/2008 00:33:52
It's an absolute disgrace that something like £2m was spent on making this film. Good videos can be made for peanuts these days. Pure arrogance using taxpayers money in this way but what else are visitscotland good at? Nothing.
2

subrosa,

04/03/2008 00:36:53
She stressed that VisitScotland worked to "deliver benefits for local communities" and acted immediately when concerns were raised.

What does the above actually mean? I deal with these people regularly, out of necessity, and I'm endless asking them to explain what they're saying. At one last meeting I found myself standing and saying ' what's wrong with Scottish education nowadays? Can none of you speak sense?" The silence was golden.
3

!Ya basta!,

04/03/2008 02:09:49
Come on Subrosa, get over yourself. The video probably was funny and a bit quirky. So what if they were naked, its no big deal. Since when have the church been the guardians of anything other than pious claptrap?

The islanders will all benefit from increased visitors surely? Not sure where the 2M figure comes from and presume that is for the whole film not just the Barra bit. Does seem a bit pricey but sure Peter Webber's services post Oscar don't come cheap.

Maybe you need a holiday Subrosa. I heard Barra is good for skinny dipping.


4

Guga II,

Rockall 04/03/2008 05:41:59
"Our intentions were good but we got it wrong".

That's the ongoing story for VisitScotland. They are a waste of money and resources. Time that lot were shown the door, and a new organisation set up.
5

Garry Otton,

RELIGION IS THE PROBLEM 04/03/2008 07:17:33
If 'Keep the Clause' showed the rest of the world what a sexually backward nation Scotland is - McQueen's attitude is only endorsing it. As a priest, his approach to sex is not normal and most likely behind the strident, political point-scoring on morality. Barra will get over it. The Catholic Church never will. (Serialisation on 'Keep the Clause' on Scottish Media Monitor website).
6

Nell,

The Preservation Hall 04/03/2008 08:08:09
No. 8 Dave:- Would it have been a bigger part if they had filmed it in the summer?
7

Roy,

04/03/2008 09:08:40
Barra's the place to hang out.

Surfers do it standing up!
8

Gothic Rose,

04/03/2008 09:25:52
Behave yourselves. Much too early for such shenanigans.!:)
9

Mallory,

Edinburgh 04/03/2008 10:04:59
Did they remember to show the dumped cars at the beach?
10

Furchrissake,

04/03/2008 10:16:27
'She stressed that VisitScotland worked to "deliver benefits for local communities" and acted immediately when concerns were raised.' So, where was she when the money was being spent and the decisions made? Did anyone do any research before money was spent? Seems not.

Lovely though Barra is, the population is mainly Catholic. Surely, asking some of them would have helped the decision-making?
11

Nell,

The Preservation Hall 04/03/2008 10:30:30
Dave:- Is number 18 from Wester Hailes?
12

Donna Black,

VisitScotland 04/03/2008 10:49:34
I work in the press office at VisitScotland and wanted to clarify a few things regarding this story. The cost of the recent filming on Barra was £7,400. The £2million figure quoted relates to our new cinema advert featuring Barra, and other marketing that we are doing in London, the Midlands and the South of England. You can see the cinema advert at www.visitscotland.com/perfectday. Most of the footage we shot on Barra will still be used, so the £7,400 investment has not gone to waste. It is just the footage of the naked surfers that we have decided not to use. We made that decision as soon as we received feedback from local residents about their concerns. Our intention was to promote adventure sports to a younger audience on YouTube, however, we realise we misjudged this element of the filming, and have apologised for any offence caused. We will continue to promote Barra and other parts of Scotland as ideal locations for adventure sports, just without the nudity!
13

newview,

Edinburgh 04/03/2008 10:53:09
How tedious, SubRosa! Please get your facts right. VisitScotland appear to me to be doing a good job. Sure they may have made an error of judgement here with respect to the local community, but they have clearly dealt with it in the right way since. Bottom line is that they are working hard to promote Scotland. Half-baked, ill-informed comments don't help.
14

Joanna,

Cambs, England 04/03/2008 10:57:51
"It is just the footage of the naked surfers that we have decided not to use."

Ah, that's a shame ;)

Seriously though, we get a lot of the Visit Scotland ads here at present, I think they're good. However, if you want to entice the 'older generation' from England, the traditional approach will work best, so a few more scenic ads would be a good idea. They love all the scenary and are the ones most likely to go on a coach trip to the 'lochs and glens'.

Just my opinion, of course :)
15

Doreen,

The Cyber Shebeen 04/03/2008 10:58:17
I'm willing to bet it was only the middle aged and elderly..and the priest..that complained about a few fellas giving their giblets an airing...no wonder youngsters are leaving the islands to head elsewhere.....
16

Biggar Mac,

04/03/2008 11:15:19
What a lot of killjoys. We've had the calendar girls (and boys locally) A few muscular male bodies freezing in Barra would make a pleasant change.
17

subrosa,

04/03/2008 11:17:09
!Ya basta!, 04/03/2008 02:09:49
Come on Subrosa, get over yourself.

I couldn't care less if they were stark naked or were on fire. You didn't read my post. My point was the cost of this video (which wasn't mentioned in this article but was in another). That was in the region of £2m.

You obviously don't mind your tax being used for purposes such as this but I do. Visitscotland waste more of our hard earned money than most quangos and that's saying something.

Yes I do need a holiday but Stobo Castle's more my style :)
18

subrosa,

04/03/2008 11:20:51
newview, Edinburgh 04/03/2008 10:53:09
How tedious, SubRosa! Please get your facts right. VisitScotland appear to me to be doing a good job.

I have my facts right. It's your good self who is lacking in knowledge about visitscotland. Have you ever had dealings with visitscotland? If not then don't make such comments. There are many thousands of people in the tourism industry who would second my comments without hesitation.
19

subrosa,

04/03/2008 11:25:11
# 21

Nothing wrong with nudity. It's the way you waste money that bothers me. Billions over the years have been poured down the drain with your various 'schemes'. The last one, I remember, was to encourage the Chinese to come to Scotland.

I won't fall for your spin, I know your quango too well.
20

Ghost Of Scotland Past,

04/03/2008 11:32:04
So it should have been banned, three naked male surfers is nothing more than pure exploitative sexism, disgraceful
21

Ghost Of Scotland Past,

04/03/2008 11:43:21
"Canon MacQueen, who has been on Barra for 56 years, confirmed he complained to VisitScotland but said: "They already had a complaint ahead of me."

"These surfers were naked and running down by the island's airport carrying surfboards. Many people were outraged.

Contrast and compare previous quotes with

"One islander said: "The rest of us had a good laugh. The surfers were posing and positioning the surf boards in front of themselves. They must have been freezing."

So two complaints, is hardly representaive, and not very democratic.

The good Canon has been on the island 56 years, why, does nobody else want him?

"We don't want to attract this kind of tourism to Barra. We are overbooked in the summer as it is."

What, you are overbooked with naked surfers, are you?
What are you complaining about then, are they all male?
22

Furchrissake,

04/03/2008 12:34:02
19# Dave from Barra - What I meant was, Barra is a lovely island, the residents are mainly Catholic, and if VisitScotland had any sense, they could have carried out research among the island's population before going ahead with such an idiotic idea.

23

Craig Munro,

04/03/2008 14:31:06
Needing a surfboard to cover yer modesty in a high wind on Traigh Mhor?

Ye could have done it with a slice of toast.
24

,

04/03/2008 15:14:15
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
25

Garry Otton,

RELIGION IS THE PROBLEM 04/03/2008 15:39:46
"Who are these people who are supposedly 'speaking up for Scotland?'

Certainly not you! Religionists are turning this country into a miserable theocracy like the one we had in the seventies and eighties when so many young and talented people fled. VisitScotland was addressing young people in a language they understood. Who are these superstitious fools who want to impose their twisted morality and 'speak for Scotland?'
26

OscarMacApfel,

Dumfries 04/03/2008 15:52:33
Seems crazy to me, imagine turning your back on the extremely lucrative naked surfboarding dude market.

Now if it had been surf chicks with boogie boards....

Donna, it's a waste of £7400 to just dump the surfing Barra footage, can someone in your office not just accidentally leak it onto youtube?
27

Ghost Of Scotland Past,

04/03/2008 16:02:43
Hey 39) chill man ah'm no interested, nae burds ye ken
nae burds, that's sad is it no? Whit were thae folk thinkin wis they tryin tae attract thae gay surfin noods...
ah mean dudes, or nood dudes, nah!
28

OscarMacApfel,

Dumfries 04/03/2008 16:07:10
Tsk Scotland's past are you afraid of your sexuality?

Go on knock off a crafty one.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cveZR4e91kU
29

subrosa,

04/03/2008 16:13:27
#23

There are plenty old wifies not adverse to a bit of nakedness :)

What I don't understand is promoting Barra when it's bulging at the seams in summer. Very poor planning as usual. With a little research by the over-staffed organisation they could have found plenty areas of the west which do require publicising. Methinks this was a nice wee weekend oot for certain visitscotland staff paid for by us taxpayers.

Call me a cynic....
30

Fanling,

04/03/2008 17:17:40
#36 Jwil
"I think that most Scots know that Barra is highly religious community"

Pull the other one. I take this opportunity to think that most Scots do NOT know that tritely trotted out "fact". I am a highly educated Scotsman and was unaware of your assertion until you gratifyingly informed me. Unfortunately, your righteous
religiosity overwhelms your common sense. "Moral boundaries" be b*ggered. This was obviously a lighthearted piece of film, low on the shock-horror Richter scale. That a sterile unenlightened (56 years here and counting) "celibate" can rail against
this is lamentable as well as uproariously laughable.

#38 Garry Otton
Yep, religion IS the problem and always will be.


31

Fanling,

Guangdong 04/03/2008 17:23:32
#36 Jwil
"I think that most Scots know that Barra is highly religious community"

Pull the other one. I take this opportunity to think that most Scots do NOT know that tritely trotted out "fact". I am a highly educated Scotsman and was unaware of your assertion until you gratifyingly informed me.

Unfortunately, your righteous religiosity overwhelms your common sense. "Moral boundaries" be b*ggered. This was obviously a lighthearted piece of film, low on the shock-horror Richter scale. That a sterile unenlightened (56 years here and counting) "celibate" can rail against this is lamentable as well as uproariously laughable.

#38 Garry Otton
Yep, religion IS the problem and always will be.


32

Ghost Of Scotland Past,

04/03/2008 17:30:11
awricht 43) an 44) ah'll pu em baith but ye micht fa ower. Ah huv hud a silly thoucht wud it no be strange if thon Dave frae barra wiz the vicar in question. Nah it coulnae be could it.
33

Calum Crubag,

04/03/2008 18:16:19
Everyone knows that Canon MacQueen was only pissed off cos the surfers weren't circumcised. Plus, we all know that native Barraich are born with their clothes on. Aodach salach ge-ta ach cha bu nair e!
34

Calum Crubag,

04/03/2008 18:17:50
#38 - agree. Religion is the problems. Canon MacQueen should concern himself with rooting out the many child abusing priests that seem to get shifted from post to post by the Vatican.
35

Lanna,

SCalif 04/03/2008 18:19:30
#23 Joanna, #24 Doreen,
shame they've wasted the film, but surely the effort would've been better spent were it a summer's day!! :)

#32 Dave,
yer place is on the list to visit, so here's an early howdy,...how's it hangin, dude?! :)
36

Andrew Scalloway,

Stirling 04/03/2008 18:29:12
Pitiful religious bigot and 'racist' he called the surfers not 'real' Barra folk...just like himself!
37

John Blackley,

Winter Garden, FL 04/03/2008 19:02:37
With the proceeds from increased tourism, was VisitScotland planning to build a bronchial disease hospital on Barra?

I've read quite a bit in the past few weeks about a desire to increase the tourist take in Scotland. Perhaps locking up the entire VisitScotland staff would be a good start.
38

subrosa,

04/03/2008 23:09:57
"Fanling, Guangdong 04/03/2008 17:23:32: I am a highly educated Scotsman and was unaware of your assertion"

Obviously you lack knowledge of your own country. Your statement 'highly educated' smacks of pomposity - something which the Scots don't carry well.
39

Doreen,

The Cyber Shebeen 04/03/2008 23:38:20
51....As does yours....ask the average weegie or Edinburgh buddie and pound to a penny they wouldnt have a clue....any bets mate?
40

subrosa,

05/03/2008 00:21:35
# 52

I'm quite sure most people who live in the west of Scotland would know that fact. I'm not your mate btw. The west of Scotland has a different attitude to religion in comparison with the rest of Scotland. Of course maybe you're lacking in basic education too.
41

Fanling,

Guangdong 05/03/2008 06:05:21
#51 & 53
My, you really do get hot under the collar. I was only making a point by stating a relevant fact, which you angrily construe as "pomposity". (LMAO!) Then you narrow your focus to "west of Scotland". Yes, the rest of Scotland is well aware of the "religious" attitudes existing in the west. Thank christ I'm from "the rest of Scotland".

#52 Doreen
Nice one. He knows it's true too.

42

subrosa,

05/03/2008 09:42:18
# 54

Why do you assume posters are male? Your fact wasn't relevant. Narrow my focus to the west of Scotland. Auch away wi ye. Can't be bothered discussing this with such a fool.
43

Fanling,

Guangdong 05/03/2008 11:58:17
#55
Talking to yourself again?
44

Doreen,

The Cyber Shebeen 05/03/2008 23:13:12
53....nah...you owe me mate....

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.