Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Government urged to step in as tweed weavers face long lay-off

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 10 June 2008
THE Scottish Government has been urged to intervene to help save the future of the Harris Tweed industry amid fears that more than 100 weavers might be made redundant due to a lack of work.

Reports yesterday said Brian Haggas, the Yorkshire businessman who bought a controlling interest in the industry two years ago, had ended production for this year, putting the future of over 100 weavers in doubt.

The Kenneth Mackenzie mill in
Stornoway, the biggest in the industry, said work would still be "trickling" out to weavers until September or October and denied any pending crisis.

But weavers and politicians say the strategy adopted by Mr Haggas, who is concentrating efforts solely on men's jackets, has led to concern. He is understood to be on holiday and could not be contacted for comment.

It is understood a massive stockpile of the cloth in China means that weavers, who work the loom at their own homes across Lewis and Harris, are expected to be out of work until next year.

Mr Haggas has created widespread concern by ditching mass production to concentrate on just one style for his in-house brand of men's jackets.

The range of garments – named Barva, Laxdale, Tarnasay and Dalmore – are marketed under a newly-established company called Harris Tweed Scotland. But the mill recently exported its last shipment of tweed – enough to make 70,000 jackets – to China to be tailored into jackets.

A six-strong Yorkshire-based telesales team is busy trying to solicit interest for the new range, but the outcome will not be fully known until September when the winter market opens. Even then, there is thought to be plenty of tweed in store in the Far East to supply the orders.

Calum Maclean, a weaver, said: "There may not be any production for the next seven months or even later. The saddest thing is that Haggas took over the biggest mill, but now it is just small-scale." He added: "Many people rely on the tweeds. I just don't know which way to turn."

Angus Campbell, the vice-convener of Western Isles Council, said last night: "I've been contacted by individual weavers very worried about their future, even if there is stuff going out over the summer.

"There was always a danger with this approach that when they reached a certain level production would be virtually stopped, particularly when he has knocked back other work."

Mr Campbell said there was an opportunity for independent mills to market other products during autumn shows, a busy time for the industry to attract new orders.

"I've written to Jim Mather, (the enterprise minister], suggesting there is an opportunity for some investment in promotional work and retraining so that they are in the best position possible at the end of the summer to take advantage of any work that comes their way," he said. "It's a one-off opportunity for the government to invest money in Harris Tweed now to make these two mills viable.

"If we keep slipping down off the radar, it's going to disappear altogether. We need these companies to be winning orders and we need Harris Tweed to be promoted again at the top of the range."

More than 30 self-employed weavers, who send their tweeds to the mills for finishing, were made redundant at the Mackenzie mill last month. Mr Campbell fears others may drift away from the industry and find work elsewhere.

Archie Macdonald, the area manager for the Highlands and Islands Enterprise team in Stornoway, said the industry has significant potential and is vital to the islands' economy.

John Alderson, manager of the Kenneth Mackenzie mill in Stornoway, said: "At this present time, we are still sending out tweed to the weavers and that will continue to trickle out until September to October at least.

"There are areas where we have to stop at present, but that is because the drains need to be fixed."

The home-spun fabric that conquered the globe

FOR centuries the islanders of Lewis, Harris, Uist and Barra have woven the cloth the world knows as Harris Tweed. The inhabitants of the west of Scotland, including the Outer Hebrides, had traditionally made cloth entirely by hand.

As the Industrial Revolution reached Scotland, the mainland turned to mechanisation but the Outer Islands retained their traditional processes. Lewis and Harris had long been known for the excellence of their weaving, but until the middle of the 19th century, the cloth was produced mainly for home use or for a purely local market.

But in 1846, Lady Dunmore, widow of the late Earl of Dunmore, had the Murray tartan copied by Harris weavers in tweed. This proved so successful Lady Dunmore devoted much effort to marketing the tweed to her friends and then improving the process of production.

As a result of her marketing efforts, increased sales of the tweed were gradually achieved and trade was established with cloth merchants across the UK.

Harris Tweed must be made from 100 per cent pure virgin wool, dyed, spun and finished in the Outer Hebrides and hand woven by the islanders at their own homes "in the islands of Lewis, Harris, Uist, Barra and their several purtenances."

It is now fashioned into suits, jackets and coats for men and women in both town and country styles to dresses, blousons, hats, luggage, furnishings and even slippers.







Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 09 June 2008 9:58 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Fifi la Bonbon,

10/06/2008 01:27:46
Mr Haggas will be coining it in, sending the tweed off to China to be made up into jackets by people who are effectively working under the gunsights of the People's Liberation Army, and flogging them off for six hundred dollars.

I wouldn't mind some tweed stuff, but not for £300 and not made by Chinese forced workers. Marks and Spencers should get tore in, and the local FE college should train up some local tailors.
2

Nikostratos,

10/06/2008 01:44:48
Well if the First minister agrees for a tweed suit to be made to cover his ample body....then the amount of tweed needed would keep the Tweed industry gainfully employed for the next two years...easy peasy!
3

scotsdoc,

NANAIMO 10/06/2008 03:39:07

Ah! HARRIS TWEED, wonderful stuff and way back in the 1940's as a teenager I got the most wonderful tailored Harris Tweed Jackets at Montague Burtons for FIVE POUNDS!!!!!!!

Well throughout my career I have continues my infatuation with Harris Tweed and now at 78 I have about six remaining(I've given my son some).......The trouble is that every where I go now in Nanaimo on Vancouver Island I seem to be in SUPER HEATED CENTRAL AIR CONDITIONING and instead of striding over the moors of Yarrow, I travel everywhere in a heated car!!

It's a damn shame but I seldom get a chance to wear them. My oldest is over 50 years old, shows a bit of wear on the Front edges but looks magnificient against these light weight faux tweed fabrics that jackets are made of these days!
4

Navvy,

10/06/2008 04:16:01
Jings, the whole business is the creation of a single aristocrat. Surely time to revile her.

Seriously though, apart from the rhetoric on the PLA form someone who probably has never been to China, I agree with fifi. Few Scots wear Harris tweed anymore.
5

Liberal for life,

Dunblane 10/06/2008 08:12:43
This is a serious issue concerning a Scottish iconic fabric that is obviously not safe in this mans hands. Come on all you Scottish business men who beleive in our countrys future-save harris Tweed for future generations. Maybe a certain Mr Trump could be persuaded to spend his money more wisely that he appears to be doing in Balmedie?
6

thinking,

Scotland 10/06/2008 08:45:25
Those who are moaning at the loss of work and think there is a greater demand then, instead of moaning, set up your own company to make and market it.
I have run a business as well as being an employee so I know how markets work and you can't sell what is not wanted
If it is not viable why should the taxpayer pour money into it?
7

Mikey,

10/06/2008 08:47:01
You have to laugh at people like niko. While sneering about how much fabric would be needed to swathe AS, he forgets to inform us how much more would be needed just to cover his (niko's) mouth!
8

Pilrig.,

Livingston 10/06/2008 10:09:07
2 - such wit, dont give up yer daytime job
9

Nikostratos,

10/06/2008 10:11:05
#7
Just wee tiny little bit.....sneer.....
10

Willie Macleod,

Wick 10/06/2008 12:04:38
The Work Of The Weavers


We're all met together here to sit and crack

With glasses in our hands and our wark upon our backs

There's nay a trade among them that can mend or mak

If it wasna for the weavers what would ye do

You wouldna hae a claith that was made o'woo

You would nae hae a coat o' the black or the blue

If it wasna for the wark o' the weavers
11

Calum Crubag,

10/06/2008 12:35:27
#6 - so you object to subsidies. It may be a valid point but where do we stop? Many huge companies are offerend £millions to 'relocate' to Scotland, before closing down after a couple of years. The Nuclear Industry may be 'clean' but is hugely uneconomic and couldn't survive without taxpayer's billions. And then there's the war industry....
12

Biker,

Ayr 10/06/2008 20:16:49
This is rather remeniscent of the knitwear industry in the Borders.
13

M1k3,

Glasgow 11/06/2008 12:42:35
@thinking: try doing some. These men are skilled artisans not marketers or businessmen.

There is a HUGE market for Harris Tweed, the issue is that Mr Haggas has bought the biggest mill on the island and is using it solely for his own company Brook Taverner to produce ONE single jacket design in only FOUR tweeds. I have seen the tweed sample library at the mill and there are over 1000 beautiful patterns to choose from. His saving grace is the investment he has made in machines at the mill but this is of little consequence if they are to lie idle. This should be the busiest time of the year for the weavers and here they are without.

Haggas's short sightedness has instantly limited the potential market by ridiculous proportions. Harris Tweed is a wonderful fabric who's use should not and has never been limited to scratchy sports jackets. It has been used in couture (vivian westwood), streetwear (nike, visvim, stussy), home furnishings (ralph lauren), footwear (jimmy choo) and countless other forms. And here it is reduced to four patterns and one jacket style. No wonder there is no work for the weavers.

Last year Haggas tried to refuse a £1 million order from German company Bawi which kept the men in work until march this year. The order would have been refused had the German company not enforced the contract they had with Haggas' predecessor. The 20 pattern, lightweight doublewidth order did not fit with his plans to produce the great cloth for his own clothing company...

Make your way to his clothes shop on line and try and find the sole garment representing Mr Haggas' vision for Harris Tweed, a unique handwoven fabric of great history, distinction and potential. And while you're there consider buying one, it may soon become a collector's item if the industry continues in this manner.

http://www.brooktaverner.co.uk

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.