Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Children's chief calls for ban on Mosquito

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 12 February 2008
SCOTLAND'S Children's Commissioner today backed a campaign to ban a device which deters young people by emitting a high-pitched sound.
The gadget, known as the Mosquito, exploits youngsters' ability to hear very high frequencies, something which declines once people reach their 20s.

Up to 3500 are estimated to be in use across the UK to disperse children and young people in areas
such as parks and shopping centres.

Kathleen Marshall, Commissioner for Children and Young People, joined civil liberties campaigners in condemning the device. The "Buzz Off" campaign was launched today in England by Professor Sir Al Aynsley-Green, and Ms Marshall agreed the device did not respect children's rights.

She said: "The 'teen tormentor' or 'teen repellent' is an ultrasonic weapon used against our children and young people indiscriminately. Its use would not be tolerated for any other section of our society. Young people have a right to assemble and socialise with their friends, without being treated as criminals.

"There needs to be an outright ban on this device which affects not only teenagers, but also young children, babies and young people with disabilities."

In December, Ms Marshall described the devices as "sinister" and called for them to be withdrawn from sale. Today, she vowed to continue to lobby the Scottish Government, the police, supermarkets and the manufacturers for a ban.

It is not known how many of the devices, which are manufactured by Compound Security Systems, are in use in the Capital. The firm's official outlet in Edinburgh told the News today that it had only sold five in the past two years, three of those to customers in Ireland.

However, a spokesman said that because the devices were available on the internet, it was hard to know just how many were being used in any one area.

John Loughton, from Pilton, chair of the Scottish Youth Parliament and recent Big Brother winner, said: "If ever there was a device which highlighted the terrible way in which young people are treated in society then this is it. Since when did standing in an area become a crime?"

The Mosquito was invented by Howard Stapleton, from Merthyr Tydfil, South Wales. Mr Stapleton said a test case in the courts might be the only way of establishing the Mosquito's legality.

Rob Gough, who was the first to test out the device at the Spar shop he runs in Barry, South Wales, said he would defy any ban.

Mr Gough, who has been using the Mosquito for more than two years, said: "It's been a great success for me."





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 12 February 2008 1:13 PM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Mike Tuquet,

12/02/2008 14:25:29
What about the rights of individuals to go about their business without being molested, abused or any other interference that some of these youth create.
This device has a radius of 15 metres and is only activated by the shopkeeper as and when it is necessary.
Ms Marshall wants to think of the wider community before making such crass comments.
2

Chris.J,

Edinburgh 12/02/2008 14:38:06
#1 totally agree. This is part of a co-ordinated national PR push today by the Children's Commissioner to raise their organisation's profiles. Unfortunately they are coming across as the type of simpering apologetic wets that allowed youth crime to get to its current levels. Instead of PR like this we need some evidence that this quango actually understands both sides of the youth crime issue.


"Since when did standing in an area become a crime?"
If that was all they were doing there wouldn't be a problem. Trouble is that in the real world these congregating little angels cause all sorts of anti-social issues.
3

Malice Mizer,

Hull 12/02/2008 15:14:53
About time they're getting rid of these, I was 19 when one of these badly affected my hearing. I don't form gangs outside shopping centres, I don't give abuse nor do I go out of my way to cause trouble. They put them on during the day when I, as a University student, am about - and because of that, I'm going to be deaf within a few years.
4

Mr C,

12/02/2008 15:31:29
Kathleen and the Professor.....you both are totally detached from reality....you have no respect or regard for the rights of other people who constantly have to put up with these street scum who are making life a misery for the rest of us. You ask since when is hanging around streets a crime? Not only is there laws against loitering there are laws there to stop antisocial behaviour its just they are not being used. You must make a good living as a hippie with a cause, but you are a part of what the problem is with the UK today. There are many young people who you should be prioritizing instead of these losers in life. thankfully their attitude and behavioural problems catches up with them later on in life - their drink/drug/ poverty relationship malfunction problems, but in the meantime we should be pressing for more control and give the police greater leeway to deal with them AS THEY SEE FIT, when you tie up the Cat dont complain when u get bitten by rats, im thinking if they dont do what they are told a baton over the head should get the word around, you want to ban a little music box?? how PATHETIC. Ok It not fair that it affects anyone under 25, which includes me, but then again I dont stand on street corners ruining peoples lives, there are plenty of things to do these days for youths, parks, free clubs, cinemas, books, televisions, computers, No there sad lives make their only entertainment is the misery they put on other people. because they have always got away with it turn into unproductive antisocial adults, answer why we have the largest prison population in Europe? Because these assholes you protect and get pampered think they can do whatever they want to others and not deal with the consequences.
5

Sarcasm,

12/02/2008 15:32:12
5.
What they have them installed in universities now.
That is bad.

It's enough to drive you to a shopping centre I expect.
Study harder, you'll learn to stay away or use earplugs.
6

JFW,

New Town 12/02/2008 15:37:18
The fact of the matter is people have to resort to these tactics as the authorities are doing almost nothing to either prevent or punish the significant amount of anti-social behaviour we're seeing from youths. We all know that only a small minoity of kids are causing trouble but the ones who are need to be dealt with pretty severly.
I've had 2 run-ins with neds in the less than 4 days; first bunch were casing cars and basements in the area; very obviously hoping to do some sort of smash and grab, something we've been suffering a lot of in the area recently. I called the Police and made my presence known and immediately was on the receiving end of very threatening behaviour, made all the worse by the fact they were perfectly sober - a particularly dangerous variety of ned.
Yesterday found a pair of neds climbing through our garden; they were in a neighbour's place by the time I went out and do you think they gave a crap about being seen prowling around. Asked them to leave but got nothing but abuse and again I had to show them I was calling the Police before they slowly skulked away, threatening to come back and do my windows in.
Most kids are fine, just doing what kids do; a small minority of scum need to be sorted out, and I don't mean the carrot approach, I'm mean the big stick approach. Until then people should try whatever works to deter the little fcukers; a bit of vigalante justice wouldn't go amiss in my opinion.
7

Incandescent,

12/02/2008 15:57:18
#5 Malice Mizer

Utter nonsense you troll. The sound pressure level (SPL) of these devices is so small that it would take literally months of wearing one as a hat to match the impact on your hearing of a single hour in a nightclub.
8

SPG,

edinburgh 12/02/2008 16:06:19
#5 Malice Mizer Serves you right for coming over like a dick anyway.
9

,

12/02/2008 16:21:35
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
10

,

12/02/2008 16:24:17
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
11

Finbarr Saunders,

12/02/2008 16:28:43
#5 - Malice Mizer - I think it's safe to say that your eyesight will deteriorate long before you go deaf!
12

Portland Geoff,

Edinburgh 12/02/2008 16:57:55
Kathleen Marshall is utterly correct, these contraptions are a disgrace and will only serve to drive a wedge further between young people and the communities in which we live. The tabloids and the curtain twitchers are all too swift to blame the ills of the world on the youth of today. They readily forget however, that young people are far more likely to be victims than perpetrators of Antisocial behaviour and that almost 60% of ASBOs imposed in this country have been done so against adults. Frankly we have failed the younger generation and should be ashamed. Time for the Mosquitos to face a swatting.
13

Unimpressed one,

12/02/2008 17:33:23
#15 - Pri*k.
14

Incandescent,

12/02/2008 17:40:55
#15 Geoff - "young people are far more likely to be victims than perpetrators of Antisocial behaviour"

Oh dear. You should be ashamed of yourself for making such a frankly ludicrous statement. By whom, may I ask? Presumably the large groups of intimidatory adults hanging around and drinking in the streets at night? "We" have not failed these children - their feckless parents have and I for one resent this tendency for "us" to be lumped together with "them" in such statements.

The simple fact is that all other means of control over the perpetrators have been removed by the nanny state under foolhardy "human rights" legislation. The more technological solutions that can be employed, the better for us all. I for one look forward to when we can "set phasers to malky".

15

A Friend of Fernando Poo,

Newington Childcatcher Unit 12/02/2008 18:43:43
"Nobody has come up with a practical solution to the groups of intimidational youth which the police are unwilling to disperse."

I find that putting out poisoned cider as bait works very well, though it does kill the occasional sparrow.
16

The Broon,

12/02/2008 18:55:59
I think that the mozzie is a good idea if used in places where there are existing problems with badly behaved teens.

I read somewhere that playing classical music has a similar effect and makes the little darlings hot-foot it elsewhere.
17

henrymanchester,

UK 12/02/2008 20:11:16
Ha!

I'm going to put three of them in my garden,one on my front lawn and two in my car!
18

Griffe,

12/02/2008 21:09:07
Solve one problem. Sack Ms Marshall.
19

Iain's,

Spain 12/02/2008 21:19:39
It was probably necessary in Merthyr Tydfil.
The council closed the local grammar school and turned it into a museum. MT is now officially one of the worst places to live in the UK.

More seriously, what is the effect of the gadget on babies and mentally ill or retarded children?

Oh! I forgot, nobody gives a damn about its effect on children.
20

morris,

edinburgh 12/02/2008 21:26:10
Deters young people : Sounds like a contraceptive.

Could they not just play Max Bygraves records.That works quite well Ive been told.
21

morris,

edinburgh 12/02/2008 21:28:39
21

Could we insist that its included in nearly every record released after 1989 ?
22

Conan the Librarian™,

12/02/2008 22:57:56
29
I thought it was?
23

Conan the Librarian™,

12/02/2008 22:59:20
snap
24

Eve,

Scotland 13/02/2008 15:46:27
What about the babies and toddlers, will they NOT be able to hear the noise.

There is nothing worse than hearing such a young child being really upset. In portulaca when they are screaming cause they have sore ears. How would a parent or the adult looking after the weeone going to know it's the noise if they are over 25 and don't hear it them self.

Never mind the fact that NOT all youths hang about to cause trouble, some well all in the begging are just bored and have nothing better to do.

Youths have also been social exclude in more resent times as being labeled hoodies or NEDS. A lot of youth culture crimes can be avoided by social including the youths in to society. Some sport initiatives have worked well in the past.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.