Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


BBC in racism row over 'disgraceful' Harry Enfield maid sketch

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 08 October 2008
A COMEDY sketch in which a man urges his neighbour to "mount" a Filipina maid has been attacked by the Philippines government and community groups in Britain.
An online petition condemning the skit, on BBC show Harry and Paul, starring Harry Enfield and Paul Whitehouse, as "disgraceful", "distasteful" and "tantamount to racism" attracted hundreds of signatures yesterday. Calls were growing last night for
the BBC to apologise.

The Philippines government has already protested over the sketch, which was aired on Friday, 26 September.

Its embassy in London has sent a letter of protest to the BBC, the Secretary of State for Women and the Press Complaints Commission.

The plight of millions of Filipinos working overseas is a sensitive issue for the Philippines, whose economy is kept afloat by the billions they send home from abroad.

During the sketch, a man urges his lethargic neighbour to have sex with a Filipina maid, who is wriggling provocatively. He encourages the neighbour to "mount her", telling the maid, wearing a grey uniform and apron, to "present your rear".

The petition, attributed to the Philippine Foundation, calls for the "re-education" of the BBC.

There are also plans for a silent protest vigil at the BBC building at White City in London.

Other Filipinos in the UK said the BBC comedy scene was worse than the script of an episode of the American TV series Desperate Housewives, which questioned the ability of Filipino medical graduates.

A BBC spokeswoman said: "We have not received any formal complaint."

A spokesman for Tiger Aspect Productions, which makes the show, said it had not meant to cause offence.

"Harry and Paul is a post- watershed comedy sketch series and as such tackles many situations in a comedic way," he said.

"Set in this context, the sketch in question is so far beyond the realms of reality as to be absurd and in no way is intended to demean or upset any viewer."

In the Philippines, the foreign secretary, Alberto Romulo, summoned the British ambassador, Peter Beckingham, to discuss the matter.

The British Embassy in Manila was forced to issue a statement saying the BBC had editorial independence and the views portrayed by the network "are completely independent" from the government.

ANALYSIS

ANDREW Jones, a former senior BBC manager and head of journalism at Robert Gordon University in Aberdeen, said comedy makers deliberately courted controversy.

"The Filipinos are absolutely within their rights to protest, but the reality is that satire is often disguised to challenge people's thinking," he said.

"It doesn't automatically mean this sketch was meant to stereotype Filipinas.

"Comedy is under a lot of pressure to do something new – to push the boundaries of taste and decency and challenge the world we live in.

"But performers need to realise people are more tolerant about issues such as religion and less tolerant of others such as racism."







Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 07 October 2008 9:41 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Douglas,

Bathgate 08/10/2008 00:27:49
The outrage of the great and the good might be better directed at the many agencies offering women for "friendship and love". Many seem to be based in, of all places, the Philippines. Nothing sordid going on at all I'm sure
Perhaps the silent vigil represents a collective hanging of heads in shame.
2

Maisie from Morningside,

08/10/2008 02:42:59
This sounds funny.
Will the programme be repeated?
3

Guga II,

Rockall 08/10/2008 04:47:25
Yet another good reason for scrapping the iniquitous television tax, and forcing the EBC to compete on the open market.
4

,

08/10/2008 07:53:43
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
5

Unimpressed one,

08/10/2008 07:56:52
Maybe there's quite a few old men here in Scotland who might need to return their mail order brides to salve their consciences then.
6

Tweedmouth,

Coldstream 08/10/2008 09:25:52
The BBC lost the plot long ago- it is now staffed largely by politically correct idiots who can't distinguish common decency from genuinely absurd comedy. Some months ago the 'light comedy' LOVE SOUP starring Tamsin Greig - featured a scene in which a naked woman was raped in the shower by a large dog; that's right - 'raped by a dog' for comic effect. When I wrote to Ofcom quesioning why the BBC thought this was 'funny' they wrote back saying that they had to protect the 'human rights of the artist to creative freedom' under the Human Rights Act. The point was that the scene was utterly tasteless and far too graphic to be regarded as 'absurd'.
When women being raped by dogs is regarded by the BBC as 'light comedy' we have really entered the age of decadence. What next? Women being raped by horses - as happened in the Roman Arena. Wow, I bet that will be funny!
7

Destroy the Planet,

08/10/2008 10:00:04
#3 Its on bbc's iplayer, its funny and has to be seen in perspective
8

Cauchy Riemann,

Wales 08/10/2008 10:13:30
#7 Tweedmouth wrote:
"The BBC lost the plot long ago- it is now staffed largely by politically correct idiots who can't distinguish common decency from genuinely absurd comedy."

Agreed. The beeb produces garbage now. Its time for the licence fee to go the way of the dodo.
9

Scythia,

Alba 08/10/2008 10:36:26
The "r" word is most over used and misapplied word in Britain today. Describing stereotypes is now racist ( 11th commandment). Perhaps the liberal groups should asking whether this guy is fit to be working for the BBC.(http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-470244/Comedy-star-Chris-Langham-downloaded-video-teenage-girl-raped.html)

Unfortunately, across society (if there is such a concept anymore), the direction is one way. When my local authority sent out a brochure with no white face present (despite 6% ethniticity), that's fine. Conversely had the situation reversed, every "equality" group would have been baying for the Provost's head. The BBC and NuLab have been actively pushing this agenda for the passed decade. Ok in one direction, anathema the other.
10

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 08/10/2008 10:42:10
The Phillipines are a repressive and frantically Muslim nation and deserve all the derision we can throw at them.

Groups there have burnt down Christian churches and slaughtered worshippers.

I have no pity if they are satirised by the brilliant comedic talents of Enfield.
11

Lianachan,

Highlands 08/10/2008 11:50:50
If I complained about every racist Scottish stereotype I saw on the BBC I'd scarcely have time to do anything else!
12

Donald, Edinburgh,

08/10/2008 11:55:39
I'm so sick of stupid, racist, self-deluded and nasty idiots like #12 above, going ON and ON about how the white person is attacked, that minroties are lording it over us, that 'PC' doesn't let us be racist and sexist any more, boo hoo.

Saying a whole nation should be derided because 'it is a Muslim nation' is a ridiculous, indefensible statement that wouldn't be allowed to pass in a primary school debate. It's indefensible intellectually, morally, theologically and in terms of humanity.
13

Guga II,

Rockall 08/10/2008 12:00:46
#12 TCW.

The Philippines are a largely Catholic country, not Muslim. The Muslims are mainly in Mindanao. Moreover, they are not a repressive country, at least not since they got rid of Ferdinand Marcos. I'm rather surprised at your "tabloid" approach. I expected more of you.

14

Alternative (High-Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 08/10/2008 12:04:15
Racism? Schasism!

It's COMEDY for christs sake. It's not to be taken seriously. It is a JOKE.

In the same way that Til Death Us Do Part and Love Thy Neighbour were commedy shows, so is this.
15

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 08/10/2008 12:29:03
15 Guga II

I got the Phillipines mixed up with Pakistan.

So sorry. I shall now retire to my bedchamber in shame at my ignorance.''

CCan you ever forgive me?
16

paul the binman,

08/10/2008 12:37:36
As a Geordie,I find the sketches every week funny,but then again I was brought up in a country that used to be proude of its ethnic mix and its ability to laugh at its self.I read articles like this and it makes me glad we do have the ability to laugh at our selves,god help us if the sketch about having their pet "northener" put to sleep because he was getting old ever upsets the "pc"mob from what ever background.
17

Lianachan,

HIghlands 08/10/2008 12:58:29
#20 I don't remember hearing much in the way of coomplaint from Scots about, say, Groundskeeper Willie from the Simpsons. Comedic characters should always be treated as such.
18

Bemused and above it all,

08/10/2008 13:36:57
But the key question is would you do her?
19

Donald, Edinburgh,

08/10/2008 14:13:14
#21 The extent to which humour is offensive depends on the relative power of the one being made fun of. Groundskeeper Willie is amusing and inoffensive because in real life, Scots in America are not a downtrodden underclass. A comedy sketch about a poor hapless crofter during the Highland Clearances would be far more offensive, obviously, because crofters really were victims of power. The reason Filipinas are upset should be obvious, after a moment's thought. The inability of so many here to get this is depressing.

20

Lianachan,

HIghlands 08/10/2008 14:27:44
#23 What a terribly patronising reply. I get it, alright. I just also happen to think that the sketch in question (unusually, for that show) was pretty funny.
21

Donald, Edinburgh,

08/10/2008 14:42:57
#24 I think your suggestion in #21 that people who are offended should take a leaf out of your sense of humour was more patronising than anything I said.
22

Matt there,

Somewhere 08/10/2008 17:26:09
That Harry Enfield! He's SUCH a commedian!

Well, no, he isn't, really...
23

BK,

Cyberspace 08/10/2008 18:11:38
'#18 Love thy Neighbour was not a comedy show. It was a disgraceful and unfunny racist parody of one. ITV would rightly be prosecuted were they to make anything as vile as that today. It ranks with the Black and White Minstrel Shjow as one of the disgraces of UK television.
24

Media 1,

cape town 08/10/2008 19:17:05
Are they angry because the man mounted a philipino? Or because the man mounted a woman?

What actually happened?
25

Charley,

Dubai 08/10/2008 19:56:31
I agree with the Philippines here - a horrible stereotype, cheap shot, perhaps an easy laugh? I have worked in the PI and the people do not deserve this cheap derision....awful. And the PI is very much a catholic country...I don't mind the northerner jibe. That north of Watford I guess...
26

,

08/10/2008 20:08:37
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
27

Jock Tamson,

Scotland, Caledonia, Alba 08/10/2008 20:46:10
If anyone wishes to follow the links provided above and then watch parts 2 & 3, then they will see that the programme is taking the proverbial out of various people in the society of GB.

How long ago was it that the same sketch would have featured a Swedish girl as the sexual attraction? Were the Swedes up in arms about it? So what's the difference?

At the end of part 1 and the beginning of part 2 you will see Mr Enfield ripping the youreen from an awfy, awfy Home Counties type. Much less desirable.

Any complaints about that? Reminds me of the Miller ad and the French when the voice said " sooner or later the frog'll croak".
28

Media 1,

cape town 08/10/2008 20:50:51
I havent seen the clip, but I can almost imagine that there has been an over reaction from the "secret agitators' who pretend to be morally pure but prove time and time again to be the ones we should be more cautious of.

The person who condemns a stereotypical joke does so because he or she finds truth in the clip, whereas the rest of us find humour only.
29

Jock Tamson,

Scotland, Caledonia, Alba 08/10/2008 20:51:48
Btw. I take it Philipina is the feminine and Philipino is the masculine? That's like the Italian. Julio and Julia. Which is why Bimbo should be Bimba.
30

Jock Tamson,

Scotland, Caledonia, Alba 08/10/2008 20:54:55
Media 1@33. Can you not copy and paste the liks already provided and see for yourself? It's quite safe, you know.
31

Jock Tamson,

Scotland, Caledonia, Alba 08/10/2008 20:57:25
Media 1@33. Can you not copy and paste the links already provided and see for yourself? It's quite safe, you know.

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=FL9KrTGx28E

See, I just managed that - and corrected my typo from 35.
32

Matt there,

Somewhere 09/10/2008 01:05:53
Stuff and nonsense, BK!

Love Thy Neighbour was a programme that shone a very powerful searchlight on entrenched racist attitudes that were, sadly, endemic in British society at the time.



 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.