Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Vettriano: Art world's élite finally want me – but I draw the line at a portrait of Monty

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 29 October 2008
HE IS one of the world's best-selling painters yet has been shunned by the Scottish art establishment. Jack Vettriano's best known painting, The Singing Butler, sold at auction for £744,000 and is one of the most reproduced paintings of modern times, but none of his works has ever been acquired by Scotland's national galleries.
Now, the Fife-born former miner has revived his long-running feud with the National Galleries of Scotland (NGS), claiming he was finally asked to paint a portrait for its collections – only to turn the opportunity down because he did not like the proposed subject matter, golfer Colin Montgomerie.

Vettriano, 56, told an audience at a charity event on Monday how his dealer had revealed an approach from the galleries, which have none of the artist's works in their collections.

Speaking at the Adam Smith College, in Kirkcaldy, he said: "I was in France when I got a call from my art dealer, who said there might have been a breakthrough. 'The national galleries would like you to do a portrait'. I said, 'Who?'. 'Colin Montgomerie'.

"I said, 'I'm afraid that the answer is no', I don't do men with breasts, and I don't mean that as unkind to Colin Montgomerie.

"My art dealer said, 'Think about it' and I said, 'I have, and the answer is no'."

Later in the evening at the event, An Audience with Jack Vettriano, the artist was asked if he would ever paint a man as anything other than a prop for women. He replied: "I have to paint a face I like. Have you seen Colin Montgomerie's face recently?"

Neither Montgomerie nor his representatives could be reached last night.

However, gallery chiefs denied knowledge of any approach being made and insisted the NGS had not commissioned a portrait of the golfer.

A go-between, believed to be trying to break the impasse between the NGS and Vettriano, is thought to have suggested the idea to gallery officials.

The Scottish National Portrait Gallery last night insisted it had not instigated the approach and that the idea of a commission had not been formally discussed or approved.

An NGS spokeswoman said: "A few years ago, a suggestion was made to the NGS for a portrait but no formal approach was ever made by us to the artist.

"Any formal approach would have involved James Holloway, director of the portrait gallery, and would have to have been approved by our senior management team. He is adamant that did not happen."

Vettriano has launched a string of attacks against the NGS over the years, concerning his repeated rejection by its senior officials and curators.

Last year, the then director of the Scottish National Gallery of Modern Art described the artist's work as "lifeless".

Vettriano also used Monday's event to launch an attack on Sport Relief, the charity which organised the recent auction of portraits of sporting celebrities by leading artists.

Vettriano criticised the charity's organisational skills after his portrait of Zara Phillips, the Queen's eldest granddaughter, sold for just £36,000, despite some experts predicting it could fetch over £1 million.


Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 28 October 2008 9:10 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Jack Vettriano
 
1

somerferg,

perth 29/10/2008 00:45:39
Eem Jack you need to take a look in a mirror - your no oil painting yourself pal.
2

Maisie from Morningside,

29/10/2008 00:52:09
So, it turned out the art world's elite DIDN'T want him.
He could always try the "Vision On " gallery........
3

senza nome,

29/10/2008 01:01:41
Vettriano was never a miner.He was a mining engineer.He didn't work down the pit but it's more romantic to say that he did and journalists continually repeat it.
4

Mackie,

Leith, The Home of Golf 29/10/2008 01:18:44
Welcome to the club Jack!
Nice to see someone not too shy to "tell it like it is!"
Maybe Gerald Scarfe would be better suited to do this portrait, maybe not, but you get the drift - someone who could capture the nature of the beast!
5

jerrymanders,

29/10/2008 01:19:51
Big canvas needed.
6

Mackie,

Leith, The Home of Golf 29/10/2008 01:33:10
You couldnae make it up!
7

Guga II,

Rockall 29/10/2008 01:45:29
He sounds like a nasty and bitter little man.
8

Finlang,

Switzerland 29/10/2008 02:41:37
Why perma-sulk Vettriano can't accept his well-earned squillionaire status is probably beyond most people's comprehension. Admittedly, the art establishment has kept him at arms length, probably on account of his general naff subject-matter.

That's a debatable point and shows the establishment, more than Vettriano, in a bad light. His impressive technique is not in question. His attitude is though. He is a lucky man. Most artists would chew their knuckles off for a fraction of his financial reward.

#3
Yep, the miner romanticism rears its head again. Idle journalist at work.
9

donald,

glasgow 29/10/2008 02:44:58
He could paint John Prescott
10

W Smith,

Middle East 29/10/2008 02:58:52
The irony is that multi-millionaire Jack is acting like a diva while playing Fife's answer to Che Guevara.

The I'm-a-moody-creative-misunderstood- rebel-who-has-to-live-on-the-edge routine is a bit boring.

Bottom line is Jack you're from Methil!

Try being yourself Mr Hogan...sorry ... I mean Mr Vettriano.
11

Dougie Douglas,

Brisbane 29/10/2008 04:01:53
Er, hold on.

Surely the fact that he is one of the most commercially succesful artists in the world shows that his work has wide appeal. The national gallery should remove their heads from their backsides and take a reality check. The gallery is for the enjoyment of the widest possible cross-section of people possible.

Just because his work dosen't float their boat does not mean that it has no place in a gallery designed to celebrate Scottish art.

This is art snobbery.

At the same time Jack probably dosen't help himself by, seemingly, having a huff about it all.

Chill pills all round.
12

Geraldine Firequeen,

the pits of nelson 29/10/2008 04:48:43
disgraceful, foul-mouthed thugs (see other piece) don't they mean Ross and Brand?
13

Expat artist,

home 29/10/2008 04:58:55
I know the establishment's(whoever they are)epithet assessment of Vetrianno's work includes: hamfisted,lifeless,sentimental,Hollywood retro,commercial,populist junk.
Now, if these were qualities he should be in the NGS Modern as most of these qualities are already there - but not in such a concentrated form.
14

r1niceboy,

yankeeland 29/10/2008 05:16:23
I always thought his stuff was too much off an Edward Hopper knock off. That said, it's appealing to look at. But only in the same way Mendelsohn was to Mozart
15

gus1940,

Edinburgh 29/10/2008 06:59:46
I am amazed that nobody has ever commented on the fact that 'The Singing Butler ' is a mirror image.
16

Richardinho,

29/10/2008 07:19:21
This article was plagiarized from 'The Onion' right?
"Portrait painter turns down client for being too ugly!"
Said Area Artist last night: " I'm afraid that the answer is no, I don't do men with breasts, and I don't mean that as unkind to Colin Montgomerie.
17

albanman,

29/10/2008 07:19:42
It is now well known that the "Singing Butler" painting was copied from an book on how to paint: in the original the maid wore a checkered dress and the butler had no handkerchief. It's a nice painting, but not original to Vettriano. One glaring mistake he made in the painting of this upperclass couple is that it is the woman who is leading the dance: hardly something that would have been done in that situation. I agree with others that Vettriano is a bitter man; he is full of his own self-importance and should be happy with his millions and stop complaining.
18

Richardinho,

29/10/2008 07:22:45
The National Galleries are now looking for an alternative painter to depict the famous Scottish Golfer. A spokesman said 'he must be willing to paint ugly people'.
19

paulr,

edinburgh 29/10/2008 08:02:42
We have all heard the commonly used american slang term which fits this perfectly
As***le
20

,

29/10/2008 08:05:32
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
21

AbandonAllHope,

29/10/2008 08:17:20
Would you want a picture thats been painted by projecting a photo onto a canvas and then the spaces filled with colour, exactly, i would feel ripped off as well.Its populist art for frustrated execs in there Edinburgh boardrooms.
22

Ronnie Dewer ,

Edinburgh 29/10/2008 08:49:56
Jim Scullion, twice European Sport Artist of the year, shortlisted for World Sport Artist 2008, born in Scotland, lives and works in Scotland, Should the NPG not be asking him to paint Montomerie? It's time they spotlighted real Scottish talent.
23

Sile,

29/10/2008 08:51:50
From the above comments it would seem that the Scottish spirit is selective, Vettriano was shunned by the Scottish elite because of the awful snobbery in the art world, I acclaim his talent have been to several of his exhibitions, and might tell you his portrait of Zara Phillips is outstanding, and that's in all probablity is why the supposed experts now want him. I am glad he has had the chance put two finger's up to them up to them...
24

Class On Grass,

On-course 29/10/2008 08:55:45

Hey Jack,
I love your work, but there's no need to bad-mouth Monty, who turned out last Saturday at his local
village golf course during some of the worst weather seen on the course, to help raise cash for the
new club-house.
He gave a demo (great driving into ferocious cross wind/rain) outside before being forced into the old club for questions.
A great man indeed. Positive, not negative, Jack.

25

jross,

Erskine 29/10/2008 09:06:54
I am a HUGE Vittriano fan. I left Scotland 20 years ago but on a visit a few years ago I bought 2 prints which now hang in my home in W Australia. I am so proud of them and love when people about them and I say Vittriano is a Scotsman. It is shameful that he has not received the appropriate recognition in Scotland for his talent. He can pick and choose his subjects - he can do no wrong as far as I am concerned because of his huge talent which Scotland ought to recognise as appropriate to his desires and he should not be asked to portray something which does nnot appeal to him. We as Scots should appreciate his talent.
26

Pete McClelland,

29/10/2008 09:20:04
Jeez! You negative ***kers! The vast majority of you lot have caught the 'English' disease of knocking every succesful person. ............. tossers
27

Phil the Flooter,

29/10/2008 09:43:57
Have met Jack on a few occasions, a nice guy who tells it as it is. Scotland is riddled by an art 'old boy ' network who heap scorn on artists 'not in their circle' or not quite posh enough.
28

The Federalist (the poster formerly know as NAUON),

29/10/2008 10:02:14
#27 Vettraino is a painting-by-numbers "artist" - he is a con-artist in the mould of Hirst, Emin and the rest who has fooled many in to buying his mediocre imitative "art".

Why is the art world do full of these self-publicists?
29

The Federalist (the poster formerly know as NAUON),

29/10/2008 10:22:16
#28 Should read:

"Why is the art world so full of these self-publicists?"
30

Red Tower,

Dunoon 29/10/2008 11:16:40
I'll paint Monty
31

Herne the Hunter,

All of Scotland 29/10/2008 11:26:36
Its interesting that Leonardo Da Vinci's best works are drawings of grotesques,Rembrandt equally loved painting ugly portraits.Noel Paton also loved to paint the ugly and the beautiful as it appeared before him.
Like playing for your country,painting for the National Gallery should be an honour. I agree with Ronnie Dewar,ask Jim Scullion to do the portrait you will get a much better painting for the Nation.
Duncan MacMillan and Jack Vettriano should be given a set of boxing gloves each and put in a ring that way we would all get value for money entertainment!.
32

Red Tower,

Dunoon 29/10/2008 11:45:31
#32

I agree. When art is dumbed down it fails in its primary purpose i.e. to cause us all to grow a bit bigger. Great art should cause us to be exalted in its presence. The "Singing Butler" pales into insignificance when compared with the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel.
33

Helmslee,

Edinburgh 29/10/2008 11:47:59
Why shouldn't JV choose not to paint CM. After all, CM probably reminds him of the art establishment in Scotland - arrogant, surley and bad tempered.
34

AbandonAllHope,

29/10/2008 12:00:52
Monty turns up for photae
Jack sends photae tae boots for development
Jack projects said photae on canvas
Jack draws round the image and marks the colours 1 - 10 to match his paint.
Jack fills in the spaces
Populist masses flock to throw there cash at the resulting masterpiece.
Jacks ego grows.
Boots dont get any cash for there effort.
35

Chico Mendez,

29/10/2008 12:07:20
'Zenza Nome' 'Vettriano was never a miner he was a mining engineer'
So what? My father was a mining engineer and went down the pit everyday of his life until he was 63.
Your comment is purile.
36

Chico Mendez,

29/10/2008 12:14:43
'The McKellarator'
Jack Kane may have been born in Scotland (to Irish parents) but the link you suggest quotes his nationality as American. Not too proud of his roots then?
37

scottfin,

glasgow 29/10/2008 13:32:55
Ridiculous comments by JV. Eejit.

If i had any of his cack paintings I would burn them.

38

gorgeousgorgieboy,

Edinburgh 29/10/2008 16:30:33
This guy is in the same class as Irving Welsh.

Visual and literal b0ll0cks.
39

Brian the Barbarian.,

slums of granton 29/10/2008 16:56:58
What's the matter here ? Can jack not find a picture of Monty to copy which is what this chancer has done all his life. FACT .Most of his famous pictures were copied from a book on how to draw !

And why does he have to insult Monty who generally speaking has been a fine sportsman and someone most Scots admire ?

All in all though he has come a long way from when he used to paint girls from saunas in Leith and use the pictures to pay the boss for getting brought off.

Why he is now an insufferable snob rather than just a plaguristic fraud is a mystery, with all his money surely he could buy a box of kleenex and dry his eyes apart from the other uses he will be familiar with.
40

Stephen Cowley,

Edinburgh 29/10/2008 17:04:05
What gets me is that the National Galleries missed a classic Peploe painting for £500,000 or so a few days ago and no-one batted an eyelid. Yet they talk of £50 million (to be handed to some needy aristocrat) to "save" some Titian work . If you go to the Belgian National Gallery in Brussels, you see that they take pride in local artists and their heritage. Why doesn't Linda Fabiani do something about some of this?
41

tearortwo,

burton on trent 29/10/2008 17:28:18
Vetrianno and Montgomerie are both exceptionally talented Scots. Why do we not talk Scotland up instead of down for a welcome change?
42

GEORGE KING,

DUMFRIES SCOTLAND 29/10/2008 17:36:38
What a credit to Scotland and he turned up his nose to the establishment.
43

Wullie67,

29/10/2008 19:59:22
The big question is who is going to paint Monty. It's a shame Rubens isn't still alive. He could do a brilliant full figure nude, with wee angel wings and fantastic boobs.
44

heid the Effin Baw,

frae fife 29/10/2008 21:00:51
are you sure thats vettriano in the phoatie he looks awffy like albert steptoe
45

Sile,

29/10/2008 21:09:56
32# JV has learnt his art, Artists through the ages have used tools to help them achieve, from cannelleti to vemeer, from lightboxes to obscurers, someone mentioned the cistern chapel templates were used to achieve that.seeing and learning colour takes hard work sweat and tears, as I said his portrait of Zara Phillips is outstanding, he was and has been snubbed by the Scottish elite untill his signature went on Zara Phillips portrait, so you won't convince me that they are not elitist snobs.
46

John Cameron,

St Andrews 29/10/2008 23:54:19
I think the nation would benefit greatly from a huge painting of our treasured national grotesque, Mrs Colin Doubtfire.
47

jross,

Erskine 30/10/2008 09:29:42
I know nothing of Jack Vettriano as a person but his art has huge appeal - whether it is art or not is immaterial as it appeals to the populace. His art is popular and unique and people love it - this is enough to make him an artist of note. The Scots should be proud of him and not be knocking him. Anyone who is successful should be recognised as having something unique. I personally love his work as it tells a story to which I put my own meaning. How many other artists has Scotland produced in the last century?
48

Brian McSewell,

Edinburgh 30/10/2008 11:55:32
Scotland has produced many many artists in the last century, few of them would,I hope, be as pointlessly rude as Jack V was to Colin M.
As to Vettriano's work, for those that like that kind of thing that is the kind of thing they like. However I do feel his Chip On Shoulder bluff has been called. On being offered a commission he has retreated into unpleasantness. Could this be because he can't actually draw faces...only profiles? I'm reminded of Vladimir Tretchikoff whose painting of a Green Lady adorned many 70's walls. Jack V's work will date as badly.
49

jross,

Erskine 31/10/2008 11:28:08
#54 I appreciate that everyone is entitled to their own taste. Vettriano's art perhaps does not portrait faces because he cannot draw faces but he conveys so much more - his pictures are conveying atmosphere, mood, a story, environment and much more - maybe only those who appreciate his work can see that.
50

ratatouille,

31/10/2008 14:54:50
Vintage Vettriano of the "it's no' fair" school. Always some-one else to blame! His painting of Zara Phillips was under-sold; he was asked to paint someone he considered below his radar as a subject. Life isn't fair, but you are doing pretty well, Mr Vettriano. Count your blessings and recognise that you're never going to please everyone.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.