Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Unhappy New Year for Edinburgh as Hogmanay festivities face cutbacks

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 06 June 2009
EDINBURGH'S world-famous Hogmanay celebrations are facing a huge shake-up after the event made a big loss for the second year in a row.
About 10,000 unsold tickets and the need to run extra advertising campaigns led to last year's celebrations making a loss of more than £500,000.

Now a number of flagship events face being axed or dramatically scaled back under plans to reduce th
e burden on the taxpayer.

Cuts are being examined both this year and next, despite last year's programme being scaled back and the budget for the event being pegged in the face of rising costs.

No major events sold out last year for the first time, despite good weather on the night of Hogmanay and a promising weather forecast.

The Scotsman can also reveal that the estimated economic benefit from the capital's Christmas and Hogmanay festivities has shrunk, from an estimated £53 million in 2002-3 to the current £32m from the most recent festival.

Unique Events, the Edinburgh firm with the contract to produce the celebrations, is to be handed more responsibility for the four-day programme on condition that it sticks to an agreed budget.

The council, which has put £1.4m into the festival in recent years, had taken many elements in-house, with mixed success, according to insiders.

One source said: "The council has been heavily involved in the management of both Christmas and Hogmanay, and this has not resolved the financial headaches surrounding the festival, particularly over Hogmanay.

"The situation has reached a bit of an impasse. There is no more money available for Hogmanay from the council's budgets, but the costs keep rising and there is a greater need to spend money marketing the programme because of the economic slowdown."

Expensive open-air events on 30 November and 1 January are thought to be the most under threat, and the number of stages at the street party could be cut to try to save money.

However, insiders at the council say they are likely to resist any attempt to reduce the 100,000 capacity of the street party, despite thousands of tickets being left unsold last year.

Last year saw the scaling back of the fireworks display and the scrapping of outdoor events in Holyrood Park in a bid to save money.

But the budget overrun is thought to have dwarfed the £300,000 loss the festival made the year before, when the Hogmanay street party was still recovering from a previous cancellation due to bad weather.

Steve Cardownie, the city council's festivals and events champion, said: "Edinburgh's Christmas and Hogmanay programmes are envied across the world.

"The winter festivals are the only festival programmes still managed from within the council. This presents a unique set of problems in that we are bringing lots of people into the city for these fantastic events at a significant cost, yet the council doesn't generate any of the additional income that comes to the city.

"The council assumes all the risk associated with producing these massive events. The producers currently have no responsibility for ticket sales or marketing their events and this is not sustainable given the council's current financial predicament."

Pete Irvine, director of Unique Events, declined to comment yesterday.

His firm has recently been awarded a contract to run and promote events in Edinburgh's new-look Grassmarket following its multi-million-pound makeover.





Page 1 of 1

 
1

subrosa,

06/06/2009 00:05:53
Scrap the whole thing. It's the most awful event I've ever attended. Being enclosed like cattle and paying for it isn't my idea of pleasant entertainment.
2

brianmca3,

auld reekie 06/06/2009 00:55:16
make it free again,why should edinburgh tax payers,have to pay to get onto a street,that they pay council tax for
absolute shambles
Steve Cardownie,go back to labour as you have brought the labour curse with you,ie events and ggod things rot away and turn to dust
im sure your ex commrades will welcome you back,as your blackening the snp name,and handing labour a big stick,instead of you beating them with said stick
3

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 06/06/2009 00:58:25

Apart from the extra revenue that the Hogmanay festivities bring, the Hogmanay festivities do nothing for the residents of Edinburgh, and actually have become a pain, with all the restrictions put in place because of the Hogmanay festivities.
And to 'Top-It-All', our Scottish Soo Called Television Networks, cannot even Televise the Hogmanay festivities in a correct manor.
One switches their television on, on 'New-Years-Eve', to see the 'Heart-of-Edinburgh' and what is taking place on 'New-Years-Eve', and all you get is a programme, that a group of 5year olds could do better!
Quite Frankly!, Just 'Bin-The-Lot', and save the money spent for the needy in Edinburgh, on 'New-Years-Eve' and televise, the good you are doing for them,...
Apart from the extra revenue that the Hogmanay festivities bring, the Hogmanay festivities do nothing for the residents of Edinburgh, and actually have become a pain, with all the restrictions put in place because of the Hogmanay festivities.
And to 'Top-It-All', our Scottish Soo Called Television Networks, cannot even Televise the Hogmanay festivities in a correct manor.
One switches theier television on, on 'New-Years-Eve', to see the 'Heart-of-Edinburgh' and what is taking place on 'New-Years-Eve', and all you get is a programme, that a group of 5year olds could do better!
Quite Frankly!, Just 'Bin-The-Lot', and save the money spent for the needy in Edinburgh, on 'New-Years-Eve' and televise, the good you are doing for them,...

...But do me a favour!, do not use the BBC or STV for the televising, just go to any Primary School in Edinburgh, and ask 'teacher' to get their Children for this task, as I want to watch a programme with a modicum of relevant content, and not the usual hair-brained, rubbish we have become accustomed with, on New-Years-Eve.
...But do me a favour!, do not use the BBC or STV for the televising, just go to any Primary School in Edinburgh, and ask 'teacher' to get their Children for this task, as I want
4

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 06/06/2009 01:04:52

#3,

Dont Ask!, because I do not know!

Here is what my comment should of been and was,


Apart from the extra revenue that the Hogmanay festivities bring, the Hogmanay festivities do nothing for the residents of Edinburgh, and actually have become a pain, with all the restrictions put in place because of the Hogmanay festivities.
And to 'Top-It-All', our Scottish Soo Called Television Networks, cannot even Televise the Hogmanay festivities in a correct manor.
One switches theier television on, on 'New-Years-Eve', to see the 'Heart-of-Edinburgh' and what is taking place on 'New-Years-Eve', and all you get is a programme, that a group of 5year olds could do better!
Quite Frankly!, Just 'Bin-The-Lot', and save the money spent for the needy in Edinburgh, on 'New-Years-Eve' and televise, the good you are doing for them,...

...But do me a favour!, do not use the BBC or STV for the televising, just go to any Primary School in Edinburgh, and ask 'teacher' to get their Children for this task, as I want to watch a programme with a modicum of relevant content, and not the usual hair-brained, rubbish we have become accustomed with, on New-Years-Eve.

5

,

06/06/2009 01:10:21
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
6

fife runner,

06/06/2009 07:12:37
in my opinion it is poeople standing for hours in sometimes bad conditions who are unhappy with life.
7

dba,

HAYMARKET 06/06/2009 07:51:02
This story IS AN ABSOLUTE DISGRACE.

'For the SECOND year running, the event has made a £500,000 LOSS!'

1: The first citback should be the immediate resignation of Councillor Steve Cardownie. Our 'Festival Czar'.
2: Audit Scotland should demand, exmaine and PUBLISH detailed accounts showning EXACTLY what income the events generate and who get paid when, when and where.
3: GIven that the Scotsman has reported that in the next few years the COuncil is facing a 92 MILLION POUNDS in loss of funding this annual Baccanalia should NOT RECEIVE A PENNY OF PUBLIC MONEY.
4: Audit Scotland should carry out a FULL INVESTIGATION AND EXAMINATION of (a) Unique Event's Accounts and publish them and NO FURTHER contracts should be awarded to the Company or it Director Mr. Irvine.
5: The COuncil, should appoint, with immediate effect a special watchdog sub-committee (publicly accountable) to investigate the past two years accounts and apporntion responsibility for them.
6 UNDER NO CIRUMSTANCES should any more public funds be given to any of the many aspects of this shanbles and, in fact, Unique Events should be required to (a) Publicly announce what THEY are going to do in resepect of the deficit and (b) Publicly APOLOGISE to the citizens of the City for this annual disruption to the centre of the city.
7: The ONLY people who benefit from this annual shambles are the shops, hotels, bars, restaurants and travel companies - THEY want a 'Festival' - fine - THEY can pay for it!

UNLESS the current administration realise what a load of utter nonsense has been going on for the past many years over these events and their funding - peoploe will finally come to realise the truth - it makes MP's expenses look like a KINDERGARDEN!

Over the next few months many decent ordinary folk in Edinburgh are facing redundancy - better every spare penny we can find is spent on them - than this drunken shambles that constantly causes disruption and losses.

WE STILL HAVE NOT SEEN PUBLISHED A
8

The Answer,

Glasgow 06/06/2009 07:56:09
A massive 585,658 youtube hits for London New Year 2009

Length 11.24

tinyurl.com/a6oao6



A pathetic 4,564 hits for edinburgh 2009

Length 4.06

tinyurl.com/qonemf
9

allan58,

edinburgh 06/06/2009 07:56:38
Bin it! This event is well past its sell by date. I've been there, seem it , done it, bought the t-shirt!
No more. It's tacky & tatty!. I particularly resent being barred from access to parts of my home city merely because I don't have a "ticket". In any case, with Edinburgh city centre looking like a war zone, the very idea of this "celebration" right now is just nonsensical!
Perhaps we could have instead our own version of the Up Helly Aa festival in Orkney ? A ceremonial burning of the wooden tram? Now, THAT is something I could support!
10

RDavis,

Vienna 06/06/2009 07:59:17
what are the English going to do for entertainment?
11

,

06/06/2009 08:22:42
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
12

FTH22inarow,

edinburgh 06/06/2009 08:28:14
scrap it altogether and give us our city back
13

Snails dont like curry and chips,

Edinburgh 06/06/2009 08:37:27
They can't continue with the main events anyway once the white elephant choo choo starts running along Princes Street - I agree, scrap the lot - it is well past its sell by date and nothing but a massive inconvenience for the council tax payers.
14

hibbydoug,

edinburgh 06/06/2009 09:19:15
End the drunkfest now, fix the pavements instead.
15

Al Pacino,

06/06/2009 09:37:23
In the good old days a few thousand folk went up to the Tron, had a laugh and then went home. Some dummy tried to to hi-jack Hogmanay in 1996 and turn it into a street party, which was poorly organised, and it all went wrong with overcrowding. Tickets were given out free and an event area was designated until it was decided to start charging people to attend. It's a classic example of a good idea being ruined by people trying to organise fun. The street party is utter garbage, i'd advise anyone to avoid it.
16

Jacqueline Hyde ,

On the shelf 06/06/2009 11:02:46
From the moment the then STB withdrew its support from the "World's Biggest Hogmanay Party" in Aviemore and ploughed its resources into a banal, featureless street party in Edinburgh, it was clear that all the traditions of this very Scottish occasion would disappear into a mist of marketing hype and mediocrity.

It is simply another example of the ongoing "ethnic cleansing" of our cultures and our heritage.

17

Euan,

Edinburgh 06/06/2009 11:05:13
#7 makes some very good points.

The council is indeed staring into the financial abyss as it makes cut after cut to try and make up a £92 million funding deficit.

More schools and community centres are going to be shut soon and the tram project continues to show just how much it is going to drag Edinburgh down in the years to come - and we still persist in wasting money on what is now a very outdated and quite frankly very dull new year 'party'.

I say scrap the whole lot and get Edinburgh back on it's knees and striding positively into the future rather than constantly trying to bail out a sinking ship.
18

Herman The German,

06/06/2009 12:32:42
#5 Flora,

"I would of thought that £500,000 loss is small"

Did you go to the same school as Charles Linskaill?
19

bluehead,

edinburgh 06/06/2009 13:18:50
the cuts will be a good thing,it might keep a lot of drunks of the street,I have never understood how people can enter large crowds like that,they must be mad,!the whole situation is all false,with all these drunks stotting all over the place causing great nuisance to all and sundry,and shouting "happy new year" to people they don't know and probably couldn't care less about,perhaps a thunder storm might help by keeping all the drunkards quite and give the rest of us peace------happy new year!!!!!!!!
20

Chatatara,

Edinburgh 06/06/2009 15:51:11
This is really a new event and is not very well covered by any tv channels and the fireworks are really rubbish. I say ditch it. If you want to come to Edinburgh for Christmas an dNew Year fine, but dont think the ''' street party ''' is going to infulence anyone really
21

EPH,

Kent 06/06/2009 18:07:48
#10'What are the English going to do for entertainment'I think you wll find that London has far better New Years then Scotland now and it is free.
22

nostress,

grangemouth 06/06/2009 19:30:13
#22 London has far better New Years then (sic) Scotland now and it is free

I think you'll find that London council tax payers will be picking up the tab for cleaning up the mess and for the lovely overtime for your Met mob - or maybe that should read we Scots will be picking up the tab as usual as we've been subsidising your part of the world for years.
23

jane shore,

london 06/06/2009 20:28:19

post 23 Oh no you havent!!

24

Jseb,

edinburgh 06/06/2009 20:32:10
This story is a LIE!

Simple they say (but who trust what they are saying now? its not because it's written that it's true) that they have made a loss for the second year in a row.

BUT facts are that 3 years ago the tickets were £5, and 4 years ago they were even cheaper (£2.5). And they did not make a loss...This year it was £10, a shame.

Anyway, it became rubbish, not going anymore.

And I just found out that taxpayers (US) are paying for it...

Well done again "government", you are proving you extreme retardness...

Maybe this year you should put dummy tramways in Princes Street...wait a minute, its in Princes Street it will be closed for the tramway works of the years 2008-2057!!

HAHA, RET@RDS! That is not even believable how stup1d they are.
25

stan102,

06/06/2009 21:30:23
Edinburgh Council has to find £92 million pounds from front line services and plans to cut services, jobs and to privitise and out source.

AND HOW MUCH HAVE THE UNWANTED TRAMS COST SO FAR?
26

Brodric,

06/06/2009 23:49:49
I think it would be a great shame to scrap it - but it does need to be re-organised and I don't think that Pete Irvine has any new ideas up his sleeve.

It is also shocking that the Council takes all the risk. Cushy number for Pete - eh?

The major loss making parts should be thoroughly investigated, as should the marketing costs.

Those parts that are most successful should be built on and there is a lot of scope for more attractions.

Some resorts charge accommodation providers a small sum of money as a tourist tax. Perhaps this could be applied in Edinburgh and could also apply to the pubs, clubs and restaurants who benefit from the additional customers passing through.
27

,

07/06/2009 01:11:52
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
28

,

07/06/2009 01:13:50
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
29

Hiram Greenbaum,

07/06/2009 20:14:51
Surely this must have something to do with this damn silly tramcars project nonsense. Edinburgh looks like a right $hithole, and no American in their right mind would want to go there to spend New Year.

We used to come every year with the family, but since
the storm cancellation debacle, and now the scrapyard you call Princes Street, London seems miles better.

30

Panenka's Chip,

Edinburgh 08/06/2009 09:12:05
So hold on a minute.

Unique Events loses yet more of the council's money, fails to come with a series of events that sells out and makes little or no attempt to change what is now an extremely tired formula?

And now the Council are 'handing them more responsibility' ??!!

The council are (I hear on the grapevine) laying off the staff who worked on this project, staff forced to kow-tow to Unique's baffling 'organisation' of this festival?

People should be aware that Unique Events is a company who have already had to cancel one of their few other 'big' events in the Outside Festival, already this year - interesting that when their own cash was on the line, Unique Events didn't think twice about canceling their event, letting hundreds of people down as a result... Not so cautious with the taxpayers shilling it seems.

So what does Mr Irvine, 'MBE' *have* on Cllr Cardownie and the Council's Directors exactly? Details of their more 'fruity' expenses? Compromising photographs? I think we should be told or maybe a proper newspaper might actually investigate this?

Failure rewarded again by the Council.
31

R Davis,

Vienna, Aiustria 03/09/2009 09:32:59
"EDINBURGH'S world-famous Hogmanay celebrations"...it is only famous in the eyes of the Organisers. I haven't seen pictures of it appearing in any of the newspapers here or the television stations.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Today's Vote

Is September too early for shops to be grtting out their Christmas stock?
Yes, it’s shameless and desperate
No, It will help me spread the cost of Christmas
Don’t care, I've already done my Christmas shopping

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.