Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Budget clears final hurdle after Lib Dem deal

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 04 February 2009
THE Scottish Government has finally secured enough support to pass its Budget for the coming year, after striking a deal with the Liberal Democrats.
The package was thrown into confusion when it was rejected by the parliament last week, but Alex Salmond now has the guaranteed backing he needs, from the Tories, the Lib Dems and the independent MSP Margo MacDonald.

The First Minister would like
the unanimous backing of all parties in the parliament and he will hope to have done enough to get Green and Labour support when the bill comes up for parliamentary approval today.

But both the Greens and the Scottish Labour Party refused to commit last night to supporting the Budget, as they were waiting for assurances from Mr Salmond on the details of the deals they had been offered.

If they receive the assurances – for the Greens, it is full funding for a £33 million home insulation programme, and for Labour, it is the delivery of 8,000 new apprenticeships – both will back the Budget. If not, they will oppose it.

The Greens were due to have further discussions last night but were waiting until today to confirm their final position.

The decision by the Lib Dems to drop their demand for a 2p cut in income tax – which would have taken £800 million away from the Budget –was key.

The party had insisted on that policy right up to last week's vote that threw out the Budget, but, as soon as that debate was over, its MSPs abandoned this principle and made it clear they were willing to support the Budget for much less.

John Swinney, the finance secretary, yesterday revealed he had agreed to table an official submission to the Calman Commission into devolution, calling for borrowing powers for the Scottish Government – something he supports.

The finance secretary also agreed to set up a finance sector jobs task force, to implement a "strategic review" of government spending, and to give a commitment that the first tranche of schools would be built under the Scottish Futures Trust model this year, something else that was expected anyway.

Mr Swinney said: "I'm very pleased to say that today we have reached agreement with the Liberal Democrats which will assure their support for the government's Budget when it is presented to parliament tomorrow. I think it's important to say at the outset that, quite clearly, we do not agree on absolutely everything between the (Scottish] Government and the Liberal Democrats.

"But what we have secured is an agreement that will ensure the government's Budget can be passed."

Mr Swinney added that the deal with the Lib Dems did not have any cost implications for the Budget, describing it as being about "strategic economic and financial engagement".

Tavish Scott, the leader of the Scottish Liberal Democrats, insisted he had been right to drop his earlier demand for a 2p tax cut, which initially closed the door to the party before the Budget vote last week.

"There's lots of maybes in life and we're dealing with the now and present, and that's where we are," he said.

The Shetland MSP said that moves to discuss borrowing powers with the Calman Commission was a victory, and he claimed that the strategic demands – as opposed to specific spending commitments – was the correct approach.

Mr Scott went on: "Now and again, politicians have got to raise their eyes above the day-to-day nature of what's happening in parliament and look at what's happening to jobs, look what's happening to the country outside parliament and recognise it's important to look to the long term."

However, one of the concessions the Lib Dems claim to have won during their negotiations with the SNP government has raised eyebrows among opponents.

The Conservatives claim that the review of spending, which the Lib Dems claim will save millions of pounds, was promised to them last month.

The Budget was initially expected to be approved in three stages – two this week, with the final debate and vote next week – but parliamentary managers agreed yesterday to accelerate the process and it will now be approved today.



Page 1 of 1

 
1

webwise,

Scotland 03/02/2009 22:22:27
The biggest story in Scotland today is the missing register of voters for the recent Glenrothes by-election.

GLENROTHES PARLIAMENTARY ELECTION 2005

Postal votes issued 4,181
Postal votes into count (not available)

Total Votes Cast 37,414


GLENROTHES BY-ELECTION 2008

Postal Votes Issued 6,954
Postal Votes into count 5,548

Total Votes Cast 36,220

A 1200 drop in voter turnout, yet an increase of almost 3000 postal votes issued.

With the register of voters now disappearing, it is surely time to hold an inquiry into the election result that no-one could believe - even Labour.
2

Rufus-T-Firefly,

03/02/2009 22:36:37
#1
.....................................................................................................................................................................................SNP<=======BADLOSERS........................................................................................................................................................................................
3

Rufus-T-Firefly,

03/02/2009 22:51:55
Anyway Webwise, back to the budget.

I see no mention of any money being put aside for Lossiemouth's new "Spaceport".

Whatever happened to that?

Remember this....................

THE SNP wants Scotland to be home to the UK's first commercial spaceport.

RAF Lossiemouth in Moray has been identified as a potential launch site, and Angus Robertson, the local MP and the SNP's Westminster leader, is backing the idea.

Mr Robertson said: "Other countries are keen to be at the front of the queue and I would like to see Moray remain front-runner.

"It would be a mistake to underestimate the tremendous potential of these flights, which will probably also launch satellites into orbit as well as offering tourist flights into near-Earth orbit."

HAHA

Brilliant.

Vote SNP and you can listen to AC/DC on your Ipod as you travel to Mars.
4

Rasco,

04/02/2009 00:11:25
#3 Rufus your a poor we person if you check your facts it was Richard Branson who first mooted RAF Lossie.
5

Tris,

04/02/2009 00:20:32
Rufus being silly again.
6

,

04/02/2009 00:38:11
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
7

UK007,

04/02/2009 00:46:20
#3 RFT - Brilliant and well thought out strategy linking the budget with Lossiemouth's new "Spaceport".Well done.
8

,

04/02/2009 00:46:35
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
9

,

04/02/2009 00:46:51
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
10

Dark Lochnagar,

Symington 04/02/2009 01:55:48
Tell the greens to go and vegetate themselves.
11

subrosa,

04/02/2009 02:17:21
# 11

That's not a good idea. Just because Patrick had a sulk last week he shouldn't be thrown out of the house.
12

Scottish 'N British,

04/02/2009 02:22:22
Phew. Settled. At last. Sunny days lie ahead.

But wait. Its no' a change o' government settled, only the budget. They cannae even get that right.
Such numpties.

Ach, well, we live in hope.

An' its no' a doom and gloom. Kleenex will be happy at getting the contract to supply tissues to mop the sweaty brows of the panicky SNP ministers!!

Ony chance o' an inquiry intae yon SNP's incompetence on this matter?
13

Scottish 'N British,

04/02/2009 02:30:03
3

Funny, is it not, that the areas in which Lossiemouth and Condor are found return Separatist MP's and MSPO's, yet exist on lucrative UK MoD contracts?

The Unionist politics may no' be to their taste, but the Unionist money sure is!!

We should move them. Loyalty to Britain, and all that.

14

Queen D,

Glasgow 04/02/2009 06:20:51
The libs have dropped their demand for the 2p tax and that was key to the agreement??
No! The Liberals knew that no one in Holyrood supported this demand, I suspect they were trying to climb into bed with the schemers in the Labour Party,clawing their way back to power.
They have now realised that they could lose bigtime and are climbing down while spinning their face saving line , aided and abetted by the incredible Scottish media.( and I don't mean incredible in a nice way ,just in case anyone had any doubts!)
The Labour Party has painted itself into a corner and hell mend them.
15

Angleland Isover,

04/02/2009 06:48:32
The party is a joke, move south.
16

Macuistean,

Isle of Tiree 04/02/2009 07:05:13
15 Queen D:

This whole episode reminded me of Bush and Blair. Bush said jump and puppy dog Blair jumped. Now Alex Salmond has his own puppy dog or is it a full litter?
17

Wardog™,

04/02/2009 07:38:10

3. Do you genuinely try to be an idiot or does it come naturally?

How old are you son?

18

,

04/02/2009 08:02:19
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
19

Queen D,

Glasgow 04/02/2009 08:05:55
Hello sunny Tiree!
I like the idea ofthem as a " litter" seems to cover them pretty well!( Maybe drop the " a "!)
20

Scottish 'N British,

04/02/2009 08:22:29
17

Aye, guards at balmoral, Glamis and Edinburgh castles.
Don't forget patrols for the border with England.

Are there plans for a SAF? Do tell.

We already know that Eck's Scotland won't have a Scottish Navy - unless you count fishery protection vessels.

let's stop wasting time and move the operations to Lossiemouth and Condor to Unionist voting areas, where the loyalty is and where the locals can breathe easily. Leuchars is OK where it is.



21

Thomas the Tank,

Edinburgh 04/02/2009 08:31:16
Oh dear - not even crumbs off the Big boys' table for wee green Patrick of the petulant pouted lip?
22

Daveunderwater,

Back O Benachie 04/02/2009 08:34:40
Looks like the SNP have done a deal with Labour on apprenticeships

Keep the unions on our side Eck

All will be revealed after meeting at 9:30 am today

LOL
23

Scottish 'N British,

04/02/2009 08:40:19
On the contrary, Harvie came out of this well.

Salmon and Swindley were the ones who tried to ambush him at the last minute. Brinkmanship, amateur-style.

Let's remember Harvie's demand. It wasn't to take tolls off bridges to help a couple of thoosand car users. but an attempt to get homes heated for ALL Scots.

Very laudable, driven down by Swindley. I think the population will remember these cauld mornings come election time.
24

TWC,

04/02/2009 08:48:03
The Nats, Margo and Tories are the only people who emerge with dignity. The Libdems? it depends what their deal is but it could be the saving of them.

The rest of the budget hardly changed so Labour certainly will be eating humble pie.
At the end of the day the Nats and their allies have won hands down.
25

Daveunderwater,

04/02/2009 08:51:12
Despite already having enough votes, ministers said they were looking for the broadest possible support - and have made offers to Labour, which demanded 15,600 new apprenticeships over two years, and the Greens, who have asked for a £100m-a-year scheme for free home insulation.

Labour have to vote for or against apprenticeships
7500 with a further 7500 in 2011

Eck boxin clever yet again,ye couldae mak it up!!

Mi sides are sair wae lauchin
26

Daveunderwater,

04/02/2009 08:54:27
Dod Broon's jaw must be gaun ten tae the dizzen!!
27

Scottish 'N British,

04/02/2009 08:56:42
28

The Nasts have no "allies" beyond MacDonald.

But that's sorted with a few £mill for her Embra.

28

Daveunderwater,

Silver City by the Grey North Sea 04/02/2009 08:57:31
Rumours are that a penny may be lopped off income tax in Scotland at next budget.

Expect a major influx of our friends from England, Wales and N Ireland, great for the Scottish Economy
29

Daveunderwater,

04/02/2009 09:00:22
31

We'll see at 5 o'clock, according to Radio Scotland it look like the deal has already been done on apprenticeships

I can't wait to see The Scotsman headline on that one

If there is one that is...
30

Daveunderwater,

04/02/2009 09:16:16
27

The only freeze voters are interested in, is the council tax freeze, which Labour voted against
31

Number 6,

Germany 04/02/2009 09:19:16
Now that the unionista parties have been brought to heal, can they now get out of the way and let the grown ups get on with running the country?

One day they will realise their stupid student politics will get them nowhere.

Brown will be furious at how easy it has been to get them to toe the line. He would have been banking on more distruption in Scotland to take the attention away from him and his sleaze ridden party as they go down the tube on a wave of corruption.

"We have done nothing wrong (GLUG GLUG GLUG), and if we have we apologise (GLUG GLUG GLUG), now shut up and get back to your picket lines."
32

Daveunderwater,

04/02/2009 09:29:24
Fy, let us a' to Glenrothes,
For there will be bickerin' there;
For Scotland's light horse are to muster,
And O how the heroes will swear!
And there will be Salmond, Commander,
And hopin, the ballot to win;
Like brothers they'll stand by each other,
Sae knit in alliance and kin.

33

SNP hypocrisy,

04/02/2009 09:51:11
No surprise really that the Liberal Democrats ABANDONED a long-held policy and sold out to the SNP for a 2nd class stamp. Labour should have upped the offer to a first class stamps, half an apple and two squares of a caramac. The carry-on of the Lib Dem's has been both shocking and hilarious.
34

SNP hypocrisy,

04/02/2009 09:53:40
28. TWC, when the SNP's allies are the Tories, that's really not something to be proud of.
35

Daveunderwater,

04/02/2009 10:00:24
38

"when the SNP's allies are the Tories, that's really not something to be proud of."

I beg to differ when the Tories win the next General Election it will be an asset
36

The west awake,

Argyll 04/02/2009 10:04:01
I think the really interesting aspect is the new "positioning" of the Lib Dems.
Any rational analysis of how the SCOTTISH Lib Dems should maximise their position IN SCOTLAND would lead to the conclusion that an "alignment" in some form with the SNP would make sense.
Why - because on policies, they are much closer to the SNP than either the Tories or Labour. Their stance on the constition is ironically where they are further away from the other Unionist parties, lets face it, Federalism is almost as much of an anathema to Labour and Tories as Independence is. On the other hand, many Nationalists are at least warm to it (for varying reasons).
The LDS have NO chance within the Calman Commission of acheiving Federalism, (they MUST know this) but they have a great chance of acheiving it via the National Conversation.
So why have they been Labour cheerleaders for so long?
Sorry to be cynical, but I think it is a BRITISH deal with BRITISH Labour to acheive PR for Westminster, which makes sense in a British context, but in a Scottish it is a craven sellout. Ming and Nichol were signed up Brits, with that auld sickness, eyes on the "big prize" ie London power, but I'm beginning to wonder if Scott has signed on that dotted line? Could he dump Calman, which is as much use to the SCOTTISH LDs as a chocolate fireguard? If he did, it would guarantee an Independence referendum and also torpedo Calman, leaving the Tories and Labour up yon creek, paddleless and directionless.
- Fascinating stuff, and more to come methinks...
37

Newtyle Railway,

Antarctica 04/02/2009 10:17:44
So nice to see Tavish on Newsnight last night trying to explain his cringing example of how to fold a tent and all for a big fat nada. Just as illuminating as last weeks example by the Labour and Lib Dems of the ancient art of back pedaling!
38

Luigiana,

Aberdeen 04/02/2009 10:18:29
What a shame, the establishment are only now getting used to the idea of a minority SNP government, when a sudden increase of political tremors suggest another big earthquake is on the way, as some of the parties reposition themselves to work together with the Scottish government during the recession.

The political landscape of Scotland has not only changed forever, it continues to change in an increasingly dynamic situation. The Scottish media now have to catch up quickly, or risk being left behind completely.
39

Newtyle Railway,

Antarctica 04/02/2009 10:21:59
Can't wait for the one some have called a plodding technocrat i.e. Ian Gray, to explain his position. Not so much of the technocrat but an awful lot of plodding.
40

bully wee alba,

Edinburgh 04/02/2009 10:23:30
#38 Hypocrite
“when the SNP's allies are the Tories, that's really not something to be proud of.”

From the Scotsman.
Published Date: 18 August 2008
By Hamish Macdonell
Scottish Political Editor
IAIN Gray, the frontrunner in the Scottish Labour leadership race, raised the prospect of a groundbreaking pact with the Conservatives yesterday as a way of taking on the Nationalists in the Scottish Parliament.
Speaking to a leadership hustings meeting in Aberdeen, Mr Gray said Labour and the Tories shared the similar aim of reducing council tax bills for the most vulnerable.

Mr Gray said Labour wanted to exempt pensioners from water charges while the Tories wanted to give pensioners a 50 per cent council tax reduction.

He said: "We really have to ask ourselves if we cannot find a way of getting some kind of compromise which would get relatively immediate succour to at least a section of the population and by working together actually drive that through the parliament."

Mr Gray said the Labour Party should be prepared to undertake that kind of cross-party approach if it was to use the parliament of minorities to its advantage.
41

Number 6,

Germany 04/02/2009 10:25:31
38# SNP hypocrisy: you couldn't be more wrong if you tried. A tory victory would be a god send for the SNP.
why can't you see that.

Labour's demonising of the tories over the years have fooled some scots into thinking it's a matter of honour not to support them, leaving them once again voting zombie like for Labour.

Once the tories destroy labour in south britain, whichs looks more and more likely as they streak away to an unassailable lead in the polls, where will that leave Scotland's little band of labourities ?

On the outside looking in with hand-wringing desperation. I can't wait.
42

Number 6,

Germany 04/02/2009 10:28:29
#45 Bully we alba: Ha Ha ha, brilliant. That will have the Labour flock scrathing their heads.

Talk about confused. Over to you SNP hypocrisy (Snigger).
43

Rodster,

GLASGOW 04/02/2009 11:16:08
Far be it from me to help Labour out , but this "SNP and Tories are allies" is just so 1970sss lol
This government in Westminster is more right wing than Major or Thatcher more Tory than the present Tories .and that is saying something.
This scaremongering does not work any more when you cannot control the message.
It was ok in the days of newspapers but now we have the internet and you cannot control the message.
Labour are going into opposition throughout the UK including Wales and Scotland for decades it is joyous.
I dislike Uninoists , however the Tories in Scotland are the most acceptable of a bad bunch.
44

The west awake,

Argyll 04/02/2009 11:22:53
38 - SNP Hypocrisy
As a Nationalist I am heartened to see Labour supporters continuing to bang on about the SNP being "Tartan Tories".
In good old Labour tradition, if a tactic worked 30 years ago (which it did) then it must work today.
Listen, Hypocrisy, no-one takes stuff like that seriously any more. Fact.
The world has moved on and most of us with it. The SNP are not the same party they were a generation ago and sure as eggs are eggs neither is the Labour Party.
In fact I suggest that if a Labour supporter was to be resurrected from his 30 year old grave and listened to New Labour, he would swear blind he was listening to a reasonably right-wing Conservative Government.

Rock on buddy!
45

IainGlasgow,

04/02/2009 11:33:58
#18

Yep he's made them all his biatches that's for sure
46

W U Merchant,

Aberdeen 04/02/2009 11:51:24
Which key post will Goldie get in Salmond's revamped cabinet? Looks like Robison and Swinney could both be for the chop.
47

Scottish 'N British,

04/02/2009 11:52:17
40

I'm no real fan of the Greens.

That said I honestly think he was between a rock and a hard place, certainly fearful of being the guy to dent the budget (again), given the logistics and atmosphere that everyone else is signing up.

History will show he set his stall out to help EVERYONE, but was bartered down by Swindley.

48

Scottish 'N British,

04/02/2009 11:56:53
33

Well that's good then, isn't it? A'body's happy.

If it does end up that Swindley has met Labour's conditions, then I'll be shocked and pleasantly pleased, because the logistics are that the SNP could have stitched Gray up, but chose to go with their stated position of getting everyone on board.

If Swindley has played it fair (which politics suggests he won't), I may even have to applaud something good done by the Separatists.

Like that'll happen!!!
49

bully wee alba,

Edinburgh 04/02/2009 12:00:02
#51

Auntie Bella is in line to be appointed as Leader of the Opposition, as the current incumbent has proven to be worse than useless.
50

bully wee alba,

Edinburgh 04/02/2009 12:07:12
Labour has announced that they will support the barely amended budget.

John Swinney has called their bluff.
51

The west awake,

Scottish - not - British 04/02/2009 12:08:51
53 - "If Swindley has played it fair (which politics suggests he won't), I may even have to applaud something good done by the Separatists."

Aye right, just like Labour "played it fair" with the Nats from day 1 of the Parliament until May 07?

I hope Swinney gives them what they deserve - Hee Haw!
- Let Gray take that "result" back (again) to his dwindling band of supporters. Still, when I think about it, what does dwindling support mean to Labour anyway? - Can always print a few postal vates eh?
52

Mr. Lachie Todd,

Edinburgh 04/02/2009 12:19:24
Unionist and Nationalist politicians are being carried away by their own importance and should keep this in proper perspective?

Denmark, a country with an almost identical population to that of Scotland, had an annual budget of £79 billion to spend last year. It puts the Scottish Parliament Budget in the shade! Certainly, Denmark is one of the highest taxed nations in Europe but it also spends a high proportion of its tax receipts on public spending.

The Danish GDP per capita income is one of the highest in the world.

In contrast to Denmark, which raised all of its massive budget by itself, the Scottish politicians simply squabbled over a cake handed to them by Westminster.
53

Doh,

04/02/2009 12:39:22
#54

If I were and SNP supporter I would be a wee bit worried that the fact that the SNP have done more to "decontaminate" the Tories than any other party.

If or when the Tories actually make back into power, according to them they already have the "most " influence over the budget, the SNP will suffer as part of the backlash.

The SNP should keep the Tories at arms length.

54

TWC,

04/02/2009 12:53:27
38 SNP hypocrisy

I don't mind the Scottish tories they will sometimes take a Scottish position. I'm not keen on Westminster Tories and I don't like the plan to selll Scottish water.
I told you Hyp, The Financial Autonomy is key for me if We get that i will support the Union if not I'll vote for Independence.
My belief is that shout no to everything th Nats say is bad policy we should support their good ideas and argue positive benefits of the Union.

57 Mr. Lachie Todd
I did most of my business with Denmark they had big town councils but private industry e=was weel paid and well taxed to pay for them.
Pensions are fairer across the board. Scotland could operate a similar system easily with Fiscal control.
55

Scottish 'N British,

04/02/2009 12:59:47
56

Anyone Awake In The West

WHERE have you been - in Rip Van Winkle mode?

Swindley has spent the last week crawling up various backsides, desperately trying to get the deal done afiore the February hols!! That sma' fact has been in a' the papers AND on the radio!!

Back to SNP HQ - or is it bed? Who can tell the difference, nowadays?
56

Arfur,

04/02/2009 13:00:44
27 Scottish 'N British, - 91% of Scotland supported the SNP re the budget you tool. Yet in your thick water clogged head you seem to think Salmond and Swinney came out of this worse than rest???? Do you practise being a half wit or does it come naturally?
57

Arfur,

04/02/2009 13:03:43
60 Scottish 'N British???????????????????????????????????????????????????

Eh thats why Gray and Scott came out after the vote with stains on their trousers anouncing they would get it sorted as soon as and dropped most of what they wanted in the budget.

I cant believe it - you are actually this thick.
58

The west awake,

Argyll 04/02/2009 13:18:15
60 Not Scottish - There has been a power of brownnosing since last week, I'll give you that, but you are confusing the recipients with the providers.
Firstly, given that 11m quid would have bought the Greens, why would the SNP have to rely on one single vote from either Labour or the Lib Dems?
If you could wake from your 50 year labour slumber you would perhaps see that the parties with most to gain from voting with the SNP today are Labour and the Lib Dems. Why - becaue they would get a tanning in an election, they know they will be blamed for wrecking the first vote and wisely won't risk getting blamed for the second.
Wakey Wakey!

59

TWC,

04/02/2009 13:21:07
60 Scottish 'N British,
Sometimes its better to say nothing and be thought stupid than to speak and confirm it.
You just make everyone doubt your saner contributions. In fact you are so deluded you could be Big Broon himself.
60

The west awake,

Argyll 04/02/2009 13:29:20
Doh - "If I were and SNP supporter I would be a wee bit worried that the fact that the SNP have done more to "decontaminate" the Tories than any other party."

- I agree that, being left of centre myself, the idea of working with the Tories in any way makes me shiver. However in this case the SNP have supped with the Devil without learning his ways.
The fact is the SNP HAD to work with the Tories because Labour and the LDs refused to contemplate doing so. I'm also comfortable that the concessions made to the Tories have been bought at very little "cost" to SNP policies and strategies. As long as that continues and until the LDs come to their senses and stop cheerleading for Labour the SNP will continue to get mine and Scotland's support.
In any case, the SNPs main policy is and will be Independence, once that is acheived, if us Scots decide to vote Scottish Tory then thats up to us (can't see it though).
61

Scottish 'N British,

04/02/2009 14:15:44
61
62

and soon to be more, methinks

I cannot believe I upset you sssoooooo much that you felt the need to post twice!!

hehehe

62

Scottish 'N British,

04/02/2009 14:20:32
64

"You just make everyone doubt your saner contributions."

Eh? What?
Compliments, is it?

Or just a Separatist on the turn?

63

Arfur,

04/02/2009 14:26:05
66 Scottish 'N British - more sorry for you. Do you still have your sticker saying 'my mummy thinks i am special'?
64

Daveunderwater,

04/02/2009 15:05:36
57

As you point out Denmark is similar in size to Scotland. the big difference is that Maersl Oil & Gas reap the benefits of their own natural resources where as ours as you say goes to Westminster

PS
We also have bacon in Ayrshire
65

Daveunderwater,

04/02/2009 15:09:49
65

You forget that from the same de'il the SNP were spawned...
66

Daveunderwater,

Silver City 04/02/2009 15:15:21
67

Most prefer separatism rather than disparate unionism
67

Daveunderwater,

04/02/2009 15:15:51
Or should that be desperate unionism?
68

TWC,

04/02/2009 15:33:20
67 Scottish 'N British,

Not a seperatist , a unonist but not a New Labour supporter anymore
69

Daveunderwater,

SNP Heartlands 04/02/2009 15:40:43
peaking at Business Questions in the House of Commons after the opposition parties in the Scottish Parliament failed to pass the Scottish Budget (2) Bill, SNP Shadow Scotland Office spokesperson, Angus MacNeil MP, criticised Labour recklessness.

Mr MacNeil said:

"Labour are playing fast and loose with Scotland’s economy, and their reckless behaviour at a time of recession is unforgivable.
"Yesterday’s no vote threatens £1.8bn in additional expenditure, which supports around 35,000 jobs, investment and action to help households and high streets.

"This recession started with Labour's economic irresponsibility, and by voting against the budget they have gone to new extremes.

"Iain Gray’s ludicrous suggestion that it would be okay to delay a budget until the summer is a monumental blunder and merely underlines Labour’s total irresponsibility on this vital issue.

"By choosing to play politics with much needed investment - money that would have secured many thousands of jobs - they have shown that they care nothing about the people of Scotland.

"The Scottish Budget would have secured funding for another year's council tax freeze. Instead, public service providers including health boards and local authorities and all who rely upon them face uncertainty and confusion."
70

Daveunderwater,

04/02/2009 15:55:36
"For we ha'e faith in Scotland's hidden poo'ers,
The present's theirs, but a' the past and future's oors."
71

Daveunderwater,

04/02/2009 16:01:16
SNP secure budget after winning Lib Dem Labour Support

STV website 16:05 4th Feb

abour, meanwhile, have also announced that it had reached agreement with Alex Salmond on "almost all" the proposals it made.

Iain Gray, the Scottish Labour leader, said the Scottish Government had agreed to an extra 7800 apprenticeships next year.

The figure falls short of what Labour had demanded last week after the Budget was defeated. Labour wanted 7800 apprenticeships every year for each of the next three years. After last week's defeat of the Bill, it scaled this down to a demand for 7800 apprenticeships every year for each of the next two years, plus an "indication" that this will continue for a third year.

Mr Gray said: "We have compromised but we believe we have done it in the best interests of Scotland. In particular there are almost 8000 young Scots who will have the opportunity of apprenticeships. But the government have also compromised."
72

Scottish 'N British,

04/02/2009 16:55:48
73

Aye right.

Separatist, no doubts.
Go home and 'out' yourself. You'll feel better for it.
73

Miss H,

04/02/2009 16:59:25
Budget passed - all voted for bar the 2 Greens.
74

Scottish 'N British,

04/02/2009 18:52:17
72

Well, from where I'm sitting, I'd say it was bad spelling. Sign of a poor education, clearly.

Veto PNS!!
Inapenance fur Abla!!
75

TWC,

04/02/2009 19:03:45
79 Scottish 'N British,

Labour got gubbed yet again, two budgets in a row, and of course Broon has admitted UK are in a Depression I told you he'd slip up again


Labour are the thickest politicians, an embarassment to the rest of us Unionists.
Time they went.
76

TWC,

04/02/2009 19:04:29
bye everybody

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.